3 ms·
> The university also cited another tweet in which she used the word ‘coconut’. Now she is suing the university for breaching her right to free speech. Isn’t it
by rvz 5y ago
> The university also cited another tweet in which she used the word ‘coconut’. Now she is suing the university for breaching her right to free speech. Isn’t it funny how the woke left suddenly supports free speech whenever its free speech is under attack...
Whatever it is that has attracted the critics attention to the author for them to resort to name calling and ad hominems which are also racist, they have now realised that they have to see themselves out.
Very ironic for the Twitter account of the Race Trust.
> The real shame is that Khanom or the Race Trust did not try to challenge my politics or arguments. .... These attacks haven’t persuaded me to alter my worldview...
To resort to ad hominems probably means that they can't challenge the author or change his mind with convincing and logical arguments. They have done an own goal and proved the author's point once again.
EDIT: You do realise that they deleted their Twitter account? That's why I said 'they have to see themselves out.' Also I don't see 'name calling' or 'ad hominems' as a useful way of a convincing someone else since that is not an argument [0]. Instead, that was the first own goal.
Now the second own goal by the 'Race Trust' is in the main argument that the author makes which is cancel-culture which he disagrees with. This issue has now transcended into real life and the university cancelled the author of the tweet.
Regardless of the viewpoints of the 'Race Trust', such cancellations just makes the situation even worse than it was before.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into ideological flamewar. It's against the site guidelines because it makes threads tedious, nasty, and predictable. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the rules more to heart, we'd be grateful. Note this one: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." Edit: we've had to ask you this numerous times before. Eventually we ban accounts that keep ignoring these requests.
- rvz 5y agoI edited and clarified my comment with context and added some substance to it and deleted another one in a different thread. Perhaps you'll now find that my comment is more 'thoughtful and substantive' and the rest of the comments in this thread have already descended further into mini flame wars. The worse thing about it is that some don't even have any evidence to substantiate their own comments. Oh dear.
- dang 5y agoOther people posting crap comments doesn't make it ok to post crap comments. That just leads to a downward spiral. We moderate these things where we see them; if other people are doing just-as-bad things and I haven't replied, that's because we only see a cross-section of what gets posted here. There's far too much to read it all.
- orwin 5y ago> To resort to ad hominems probably means that they can't challenge the author or change his mind with convincing and logical arguments. They have done an own goal and proved the author's point once again. Maybe. Either that, or people actually working in social science, or on critical race theory already read his points, responded to the ones that were new (ahah) and left it there, ignoring him and fellows commentator as they should. Again, you can be conservative and sociologist. Baudrillard did inspire a lot of those (they seems to become more and more marxist as teihr theories are refined but still). I don't understand why people take thos "journalist" seriously. Did he at least read the classics? And i mean, not even CRT author ( did not read them, this subject does not interest me). But i think the minimum you can do before trying to critic CRT is read Marx and Hegel (you have new book with integrated critics that are quite good) and obviously Derrida and Foucault. Bourdieu and Baudrillard maybe if you want some context for the first one and if you want more "conservative" views for the second, Wittgenstein because everybody needs to read Wittgenstein, and i'm forgetting Habermas who should have been the first one. Its really not interesting to debat such people, i did try. I spend two hours on trying to explain some core principles and left it here. At least now my friends understand what deconstruction is and stopped putting this under "leftist stuff". I think most conservatives agreed with Baudrillard hyperrealities (the liberals posting as conservatives did not but were still interested). It is just not worth the time.