3 ms·
That’s 4.8M people. I don’t know what “vast bulk of the money” would mean numerically, but let’s posit that it’s not less than half. Half of $4T/yr is $2T/yr o
by sokoloff 5y ago
That’s 4.8M people. I don’t know what “vast bulk of the money” would mean numerically, but let’s posit that it’s not less than half.
Half of $4T/yr is $2T/yr or over $415K/yr for the average nurse or doctor.
So, either “vast bulk” is well under half, nurses make a ton more than I think, or some assumption above is incorrect.
- tacostakohashi 5y ago> nurses make a ton more than I think, or some assumption above is incorrect. It could be this - plenty of nurses make well over $100k, plenty of doctors make well over $500k. It varies a lot based on location, specialty, overtime, but there are some good livings being made.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoAre there pensions and does this $4T figure include that? If so, that could account for a lot of the "worker compensation". But, the median wage for a medical doctor is <$250k in the US. I would be surprised if the pay amongst doctors is so unequal that the average is making >$500k. That being said, there are a ton of people who work in hospitals beside just "doctors and nurses". I wouldn't be surprised if all this factored in was close to 50% of the total pay.
- mcguire 5y agoReferring to the CDC link I posted above, physician and clinical services are 20% of total medical expenses. That's your primary care physician, nurses, labs, and specialists. (Hospital care is about 33% of the total.) 20% of $4T is $800 billion. There are ~209,000 primary care doctors in the US (https://www.ahrq.gov/research/findings/factsheets/primary/pcwork1/index.html https://www.ahrq.gov/research/findings/factsheets/primary/pc...), not counting specialists, etc. Each doctor therefore is responsible for ~$4M. Assuming for no reason whatsoever that specialists and outside labs, etc., take 50% of that, each doctor's practice gets $2M. Making ye olde "everybody costs $100,000 / year" assumption, that works out to 20 people including the doctor: nurses, receptionists, lab techs, janitors, etc. Doesn't sound terribly unreasonable.
- bradleyjg 5y agoDo you think doctors and nurses exhaust the category of health care workers? Do you think, perhaps, those sentences refer back to moving the needle rather than vast bulk?
- throwawaygh 5y agoDoctors and nurses are only a subset of workers who provide patient care in the US. There are a huge variety of technicians; basically one for every specialty. 9.8 million all-in, plus another 5.3 million other employees involved in less technical patient care (nursing assistants, non-bsn hospice workers, etc). $2T/yr divided by just the 9.8 million = 204,081, which puts average comp in the 160s. Sounds right; around here your average nurse makes about $80k/yr with excellent benefits, and they are sort of the median employee. And that's just the employees providing care. There's also an enormous bureaucracy.