9 ms·
Genius Checklist
- yshklarov 5y agoI see lots of comments arguing with the post, but seeing it in its original context is important. The full article addresses many of the criticisms: The roots of creativity and genius http://super-memory.com/articles/genius.htm http://super-memory.com/articles/genius.htm
- rangerdan 5y agoThe arrogance of someone prescribing a checklist to become a self-proclaimed "genius" is truly astounding. Only a completely dull and mediocre mind would even be interested by something like this.
- hliyan 5y agoStrangely, I have found that stress, or more accurately crises, have stimulated my creativity and shook me out of tired old modes of thinking more than anything else. Perhaps long lasting, low grade stress is bad, but the occasional spike is good?
- knuthsat 5y agoFor me, learning is stressful even when I'm doing it out of my own curiosity. I start biting nails immediately.
- ilaksh 5y agoI think most genius ideas go unrecognized or are actively fought against because people prefer the status quo just out of familiarity or because it's what everyone else is doing. But people are also highly social animals and often operate in hierarchies. So the ability to effectively position oneself socially seems key to having genius ideas or cognitive abilities recognized. That or having a friend with those characteristics.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoIn case you're also seeing 500 errors: https://archive.is/mDBZ9 https://archive.is/mDBZ9
- ccvannorman 5y agoI see Internal error [YSE-oMP1SSyd4ptIjUFctwAAAPA] 2021-08-21 17:57:56: Fatal exception of type "Error"
- sysadm1n 5y agoSite is down. Here's an Outline of it: https://outline.com/q3Abye https://outline.com/q3Abye First paragraph: > A majority of people carry the potential to become a genius. There are factors that are far more important than genes and IQ. I have compiled a checklist that I believe should work, when followed. All you need to begin with is to be free and reasonably healthy. I try to list the factors that prevent many people from accomplishing their greatest potential. The list begins with the stumbling blocks that are most likely to occur on one's road to genius. Some factors need to be balanced against each other, and some factors overlap.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoIs the author an acknowledged genius? There seems to be a gap between people who are solidly competent in a domain and perhaps somewhat more creative and insightful than average, and extreme gamechangers who completely transform an existing domain and/or invent a completely new one. Perhaps I'm wrong, but the author seems more of the former than the latter. That's not a bad goal in itself, but I'm always wary of people who seem to be applying the latter label to themselves.
- kbenson 5y agoWell, the first step in selling someone something is convincing them you have it.
- tgv 5y ago> A majority of people carry the potential to become a genius. Sure. Totally believable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oenetan 5y agoSite seems to be down: https://archive.is/3Z48v https://archive.is/3Z48v
- oenetan 5y agoI know 10x engineers and very smart people. I would say this guide is great and is a accurate reflection of how they got to be so great.
- smoldesu 5y agoThis is nice, but the biggest issue I have with all this is how 'genius' is described as if it's synonymous with being holistic. I know some smart people, a few of whom I'd probably consider geniuses too. By no means does that mean they're healthy though, I often catch them in bouts of self-loathing, messy offices, and even turning to vices when things get rough. Make no mistake, they were still sharp as a tack, but they're also human. This is a good checklist for people who want to self-improve, but for being a genius? I'd argue there's quite a bit more at play than just your frame of mind.
- AstralStorm 5y agoOr bit less, as the case might be. Sometimes it's easy to mistake expertise for genius too. Ultimately true talent cannot be earned, just wasted or ignored. One problematic thing in the list is about passion and goals. You can become an expert or even a great, but passions and goals change for a variety of reasons. A common one that will stop achievement dead on is being passionate for your family, or wanting to do something good or memorable for the world that does not align with what you do. Changing your mind is the most human thing one can do. Many a genius did not have a clear passion, but they had a different drive, such as solving a puzzle or wanted pure knowledge, or liked recognition; combined with grit and creativity and a fair degree of luck that alone can get one to genius. Material concerns are more sure to torpedo genius than stress or even disability.
- DerekBickerton 5y agoIt's the old stable genius versus unstable genius situation. For genius to have a place, it has to not hurt the genius in any way. So much genius comes with some sort of cost to the genius, in some form, like a vice as you say (e.g alcohol abuse), or the genius' mental health suffers since solitude and genius go hand-in-hand.
- hkt 5y agoA bit discouragingly, everything there about getting rid of stress and sleep appear to be immutable parts of my career. It remains a shame I've not really got anywhere to go.
- hexsprite 5y agoOne way to hack stress is to consider that there's some things that happen that are inherently stressful, and then there's the way we perceive or respond to it that can also add to that stress. I have found meditation and reframing the situation to be powerful tools for that. With sleep, one might not be able to get more hours or sleep, but it's possible to improve the quality of sleep. For example I recently was not sleeping well, was diagnosed with a sleep apnea, and now using a CPAP machine allows the sleep I do get to be better quality. Other things: journal and meditate before bed to calm the mind, stretch/yoga/qigong to relax the body
- foogazi 5y ago> everything there about getting rid of stress and sleep appear to be immutable parts of my career. There are other careers - problem solved!
- hackingthelema 5y agoHave you tried going 'inside'? Meditation can teach you to observe your own states as an outsider and affect them, kind of like hooking up a debugger to your own mental 'programs'. Once you notice yourself feeling stressed, firing up the debugger (AKA utilising your mindfulness training) and sorting through the contents of your mind can help you defuse it. Maybe you can even change a variable using your 'debugger' to improve the state of your 'programs' ;) It also helps you sleep, because the difficulties sleeping are controlled/helped by learning mindfulness. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5337506/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5337506/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6557693/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6557693/ https://www.vipassana.com/meditation/mindfulness_in_plain_english.html https://www.vipassana.com/meditation/mindfulness_in_plain_en...
- phnofive 5y agoFor context, here's an anti-flu checklist from the same site: > https://archive.is/Lrt0F https://archive.is/Lrt0F If you want to stay healthy, wear shorts all the time, run weekly half-marathons in the woods, get plenty of sleep... and avoid sick people. A few common-sense morsels wrapped in pseudoscience and self-gratifying prose.
- mirekrusin 5y agoThere is something important here that will be hard for me to articulate. The main point is that if you read through this list it’s not all nonsense you should avoid because “pseudoscience“. To put it in other words - it’s not confirmed not working facts, they are more of anecdotally confirmed working facts, which have not bad chance of becoming scientifically confirmed facts. The list is highly subjective snapshot of rituals occupying spectrum of real facttnes level. Just because item X is nonsense descent imply that item Y is also nonsense. All that to say that evaluation of this list should be more thorough as opposed to total acceptance or total rejection. I have similar problem when discussing Rudolf Steiner schools/“sects”(?) - they are really good people doing really good things compared to status quo - I love buying food from their shops because I know they have incomparable quality to what I can get at nearby shops (meat, eggs, veggies etc), they grow them in harmony (no depleting monocultures, pesticides etc). At the same time I know Steiner is pseudoscience labelled - I’m aware of it but it doesn’t subtract enough from good parts. What I’m trying to say it’s not all bad period, it’s more nuanced.
- xmprt 5y agoI think the term psuedoscience has been shifted to mean things like snake oil and alternative medicines. While that doesn't apply to this case, I think we can still call this psuedoscience. It's trying to make scientific-ish claims without any of the rigor behind science. It's like if your mom told you that turmeric powder works great to cure certain ailments and then 5 years later a study comes out which proves her right. Mom's cure was still psuedoscience until the research is actually done.
- 5y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoUgh, sorry for being jaded, but at some point I just become very tired of more anodyne self-help advice packaged under a new title. I mean, "get good sleep", "reduce stress" - this is obviously not bad advice, but it's the equivalent of telling overweight people to eat less and exercise more, point being if just giving that advice actually changed people's behavior we'd all be athletic and svelte.
- foogazi 5y ago> but it's the equivalent of telling overweight people to eat less and exercise more, point being if just giving that advice actually changed people's behavior we'd all be athletic and svelte What else would you tell overweight people? People will change when they want to - and at that point the advice becomes actionable
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> What else would you tell overweight people? There is plenty of data about what is more effective in getting people to actually change their behavior, e.g. 1. Find a workout or weight loss buddy that so you can help keep each other on track. There is loads of evidence that social connections and pressures can be very helpful. 2. Don't try to make drastic changes all at once, for example for many people doing something like completely getting rid of soda and replacing it with lightly sweetened tea can make a huge difference, and that's usually a lot easier to do than, say, never eat out at restaurants. 3. Do something that you can easily integrate into your routine instead of doing something that feels like you have to do "extra" to start. E.g. if you commute to work, if possible, park a half mile away from your office and walk the rest of they way. All of this is much better advice than "eat less".
- foogazi 5y agothose are gimmick wrappers around the solid and true “eat less, exercise more” advice
- 5y ago
- shimonabi 5y agoSince he mentions learning Kanji, I just started learning Chinese Hanzi symbols with an Anki deck. How does Supermemo compare to Anki?
- tra3 5y agoSupermemo supposed to have a better spaced repetition algorithm from what I've read. Supermemo also supports incremental reading; a very intriguing concept. Of course all of this comes together bundled in a windows app with no mobile support. Anki ecosystem is much easier to use.
- Tenoke 5y agoSupermemo has some proprietary algorithms but it's close enough. There's little reason to switch from Anki and Anki generally has the biggest community. If you are worried about the minor differences in algorithms, realistically you might benefit as much or more from finetuning your Anki intervals instead.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ttul 5y agoThe author missed a prerequisite: have rich parents. Because the low stress life is made far more effortless via the provision of unlimited leisure capital.
- edoceo 5y agoI think this is balanced by the trust-fund dumbass Idle brains rot. It's spot on tho that comfort & saftey provides the opportunity for genius to develop.
- vajrabum 5y agoThe thing is you can't see a trust fund by looking at people. It's a trope that people who have trust funds don't work but is there any evidence that is a common outcome?
- bradlys 5y agoIt’s common in my circle. They don’t take up the normal jobs they would’ve otherwise. Instead of high pressure roles that would resemble their background better they role play as a middle class earner while being FI.
- javert 5y agoThere is a reversion to mean among the children of highly successful people. Just because your dad made $100M in business doesn't mean you are that capable; you probably aren't (statistically speaking). Taking a "middle class job" is probably the best that some children of the rich can do.
- koolba 5y agoSafety, but not comfort, is what nurtures genius. It allows the individual to see the value of fruitful effort. Total destitute feels totally hopeless. A safe existence with a visible path upward acts as a guiding light.
- loceng 5y ago
- krisoft 5y ago> Never trust your memory to keep your new ideas. Once you come up with an idea, write it down instantly. I disagree with this bit of advice very much. In my experience if an idea is a good one it will occur to me again. Very often in a more refined form. Of course if you are working on something actively feel free to write it down. But when not actively working on a given problem? My brain is a good place for ideas to percolate in. Besides I have a ton of ideas. It would be silly to treat each little thing as a precious resource like a miser.
- jb1991 5y agoLegendary writer, I think maybe Stephen King, felt the same way. He said a notebook was a way to keep terrible ideas alive forever.
- hackingthelema 5y agoAleister Crowley had some thoughts on geniuses (specifically religious geniuses, but he believed genius didn't end there) and how any human being can attain towards this level of consciousness: https://sacred-texts.com/oto/aba/aba1.htm https://sacred-texts.com/oto/aba/aba1.htm Specifically, from the Q&A, he says: > Q. What is genius, and how is it produced? >> A. Let us take several specimens of the species, and try to find some one thing common to all which is not found in other species. > Q. Is there any such thing? >> A. Yes: all geniuses have the habit of concentration of thought, and usually need long periods of solitude to acquire this habit. ... His training system -- the A∴A∴ -- is designed to lead people to their genius. Interestingly, it is very similar to this checklist: it teaches self-discipline (by having to follow a specific training program); studying great people and works of philosophy, metaphysics, mathematics, etc; controlling emotions; controlling thought (including constraining it to a single idea); writing down ideas; etc. I think Crowley goes much further and was more rigorous in his approach to applying the ideas listed. In his view, you don't _become_ a genius through this work, but connect to the genius that is already inside everyone. Connecting to this Genius and finding out your goals in life is the key to a joyful life -- or, as TFA says, 'Establishing a clear goal for your life should be a priority'.
- z3ncyberpunk 5y agoWhile I see you're a thelema cultist, I would hardly take anything a sociopathic, sadistic, spoiled, trust fund brat like Crowley has to say with any seriousness. Crowley wasn't some brave misunderstood hero, he was a delusional twisted pervert with a power complex.
- hackingthelema 5y agoHave you read Hacker News' approach to comments and site guidelines? https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html > Which brings us to the most important principle on HN: civility. Since long before the web, the anonymity of online conversation has lured people into being much ruder than they'd be in person. So the principle here is: don't say anything you wouldn't say face to face. This doesn't mean you can't disagree. But disagree without calling names. If you're right, your argument will be more convincing without them. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something. And so on.
- pram 5y agoIMO it's funny they've correlated 'genius' with some holistic positive-energy regimen. I know a few people I'd consider geniuses. Actual credentialed geniuses, as in Physics PhD from an ivy. They're pretty much perpetually in a shitty mood and have the most antisocial, night-time oriented schedules possible.
- mirekrusin 5y agoI don’t think they say you have to be party goer? Sleep may be compensated by daytime naps, ie recently I learned Ronaldo naps daytime in his daily schedule which was interesting to me, he won’t get Nobel price for what he loves but still he tops at his hobby.
- bjornsing 5y ago> Physics PhD from an ivy If that’s your definition of genius you have to raise your standards. ”The world is filled with educated fools and uneducated genuises.” – Richard Feynman
- bicknergseng 5y ago- Richard Feynman, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (S.B. 1939), Princeton University (Ph.D. 1942) Agreed that credentials aren't required for a pass to the genius club, but I didn't read that in the post above either.
- xmprt 5y agoA Ph.D. is something that anyone can do with a bit of patience and effort. Does that mean we should shift the bar so it means professors are geniuses? No. I don't think any arbitrary qualifications make you a genius.
- in3d 5y agoI think that depends on the field and on your definition of “anyone.” I’d bet against an average 100 spatial/math IQ person being able to get a PhD in math or physics, even if hardworking and patient. They would probably be something like 2.5 standard deviations below average and while IQ is not the end-all and be-all, such a vast gap would make it extremely hard for them.
- civilized 5y agoThis site looks pretty interesting and some ideas resonate with me, but it also seems to be a bit of a rabbit hole, full of unfamiliar jargon and depending heavily on self-citation. Can anybody vouch for the value of digging into this?
- alessivs 5y agoYes, go ahead and read deeply. In spite of the chosen TLD, disagreeing with any piece of advice doesn't accidentally invalidate other ideas like some guru's all-or-nothing self-contained theory. There is also no luring you into signing up for a mailing list to offer you products or courses.
- mirekrusin 5y agoBaby Jesus, this is dense, good stuff.
- throwanem 5y agoThat at the moment this should 500 seems thoroughly apropos.
- csa 5y ago> That at the moment this should 500 seems thoroughly apropos. Thoroughly with reference to…
- throwanem 5y agoIf nothing else with reference to a commonly cited trait of genius being that it have its head in the clouds. That, or I suppose to the idea of someone who takes the care to compile (what I assume to be) a checklist of traits of genius, should fail to consider the basic necessity of ensuring it remain available so that people can read it. But perhaps they are the same.
- csa 5y agoFwiw, I was commenting on the use of “apropos” versus “appropriate”. I will let you look up those words, but apropos is frequently misused on HN.
- throwanem 5y agoPrescriptivism seems as footless here as in any other attempted application to the vernacular, but if it helps ease your mind at all, OED has the adjectival sense in which I used it above, and in which it's frequently seen here and elsewhere.
- UhUhUhUh 5y agoI fail to see how one can achieve, aim at or elaborate on something that is not defined.
- smusamashah 5y agoFrom list of his micro rules under Self Discipline: do not browse the web. Find materials on demand with Google. Prioritize demands with incremental reading do not read articles on the web. Preview articles that are worth importing to SuperMemo and import them for prioritized increading do not watch YouTube. Use incremental video before sleep (preferably while walking)
- lostmsu 5y agoThis does not work as you need some way to keep up to events be they scientific discoveries or shifts in power.
- xixixao 5y agoSerious question to self: How often do you need those updates? And to what depth? If you’re in Afghanistan, you probably wouldn’t miss what’s going on. If you’re not, and you’re prioritizing “being a genius”, should you care?
- lostmsu 5y agoWould not this depend on what you are trying to be a genius in? Outside of the disaster areas, political stuff probably does not matter, but your field progress might. > If you’re in Afghanistan, you probably wouldn’t miss what’s going on. In this particular instance you certainly could miss something important in time. The chances to escape there probably dropped rapidly.
- dv35z 5y agoWhat do you think about blocking off an hour a week (eg Sunday morning), and tabbing-open / reading topics of interest from this page? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Current_events https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Current_events
- lostmsu 5y agoIt does not seem much different from other aggregators. Also, just a list of facts is strictly worse than a list of facts with some debate around them. Reading a debate saves time on internalizing consequences. At least that's how I am rationalizing reading Hacker News. It covers both news like Afghanistan and computer science.
- devnull3 5y agoI think what people mean by "genius" is some innate ability which is much way superior (~10x) to general population. Example: Terence Tao attending university level math courses at age 9 [1] This cannot be explained by any checklist or regimen. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terence_Tao#Childhood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terence_Tao#Childhood
- rybosworld 5y agoAgreed. There definitely seem to be instances where someone possess innate ability that cannot be matched through perseverance alone.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoNot to defend the site... It leaves a bad taste for some reason... ... But the site never claimed that you'd become a genius by following the checklist. Just that you'd make a lot of progress. The items on the checklist also do seem to be associated with many of the people that I've met who I'd call geniuses. (I've been lucky to meet a few, at least online.) For example, intellectual curiosity, stress free life, solid sleep schedule, general happiness. It's very difficult to find an instance of a miserable genius. Misery, for unknown reasons, seems to undercut one's ability to apply their genius traits. So although I don't think this checklist is going to transform you into a genius, it does seem to be a checklist of qualities that geniuses tend to share. I just wish it was presented in a clinical, dispassionate way, rather than a "you can too!" style.
- ravenouswolves6 5y ago> It's very difficult to find an instance of a miserable genius. Isaac Newton?
- sillysaurusx 5y agoThat's an interesting counterexample, though I've often wondered what he was actually like. We only hear the tales from history, which are extremes by definition. I imagine that pg's bio might have similar things to say, but those who knew him remember how snappy and full of energy he is. His online persona and writings give a very different impression.
- Chirael 5y ago“Why did you come in so late today?” “I read a blog post that told me it would help me become more of a genius if I ‘throw away my alarm clock’, so I did!” “Well I have great news for you: You can show up at the unemployment line whenever it suits you, genius.”
- prvc 5y agoHealth (comprehending stress, sleep, fitness, disease, etc.), and regimen, combined with a good mindset/ philosophical orientation, and good (perhaps in an unconventional sense) education, are certainly all important and necessary prerequisites for peak intellectual performance. On the other hand "genius" is necessarily defined in relative terms, and is rare, although its specific numerical rarity may vary, even greatly. "Genes and IQ" certainly also present hard limits. The author seemed to be wanting to be P.C. by denying this, but ended up doing the opposite (egregiously) by grouping the two traits together as one! The invocation of the concept of "genius" itself is "problematic" in a similar ironic way.
- leoc 5y agoIf you want to know more about the author or SuperMemo, Wired has an article: https://www.wired.com/2008/04/ff-wozniak/ https://www.wired.com/2008/04/ff-wozniak/ .
- omazurov 5y ago> Instead of memorizing 20x20 combinations, you limit yourself to a standard 10x10 table (just 25% of all combinations) Actually, 26% (55/210). You say 25% and nobody notices. You say 26% and you convey a message you understand things on a deeper level (still shallow but much, much better than no level at all). I'd pick 27%, though.
- stereoradonc 5y agoWhy this post make it to the list in the first place?
- hammyhavoc 5y agoMeandering, fluffy puff piece for SuperMemo, which given that it is on the SuperMemo website itself, comes as zero surprise.
- shdh 5y agoSome people’s natural abilities outweigh the developed abilities of others without any extra work. The best is when an individual combines natural ability with deliberate practice.