3 ms·
> It escapes me how anyone can consider it for long-term carbon storage/offsetting Because, the occasional fire notwithstanding, it's not ephemeral. The canon
by ajross 5y ago
> It escapes me how anyone can consider it for long-term carbon storage/offsetting
Because, the occasional fire notwithstanding, it's not ephemeral. The canonical idea here is taking stripped land like farms, which has had all the carbon removed and burned off into the atmosphere, and replacing it (over a century or two) with a mature forest where very large amounts of carbon is stored in biomass. Yes, it burns sometimes. But over time forests house vastly more carbon than farms. So planting them is a win.
The ding against forest sequestration isn't fires, it's that they just don't work fast enough. It's not enough to scrub all the CO2 out of the air by 2221 AD, we need it done now.
- lazide 5y agoThat is... probably not correct? The forest stores x amount of carbon it has extracted while the forest exists, but forests are ephemeral over geological timescales, or in some cases even 100's of years. And while they suck up carbon while growing, they reach equilibrium relatively quickly, and then mostly just cycle it, not store much more. It's great if you have a bunch of land that COULD have a forest, but currently doesn't for some reason (harvested?) - but there isn't a lot of that anymore. If it doesn't have it now because the last one burned, then it's just getting back to it's previous storage point, not really changing the overall equilibrium. You can't easily make more land be forestable, as it requires quite a lot of water, and most places with a lot of water already have forests.
- joe_the_user 5y agoHere in California, 2 million acres burned last year and we may well have 2 million acres burn this year (we're up to at least a million). And before 1850, 2 million acres also burned, so we're essentially catching to the average - in the worst way possible. It's global warming and an abused, fire-based ecology, together. And people imagine "plant a tree" is the solution. So forests here are very ephemeral indeed. The idea that people keeping a forest here forever would fight global warming is mind boggling.
- ajross 5y agoYou're mixing some stuff up here. Land area "burned" isn't literally deforested, don't be ridiculous. Only in the worst-affected regions of the biggest fires do you see acreage where the majority of trees are killed. And even there the trunks of killed trees tend to remain standing; their carbon doesn't enter the atmosphere until they fall and rot. What happens in a fire isn't that the forest goes away, it's just that the dead fuel burns. In fact in a healthy forest, total carbon uptake significantly increases after a fire (as younger, faster-growing plants rush into the voids left by the removed cover). Yes, "plant a tree" is absolutely part of the solution. It's not sufficient, but it's important. Turning forests into low-productivity farms is a disaster, and reversing that is a huge win for carbon balancing.
- lazide 5y agoDepending on the area, some of them are destroyed. Yosemite has been changed dramatically by some of these fires for example, with the areas burned in 1990 still scrub manzanita instead of the 100+ ft tall timber that used to be there. In some of these dryer areas, it isn’t clear it will ever come back the way it was, or if it does it may be hundreds of years from now.
- joe_the_user 5y agoYou're mixing some stuff up here. Land area "burned" isn't literally deforested, don't be ridiculous. You're right and that doesn't change the basic point. That is: California and the West broad has an excess of trees and tree-density so keeping a given forest as a carbon sink is ridiculous and impractical. In fact in a healthy forest, total carbon uptake significantly increases after a fire (as younger, faster-growing plants rush into the voids left by the removed cover). California has insufficient wetland and grassland. Some of a given burned forest will become that. The ultimate, stable California ecology has a substantially lower density of trees than the existing ecology and so the fires that happen in that context tend to just clear the existing brush, leaving the trees, etc. And still, doesn't change the basic point. Edit: Reading my original post, I can't see where I claim fires "deforest" a region. Fires do lower tree density, how could they do otherwise? Edit again: there's a limit to how much carbon a given landscape can absorb, determined by its ecology broadly speaking. Through fire suppression, California and the West have managed to go past that limit. It's biting us, I'm wearing two masks outside and this is the present reality. How hard is that grasp?
- jfoutz 5y agoKinda? I think year to year stuff dies and turns to soil. At geological timescales, a forest adds a millimeter of soil over however long it takes, eventually that dead stuff turns into coal and oil. Can't quite dredge up the memories of nurse logs for evidence though. I mean, we're not going to do that. Forests won't save us from global warming. But I'm pretty sure that's one of the mechanisms so much carbon got tucked away.
- ajross 5y ago> forests are ephemeral over geological timescales No, forest cover over the whole planet has been pretty consistent over the past hundred million years or so. It's only recently that we've seen widespread continent-scale deforestation. A simple return to the geological status quo would effect a ton of carbon sequestration. In fact in the longer term (since "forests" have existed anyway) forest have been absolutely enormous carbon sinks. It took until the end of the carboniferous (the name is not an accident!) ~300M years ago for bacteria to even be able to decompose wood. Most tree trunks from that era never rotted at all, they got buried and turned into coal.
- lazide 5y agoThe existence of forests is long lived, but any given forest is not. And the carbon locked up was because the forest died and was stuffed somewhere it could not rot or burn - which is what I was talking about sequestration wise. If not locked up that way, the carbon would have been released, and some new forest somewhere that eventually popped up would grab it. Net plus or minus though depends on the epoch, as sometimes it was rain forest earth, other times relatively barren.
- jjk166 5y agoCO2 isn't stored in dead trees, and forests do not just keep sequestering more and more. If you hold the number of trees constant, you're not affecting the carbon cycle. Living trees are a reservoir of carbon. If you increase the total number of trees, that increases the size of this reservoir. A forest "moving" over the course of time is a non-issue. There are immense areas on Earth right now which were deforested within the past few centuries and are still perfectly capable of supporting forest today.