5 ms·
Critical thought requires falsifiability and evidence, but conspiracy theory only requires belief.
by ryandrake 5y ago
Critical thought requires falsifiability and evidence, but conspiracy theory only requires belief.
- inter_netuser 5y agoEvery scientific hypothesis starts without evidence. So it must be treated as "conspiracy", and not critical thought, according to you?
- coaksford 5y agoNot being falsifiable and not having evidence aren't the same thing. Conspiracy theories are usually centrally dependent upon something that is both outlandish and impossible to disprove, or some reasoning that is constructed so that it cannot be disproved, as any effort to disprove it is undertaken by "them" by definition and is suspect because they're all in on it the conspiracy. There can be no evidence yet, it becomes a problem when unfalsifiability makes evidence irrelevant.
- rspeele 5y agoExample of unfalsifiability: Alice: Trump won Georgia, but the Dominion voting machines flipped it. Look at how many votes came in for Biden late at night. Bob: It took a long time to finish counting the mail in ballots, and precincts report their results in large batches. Anyway, there was a hand recount of all the paper ballots that were scanned by the machines. If the machines had flipped votes, the paper ballots would still show the originals. Alice: Then the hand recount was faked. Bob: But observers from both parties were present for the recount. By this time the machine flip theory was widespread, so the Republican observers would be on high alert to make sure the recount is right. Alice: Those might not be real Republicans. Like the Secretary of State, they are probably RINOs. Plus the paper ballots themselves were fraudulent. The signatures were faked. Bob: So do you still think the Dominion machines did something wrong, or did they accurately scan the fraudulent paper ballots? Anyway, the state bureau of investigation did a signature audit in Cobb county and found no intentional fraud and only a couple of mistakes where somebody signed for their partner or something. Alice: The GBI is in on it. The fraud was really in Fulton county, so that's where they should've done the signature audit. Didn't you see that batch of secret ballots they hid under a table and pulled out when nobody was looking? Bob: The security camera footage shows that the ballots from under the table are the same ones that were opened from envelopes while the observers were watching. They were just the next batch waiting to be scanned, nothing abnormal about them. The state released the whole footage online, including the parts Trump's lawyers conveniently skipped past. Alice: I know it was stolen. The details of how they did it might never come out, but I can tell Trump really won.
- phaemon 5y agoThat is literally the opposite of how scientific hypotheses start. I'm guessing you're not a scientist.
- pfarrell 5y agoExactly. Most scientific hypotheses start after “hmm… that’s weird.”
- inter_netuser 5y agohow do they start?
- mindcrime 5y agoInductive inference from empirical observation? Abductive inference "to the best explanation" to try and explain some apparent anomaly?
- recursivedoubts 5y agoThe topic isn't what your own personal definition of a "conspiracy theory" is. Rather it is whether the term "conspiracy theory" can be introduced into a conversation and terminate thinking.
- the_af 5y agoThe claim that calling something a conspiracy theory is always done in order to shut down inconvenient or provocative conversations is, itself, a thought terminating cliche. "Someone called my rant a conspiracy theory, therefore I'm on to something!"
- pessimizer 5y agoI'm sorry. Every time I hear the term, I forget what the conversation was about and can only think about how to destroy our enemies who are spreading counterproductive, unverifiable, unfalsifiable, anti-consensus rumors to suckers.
- still_grokking 5y agoAnd here we go again… What you're talking about is actually the cliché of a "conspiracy theory". A lot of things that are called like that aren't anything one could call "a theory" at all. The point is: Any random BS claim isn't a conspiracy theory. A conspiracy theory is nothing more than speculating that some parties are working or worked together in secret (conspired) to achieve something. That's all. Such a theory can usually be falsified. (At least in theory). But there is this framing that "conspiracy theory" means some arbitrary BS. That's actually why labeling something as "conspiracy theory" immediately shouts down critical thought in a lot of folks. Just call something "conspiracy theory" and the cliché kicks in and people will dismiss that something as BS. By the way: The English version of the Wikipedia disagrees. But only the English version. I've also looked at Boarisch, Deutsch, Español, Français, Italiano, Nederlands, Polski, Русский. Only the English version adds that a conspiracy theory "is an explanation for an event or situation […] when other explanations are more probable. The term has a negative connotation, implying that the appeal to a conspiracy is based on prejudice or insufficient evidence." Should we proceed to construct a conspiracy theory form that observation? Someone got obviously their framing into Wikipedia!
- the_af 5y agoI disagree that many conspiracy theories can be falsified. How often believers, when confronted with evidence, find it convincing and dismiss the conspiracy?
- still_grokking 5y agoIf you can present evidence you can prove or falsify it, right? So it's falsifiable. Otherwise you couldn't ever present any evidence. Whether someone is willing to believe in some evidence shown doesn't change anything about the fallibility property.
- the_af 5y agoBut a conspiracy theory is a social construct not subject to rational thought. The notion of falsifiability only makes sense in the context of a conversation between actors willing to accept this. The context of conspiracy theories is different. It's emotional. Goalposts get shifted, evidence is made up, no rational discourse possible. So they cannot be falsified.