4 ms·
Your first paragraph is called the Motte and Bailey fallacy [1]. You can't win your original argument, so you pick a different one that's easier, and then prete
by AlbertCory 5y ago
Your first paragraph is called the Motte and Bailey fallacy [1]. You can't win your original argument, so you pick a different one that's easier, and then pretend that you won the original.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy
- 908B64B197 5y agoIronically, it's just what Timnit Gebru did. "I can't prove algorithms are unethical, therefore I'll make a point that the (clean) energy used to train them contributes to global warming (by assuming all the energy required came from jet fuel)". [0] And then ethics tries to claim it's a real science! [0] https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/12/04/1013294/google-ai-ethics-research-paper-forced-out-timnit-gebru/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/12/04/1013294/google-a...
- rhizome 5y agoSince "I can't prove algorithms are unethical" implies a demand or requirement to prove a negative, I'm inclined to conclude that you're misrepresenting your source.
- dekhn 5y agoWhat is truly extraordinary about that paper is that it completely ignored the fact that ML is only a tiny contributor to overall power usage in computing, and also attempted to compare the training to intercontentintal flights, which use the same amount of fuel empty of full (and the planes do fly nearly empty). All of it makes it look like she just wanted to attack ML, rather than make a good faith argument. The other part of the paper (the danger of trusting things that stochastically parrot well enough to exit the right side of the uncanny valley) is interesting.
- visarga 5y agoI think she's all to willing to throw the baby (the transformer model) with the bath water. She doesn't care about AI advancement at all, and that makes me distrust her paper.
- dekhn 5y agoI didn't even make argument; I'm just asked the author to reconsider their statements given that there is historical evidence that ethics is more than just shaming and cancel culture. It's more https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_analogy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_analogy and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_emotion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_emotion
- burnished 5y agoYour comment is the "fallacy fallacy" where every statement is countered by the claim that it is in fact a fallacy. The person you responded to has a cogent reply and you haven't done anything to address the meat of the matter.
- claudiawerner 5y agoThat's a very uncharitable (and in my judgement inaccurate) characterization of GP's argument - the usage of the MaB fallacy as you've done neglects the principle of steelmanning your opponent's position, and shifts the discussion from a fact-finding mission to "winning an argument", both things that are anathema to good discourse. The article you linked expands on this criticism of the MaB fallacy in the 'Criticism' section. GP took advantage of an analogy to counter the claim that ethics is only about shaming and calling people out. Analogical reasoning is a powerful philosophical tool that can lead to important insights and discovering new questions. In this case, GP used the analogy where we apply ethics (relatively uncontroversial) in a scientific context. If the comparison is successful, it counters the claim that ethics is only a fashionable way of shaming people. Lastly, GP never claimed to 'win' the argument with the analogy (even if it were a motte-and-bailey). It's entirely possible that GP has more work to do after getting a response to the analogy.