14 ms·
Who gets to define what’s ‘racist?’ (2020)
- clipradiowallet 5y agoThe loudest voice gets to define what things mean. In other cases, the voice that is able to silence and/or censor other voices gets to make those calls.
- OrvalWintermute 5y agoI'd contend that BigTech commissars currently get to define it, as they also define volume of a voice. They are more powerful than governments, and due to their downstream effects, they can bully even BigMedia.
- krapp 5y agoLiterally nothing in your comment is true.
- OrvalWintermute 5y agoThe evidence is that a US President [1], however unpopular, and a US Senator [2], and multiple Congressmen/women have been censored [3] , and numerous other people, or messaging attached to their communications [4] . In some cases, unpopular causes, or causes contrary to a BigTech interest have been censored [5]. At the same time, certain terrorists have been permitted to distribute their messaging unhampered [6]. Although a national platform can be an issue, that hasn't stopped BigTech from stooping down to censor unpopular local govt [7] . In some cases, governments have colluded with BigTech to censor their political rivals [8] or to flag content that a state government found undesirable [9] Please provide your evidence to the contrary to disprove the truth of it. [1] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/twitter-censors-tweets-from-trump-on-saturday-morning/ar-BB1aMV19 https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/twitter-censors-twee... [2] https://www.paul.senate.gov/news/dr-rand-paul-releases-video-slamming-youtube-censorship https://www.paul.senate.gov/news/dr-rand-paul-releases-video... [3] https://thehill.com/opinion/cybersecurity/397047-big-techs-censorship-of-conservative-users-is-alive-and-well https://thehill.com/opinion/cybersecurity/397047-big-techs-c... [4] https://infogalactic.com/info/List_of_people_censored_by_Twitter https://infogalactic.com/info/List_of_people_censored_by_Twi... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_Google https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_Google [6] https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/01/most-infamous-terrorists-twitter/333662/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/01/mo... [7] https://youtubecensorship.com/2021-08-12-15-times-big-tech-censored-local-government.html https://youtubecensorship.com/2021-08-12-15-times-big-tech-c... [8] https://www.dailysignal.com/2021/07/21/biden-white-house-admits-using-big-tech-to-silence-americans/ https://www.dailysignal.com/2021/07/21/biden-white-house-adm... [9] https://survivalmagazine.org/news/huge-dr-shiva-discovers-existence-of-the-secretive-long-fuse-report-exposes-twitter-government-collusion-as-momentous-discovery-as-pentagon-papers/ https://survivalmagazine.org/news/huge-dr-shiva-discovers-ex...
- krapp 5y agoYour claims were as follows: 1) BigTech commissars currently get to define racism. First, "BigTech" isn't a thing. Despite what many right-wingers currently believe, there isn't a cabal or conspiracy involving all American tech companies, this is an ill defined term which only serves as a vague epithet and strawman enemy, like "the left" or "the gays." Second, there are no "commisars." The implication here is that tech companies have dictated the definition of racism to the population by fiat, like Communist dictators, but this clearly isn't the case. Rather, social media has caused movement from the ground up. None of the links you've provided demonstrate that racism is defined by an authoritarian conspiracy among tech companies. 2) BigTech companies are more powerful than governments. This is absurd on its face. The US could repeal Section 230 tomorrow and social media would collapse. The government could roll in with tanks and guns and burn Facebook to the ground. "BigTech" only exists to the degree and in the form that governments allow. Take a look at the recent controversy over OnlyFans. An entity more powerful than governments wouldn't be at the mercy of a payment processor, since governments, at least, can define the laws under which payment processors operate. None of the links you've provided demonstrate that any tech company is more powerful than governments. To the contrary, some show that tech companies are beholden to government. 3) due to their downstream effects, they can bully even BigMedia. I don't even know what this is supposed to mean. But none of your links prove it either. So we're left with your triggered logorrhea in this comment, where you've apparently forgotten your entire premise and decided to go on a rant about social media "censorship." This conversation has been had a thousand times on Hacker News, it's a turd eternally swirling around the frictionless fluid that is this forum. Feel free refer to any one of those, I don't even feel like pretending to care anymore, it's off topic anyway.
- OrvalWintermute 5y agoI think you have responded to a large amount of evidence of past bigtech transgressions with a blanket dismissal. You provided no evidence really, just some conjecture and text. I never said there was a blanket conspiracy, I just used the term BigTech. If a group of companies operate out of the same coastal geography, and enforce a particular type of hegemony on the rest of us, there is no need for any type of conspiracy to occur. As BigTech are competitors, that would not make sense anyways. They are more likely to collaborate together on financial matters, anti-poaching, or bid rigging ad auctions, or, preference for each other's products in exchange for favors. https://www.wired.com/story/texas-accuses-google-facebook-illegal-conspiracy/ https://www.wired.com/story/texas-accuses-google-facebook-il... > The US could repeal Section 230 tomorrow and social media would collapse. The US is very divided on Section 230 and in the face of a narrow majority, where the political enemy is experiencing censorship, is not likely to take action. Although the house may flip shortly, divided government will make change even more unlikely. As soon as the victims of the censorship change to extend into more of the anti-establishment figures on the Left also, such as Tulsi Gabbard, then that too will change. > Take a look at the recent controversy over OnlyFans. An entity more powerful than governments wouldn't be at the mercy of a payment processor, since governments, at least, can define the laws under which payment processors operate. OnlyFans is not BigTech, it is a site mainly offering a large amount of pornographic content that was on the receiving end of an article from the NYTimes by Nicholas Kristoff, aka, BigMedia. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/04/opinion/sunday/pornhub-rape-trafficking.html?action=click&module=RelatedLinks&pgtype=Article https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/04/opinion/sunday/pornhub-ra... Nicholas Kristoff is considered an establishment media figure, of the ruling Authoritarian Elite. Whether he has a D or an R after his name matters little, because he is establishment. > So we're left with your triggered logorrhea in this comment, I think you need to be a little more diplomatic on HN.
- sebow 5y agoI would also add that sometimes the voice that "sounds the most reasonable" while requiring low cognitive reasoning.(Which in turn, turns into your 'loudest voice'). Notice that this means that that voice might not be correct, it's just that often people don't bother with good explanations of what/when/etc., they just whats something that validates their own view(which sadly often times leads to a negative outcome, especially when that view has been influenced before).
- a_conservative 5y agoThere seems to be a recursive aspect to this. Accusations of racism are used to silence (censor) voices. From the article: Charges of “racism,” for instance, are primarily deployed against the political opponents of upwardly-mobile, highly-educated progressive white people. Even to the point of branding prominent black or brown dissenters as race-traitors (despite the reality that, on average, blacks and Hispanics tend to be significantly more socially conservative and religious than whites).
- avereveard 5y ago> Charges of “racism,” for instance, are primarily deployed against the political opponents of upwardly-mobile, highly-educated progressive white people. Yep. Black people get to define our vocabulary. Internet throws a fit if someone squints their eyes and talk with a Asian accent. But go "bippity boppity mamma mia" gesticulating heavily, and everyone laughs.
- adamrezich 5y agoactually it's the loudest voice with the best appeal to emotion that gets to define what things mean.
- kleer001 5y agoI would say the loudest voices and it doesn't have to be very many of them at that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoThis isn't actually about the content, but I will say I find this style of using external links really annoying to read. If you're going to sprinkle so many links through your article at least give me an idea of what they're about.
- inglor_cz 5y ago100 years ago, a similar question was posed by Lenin: "Who, whom?" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who,_whom%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who,_whom%3F) This isn't really about definition of the word; it is about political power, because whoever gets this word branded on their forehead, loses.
- yasp 5y ago> The sovereign is he who selects the null hypothesis. https://www.unqualified-reservations.org/2012/11/adore-river-of-meat/ https://www.unqualified-reservations.org/2012/11/adore-river...
- traloid 5y agoInteresting, thanks. I never expected to agree with Moldbug.
- mattparcens 5y agoAside: (that's an excellent quote and logical point) - I read the Wikipedia article on the author of that essay, and got an extremely strong impression of being told how to feel about him, more so than being presented with facts about him.
- darksaints 5y agoThat's a pretty strained comparison. Lenin was talking about the economic struggle for dominance between two mutually exclusive ideologies, of which only one could win. There was no implication of being branded with an epithet for political dominance.
- aidenn0 5y agoTo be fair, there was only one item on the list of microagressions that didn't have at least 1/5 of all african-americans classify it as something other than "not offensive" (not sure what the other options are). If a black person is answering "Is this offensive to me" and the white person is answering "Is this offensive to some black people" the numbers make total sense.
- listless 5y agoI’ve often heard the argument that we need to change all GitHub repos from master to main because master has etymological origins in the concept of slavery, and is therefore a racist term. But I’ve always heard this argument made by white people. I wonder what percentage of black people working in technology find the term so offensive that it should be changed in every context.
- gunfighthacksaw 5y agoI think changing master/slave terminology is justified, but to me master branch suggests something like master key or master prints. That which is the superior and definitive example of the collection from which it comes.
- MrStonedOne 5y agoMaster apprentice is the better analogy. as once a branch is merged, it effectively becomes the master.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adamrezich 5y agosee how quickly that slope gets slippery?
- nlitened 5y agoShouldn’t universities rename master’s degree programs as well?
- avereveard 5y agoThat comes from master/pupil
- _-david-_ 5y agoIt is 2021 so context doesn't matter. Master can mean slave owner so it needs to change otherwise someone might be offended. /sarcasm
- wolverine876 5y ago> An important first step is to actually listen to people of color about their priorities and concerns ... I couldn't agree more, and it demonstrates what is (IMHO) the core problem: Q: Why are a bunch of mostly white people talking to each other about the definition of racism here on HN? It is somewhat absurd: If the topic was federated authentication, I would shut up and let the people who have direct experience and expertise with federated authentication talk. But there aren't many African-American or Hispanic people here - or at our workplaces, or in our social lives. (Yes, there are exceptions, but generally it's true for the HN audience.) We don't know because we don't have access to people who have direct experience and expertise (you wouldn't make any serious decision with that level of knowledge, don't try to do it here). That's how many issues well-known in minority communities stay hidden or are easily dismissed by white people - they are not in our realm of experience. We don't come to work and have a coworker upset because their child was abused by police, or can't follow their dream career because of racism, etc. I've made a point of getting outside the 'white experience bubble' (my term). I couldn't recommend it more - it is perspective-shifting, mind-altering. That bubble, once most of my universe, now seems like a small bizarro-world in the much wider universe of reality. It's not hard: Talk to African-Americans - not as 'Black People' but just as people, with their own experiences, etc. Essential: Shut up and listen; don't agree, disagree, prompt, cross-examine; just give people space; you know as much about racism as I know about federated authentication. Also, look around and notice when, in a country that is ~60% white, your environment is 99% white, and try to find somewhat more diverse spaces. When a bunch of white people start trying to derogate racism, laugh. To circle back to the article: One way to address racism (and that bubble) is to create environments where minority people feel welcome. Changing some words and customs is a cheap, easy way to do it, even if it's (inevitably) imperfect.
- uniqueid 5y agoOne approach might be to argue that relatively well-off and highly-educated liberal whites — by virtue of their college education and higher rates of consumption of ‘woke’ content in the media, online, etc. — simply understand the reality and dynamics of racism better than the average black or Hispanic. I would strongly advise against anyone taking a stand on that hill. I'd advise against that wording, which I think the author tailors to sound as preposterous and obnoxious as possible.
- wolverine876 5y agoHow would you word it?
- uniqueid 5y agoThe average person, of any so-called 'race', doesn't know much history, economics, law, philosophy or sociology. So it's not ridiculous to claim that a highly-educated person can perceive actual cases of racism that the victim, if lower-educated, cannot. First-hand experience is powerful in some situations, but worthless in others. If it weren't, diabetics wouldn't need doctors.
- gm3dmo 5y agos/woke/being nicer to people/g
- noptd 5y agoHaving witnessed individuals make that claim on a few occasions, I'd say it's entirely accurate though I'm sure we can haggle on percentages.
- f154hfds 5y agoMy employer recently required me to take a training course on privilege, allyship, implicit bias and intersectionality. It was something like 2 hours total spread over 4 trainings. I found it hard to directly criticize anything they said as the majority of it was common sense and anything objectionable wasn't so egregiously objectionable to warrant any real complaint from me (not that they gave me the option, feedback in the series was suspiciously absent). The main problem with it as mentioned in the article is the incessant fixation on victimhood. I feel that our culture's relationship to victimhood is no better than the ancients but just in the opposite extreme. Before there were precious few 'celebrated' victims (victims lifted up and supported by society) - they mostly lived and died in obscurity perhaps not even knowing the nature of their victimhood. Now we want to explore each person's past and expose anything that could possibly be construed as oppression/victimhood and expose it to the world. We end up with the other type of error: people presented as victims who aren't (relative to our perception, of course victimhood is on a spectrum). No one wants a society full of victims, but we equally can't have a society organized via victim hierarchy (intersectionality).
- taeric 5y agoOddly, this reminds me of the trope in a lot of fiction where the main protagonist has a super twisted back story. It is super tiring and doesn't seem to actually be necessary or informative.
- jessaustin 5y agoYou must not be a DC Comics fan? It's often useful to the plot for the protagonist to be separated completely from normal concerns (and support systems). In our crowded modern world, the hero's journey can't really be into the wild. Of course we'd all like less hackneyed plots, but it's not a perfect world... https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/DarkAndTroubledPast https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/DarkAndTroubledP... https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/DeceasedParentsAreTheBest https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/DeceasedParentsA... https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RapeAsBackstory https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RapeAsBackstory
- gm3dmo 5y agoI'd be happy with Dave Chappelle defining what's racist.
- kcplate 5y agoBy far the wisest comment on this thread.
- moth-fuzz 5y agoThe key phrase is identity politics - I hope internet discourse begins to move away from this framework, but as of now politics is entirely focused on the nouns - who, what, when. The immutable states of ones’ person. The answer is to move to a verb-based politics: what does this person do? What have they done? What do they say? What do they think? Are the dialectics good? Is the methodology sound? Does it make sense? Does it help? Does it hurt? People will say “listen to black people” while simultaneously dehumanizing all black people into a monolithic and tokenized opinion-vessel. I personally know black people, gay people, trans people, disabled people, who are exhausted of being that vessel. Of being a walking textbook for other people to memorize. The truth is that black people, and all people of color, are diverse culturally, emotionally, and intellectually and in order to be a good ally you have to not only listen to All of them, as well as your own heart, and you must use your critical thinking skills to determine what you personally think is correct - and act on it. You must be active and competent, and you must not regurgitate. At the end of the day there will be black people who agree with you and black people who disagree with you, but you can hope your efforts at activism will help both groups regardless.
- corey_moncure 5y ago> as of now politics is entirely focused on the nouns - who, what, when. The immutable states of ones’ person. The answer is to move to a verb-based politics: what does this person do? A sociology teacher I had at UMich said a lot of things I disagreed with but one idea that I'll never forget is that prior to the 20th Century, there were no homosexuals. Humans haven't changed- there were homosexual acts, which individuals may have practiced at varying levels according to the time and place in history. But it wasn't something that came to define one's identity until very recently in history.
- krapp 5y agorelated: "Shakespeare needs more gay[0]." [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZWMTGF1pNw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZWMTGF1pNw
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 5y ago...one of the very worst charges that can be leveled against someone – especially a white person – is to accuse them of being racist. This won't be true no matter how many times you repeat it. "As a white person", I have been accused of racism. My response was to apologize and attempt to do better in future. I have largely been successful in those better attempts. When I have fallen short, I have apologized again. At no point have I been fired or done prison time for my momentary racist episodes. TFA seems like a ridiculous attempt to incite the problem it poses as lamenting. Flagged.
- kyleee 5y agoYou've had momentary racist episodes? Does that happen frequently?
- jessaustin 5y agoYes that was explained in the immediately preceding paragraph: "As a white person", I have been accused of racism. Off the top of my head, I can think of three instances over the course of my life; there may have been others.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoThat does strike me as a bit odd. I don't think I've ever experienced anything like that nor have I met anyone else prone to do that. I hate to assume, and i mean no offence by this, but is something like this indicative of a mental illness? I can't imagine why else someone would be prone to have something like that happen to them.
- moistly 5y agoAnd you have not? I suppose I might believe you’ve never used “gypped” (c.f. Gypsy, which is itself a derogatory term for Roma)—if you’re quite young or don’t live in North America. I know I used it, up until I learned of its origin; now I try to avoid using it. Learning is fun.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y ago
- phkahler 5y ago>> Yet, white college students and graduates were significantly more likely than the average black or Hispanic respondent to brand these statements as “offensive.” This effect was especially pronounced among white highly-educated respondents who identified with the left. This is what is called Cancel Culture. It is really not OK to be offended on behalf of someone else. When people do this, they are infantilizing (is that a word?) the supposedly offended and some of them don't like that behavior. But go ahead and change your git repository to "main" instead of "master" just in case someone thinks it's some kind of slavery reference (everyone will update all their documentation and tutorials right?). Next we can work on your cars brakes (master cylinder), anything that involved master templates, certain golf tournaments, and what on earth are we going to do with all those masters degrees?
- darksaints 5y ago> This is what is called Cancel Culture. It is really not OK to be offended on behalf of someone else. When people do this, they are infantilizing (is that a word?) the supposedly offended and some of them don't like that behavior. The Cancel Culture term is one that is thrown around as if it is only something that leftists do. And with respect to projecting offense to perceived racism, the left certainly has that market covered. But what about projecting offense to veterans when someone takes a knee to the national anthem? The rush to define Cancel Culture is just as politically motivated and politically applied as the rush to define racism.
- d0gbread 5y agoThere is some nuance here you're glossing over. First, someone can be offended but not targeted. My dad's racist rants offend me, that's not cancel culture. And it's not on behalf of the group he's ranting about, it's because he's a savage. I'm offended by his lack of effort, empathy, and curious conversation. Second, surely you can appreciate the difference between master in a master-slave configuration and master as in, good at something. A masters degree doesn't imply a slave degree.
- phkahler 5y ago>> There is some nuance here you're glossing over. No, I'm not the one glossing over anything. git repositories don't have "slave" branches, just a "master' as in template or origin. It's other people who think every code repository needs to be renamed because they don't understand the difference. Or worse, since like the article indicates it's mostly highly "educated" white people that want this, they are implicitly saying other people don't understand the nuance (I wouldn't even use that word, since the situation is so far removed from slavery).
- myWindoonn 5y agoRacism is when people believe falsehoods about genetics and heritability, particularly when they believe that humans form multiple races. It's that simple. We should require sociologists to take an introductory course in molecular biology so that they grok this part of human nature. Edit: Downvoters should be required to also take a molecular biology course.
- jessaustin 5y agoVery few people care about genetics and heritability with respect to "race". In the spirit of charity I'd like to assume that no one commenting here cares about that.
- myWindoonn 5y agoI have bad news for you, then. Search "white people", "asian people", or "black people" with your search engine of choice, and use syntax like "site:news.ycombinator.com" to limit it to just our community. In the spirit of charity, I'll assume that you haven't done this search, and are blissfully unaware of the racist comments that tend to flow through this site. However, since we're relying on (Gricean) charity, let me point out that you're not following up with the maxim of relevance. The headline and article are centered around the question of the definition of racism, not whether the amount of racism exceeds some particular benchmark.
- jessaustin 5y agoThe racism under discussion here concerns social categories, not biological ones. That someone could in good faith fail to notice this strains credulity.
- dqpb 5y agoThat just reinforces how meaningless the concept is.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jet_32951 5y ago"The power to define is the most important power that we have. He is master who can define." -Stokely Carmichael So the question is crucial. It is lost within most debates and within most legal judgments, yet it is the foundation of argument. Muzzy definitions provoke disagreement without the participants' understanding. Clear definitions are the bedrock of reasonable conclusions. The article doesn't specify the answer either. It appears to enter into a circular argument: that because "woke" leftist white people habitually get the nod, they do here too. There is something fundamentally wrong here but I cannot put my finger on it.
- noobermin 5y agoI feel like the author dismisses the other explanation too easily. I might be wrong, but I don't really know if it's "educated whites" more than just "educated people" who yes, unfortunately skew white. If there is evidence educated POC also take this stand then I suppose I stand corrected. For example, a lot of "woke stuff" I hear or see from activists or sociology educated creators on youtube or twitter are people of color. A very controversial analogy I can give which I hope is not in misunderstood is analogous in degree is child sexual abuse. I forget where I read it but because children are innocent, they don't often feel hurt from the initial abuse. However, from growing and becoming aware what had happened does the nature of the abuse become apparent to them after which the trauma begins to become real. Hopefully in this case it is clear that "not being aware x is bad" is not a sufficient argument for "x is not really bad." I feel like on some level that is well below this analogy in terms of severity and mere obliviousness to the overall connotation of what might be happening (as we're talking about adults who are merely oblivious to facts of history or power relations in society) lie acts or systems of racial discrimination. For example, perhaps a black person trying to get financing to buy a home in the 60s wasn't aware of redlining and instead might merely interpret it as being how things are. It does not mean that that obliviousness meant it was okay and that such harm crept into other areas that were more apparent and directly felt (like lower rates of wealth for blacks, and thus more exposure to crime and neglect in communities). The average poor person of color would be cognizant of the more apparent ills of ghettos while not really being aware (and thus offended) by the deeper structural causes of the more apparent ills. Another example, a new refrain amongst some activist is that urban highways are a legacy of racism. This is a true fact if you look at the history, urban highways often demolished poor parts of a city and divided the remaining poor neighborhoods from well-off neighborhoods, intensifying segregation and its ills. If you ask an average poor person if they think urban highways are a source of ills for them today, they'd probably say no even though it is a fact that it was. Even for someone without a car who is more likely to be a victim of road fatality (poor POC are more likely to be victims of pedestrian fatality from car drivers) they may know life is harder for them in general without a car but they simply are unaware of it being a system of power (car culture) that has a lot of roots in history and isn't merely the state of nature. Anyway, while I feel like it is good for academics to be tempered by the groups they want to understand (that's fair and should be a key consideration, of course), people really should not discount sociologists and their research, especially as not all of them are white and some do in fact experience said systems of power they critique and have in addition tools and knowledge of history to put said analysis in context.
- dqpb 5y agoI’ll take a stab at it. A racist is somebody who believes in race.
- akomtu 5y agoIt's the belief that you are your body and that one body model is better than another body model. The first belief is considered a self-evident truth today because questioning it is "unscientific". The second isn't really wrong, but when it's mixed with the first idea, it turns into racism.
- lambertsimnel 5y agoI understand your comment as suggesting that body models are races, but I take a different view. Maybe, other things being equal, some heritable traits are good. People possessing them might have superior body models. However, I think racism needs two more beliefs: 1) that race objectively exists 2) that race correlates with superior/inferior body models
- akomtu 5y agoRace as the body type exists in the same sense car models exist. Some could argue that SUVs are superior to sport cars. Whether race exists objectively is another question. Per some schools of buddhism, material things don't exist objectively because they lack their own substance.
- dqpb 5y ago> Race as the body type exists in the same sense car models exist Really? How many body types are there?
- akomtu 5y agoMany. Asians, Africans and Europeans are three notable subtypes. But again, if this makes you feel agitated, that's because of the belief that body is a permanent extension of the human's true self. Once this "scientific" idea is analysed and rejected, the clouds of emotions will clear.
- jrm4 5y agoHaha, am I like literally the only black person here? I'm serious, I've been scrolling down and I don't see anyone else? Anyway, to try to summarize it all; Nothing surprising about the article; the difficulty comes in where very well meaning people try to come up with concrete/discrete "solutions" to racism, which is difficult. My take on most of them is, yeah, a lot of them are awkward and clumsy, but a hell of a lot better than nothing? It's a conversation. Anecdotally, I'm remembering a thing where at my alma mater they wanted to change the name of a title from "House Master" to "Faculty Dean." Fundamentally, like, who cares either way? It's really not important..but For me, the most telling thing wasn't so much the name itself (which me and my friends had a ton of jokes over), but how much people appeared to be invested in keeping the old name, as if it were that special, i.e. -- as people tried to defend the old name and just had terrible arguments for doing so, it became clear that the cause was "something else," i.e. if the old name was "House Leader" or something, I'm 100% certain those same people would NOT have been fighting that hard. So yeah, it's complicated.
- chrismcb 5y agoPeople also don't like change, especially when it seems nonsensical. In your specific case I could see some friction against the term "Dean" as it has a connotation that might but apply here. When I was in University they changed the logo. There was a huge uproar. Mainly it didn't make much sense. If course, now, decades later I love it. But just because people don't want to change doesn't always mean racism is involved.
- jrm4 5y agoRight -- but of course you're bringing up the HUGER issue of "what is racism?" - where the binary of "racist" or "not racist" is hugely deficient and frequently unhelpful. The easiest way I can think to explain it: e.g. Any white person who openly calls me the n-word is very likely a harmless loser to me. More likely to harm me and others; a more powerful person who's intelligent enough not to use it, but may wield language strategically, like perhaps while trying to get elected, denigrates the black opponent by saying "let's not monkey this up." That person might actually like black people, and was being strategic to get racists votes through the dog-whistle, since they have plausible deniability. The second guy feels "less racist," right? BUT HE'S MUCH WORSE THAN THE FIRST GUY in my opinion.
- pix64 5y agoNew rule, HN is only for technical discussions. This thread is full of ugly, thoughtless garbage.
- dqpb 5y agoI would argue that “Who gets to define what’s ‘racist’?” is a technical question.
- cycomanic 5y agoWhile the article makes some good points, I find the quoting in the article highly problematic and I expect much better from an academic. There are multiple examples were the sources actually do not say what they are being quoted for, for example the citations about the harmfulness of the perception of race, or the argument on the non exist ant connection between implicit and actual racism (the cited sources say that the test hasn't lived up to scientific standards, which does not necessarily mean that implicit racism doesn't exist). They also compare numbers in different studies to each other which really doesn't work. I do agree that we need to have a discussion about how we deal with racism and be careful to ever expand its definition, but we should be have this discussion evidence based and not try to resort to strategies of selective quoting.
- ed4bb9fb7c 5y agoI always wanted to know where does this put me in the American race war: - I come from Eastern Europe - my ancestors were enslaved, bought and sold for hundreds of years as far as we know - my family was raped, prosecuted and killed by NKVD, KGB and has been through gulag - my family always struggled with poverty and only hard work and education of multiple generations got me where I am - I’m white and didn’t see a person of color until I went abroad - I emigrated to US 10 years ago Company trainings are obviously a wrong place to ask this but: what is my place in the racism discourse? Why am I lumped with all the white people group and forced to “accept” white privilege? How do I get out of this madness without hurting myself?
- RickJWagner 5y ago"Racism is not dead, but it is on life support — kept alive by politicians, race hustlers and people who get a sense of superiority by denouncing others as 'racists.'" -- Thomas Sowell