3 ms·
Let's consider your comments applied to another ethical area: eugenics. That was a previous area where scientists did something which is now considered highly
by dekhn 5y ago
Let's consider your comments applied to another ethical area: eugenics. That was a previous area where scientists did something which is now considered highly unethical (remove the sexual autonomy of people due to incorrect scientific judgements). Would you say the people who opposed eugenics were "shaming" the scientists, or helping "guide them to making better decisions?"
I think there are many concerns around ethics in AI, but the majority of the players are not contributing (folks like Timnit, with the stochastic parrots paper, the sections on power consumption are completely technically wrong). Sara Hooker is a much better spokesperson for this, but I'm really struggling to see the point in her paper, beyond "we should identify existing data biases and make algorithmic changes to reduce them" which just sounds like "we need regularization that is the opposite of L1 and L2".
- 908B64B197 5y agoIt's interesting you had to pick illegal practices to attempt to make a point, while my point was that ethics was used to shame practices when the legal system couldn't be used because of a lack of rigor.
- dekhn 5y agoeugenics wasn't illegal at the time. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/14/science/haunted-files-the-eugenics-record-office-recreates-a-dark-time-in-a-laboratorys-past.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/14/science/haunted-files-the... When the Eugenics Record Office opened its doors in 1910, the founding scientists were considered progressives, intent on applying classic genetics to breeding better citizens. Funding poured in from the Rockefeller family and the Carnegie Institution. Charles Davenport, a prolific Harvard biologist, and his colleague, Harry H. Laughlin, led the charge. ... By the 1920s, the office had begun to influence the United States government. Laughlin testified before Congress, advocating forced sterilization and anti-immigration laws. Congress complied. The Immigration Act of 1924 effectively barred Eastern Europeans, Jews, Arabs and East Asians from entering the country. And, at the state level, thousands of people who were deemed unfit were sterilized.
- claudiawerner 5y ago>while my point was that ethics was used to shame practices when the legal system couldn't be used because of a lack of rigor. I'm confused as to why that would be a bad thing. For instance, liars are shamed, even though it would be ridiculous (and harmful) to create laws against lying in all cases. At the same time, the law sometimes takes account of ethics (rather than harm) to make laws, for example, the illegality of corpse desecration is not about harm, but about ethics - what it says about our society if it were legal.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> For instance, liars are shamed, even though it would be ridiculous (and harmful) to create laws against lying in all cases. But lying under oath or false advertising are illegal. > for example, the illegality of corpse desecration is not about harm, but about ethics - what it says about our society if it were legal. That's morals, not ethics. And it's rooted in religions.
- claudiawerner 5y ago>But lying under oath or false advertising are illegal. That's why I said "in all cases". Clearly, lying isn't only immoral in the cases of lying under oath or false advertising. It's still immoral for me to say that a ball is "out" in tennis when I clearly saw that it's "in", even if doing so is not illegal in most cases. >That's morals, not ethics. And it's rooted in religions. The difference is immaterial. Even most ethical codes are rooted in religious thinking at some poitn in their formation. That doesn't make them invalid ethical codes. Ethical codes are generally constructed on the basis of morality, or in some cases on the basis of professional conduct - but even that isn't only practical.
- visarga 5y ago"Liars are shamed" had a different meaning in 1990's than today. We've gotten to the point of pervasive surveillance and infinite storage. That's why public shaming, a social tool based on mob justice, is becoming an even worse act of violence. It destroys lives with little due process, riding on powerful preexisting social and political emotions.
- bobcostas55 5y agoThere was nothing incorrect about their scientific judgments. Modern behavioral genetics have confirmed both the concerns and the potential effectiveness of the eugenicists. What changed was that, as a society, we no longer think the trade-off is worth it: we are now willing to sacrifice future generations to quiet down our conscience. How much of this is actually a considered choice, and how much of it is simply down to the fact that future people aren't around to complain...I'll leave it to you to decide.
- dekhn 5y agoI think you're probably limiting yourself to the idea that "selection can be applied to human breeding" which I do agree seems to be scientifically possible. They were roughly correct about that (but far from being able to exploit that knowledge). The ethical concerns in eugenics weren't about that at all, though, they are about removing autonomy from people based on morally and scientifically questionable ideas (the eugenicists had many more scientific ideas which were just not supported by data, then ones that were).
- AlbertCory 5y agoYour first paragraph is called the Motte and Bailey fallacy [1]. You can't win your original argument, so you pick a different one that's easier, and then pretend that you won the original. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy
- 908B64B197 5y agoIronically, it's just what Timnit Gebru did. "I can't prove algorithms are unethical, therefore I'll make a point that the (clean) energy used to train them contributes to global warming (by assuming all the energy required came from jet fuel)". [0] And then ethics tries to claim it's a real science! [0] https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/12/04/1013294/google-ai-ethics-research-paper-forced-out-timnit-gebru/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/12/04/1013294/google-a...
- rhizome 5y agoSince "I can't prove algorithms are unethical" implies a demand or requirement to prove a negative, I'm inclined to conclude that you're misrepresenting your source.
- dekhn 5y agoWhat is truly extraordinary about that paper is that it completely ignored the fact that ML is only a tiny contributor to overall power usage in computing, and also attempted to compare the training to intercontentintal flights, which use the same amount of fuel empty of full (and the planes do fly nearly empty). All of it makes it look like she just wanted to attack ML, rather than make a good faith argument. The other part of the paper (the danger of trusting things that stochastically parrot well enough to exit the right side of the uncanny valley) is interesting.
- visarga 5y agoI think she's all to willing to throw the baby (the transformer model) with the bath water. She doesn't care about AI advancement at all, and that makes me distrust her paper.