6 ms·
Point-to-point Wi-Fi bridging between buildings–the cheap and easy way
- gandalfian 5y agoHe used tp-link gadgets to go 80m through some tree to his shed. Glad he's happy but not really that far? 800m would have been more interesting.
- unstatusthequo 5y agoFor $100, not bad though. Sure you could do Ubiquiti, but not for $100 and since a lot of Ubiquiti gear is sold out right now, at least he got it done.
- Scoundreller 5y agoIf you just need one ptp link, you should be able to find a used set of their older stuff. It’s an 80m link and you’re not trying to keep your CPEs consistent like a WISP.
- mustardo 5y agoThats what I did, used second hand locoM2 units from a WISP for $20-40 each
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tshaddox 5y agoIt was interesting to me because I had no idea there was relatively affordable consumer gear like this. I was into “cantennas” back around 2005 or so but hadn’t thought or read about point to point wireless connectivity for many years.
- gregsadetsky 5y agoMikrotik has a number of point-to-point products [0] some of which are pretty inexpensive ($50 per device). Promotional material for the DISC Lite5 mention a ~5-10km range. The LDF [1] in particular is intriguing -- it is "meant to be installed on satellite offset dish antennas" i.e. you can re-use a (potentially already installed) dish antenna as a reflector. Configuring these devices is not exactly intuitive though. [0] https://mikrotik.com/products/group/wireless-systems https://mikrotik.com/products/group/wireless-systems [1] https://mikrotik.com/product/rbldf_5nd#fndtn-gallery https://mikrotik.com/product/rbldf_5nd#fndtn-gallery
- jcrawfordor 5y agoWatch out, it's 100% possible to do long ranges over WiFi but the speed tradeoff at long distances can be significant. Devices made for long-range use will either autoselect or allow you to manually select an encoding, which will need to be lower-rate as the range increases. Documentation often gives radio performance values for different encodings, e.g. the Mikrotik DISC Lite5 gives Tx and Rx specs starting from 6Mbps (essentially 802.11a) up to MCS9 (256 QAM) which can do well over a gigabit. We can do some naive calculations to estimate that MCS9 is achievable at up to 5km (really pushing it) while 6Mbps works out to 50km or more! In practice there are other factors that will limit these because you start getting into fresnel zones and such, especially as you get over a few km. The Ubiquiti devices are a bit more expensive but are easier to work with than Mikrotik. They also have higher-end options available for very long range use, 50-100km type scenarios, although the data rate gets very low.
- gtvwill 5y agoMikrotik has gear for punching that far. Mikrotik > ubiquiti. If the setup is overwhelming you probably don't have the knowledge to legally throw a WiFi >500m and not get arrested. (You need acma license in aus for any links >800m off memory). You shouldn't be doing long WiFi links if you don't know what your doing. On the shorter end of things tho lol mikrotiks new app make setup as pleb as ubiquiti if you need that level of simplicity. Devices cost about 1/3rd too. I don't sell anything else for WiFi or networking unless you need >10gb mmwave....which you don't.
- bostonsre 5y agoThink I've read that these things can go a lot further. Took a look at them a while back and they are pretty neat. Was contemplating getting one for my apartment and one for my backpack so I could work on the lake in front of my apartment.
- gerdesj 5y agoI ran ethernet down to my summer house about the same distance. The first 30m in external grade 25mm plastic round conduit, then underground. 1.5 to 2 spade depth, 2" of gravel/stones/whatever to run water out. I used underground stable plastic conduit, weld glued together. At 0.75ish spade depth, I put a black/yellow warning tape. I ran two CAT6 cables. I ran a SWA (steel wire armoured) power cable down too in an earlier project and have four double IP66 (EU regs for water and dust ingress - 66 is good for an accidental spray from a hose) My garden backs onto a park and my summerhouse has a POE switch with an AP in it. I can get wifi in the park to quite a long range. I also have a DECT extender in the summerhouse. The range I can use my house phones (I have an IP PBX) is pretty mad.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoHe also had one of the access points attached to a cat-scratching post in the house. I found the user-contributed installation hints to be helpful: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/point-to-point-wi-fi-bridging-between-buildings-the-cheap-and-easy-way/?comments=1&post=40157966 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/point-to-point-wi-fi...
- jessaustin 5y agoIt's nice to try out something new and write about it. In this case, IEEE 1901 devices would probably be cheaper, faster, and more reliable than IEEE 802.11. Also, that doesn't look like "80m" to my eye... if that distance is correct it implies that the hatchback is between 7m and 8m long, which seems about twice what one would expect.
- Scoundreller 5y ago> Most people in rural areas should use 2.4 GHz for its greater range and penetration Uhhhh, well; 900mhz would be better if you need penetration. As for range, the higher the frequency, the narrower the fresnel lenses and therefore the better the range you get without tall towers. What makes 2.4 particularly usable in rural areas is that you’ll have the lowest amount of interference (usually). What I like about this install is that they’re going through glass, which might even be worse for RF than the barn wall.
- jareklupinski 5y agoI forgot whether throughput was at all a function of bandwidth, and google reassured me that so did the entire first page of results https://www.reddit.com/r/networking/comments/5w7yt9/everyone_says_900mhz_throughput_is_super_low_is/ https://www.reddit.com/r/networking/comments/5w7yt9/everyone... 100Mb/s seems to be the upper limit of a perfect link? That would be cutting it close for a single family all on zoom/netflix at the same time. Edit: thought buildings meant like "apartment buildings", not single family residences on both ends
- tuatoru 5y ago> What makes 2.4 particularly usable in rural areas is that It's incredibly cheap, being mass produced and mature, and it works fine up to a few kilometres. Replacement is so easy and cheap, that it's not worth bothering with lightning arresters and all the rest (except if fire is a major consideration.)
- UI_at_80x24 5y agoI'm disappointed in this article for several reasons. Ars used to be such a great tech/news site. I would have much more interested if they had dug a trench, installed fiber, or hell UTP CAT5 or CAT6. [0] This wasn't a 'tricky' task, you are operating within spec of all network cabling released in the last 20+ years. As another posted pointed out, 800m would have made for a more interesting story even if it was just buried fiber-optic cabling. The other part that annoys me is that no foresight for the future was taken into consideration. Let's assume that there are no trees blocking the line-of-site between the two antennas. Will it remain clear and obstruction free for the next 10 years? What about 20? I have a cable conduit installed between my house and my garage. 30'ish feet. That conduit has not had a problem since 1985 when it was installed. The cabling was upgraded from intercom to phone to network CAT5. Being out in the elements will age your equipment. Future proofing AKA How often do you want to climb up that ladder: Wireless tech has horrible shelf life and is quickly surpassed. Data needs are always increasing. The 1Gb/s switch I installed back in the 2000's can still handle the workload today, but the wireless AP I installed 5 years ago is buckling under the load that it can't accommodate. This article is as impressive as telling us the story of how they might have upgraded their service from 1Mb/s DSL to 10Mb/s cable. [0]For twisted-pair Ethernet, maximum cable length is 100 m (Cat-6A for 10GBASE-T, Cat-5e for 1000BASE-T or 100BASE-TX, Cat-3 for 10BASE-T).
- Johnny555 5y agoA $100 wifi link with off the shelf equipment sounds more interesting to me (and applicable to my life) than a $1000 trench with fiber.
- 0x000000001 5y agoWhy are Americans allergic to aerial cable runs? Fiber and Ethernet are low/no voltage and don't need to be buried to comply with the electrical code.
- Johnny555 5y agoI can't speak for all Americans, but in the two cases when I've set up a Wifi link: #1 - I don't really want an aerial cable running through my back yard, plus it'd have to be pretty high to give enough clearance for the septic pumping truck. #2 - running cable between the 10th and 13th floor of buildings across the street from each other would require permission from both building owners, and maybe a permit from the city too. While a wifi link just sits in the windows on each side.
- j_walter 5y agoI've used Ubiquity AirMAX products (2x nano m900 if I remember correctly) for my point to point network sharing between my house and shop for a few years now without issue. Both are PoE and both ends transmit through walls without much signal loss. I don't need super fast throughput since it's just a shop, but I still get >100Mbps consistently.
- lisnake 5y agoI've built 2 km radio bridge to my parents house over congested city area using 2 ubiquiti airFiber routers. Wasn't even that hard. I think they were using 60ghz spectrum
- Faaak 5y agoI used ubiquiti rocket M5 to go from my house (without internet) to my parents house (21km away). It works well (50mbit/s). For the curious: https://www.reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/j4y4f4/my_21km_p2p_ubiquiti_link/ https://www.reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/j4y4f4/my_21km_p2p...
- ant6n 5y agoIs there more than one photo?
- xvf22 5y agoFirst comment mentions more pictures. " More pictures here: https://imgur.com/gallery/zqLVEh5 https://imgur.com/gallery/zqLVEh5 "
- morjom 5y agoOn a somewhat related note, is there something like this but for connecting to towers? I currently live in a (I suspect) pretty Faraday cagey house right now and been thinking of ways to get better signal strength.
- tuatoru 5y agoCellular service towers? Yes, "signal boosters" exist. Make sure you get a licensed one, and it will probably have to go into some register of radio transmitters. Hopefully the license is only a one-time cost.
- JustFinishedBSG 5y agoYes https://mikrotik.com/products/group/lte-5g-products https://mikrotik.com/products/group/lte-5g-products
- bserge 5y agoI used a couple of these: https://www.tp-link.com/us/business-networking/antenna-and-accessory/tl-ant2424b/ https://www.tp-link.com/us/business-networking/antenna-and-a... And 2 cheap Asus routers for 400 meters. Would've likely worked for twice that distance. Iirc the total cost was less than 200 Euros. Pretty cheap and easy, too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- supermatt 5y agoI have a few tplink cpe210. To provide access throughout my farm. They are great, but every year I have had to replace one of them as they simply stop working.