5 ms·
A popular theory is that this was motivated by the government somehow, and they had to comply by hiding it under the guise of something else.
by userbinator 5y ago
A popular theory is that this was motivated by the government somehow, and they had to comply by hiding it under the guise of something else.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoIt could be the other way around. Interesting thoughts: https://mobile.twitter.com/benadida/status/1424764923717066758 https://mobile.twitter.com/benadida/status/14247649237170667... > I don’t see a huge threat to privacy, but I’m not sure how this meaningfully stops CSAM. My guess: Apple is trying to stave off more heavy-handed gov intervention. Thread:
- dmitryminkovsky 5y ago> Apple is trying to stave off more heavy-handed gov intervention. This is an interesting and charitable interpretation, but if so, then this tactic will fail. As others here have pointed out: with this capability in place, the only thing stopping them from total intrusion is now merely policy. And that's scary and dangerous.
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoYeah and FYI it is not my position on the issue and adding because I found the thread curious. I just can’t even begin to imagine what a gigantic company like Apple’s real government relations are like however.
- matwood 5y agoI think what is making people uncomfortable is the realization it's always been policy.
- Macha 5y agoYou could argue that it's policy to develop or not develop this feature, but if the feature doesn't exist, you could always refuse the update that provides it, whereas if apple adds tiananmen-square.jpg to this list in China after the feature is out there, then you don't know until you're already screwed.
- matwood 5y agoThe list is only updated with new versions of iOS. So if that's a concern wait until new versions are compared against old prior to updating. Downloading the list outside an iOS update would be a new 'feature' just for China. If we're in that mode, then Apple could also have just added scanning for only China. Finally, the list is an intersection from at least two jurisdictions. I think there is plenty of good debate to have around this feature, but I also think it's important to start with the discussing the feature as is today.
- Macha 5y agoI have to disagree - I think with the ease of extending the feature, and the track record of similar features being extended, we need to consider the long term implications. Not doing so in previous instances is how we got UK ISP filters for CSAM extended to copyrighted material, for example.
- kalleboo 5y agoApple doesn't even need to add scanning "just for China", all Chinese data is stored on the servers of a Chinese partner.
- matwood 5y agoCorrect, but people keep pointing to China as a state entity that will abuse the new system.
- shuckles 5y agoA lot of people who claim that this feature made it “easy” to scope creep don’t appreciate that Apple escrows everyone’s keys for its “end to end encrypted” messaging service. Who would be able to tell if they dropped a couple extra keys in that list? I can think of dozens of security and privacy claims on iOS that are a simple configuration change away from being totally defeated.
- headShrinker 5y agoThere is big talk of a federal anti-trust against Apple. The rumors have been swirling for months. Apples CSAM initiative might be an attempt to cool things off at the justice department. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/apples-hot-antitrust-autumn-storm-clouds-are-forming-from-multiple-directions-11628711809 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/apples-hot-antitrust-autum...
- dahfizz 5y agoWhat does CSAM have to do with anti-trust suits?
- vegetablepotpie 5y agoWhat does politics have to do with politics?
- MerlinDE 5y agoAnti child abuse measures are regularly utilized to push for measures you otherwise can‘t establish. Most of the time surveillance and censorship. Just look back 10+ years to Germany, where „Zensursula“ tried to establish DNS blocking for the media industry by arguing for child safety. The approach is always the same. Just this time, Apple has so many devices in the market, that if this succeeds we‘ll all be headed for surveillance disaster. Given that fact that Snowden’s revelations didn’t generate ANY actions within the public, I doubt to see any actions this time.
- wpietri 5y agoTwo things. One is political give and take. As their people negotiate with particular political actors, "We'll give you nothing," works much less well than, "We can't give you X, but how about Y?" The other is that the tech giants are looking unaccountable and antisocial. Privacy absolutism is popular here, but there are real social costs to it, so it's not popular everywhere. If Apple can say, "Yes, privacy is important, but we're not crazy; we agree we don't want to help out child pornographers", then that is much better positioning.
- 5y ago
- ryeguy_24 5y agoCould it be that Apple thought that child pornography was going to get the most sympathy from society for this general approach of scanning libraries? They may have expected some HN push back but maybe hoped for some halfway decent press related to helping combat this abuse. I ask that question in curiosity but I'm super skeptical because this is actually surveillance.
- sk2020 5y agoThe implementation also means Apple has plausible deniability if the “CSAM” in their database actually contains images associated with political enemies of whatever regime supplies the source material. How would you know the hash you are testing against isn’t just a Winnie the Pooh? You really can’t. Really, it’s probably the best way to keep the police state from destroying your business while trying to sleep at night.