6 ms·
> Every country props up its auto industry, so why worry about a domestic supply? War. In the event a war breaks out, a running auto plant can be re-tooled rel
by shadowgovt 5y ago
> Every country props up its auto industry, so why worry about a domestic supply?
War. In the event a war breaks out, a running auto plant can be re-tooled relatively rapidly into a light and heavy armor plant. It's not even a question of whether allies could supply tanks and troop transports; it's about having domestic capacity to make them because enemies could execute blockades and disrupt allied resource supply.
- sonthonax 5y agoIs that still true now?
- shadowgovt 5y agoGreat question. It's still doctrinally true (i.e. governments believe it is true; it was one of the reasons cited for the US federal government buying key stake in domestic auto manufacturers instead of letting them go bankrupt during the real estate market crash), but whether light and heavy armor is actually of military worth in an era of drones and air power is a question I don't have the military training or knowledge to answer.
- starfallg 5y agoYes, because heavy industry produces light and heavy armour, and heavy industry is also required to produce military drones and other weapons.
- sonthonax 5y agoI'm unsure whether you can still retool an automotive factory to produce war materiel. During WWII Ford automotive plants produced aircraft, but back then the construction techniques needed to build a bomber weren't all together different from a car (think larger engines and chassis). > whether light and heavy armor is actually of military worth in an era of drones and air power is a question I don't have the military training or knowledge to answer. On this point, it obviously depends on what kind of war we're fighting. The British used unarmoured and open top Land Rovers with 50cals mounted on the rear for the first few years in Afghanistan until the government got its act together (they looked cool, but were IED death traps). There's a similar story with the Humvee. Nonetheless, civilian style vehicles had their use.
- mywittyname 5y agoYes. One scary fact that I learned is that, in war games between China and the USA, China almost always wins due to superior production capacity. Those $100B American battle carriers and $40MM advanced fighter jets can be taken out by $50,000 rockets/missiles produced at a rate of hundreds or thousands per day.
- huge87 5y agoThis is in line with my intuitions; do you have any sources so I can read more?
- mywittyname 5y agoSure! https://www.stripes.com/theaters/us/2021-07-27/US-China-military-war-game-hyten-2326077.html https://www.stripes.com/theaters/us/2021-07-27/US-China-mili...
- onepointsixC 5y agoThat doesn't support your core thesis that the US will lose a protracted war and that mass producing missiles is going to actually led to planes being destroyed. That's not how that works.
- NotSammyHagar 5y agoNotice this resembles somewhat (in reverse) the WW2 situation with high quality German tanks and Japanese Zeros etc and the us making many more tanks and planes compared to the Germans and Japanese. But we are on the other side of that now.
- alisonkisk 5y agoIsn't the reverse also true?
- lallysingh 5y agoYup, but that leaves you at a draw for existing assets and you depend on production capacity after that.
- bumby 5y agoYes, I remember an article on HN a while back that referenced a DoD report stating a dwindling manufacturing base as a major national security risk. Related, they track a “manufacturing readiness” metric
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoArmored vehicles are a little over 100 years old invention. That's only a few human generations.
- humaniania 5y agoNuclear armed countries going to war is supposed to be an extinction level event. That's the whole point. It's supposed to be unthinkable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_assured_destruction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_assured_destruction
- starfallg 5y agoThat's the same reason why food security is so high up on domestic priorities also. If a country is dependant on other nations for food, then in case of war you just need to target their logistics chain to starve them into submission. All those subsidies make sense, if you view the nation-state as primarily concerned with its own survival.
- Scoundreller 5y agoThis is Canada. We ain’t going to run out of food. The funny thing about a centrally-planned dairy system is that it takes very little disruption to destabilize it.
- starfallg 5y agoAs a fellow Canadian (living in the UK currently), we may like to think of ourselves as an independent and sovereign nation, but we are very much tied to the hip with the US in terms of defence. Our food security strategy hence is also aligned as such.
- flavius29663 5y agothis. If you look at all the strategic industry subsidies, you will see this common denominator. Corn in the US is stupidly subsidized, so much corn that it ends up in car tanks. But guess who will not have a famine even if the worst war + disasters strike? Car factories might not make good tanks, but the mechanical engineers and tooling knowledge is invaluable and can't be scaled up overnight. Same with solar panels, there's a reason both Obama and Trump imposed protective tariffs. One of the few areas both parties agree to. PV panels are the future of energy, so you need to have domestic factories no matter the cost.
- jbay808 5y ago> PV panels are the future of energy, so you need to have domestic factories no matter the cost. Another benefit of domestic factories is domestic innovation. It's much harder for an engineer coming out of university and going through their career working at an office computer terminal to ever make a breakthrough innovation, if they can't step inside the factory to see how things are really done. If that factory is down the street, it's much easier to do an apprenticeship, get a tour, or chat with the manager about their pain points. If it's in another country, you'll have to schedule a formal visit and you'll probably need to be a very important customer for that to happen. Grad students coming out of a research lab would tend to focus on getting an extra 0.2% cell efficiency, but it's more likely that the innovation that makes PV competitive is something like reducing the scrap rate, or figuring out how to run cells through the QC machines more quickly.
- Scoundreller 5y ago> Corn in the US is stupidly subsidized, so much corn that it ends up in car tanks What would the land be doing without subsidies?
- freemint 5y agoServe nature? Keep bio diversity and be a buffer for nature.
- hypertele-Xii 5y ago> guess who will not have a famine even if the worst war + disasters strike? Worst? Really? You think corn fields survive nuclear war? An asteroid the size of you know what?
- NotSammyHagar 5y agoExcept for getting subcomponents and today ics are the crucial thing. What do you bomb first, the ic manufacturing of the other side? Or take it away by force (like Taiwan's).
- namelessoracle 5y agoI am skeptical that a modern automobile factory could be converted to make tanks or airplanes at any kind of scale using current designs. The stuff is so specialized and automated now that even the workers probably wouldn't have much translatable knowledge as WW2 days. You would i guess have a supply of welders to lean on at least that would ramp up faster than someone fresh. But I doubt a factory that makes modern cars can handle making M1 Abrams without so much additional tooling and extra equipment that you are halfway to making a new factory anyways. (they could probably handle making light vehicles like cars and bikes at least) Maybe if we had mass production style designs that were built purpose first to get cranked out. But we don't, and there isn't profit in that for the Military Industrial Complex.