3 ms·
What is the pitch for the hyperloop? If you owned a 300 mile right of way between your two destinations, is it actually substantially better than a train in te
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
What is the pitch for the hyperloop?
If you owned a 300 mile right of way between your two destinations, is it actually substantially better than a train in terms of speed or energy use? Or is it only because it can burrow under existing infrastructure that it becomes worth doing?
- stonemetal12 5y agoMy understanding is the main benefit is reduced energy consumption because of low wind resistance. Otherwise it would be your "average" high speed rail.
- marcosdumay 5y ago> is it actually substantially better than a train in terms of speed or energy use? That's the idea. You can get one or the other, or a mix of them, but if it's built, you'll probably get speed, because energy consumption isn't a viable commercial feature of high-cost transportation.
- credit_guy 5y agoSeveral points: * cheaper to acquire rights to build. Elon envisioned the tubes suspended on some pillars built on the median strip of existing highways. No need for eminent domain, or difficult land acquisition negotiations * much lower air resistance: the pressure (and so density) of the air in the tube is supposed to be about 100 times lower than the atmospheric pressure. So the air resistance should also be 100 times lower for the same speed. * lower track maintenance: high speed trains are supported by steel wheels getting in touch with steel rails on a tiny area. Therefore tremendous pressure and vibrations. The load of the hyperloop train is supported over a huge area via air pressure. The load felt by every single square inch of the tube should be thousands of times lower than the load felt by the train rails when the wheels pass over. * potentially higher speed.
- renox 5y agoI doubt that there are many credible pich for the hyperloop.. Especially when one of the selling point of the hyperloop was that they would use "air cushion" to float above the ground but then they switched to "magnetic levitation" so now it's a maglev train variant, an even more expensive one than the current maglev trains..