24 ms·
To be honest... None. It's a choice. You might wholly disagree, but recent events aren't enough to get me to switch yet, because I think the competition has to
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
To be honest... None.
It's a choice. You might wholly disagree, but recent events aren't enough to get me to switch yet, because I think the competition has too many tradeoffs.
I can get my photos scanned against a CSAM database... or I can have Google tracking my location constantly regardless of what they say (as they've been proven to be misleading in the past)... or I can use a Linux phone and say goodbye to battery life and useful apps I need. I'll pick CSAM Scanning over my Location data being in the hands of Google, sorry.
And as for my laptop, macOS doesn't scan, and the M1 is too impressive and has me spoiled. And I have too many horror stories with both Linux and Windows and can't stand either of them. (Don't tell me switch to Linux - I've tried over a dozen distributions over the last decade. It's just not there yet.)
- netsec_burn 5y agoAOSP/FDroid would be a middle ground for your requirements, no?
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI've tried that too. But I work from home and not having the ability to use Banking apps on AOSP without a ton of patching and hacks that could fail anytime afterwards is an issue. Also the camera performance on AOSP is noticeably worse in my experience, and I'm not alone. To make AOSP "usable" for my life, I need to install the Play Store. At which point I've already lost and would prefer an iPhone for my privacy.
- RMPR 5y ago> To make AOSP "usable" for my life, I need to install the Play Store. At which point I've already lost and would prefer an iPhone for my privacy. To be fair you don't need to, I use Aurora Store, they have a guest mode where you don't need to register any account.
- ByteWelder 5y agoThere are plenty of Android flavours that don't have Google apps, like https://lineage.microg.org/ https://lineage.microg.org/ In my limited experience so far, LineageOS works much better than it used to on my HTC Desire. Battery life has been better than any of my iPhones (3G, 4S, 5S, 7 and XS) ever had. That said, if I had to chose between a Google Android phone and an Apple phone, I'd still pick the Apple one. Luckily there are more choices these days.
- mylons 5y agoandroid is no where near competitive with apple’s user XP. i was a long term android user until 3ish years ago. i’ll never go back to a fragmented device ecosystem again if i can help it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alangibson 5y agoIt's like QWERTY vs Dvorak. The best one is the one you're used to. I personally find Windows and iOS frustrating, but I know it's because I'm used to Linux and Android.
- mylons 5y agothat’s not true. i just gave an example of switching from what i was used to, to something new that i thought was superior.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoWhy would fragmentation be a problem as an Android user?
- mylons 5y agogoogle doesn't control for device screen sizes, software that other vendors load on, or the CPU/ram/storage on the phone, watch, or tablet. they also allow 3rd party app stores. this creates an experience that is out of google's control and in a lot of cases is sub optimal for the user. it's not as stream lined or polished as it could be.
- runjake 5y agoPlus, in the same use case (photos in the cloud), they’re still being scanned for CSAM and probably piracy and whatever else Google scans for.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoGoogle has been scanning photos for CSAM for... what, almost a decade now? Also, as an iPhone user, contrary to the recent Hacker News fight, I actually view this CSAM scanning with a sign of hope, because this hints that we could get end-to-end encryption on iCloud Storage. The CSAM scanning is rumored to be just a prerequisite to get the government to shut up with their biggest critique of E2E, so that Apple can then turn it on. If I can get E2E storage from iCloud but accept CSAM scanning on my device to satisfy the law... I'm OK with that choice. You might not, in which case, Android (and I'll probably buy a backup Android phone "just in case").
- sigmar 5y agoOh yes, I'm sure the FBI will be satisfied with using the backdoor to only find CSAM, they definitely will not use the access for 'anti-terrorism' and drug enforcement. That sounds just like the FBI. What good is E2E encryption when they can scan your client with a backdoor? All Apple is doing with this hashing is giving themselves plausible deniability when this access gets abused down the road. "Oh we didn't know they would use those hashes to arrest those protesters, we couldn't have foreseen this"
- gjsman-1000 5y agoE2E with some scanning at the onramp is still much better than no E2E. If iCloud was compromised, your data is still safe, among many other reasons. If the US Military physically raided the data center and carted out all the hard drives, my data would still be secure. It's still a better alternative. It's not perfect by any stretch, but it's better than what we have now. Also you are aware Google Photos, Facebook, etc. do scanning anyway and have for almost a decade?
- deleted 5y ago
- 0x0 5y agomacOS has been announced to scan just like iOS
- gjsman-1000 5y agoIncorrect. It will use a generic model to warn children that they could be exposed to nudity, but that runs on-device and sends nothing to Apple. (It's just a generic nudity detection model). On iOS and iPadOS, they will implement the iCloud Photos CSAM scanning, but Apple left out macOS as having that for now. Rumoredly according to GitHub reverse-engineers of the system, it's due to the mathematical precision of the NeuralHash algorithm being processor-dependent on ARM and not Intel.
- 0x0 5y agoFrom https://www.apple.com/child-safety/ https://www.apple.com/child-safety/ : > These features are coming later this year in updates to iOS 15, iPadOS 15, watchOS 8, and macOS Monterey.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoIn that case, I'm not sure. The people reverse-engineering the algorithm say they aren't quite sure if that's because the system hasn't shown up in MacOS Developer Previews yet (where it has in iOS and iPadOS), or if that's because they are referring to the generic nudity detection instead of the database matching system. For now, the security experts looking at this say that the nudity detection model is on all platforms, but the database matching in iCloud Photos is only on iOS and iPadOS and it's unclear whether it will come to macOS.
- djrogers 5y agoThat's at the end of a summary of all 3 features. Each one has the specific OSs listed though: > iOS and iPadOS will use new applications of cryptography to help limit the spread of CSAM online
- tpush 5y agoIt's a bit confusing; 2 paragraphs above that line: "Next, iOS and iPadOS will use new applications of cryptography to help limit the spread of CSAM online, while designing for user privacy." That implies macOS isn't getting the CSAM scanning stuff (yet?).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- scoopertrooper 5y agoExactly, I think people are just getting a little too worked up over this whole thing. Apple computes a hash of each image you upload to iCloud then check it against a list of CP hashes. Of all the things in the world to get worked up over, this is ridiculous. I get it, the mechanism they're using has apparent flaws, and maybe some whacko could somehow get access to your phone and start uploading things that trick the algorithm into thinking you have CP. But, that alone is such a ridiculous phobia, if someone has that level of access to your phone, they could upload real CP and maybe even upload it to your Facebook for good measure.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoAlso, all of the "situations" where this could be abused are already applicable on all other platforms. There's no reason your Ex couldn't upload CSAM to your Google Photos account, or to your Facebook account. Google Photos and predecessors have scanned since, what, 2013?, and would detect it, and would report it to law enforcement. Despite this having been a possibility for almost a decade... there's a suspicious lack of headlines of this attack occurring.
- carnitas 5y agoApple hashes all of your photos offline and then pinky promises to only check the hashes against the official on phone database when the user initiated an upload. The problem isn’t about wackos it’s about governments forcing Apple to do things with this new weapon
- gjsman-1000 5y agoEvery other cloud storage provider has implemented scanning since 2011-2013.
- merpnderp 5y agoI haven't seen a single person concerned about Apple scanning photos in iCloud. The problem is entirely that the scan is happening on your personal phone with apparently some janky implementation that in one week has already shown to have serious flaws.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rhn_mk1 5y ago> I can get my photos scanned against a CSAM database... or I can have Google tracking my location constantly That's a false dichotomy. There are competitors offering various levels of maturity and functionality. Jolla exists, PinePhone, Xiaomi, Librem 5, dumb phones, POTS landline, no phone... And yes, Linux on the desktop is also a valid choice. It most likely won't track you either.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThere's a reason why that's 98%+ of the market. There is a dichotomy between the two camps in the smartphone market, everyone else is fringe. On the fringe, good luck using banking apps, transit apps, vehicle rental apps, or other apps increasingly necessary and useful. I don't think you know what you are talking about when you mentioned Xiaomi as an option. That would be among the dumbest options you could possibly choose. Linux on the desktop is a valid choice, but as I said above, don't tell me to switch to it, it's just not practical in my life. I've tried over a dozen distributions since 2011 and probably over fifty releases of them, and Linux isn't there.
- mateuszf 5y ago> On the fringe, good luck using banking apps Tried that yesterday on CalyxOs with anonymous MicroG account and my banking app works fine. No problem with contactless nfc payments.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoAren't anonymous microG accounts illegal though? (Or at least a violation of the TOS.) Also you can't use any paid apps with this method.
- mateuszf 5y agoMaybe a violation of TOS, but I guess it's one of these things that would not be enforced at all. Same way as Oracle can't do much about Google using Java or Microsoft doesn't do anything about Wine. Regarding the second point - that's true. I've heard there are some plans to add payments to the Aurora store/F-Droid (which are alternative app stores) but right now you can't use paid apps. I consider this to be a plus though - gives me a chance to switch to open-source / self-hosted apps.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI'm reasonably confident that Google listens to every conversation I have within earshot of my phone. It isn't uncommon to find things in my news feed that are related to things I have no interest in but a friend or coworker had just mentioned to me in passing.
- guerrilla 5y agoWhat do you say about the people who have tested this and found nothing?
- hnfong 5y agoAB testing?
- laurentlbm 5y agoMaybe Google heard them say that they were going to test!
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoThere's a good chance I'm wrong, but it certainly seems like that's what's going on. I haven't seen anyone's testing of this, but it is also possible their methodology is flawed.
- thealistra 5y agoAt work you have the same IP. Your coworker may have googled what he was taking about. This is a much easier explaination than a constant mic monitoring for arbitrary phrases
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoThere are a lot of people at this company, and my news feed doesn't diverge enough to account for all of their varied google searches.
- zepto 5y ago
- cassianoleal 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28118619 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28118619 macOS does _something_ related to this system. It's unclear what though. I agree with how impressive the M1 is. I've replaced my 16" fully specced i9 with a 13" M1 Air. The only thing I sometimes miss is the larger screen but not by much.
- redisman 5y agoI find it funny how many people pick a random Chinese phone in their bid for privacy (???)
- neuronic 5y agoThat’s not a bid for privacy, it’s a bid for spite. Picking a Chinese phone based on financial circumstances, however, is understandable IMO.
- system16 5y agoI think it's less about privacy and more about what the invading actor will/can actually do. People are less concerned about the Chinese government's reach vs. the NSA or other three letter agencies in the US. I suppose if you are important enough to the Chinese government whatever they have on you could be used as blackmail, but most 'regular' people don't fall into that category.
- imwillofficial 5y ago> People are less concerned about the Chinese government's reach vs. the NSA Wait what? You’re 180 degrees wrong.
- dmantis 5y agoHe is right. US has complete power over people on their soil and basically in Europe and Asia as well. They do a LOT of extraditions of other countries citizens when they go traveling or to business trips from their citizenship countries. China, on the other hand, does not seem to give a single f* about foreigners, only about their own citizens. Most people are not so are not really endangered even if chinese spyers do know what they handle on their phones. So in battle between US spyers/China spyers I'd better give my data to Chinese, if I don't have a choice not to share my data at all. China, as well, don't try to make extraterritorial laws (like financial regulations), so it's harder to even be targeted by CCP if your are a foreigner.
- 5y ago
- fartcannon 5y agoWhat would they have to do to lose your business? Literally get you arrested? You're financially supporting the creation of an Orwellian dystopia.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoEvery other cloud provider has scanned since 2013. We're already in the Orwellian dystopia.
- nicce 5y agoI think Apple is the only major company who tries at least a little to resist Orwellian dystopia. Business model of other companies cannot allow resisting.
- Keats 5y agoAre we talking about the major company that is happy to give access to all of their users content if the country (eg China) asks? If they were really serious about privacy they would not operate under those conditions.
- nicce 5y agoCompany can't operate in the country, if they don't follow country's rules. Sad truth. They should have left the China in that case. On their defense, they have given only information which is stored by their system, not actively increasing the collection of it or creation of backdoors.
- fartcannon 5y agoLineage and Linux exist and they're incredible. You've simply give up.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoLineage requires the Play Store to have paid apps or things I now pretty-much need for everyday life, at which point you've lost and it doesn't really matter whether it's Lineage or stock Android. Linux is incredible... and still unusable for many everyday apps and workflows, and simply not an option for many people including myself. I've tried Linux distributions since 2011, they aren't there yet.
- imwillofficial 5y agoIt never will be there. A focused group of devs who care about details will always beat design by committee. Always.
- giancarlostoro 5y agoIt's only a matter of time before Google starts doing the same thing. I can't imagine Google wont do it eventually.
- bengale 5y agoI don't think they will. They already scan it all in the cloud, and the benefit of doing it on device is for user privacy, that's not something google gives a shit about.
- giancarlostoro 5y agoAll it takes is "Pedophiles are using Android to share images with one another in person by disabling uploading images to the cloud" or something like that to be a headline and the pressure will be on to follow Apple's direction.
- TrueGeek 5y agoOr does it already and didn't feel the need to make a press release.
- corndoge 5y ago> It's just not there yet Respectfully, it is there. You are not. Which is fine - I prefer a Mac for general purpose computer use, word processing, web browsing, that sort of thing. But Linux can do these things just as well, it just requires you to configure them, which is strictly a "you" constraint and not a failure of the system.
- BlueParanoia 5y agoThis is a pretty bad argument. You can apply that "you're the constraint" logic to tons of bad designs and products and claim they're not actually bad. Linux is not necessary a bad system, but usability (degree of effort, burden of knowledge, misuse risk) are absolutely a core determination on where or not a piece of technology is "there yet"
- fsflover 5y ago> degree of effort, burden of knowledge, misuse risk I don't understand what you mean. My non-technical relatives use Linux just fine. There is no "burden of knowledge".
- pshirshov 5y ago> I think the competition has too many tradeoffs. I believe that, for example, anticorruption activists and gay people in Russia who may be subjected to state-imposed surveillance won't agree with you. Apple won't leave even the russian market in case the government demands to expand capabilities of the system. And they will never leave chinese market. > macOS doesn't scan I'm afraid I have some bad news for you: "Features to detect child abuse material stored on iCloud coming in updates to US users iOS 15, iPadOS 15, watchOS 8, and macOS Monterey."
- BugsJustFindMe 5y ago> Apple won't leave even the russian market in case the government demands to expand capabilities of the system. And they will never leave chinese market. Who will? Google? Microsoft? HP? Dell? Huawei or Xiaomi or Lenovo (lol jk)? Which computer or phone manufacturers or service providers refuse to do business in Russia and China?
- pshirshov 5y agoJFYI Google left China. Not sure about Russia. Anyway that's not an excuse for implementing such a neat surveillance tool. Fortunately for now you have some escape hatches. I believe that it would be a smart move for everyone to stop paying for nooses for their own gallows and start investing into privacy. There are some realistic ways to do it, just buy a damn Fairphone for a no-brainer start.
- BugsJustFindMe 5y ago> JFYI Google left China I know they did briefly after some attacks, but I also know that they had very little market share to lose at the time and have subsequently worked to get back in. Do you have a good summary of their current position there?
- pshirshov 5y ago> Do you have a good summary of their current position there? Nope, why would I? Also I'm pro-google, just pointed to a fact I know.
- racl101 5y agoSame here.
- bastardoperator 5y agoThis^ For me it boils down to ecosystem and integration. I can have a fragmented set of devices and tools, or I can deal with CSAM having literally zero impact on me. I also have an M1 laptop, it's insane that this little MacBook Air with 16GB ram is walking all over a 16'inch Macbook Pro with 64GB ram.
- intricatedetail 5y agoWhen a pedo gets released from prison, in some jurisdictions they are required to have scanning software installed on their devices. Apple makes every customer a suspected pedo. If you are comfortable with being treated this way, whatever floats your boat. Not everyone fancy receiving the same treatment as criminal on parole.
- xtracto 5y agoAgreed, I use Linux as my desktop PC (gaming and tinkering), Mac as my work PC and the Windows computer I had just died (Surface Pro 4). My mobile is an Android. I don't any hardware or software developer... I don't really care if the US is reading my emails, images, chats and whatnot. I choose not to worry about those sort of things. My product choices are more related to functionality and basic ROI.
- androidu 5y agothis. It's 21st century people, we care about usability... What simplifies in my life if I'm moving away from any ecosystem that tracks me to the OSS way, do I have to compile my own Chromium over the night? "oh, my Linux segfaulted, let's reinstall the OS" time. Saving time on these operations is worth more than some X-company sniffing my network traffic. Yes, I care about privacy, I always decline the cookie pop-ups, always ask for GDPR contract before handing over my phone no./email to recruiters et. al. I'm doing my best without breaking usability & affecting time spent on these operations.