9 ms·
United Airlines bans duct tape restraints
- mholm 5y ago> Please remember that there are designated items onboard that may be used in difficult situations, and alternative measures such as tape should never be used.” I'd be curious what these are, and why the instinct is to use tape instead of them. Stun guns? Rope? A strongly worded letter?
- moftz 5y agoHandcuffs or zipties mgiht be onboard.
- im_down_w_otp 5y agoI think they have zip-tie restraints for wrists and ankles, but I don't know if they have anything available for muzzling.
- Hamuko 5y agoDo they actually need to muzzle people?
- relax88 5y agoHow exactly do you suggest restraining someone to a seat who is trying to bite you? Like imagine you’ve got them on the ground in the aisle and need to get them restrained in a seat… muzzling seems like a good plan to me.
- Hamuko 5y agoI mean, I'm no expert on restraining, but I think there are ways to restraining a person that attempts to bite you. I don't think the cops are reaching for the ball gag when they need to get someone cuffed and into a seat.
- relax88 5y agoCops have back seats in their cars with a plexiglass screen and doors that don’t open from the inside. They also have tasers, pepper spray, and batons. No such thing exists on an airplane so you would have to tie them to the seat somehow.
- treeman79 5y agoFlight attendants aren’t exactly know for being big and beefy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vorpalhex 5y agoThere are generally two methods of restraining a biting person as far as I know. One is to muzzle/duct tape/etc. The other is to bounce their head off the concrete until they stop trying to bite you. While we could assign airline attendants a concrete block as part of their kit, concrete blocks weigh quite a bit and are not FAA approved. I therefore recommend we go the duct tape route.
- jcims 5y agoYeah you have a cop on each arm to stretch them out and lay a third on top of them to drop elbows on their head until they stop.
- varelse 5y agoIf they're screaming at the top of their lungs solely to annoy I suspect that's quite reasonable. What's unfortunate here is that a tiny minority of people have ruined domestic travel with their behavior. It's such a shame that there's no way we could impose some sort of requirement, a sort of passport if you will, on passengers that would eliminate just about all of this. But I can dream.
- globular-toast 5y agoIt's called a class system.
- arp242 5y ago> What's unfortunate here is that a tiny minority of people have ruined domestic travel with their behavior. Isn't this sort of thing fairly rare? Usually when things are "in the news" it means it fairly uncommon, because if it happens frequently it's no longer "news". I haven't flown since COVID though, and never any domestic US flights either.
- varelse 5y agoSo these incidents seem to happen once every week or two. So is your position here that if there were a commercial passenger airline crash every week or two, people wouldn't and shouldn't reconsider flying? I haven't flown either and I have no plans to do so in the near future until either a vaccine passport system is imposed or the pandemic ends. I can wait.
- papercrane 5y agoIf they are attempting to bite people or spitting, definitely yes.
- mullingitover 5y agoYes, when they're assaulting you with saliva, a biohazard. However I think that a ventilated bag over the head is probably safer. Blocking the mouth is risky.
- Hamuko 5y agoI mean, at the moment in aviation history, they would be wearing a mask. I don't think that's going to be easily removable if you're cuffed.
- 0_____0 5y agoThat exists and I know at least police use them. Called spit hoods.
- mullingitover 5y agoThey use them sometimes, other times they just punch the restrained suspect in the face[1]. [1] https://ktla.com/news/local-news/lapd-officer-under-investigation-for-alleged-excessive-use-of-force/ https://ktla.com/news/local-news/lapd-officer-under-investig...
- bgribble 5y agoThat was the only thing about the video that disturbed me. Duct taping the dude to the seat was fine, but putting duct tape over his mouth is super dangerous. He could easily have barfed and been in real trouble.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoI would rather have a bag over my head. I've always had a fear of something over my mouth because my allergies are usually so bad I breath through my mouth.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mc32 5y agoThis is a legitimate concern. Someone could have a hard time breathing. That said, what is the option when someone starts shouting obscenities throughout a flight? Tranquilize them?
- Hamuko 5y ago>That said, what is the option when someone starts shouting obscenities throughout a flight? Ignoring them until they tire themselves out.
- mc32 5y agoNormal people yes. People hopped on something? I hope they have options, though maybe the best is off board them at the next airport and bill them.
- nradov 5y agoLand at the nearest safe airport and have them removed by law enforcement. Tolerate the noise until then. It won't hurt anyone.
- L_226 5y agoI thought the captain has a taser available usually
- macintux 5y agoThat seems worse. Harder to accidentally kill someone with duct tape.
- shapefrog 5y agoNot only is a taser still a lethal weapon in some circumstances, its effects dont necessarily last for the remainder of a flight. Most likely use would be to temporarily subdue someone to then restrain them.
- phreeza 5y agoIsn't the procedure these days that the pilots are pretty much locked in to the cockpit and can only get out when the door is reasonably secured from people charging it? I would imagine that could be hard to ensure in situations where a taser may be needed.
- CrazyStat 5y agoOn a recent Delta flight I was seated near the front and got a good view of this. When one of the pilots came out to use the lavatory one of the flight attendants stood with the food service cart turned sideways blocking the aisle at the front of the business class cabin.
- shapefrog 5y agoFluffy handcuffs and ball gags are available in the galley.
- seneca 5y ago> Fluffy handcuffs and ball gags are available in the galley Please don't make low effort posts like this here.
- striking 5y agoFrom the actual source article (https://www.newsweek.com/united-airlines-warns-flights-attendants-memo-not-duct-tape-unruly-passengers-seats-1619883 https://www.newsweek.com/united-airlines-warns-flights-atten...), > Flight attendants used duct tape to restrain an agitated and disruptive man who was able to slip out of handcuffs on a flight in 2003, according to reporting from the Associated Press. And again in 2008, a woman who physically attacked both passengers and flight attendants got the duct tape treatment on a United flight according to The Seattle Times. > A spokesperson for United declined to identify the "designated items onboard" the memo advises using instead of duct tape.
- OJFord 5y agoBut from the submission (perhaps edited since): > Unruly flyers aboard United Airlines may be detained by seat belts and plastic hand cuffs, but duct tape won’t be one of the tools utilized
- mumblemumble 5y agoThat may not be an exhaustive list.
- OJFord 5y agoOf course. I just don't think a different article saying UA declined to comment is more informative than this one thinking it knows at least some of the list.
- robjan 5y agoHandcuffs (not fluffy, as mentioned by a sibling). No key, just a latch. They are easy to release in case of emergency. Source: was cabin crew and use of cuffs was part of the training.
- mc32 5y agoI don’t see how handcuffs are better? They have the potential to injure the agitated person as well as crew trying to restrain the perp. Duct tape is gentler as well as does the job it’s being enlisted to do.
- robjan 5y agoDuck tape is harder to remove in case of an emergency. With the cuffs the latch is in a position well known to the crew so they can just be taken off.
- Hamuko 5y agoHandcuffs are specifically made for cuffing hands whereas tape is made to hold stuff together. If injuries are a concern, there are also medical-grade restraints that are less dangerous than metal handcuffs.
- mc32 5y agoGood points. Are there different kinds of handcuffs? I’m under the impression they’re designed to bind one forearm to the other, rather than bind a forearm to immovable object. Zip ties while used for temporary restraint by LEOs has weaknesses but medical restraints seem reasonable.
- falcolas 5y agoHandcuffs seem... insufficient when we're talking about someone allegedly kicking at a window.
- rrdharan 5y agoThe passenger was able to escape from the handcuffs.
- mc32 5y agoIsn’t United a union shop? Can’t the members talk any sense into the union?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lentil_soup 5y agoFrom the article: "Unruly flyers aboard United Airlines may be detained by seat belts and plastic hand cuffs"
- tyleo 5y agoDuct tape is a bad look… but if it gets to the point where it seems necessary, I don’t see why not. It’s not like people are being duct toed to seats on a whim. One of these passengers tried to kick out a window.
- willis936 5y agoIs it a bad look? If they don't get into legal hot water then it seems like a powerful marketing tool.
- gruez 5y ago> If they don't get into legal hot water I think that's what they're worried about, hence the notice.
- vlan0 5y ago>One of these passengers tried to kick out a window. Right? If someone attempts to cause structural damage at 30k feet, I'm going to stop that person with any means necessary.
- relax88 5y agoYeah, I would have zero hesitation choking that person out if they were trying to kick a window or open a door. Even if there is a risk of killing them.
- Stevvo 5y agoSomeone trying to kick through a window or open a door does not pose any threat to you. The door will not open. The window itself is strong enough to withstand any kick that someone could put on it, but that is largely irrelevant as there is the a scratch pane, and that additional window with the tiny hole in the bottom in front of it for additional protection. If you're holding a choke hold beyond the point someone has passed out, i.e. "risking killing them", then YOU are the danger to others in that situation, not mentally ill dude trying in futility to exit the aircraft at 36000ft.
- 99mans 5y agoSame United that was punching customers in the face last year?
- nikkinana 5y agoThey need to give everyone a psychological test before boarding.
- SerLava 5y agoThose crew members were heroes.
- tantalor 5y ago> use the items aboard flights designed to keep flyers at their seats > there are designated items onboard that may be used Burying the lead here. What are these items?
- kilroy123 5y agoIt's my understanding (I could be wrong) that they use a belt that's not attached to a seat. I think it might even be an extender that they hand out to parents with children on their laps.
- OJFord 5y agoMaybe it's been edited, this wasn't buried but right at the top, well before bit you quoted: > Unruly flyers aboard United Airlines may be detained by seat belts and plastic hand cuffs, but duct tape won’t be one of the tools utilized
- tantalor 5y agoOh missed that. Thanks!
- sp332 5y agoThe first line of the article says seat belts and plastic hand cuffs.
- MattGaiser 5y agoWhat else are you supposed to do with such people? There are a certain number of problem people in the human population who will need forcible containment at some point. They exist. Some people will pretend they don't for political and marketing reasons, but they exist.
- treeman79 5y agoThese days the solutions seem to be to punish everyone aside from the abuser.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- javajosh 5y agoThe world is so crazy, I'm just grateful that the passengers were not arrested for assault, or some other bullshit charge, simply for taking their fate in their own hands and restraining that asshole with available materials.
- justin66 5y agoTruly, that autistic kid and his disabled mother coulda brought down the entire plane by "kicking out the window." Those passengers are the heroic reincarnation of Charles Bronson and Clint Eastwood, or would be if Clint Eastwood were dead. It takes a lot of courage to put "assholes" like that in their place!
- warning26 5y agoI guess they’re worried about the optics, but honestly if the passengers are being a problem, I don’t really care what happens to them. Maybe what we really need is in-flight executions to permanently eliminate the threat on this and all future flights.
- my123 5y agoYes, because somebody might freak out/panic on an airplane, let them die! What are you even thinking?
- ARandomerDude 5y agoQuick executions by a crowd involved in the situation without adequate time to reflect or examine evidence. What could go wrong?
- jacob019 5y agoMy sympathy is with the flight crew. They didn't sign up to be police. They have spent the last year having to enforce mask rules. Meanwhile people have been losing their minds and bad behavior has become more common and even encouraged by a segment of the population. Imagine being a flight attendant and having to restrain someone physically, that sounds horrible. They should be given training and tools, and a bonus if they have to go through that.
- anon321321323 5y agoAnd what does this alternative look like? I'm unconvinced. Duct tape visually shows that someone was being so bad they needed to be restrained. I'd argue this is great optics: we care about passengers. And people who get duct taped are visibly restrained with no decorum. They are easily identified as having done something unacceptable and stupid.
- OJFord 5y agoThe article opens: > Unruly flyers aboard United Airlines may be detained by seat belts and plastic hand cuffs, but duct tape won’t be one of the tools utilized
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- striking 5y agoArchive: https://archive.is/7D68c https://archive.is/7D68c See also the actual source article, https://www.newsweek.com/united-airlines-warns-flights-attendants-memo-not-duct-tape-unruly-passengers-seats-1619883 https://www.newsweek.com/united-airlines-warns-flights-atten...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rdiddly 5y agoThe "optics" here might be the opposite: United's leadership is craven and terrified of bad press. Anyway I guess when flying United I'll have to bring my own duct tape!
- mnw21cam 5y agoYou might get some funny looks when you take that through security.
- csilverman 5y agoUm...if you're being physically disruptive on an aircraft in flight, and the only way to subdue you is physical restraint, I think nearly any non-lethal (and, ideally, minimally injurious) method is warranted. This isn't like when that Kentucky doctor got dragged off an airplane in 2017. Clear and present threats to a planeload of people require proportionate measures. Honestly, given the way people are behaving today, I think every plane should have security personnel. Flight attendants should not be responsible for subduing violent passengers.
- post_break 5y agoThe pilots union isn't going to go for this. Remember the pilot is god once the plane is in the air. And if he says tape him to the chair, he's getting taped. They are not going to risk zip ties or seat belts if someone is trying to fight staff and other passengers. And if he's spitting and biting? He's getting tape over his mouth too.
- pseingatl 5y agoThe window pane that the passenger has access to is not the pane in contact with the outside of the aircraft.
- hkchad 5y ago"Instead, he is asking crews to use the items aboard flights designed to keep flyers at their seats" Oh you mean like beating them over the head with this food tray? Sounds so much better.
- thrower123 5y agoIf only there were some safe way to just pump knockout gas into the cabin once everybody is boarded and strapped in, and then wake you up just before landing, air travel would be so much more pleasant.
- mnw21cam 5y agoThe Russians tried that when they had a hostage crisis [0]. It did not go well. Out of 850 hostages, up to 130 of them died due to the effects of the knockout gas. There's a reason why when you have medical surgery, you are knocked out by a highly trained specialist whose sole job during the entire procedure is to monitor your health and make sure you are responding in exactly the right way to the knockout drugs. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_theater_hostage_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_theater_hostage_crisis
- thrower123 5y ago> If only there were some safe way
- mnw21cam 5y agoI guess the other thing to note is that in an emergency I think the crew would very much like it if the passengers were alert and able to evacuate the plane on their own steam.
- clint 5y agoWon't be flying on United any time soon I guess
- encoderer 5y agoPossibly I’m cynical but I imagine duct tape leaves a mess all over the seat. Please, restrain people in a way that doesn’t cost us anything!
- chriscappuccio 5y agoI thought the frontier incident used restraint tape, it's like duct tape in size but only sticks to itself
- abledon 5y agoThe Musical Remix of the recent ducktape event, told by Alfredo Rivera: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aitLrOPSoI8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aitLrOPSoI8 (original interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XFoXmnBuLw0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XFoXmnBuLw0)
- nanis 5y agoHow many of the second guessers there have actually been in physical struggles where they are trying to restrain a person "gently" when the other person does not want to cooperate at all?
- AlbertCory 5y agoMy one and only encounter with unruly passengers (no duct taping in this one): A guy was standing in the aisle screaming, using obscenities and saying the terrorists stole his luggage in LA. A voice on the intercom asked if there were any off-duty cops on the plane. There were. They asked for the people in one block of seats to volunteer to be moved. I heard one of the cops talking to the guy. He said "Do you understand what I'm saying to you?" (I guess he was ranting about the terrorists.) The cop said "Do you understand what I'm saying to YOU?" They moved him to a window seat and occupied the other two seats in the block so he couldn't move. He was quiet. When I walked past his seat on the way to the bathroom, I deliberately didn't look at him so I don't know if he was cuffed, but I think he was (see next paragraph). The plane made an emergency landing and some cops came on board and took him off. He went quietly. I think he was cuffed but I'm not sure. So did the off-duty cops "de-escalate" the situation? I guess they did, but the duct taped kid was a different story and we can't say if that would have worked on him.
- justin66 5y agoThere are a lot of deranged internet tough guy vigilante fantasies being displayed here today, but the most fantastical idea of all is that airline aisles are big enough for someone to properly kick a window, or do anything other than be squeezed or hunched over uncomfortably.
- dmix 5y agoUnless better alternatives are actually provided to airline staff the idea of banning one option over another risks just making more dangerous options more likely. All just for optics. What are the realistic other options here? Ultimately restraint is going to be the only last resort + least violent option. Whether to the seat or somewhere else. Are they going to provide restraint belts? Plastic ties? And for what, both hands and legs assuming they don’t try to kick or slam into things? Attachable to seats or wrapped around? None of these sound nice. But providing these other restraint tools also makes people think they will be more liable to use them, before exploring other options. There’s no easy solution if there is going to be one regulated by the airline.
- angryasian 5y agoSadly we are at the point that with each cabin crew, there does need to be an assigned security that will be able to properly restrain and use force if necessary. The US passengers in particular are absolutely insane.