4 ms·
> This meant your employer would routinely check up on all aspects of your personal life. Your pay was docked if you weren't married, you home was too dirty, yo
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> This meant your employer would routinely check up on all aspects of your personal life. Your pay was docked if you weren't married, you home was too dirty, you didn't save enough of your wages, you didn't speak English well enough, your kids weren't regularly attending school, and if you got drunk after work.
Employers can demand you give them urine, blood or hair samples to prove that you haven't smoked a joint sometime within the last 30 days. They can give you psychological assessments, and personal value assessments, and deny you employment based on the results. Sometimes they assess the level of your conformity, by assessing how well you'll fit into their culture.
They can deny employment based on your credit score, or via private background checking companies that don't have to give them accurate information about you. They can use your biometrics to track you, and they can hand those biometrics to private companies like Clearview AI[1] to track you outside of work. While you're at work, they can point several cameras at you, recording everything you do and say from multiple angles, and storing it indefinitely. Some companies will spy on you with monitoring apps on your phones and computers, a risk that goes up exponentially if you need certain apps to do your job, or if you're using company equipment. If they don't like what you're doing, they'll fire you.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22681207 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22681207
- version_five 5y agoSomehow your post reminded me of John Lennon's Working class hero which basically captures this entire discussion, and was written in 1970. So I'm questioning my post above a little bit, although I don't think Lennon was contemplating the modern situation.
- slg 5y agoI disagree with almost all of those practices, but they are all arguably related to job performance in one way or another while many of the checks Ford conducted didn't have that clear connection (although he would probably argue otherwise). For example, I don't think it is necessarily accurate to believe that someone with worse credit is more likely to embezzle company funds, but it is a much straighter line to that conclusion than a married employee being a better worker. And as I said further down this thread: Things aren't universally better and they aren't getting better quick enough for most of our liking, but let's not ignore that improvements have been made.
- retrac 5y ago> than a married employee being a better worker Especially back then, but even now, it is thought that married men are, on average, are more likely to be the settled type. Dependable and boring. It was not a belief idiosyncratic to Ford. I think the idea is the man has children and a wife to feed to keep him in place and coming in to work, and also to keep him so busy and tired he stays out of trouble. Whether this weird psychological theorizing is true of course, I don't know. (Married men do die in car crashes less, today.) See all that psychometry stuff some employers do. Seems no more reliable.
- mschuster91 5y ago> I think the idea is the man has children and a wife to feed to keep him in place and coming in to work, and also to keep him so busy and tired he stays out of trouble. A bit cynical, but this is in my opinion a large part of the reason why politics is so utterly dysfunctional these days: when large parts of the population don't have the time to participate in democracy because they have to work two or more jobs to make rent, there are a couple effects from that: 1) the weight of those rich enough to go voting matters more. Basically, vote day not being a holiday in the US gives the votes of rich people and old retirees vastly more weight than they should have in a world where everyone had equal possibility to go and vote. 2) the opinion of those who have enough time and resources (paywalls...) to access decent journalism matters more, because under-informed people voting "by outrage" got manipulated in their decisionmaking process. 3) People who have to worry about getting fired for getting sick definitely won't unionize or go on strike.
- raxxorrax 5y agoYou get what you and others demand. If you accept this, it will increase, if you just leave for greener pastures, these companies have to adjust. Given, you need to have leverage on the working market of course. But if you have, not using it would not be to your benefit.
- teddyh 5y agoYou’re just blaming the victim. Reigning in these exploitative practices is the role of government, not the responsibility of an individual worker.
- clipradiowallet 5y agoPersonally I'm happy for opportunities to work. Just my opinion...but no employer owes me anything, other than compensation for work performed. You mention that reigning in these "exploitative practices" is the role of government, but I respectfully disagree. The role of government [to me] is physical safety against foreign invaders, and enforcing our laws. If these practices you speak of are so exploitative that they violate [labor] laws, then the governments role is to step in and enforce their laws. Otherwise, it seems like asking for government to decide what they accept/reject as "acceptable", and I don't trust my government(US) to do that.
- teddyh 5y agoLabor laws are not a mysterious force of nature; they were created by government, precisely to prevent exploitation by employers. The role of government is not only to enforce laws, but also to create new laws which reflect the collective understanding of fairness and create economic incentives which are beneficial to society as a whole. A society where laws are set in stone and unchanging is a society doomed to stagnation and decline.