4 ms·
Your words seem measured and reasonable, yet your final paragraph makes no sense at all. How does nuclear help avoid the need for battery storage on a carbon f
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Your words seem measured and reasonable, yet your final paragraph makes no sense at all.
How does nuclear help avoid the need for battery storage on a carbon free grid?
So many people claim this, and yet as I say it makes no actual sense. Has anyone attempted to flesh this proposal out beyond a snarky comment every time renewables get mentioned on a news article?
I'd love to be proved wrong, but as far as I'm aware there's no way building any more nuclear today makes sense unless you believe that solar and wind renewables and battery storage and green hydrogen are some kind of elaborate hoax that doesn't really exist or work.
So what are you proposing exactly? How does subsidized nuclear prevent the use of storage on the grid?
- azurezyq 5y agoThis battery farm, has a capacity of 900 MWh. While a typical nuclear power plant has a capacity of ~3000MW. So this battery farm is just... tiny. But solar power generation has a large potential for larger capacity, the shortest leg is energy storage. So if something else can be used for base load (e.g., nuclear, natural gas, hydro), solar power works well for daytime peaks.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoPlease try to sketch this out. Grab some daily production and consumption numbers from somewhere and then increase the nuclear (basically shift it straight up) and/or increase the solar (stretching upward is a rough approx but we can also flatten it) to levels that cover roughly 100% of demand. Look at the bit where both are running at the same time and compare it's area to the rest. Why is this duplicated "baseload" useful? Try it again with wind, which is much cheaper and faster to build than nuclear. The conclusion should be fairly obvious.
- azurezyq 5y agoIt's not difficult to accumulate enough capacity for solar / wind farms, I agree. But the problem is that we have not yet solved the problem of energy storage (as I said, it's tiny, compared to the capacity it can generates). So you need something to cover the night or windless periods. Did some search online and it seems that distributed wind farms may work as base load but I highly doubt it works anywhere due to seasonal winds. It definitely needs more research. Especially extreme weathers are becoming more frequent these years.
- vlovich123 5y agoA nuclear plant is constantly providing energy at any time of day and can be scaled up/scaled down quickly with no need for storage. The power plant is also drastically more energy dense in terms of MW/km^2 (although that’s an important secondary benefit). I would think that means your storage needs should go drastically down because you don’t need to store energy at all like you do with solar during sunny moments to handle night/clouds/inclement weather. That’s an obvious explanation that comes to me when I think about it a bit, so I’m assuming you must have more expertise that indicates a flaw with that line of reasoning (I’m not super familiar with technical details). Interested to hear your viewpoint. Edit: maybe you’re thinking of demand smoothing? Nuclear might need that to completely remove the need for carbon peaking plants, but my suspicion is that the batteries you need are drastically smaller than for solar because nuclear can natural load follow whereas solar can’t.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoSo nuclear can "naturally" load follow by overbuilding capacity and then just throwing away some of that energy when its not needed. But wind and solar can't do exactly that same thing?
- foxyv 5y agoModern Nuclear plant designs can throttle and peak. Even older reactors can react pretty well to changes in demand. Solar produces 0% at night and wind can vary dramatically with calms lasting for days. If wind calms at night then you are on either stored energy, peakers, and/or black-outs. Ideally we would use stored power. But, at the current rate, even accounting for expansion of supply, we can expect that it will not nearly be enough to meet climate targets. https://www.wind-energy-the-facts.org/understanding-variable-output-characteristics-of-wind-power-variability-and-predictability.html https://www.wind-energy-the-facts.org/understanding-variable...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThat link doesnt seem to support your claims about wind lulls, stating almost the exact opposite but let's stick to nuclear anyway as thats far more interesting. So in this alternative you propose, with the modern peaking nuclear reactors. What kind of capacity factor do the nuclear plants hit overall and what are you using to fill the seasonal peaks? Nukes that run only 1/12th or less of the year? It all sounds very costly if we're building lots of nuclear plants that run below their rated max. That's really going to put the price per kwh up. Maybe we could build HVDC lines to carry the power long distances from the plants. If you had two cities with a plant each but seperated by a few tinezones you could send the power from the one with the night tine lull to the one with the daytime peak. That would bring costs down I suppose. Or use the excess power for making hydrogen. Its not super efficient, but if your only alternatuve is a nuclear plant that could be generating more then it'll probably work out financially. Or use the excess energy to generate carbon free fuels for airplanes. This is starting to sound like an actual plan.
- foxyv 5y agoAt the current rate, it will take us at least a century to replace fossil fuels with battery and renewables. Nuclear makes sense in the short term until we can replace it with renewables. If we continue as we are, replacing nuclear with natural gas instead of the other way around, we will never make climate targets in time to stop catastrophic levels of CO2 emission. This is despite gains in solar and wind generation. Battery, solar, and wind make sense in the long run. However we are running out of time. We want to limit change to 1.5 celsius and we will never make those targets at the current rate. We are reaching limits of solar and wind alone in a lot of countries and storage solutions aren't being created nearly fast enough. In addition, if we are going to start capturing carbon from unavoidable emissions like concrete production we will need to increase our energy usage dramatically. Essentially, we are VERY underwater and we need something to help us stop sinking to give us time to swim our way out. Nuclear is already playing a big part in that, but not nearly enough. As it is, we could have a chernobyl every year and still not see the level of devastation that is expected to occur with climate change.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoWe are not reaching the limits of solar and wind in any country, this is just not true. And even if it was, you have not given a single reason as to why building new nuclear would help in that scenario. Talk me through it please.
- foxyv 5y agoAt a certain point, base load has to be met during low wind nights. Renewable energy is cheap and efficient. However it doesn't meet base load requirements without substantial storage. Nuclear does meet those requirements. Currently we are using natural gas. Even if you had 10x the necessary capacity of solar, you would still need some sort of night time storage which currently doesn't exist. In addition you need something to offset power losses and increased demand in higher latitudes during the winter.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoBaseload isnt a real thing. Its just a conceptual framework for combining nuclear and coal with gas peaking plants. We need to ditch the gas and coal. I'm happy to keep the nuclear as long as someone can explain how it actually helps achieve a carbon free grid. But apparently no one can.