40 ms·
It seems like places that actually did “lockdown, wear a mask, and contact trace” did better. (No place in the US did lock downs as far as I know. Several place
by sokoloff 5y ago
It seems like places that actually did “lockdown, wear a mask, and contact trace” did better. (No place in the US did lock downs as far as I know. Several places in China did. When you’re welding steel together to enforce it, it’s probably a lock down. When you’re politely asking people to try to only go to stores once per day, it’s not a lockdown.)
- tazjin 5y agoAh, the no true scotsman fallacy. If only we had destroyed our health and economy harder, it would have worked!
- sokoloff 5y agoIt was more an expression of frustration that what we did in the US was economically, psychologically, and socially destructive while not maximizing the possible benefit. I don’t know if the hill on the right or the one on the left had a higher peak, but it sure does seem like we managed to wade through the river in the valley in the middle. “Don’t let some businesses be open, but let some of their competitors stay open, wear a T-shirt over your mouth, and gather in groups of not more than six before dispersing to forage for food in the supermarkets as often as you like.” How could that possibly fail to contain a contagious disease?
- TchoBeer 5y agoThat's not what a no true Scotsman fallacy is, GP literally claimed that other countries did in fact take the necessary precautions and did better than us, which is would be a true Scotsman.
- tazjin 5y agoIt's exactly what it is, look: "Lockdowns work!" "Lockdowns didn't work in the West." "Those were no true lockdowns!" This is essentially the summary of the parent comment.
- TchoBeer 5y agoExcept the lockdowns in china were, according to GP, true lockdowns. Thus, there are true lockdowns. The no true Scotsman fallacy isn't just any time you clarify yourself.
- sudosysgen 5y agoPlenty of things in the world work like that. Half assing something often has worse side effects than whole-assing it. If we had 4 weeks of strict lockdowns and then returned to normal we would have both less covid, a better economy, and better mental health.
- nradov 5y agoThat's just wishful thinking. The virus is so highly contagious that as soon as the lockdown ended, the exponential spread would start up again. So forget it, most rational people aren't willing to tolerate more restrictions. At this point we need to focus on vaccinating as many people as possible and otherwise just accept the risk.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI'm talking about the established reality of what actually happened, not speculation.
- chasd00 5y ago"When you’re welding steel together to enforce it" Is it not obvious that doesn't work in a normal, free society? It's painfully depressing to think otherwise.
- sudosysgen 5y agoFree societies do have provisions that allow for such things used with parsimony in times of great need. When you're enforcing an actual lockdown, thankfully it only takes a few weeks and people can go back to normal for the next 2-3 months. The tradeoff to liberty and freedom is more complex than it seems. For example, New Zealand did it successfully, and I'd say there was a lot more freedom thanks to the times with low restrictions despite the brief but strong lockdowns.
- spookthesunset 5y agoNZ and AU have military in the streets to keep people in line. They are barely a good example of anything.
- sudosysgen 5y agoSo you believe that NZ is not a free society, but the US is?
- nsizx 5y agoOnly the Sith deal in absolutes.
- chasd00 5y agono, it's not complex at all. A correctly functioning government would be scared to death at even the thought of forcing its citizens into their homes (or anywhere else). A government exists at the pleasure of the governed.
- sudosysgen 5y ago
- spookthesunset 5y agoWhich is why if you plot the chart of any interesting data and compare it between regions they loom pretty much the same regardless of how “serious” the region took it. You can’t look at any of these charts and point to where mandates started and stopped. It’s almost as if they didn’t do a damn thing and in fact made things much worse.