8 ms·
The U.S. spends among the most on education of any developed country, both in absolute terms and a percentage of GDP. Our education spending is over 6% of GDP:
by rayiner 5y ago
The U.S. spends among the most on education of any developed country, both in absolute terms and a percentage of GDP. Our education spending is over 6% of GDP: https://waterpedia.wiki/image/education-spending-share-gdp-selected-countries-2015.aGqj https://waterpedia.wiki/image/education-spending-share-gdp-s....
All of the people involved in these foreign war debacles were highly pedigreed. (Fun fact: the President of Afghanistan, who fled Kabul yesterday, is an Ivy League-educated professor who "literally wrote the book on fixing failed states.")
The education, in fact, the problem. Universities is where people learn hare-brained ideas like Wilsonianism. It's where people learn to view government as a set of laws and policies and boxes on org charts, rather than the manifestation of the culture and political tradition of people.
Coming from a traditional Muslim country ourselves, my family knew in 2001 that nation building in Afghanistan was an absurd idea. Our own country has a thousand-year head start on Afghanistan in terms of civilization, and has still struggled with democracy. It's not in the people. But Americans are so far separated from their culture--that is to say, their village won't die of starvation if they indulge in cultural experimentation--they can't even locate the wellspring of democracy in culture and traditions.
- mc32 5y agoThe cultural aspect is critical and people have overlooked in many places. The Optimism for Russia after the fall of the USSR, Ukraine and Afghanistan, Libya, etc. Places with no democratic foundation or tradition but plagued by corruption. It needs to grow over decades organically for the people to get used to the idea and the institutions, for example, like in Hong-Kong. Singapore is another example and they yet don't have completely open democracy. The ground must be fertile, as they say in allegorical terms, for democracy to take root. You can't impose it and then wish it to work and have it work. You can't throw money at it (as AF has shown us). It's a messy process. Sometimes, like Panama, you have the right accidents happen and it works --but at least then they could rely on the legacy of Marti (as they were part of Columbia during independence from Spain) and they had the US administer the Canal Zone till '00, I believe.
- rayiner 5y agoIn Bangladesh, we have had real elections, leaving aside the the assassinations and that one military dictatorship. But we're back to one-party rule as the leader of the opposition party has been jailed. And that's after having 800+ years of civilization under the Sultanates and 200 years under Britain. It's not economics--our PPP GDP per capita is about what the U.S. was at in the late 19th century (at which point it had been a successful multi-party democracy for 70-80 years).
- DSingularity 5y agoThe western democracies are so pure and noble. Definitely not colonizing, dictator supporting, or war mongering countries.
- mc32 5y agoApparently you have some advice for the State Department about how to stabilize a place that has lacked stability for centuries, I bet they could use some advice about now.
- cycomanic 5y agoIf the interest was actually stability then there is plenty of advise. The thing is most of the actions of the US are not out of the interest of stability, it's pure economics and political influence. The US has destabilised or overthrown many stable democratic governments for a more US favourable dictator.
- DSingularity 5y agoYeah I do actually : leave them alone.
- random314 5y agohttps://chomsky.info/fateful02/ https://chomsky.info/fateful02/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zzleeper 5y agoIn my country the two best economics are offered by a leftwing/socialist and a rightwing/free-market university, respectively. What always astounded me was that even though the faculties are nuanced and respect both sides, the students are just blindly leftist or rightist when they graduate. For instance, teachers at the pro-markets university know that markets have failures so blindly free markets is usually not the answer. But students? Hell no. So universities are indeed effective at imparting not just tools and teaching people how to learn, but at brainwashing maybe 90% of the students into following the beliefs they teach them. How do you break that? No clue. But I see the same thing with people consuming media, etc. so I guess it's just a human trait.
- Yoric 5y agoThat's a very interesting point. As a former academic myself, I can confirm that universities are unfortunately good at building cult-like followings - not only cult-like followings, thankfully, but still. Do you think that this has an impact on the situation in Afghanistan?
- jessaustin 5y agoHe now has an excellent opportunity to write another book on this topic!
- surfingdino 5y agoNo, education is not the problem. Universities are supposed to be places where different ideas are meant to be discussed openly without fear of persecution. It is easy to criticise ideas that failed after the fact, but that is not the reason to criticise universities or education. We are talking here using a system based of decades of trying different ideas none of which were developed with a guy with grenade launcher or a religious man in a religious school. Education is not a problem. People who don't value it and don't learn from the past are.
- juanani 5y ago>ideas discussed openly Ive been under a rock for a good while but did not notice you down here. Where the f you been this whole time? You think US universities are the place this happens today? Wow. In the times of woke culture? Teehee
- surfingdino 5y agoI wrote that they are "are supposed to be" not that they "are" such places. Their current state does not negate the idea. The alternative is no education and no freedom. It is not a good alternative.
- CRConrad 5y ago> The U.S. spends among the most on education of any developed country, both in absolute terms and a percentage of GDP. Just like it does with health care... And apparently, it's just as effective in education.
- selimthegrim 5y ago>Our own country has a thousand-year head start on Afghanistan in terms of civilization Way to ignore Bactria there, Khwarezmia, Kanishka, Mes Aynak, Mundigak, the Indo-Greeks. Do better. You should be ashamed.