4 ms·
> Savers who don't stupidly hold their savings in cash... Well, hang on a second. While it would be stupid to hold savings in cash, the group we're really talk
by roenxi 5y ago
> Savers who don't stupidly hold their savings in cash...
Well, hang on a second. While it would be stupid to hold savings in cash, the group we're really talking about are on the margins - the sort of people who might have 1-6 month's salary saved up for emergencies. That is too small an amount to invest; it needs to be available in an emergency.
I think it is unfair to call such people stupid. They are forced by circumstance to make a bad decision; they can't take the risk of being hit by a stock market downturn and a job loss at the same time. Inflation punishes them (saved 6 months salary, in preparation for a big crisis? Like say a global pandemic? Ha! Stupid! We'll drain that).
Even if you want to quibble about the wisdom of an investment strategy, inflationary policies are setting up terrible incentives here. People with an emergency fund should be rewarded, their behaviour was appropriate in preparing for 2020.
Also, we shouldn't be assigning the tax burden based on who is and isn't stupid. Not that I personally mind, but it isn't fair.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoAgreed. Poor people are not stupid, they just have different constraints. They have to do what they can with very little. Gotta be smart to make that work.
- perryizgr8 5y ago> on the margins - the sort of people who might have 1-6 month's salary saved up for emergencies TIL I'm on the margin.
- roenxi 5y agoThe margin is large. But inflation means that Mr. Mouse is (correctly, in my view) calling part of your savings a little stupid. I'd rather we had a system where that decision gets called prudent.
- imtringued 5y ago> I'd rather we had a system where that decision gets called prudent. That prudence causes unemployment, business cycles and relative poverty. I would rather have a world without that kind of prudence.
- logicchains 5y ago>That prudence causes unemployment, business cycles and relative poverty. Clearly you've never had the experience of being poor, living paycheck to paycheck, deep in debt and trying to scrape together what meager savings you can. What kind of person are you, to wish that experience on someone in the name of some pseudoscientific, unfalsifiable claptrap about business cycles? Savings is how the poor move to middle class; destroying that savings is pulling the ladder out from under them.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoI keep 600k in shares and 20k in cash. Now tell me how I cause unemployment and poverty.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> They are forced by circumstance to make a bad decision To be more precise it's not a bad decision, on the contrary - it's the optimal one. You definitely need to keep some cash for unforeseen events - and if you don't, this can be called a "bad decision".