6 ms·
Nearly all of those aren't true. > -Causes people to pay taxes on capital gains even when their purchasing power hasn’t risen. This one is actually true. We c
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
Nearly all of those aren't true.
> -Causes people to pay taxes on capital gains even when their purchasing power hasn’t risen.
This one is actually true. We could easily fix it by calculating capital gains as adjusted for inflation (and make up the revenue by using the ordinary income rate instead of the capital gains rate).
> -Causes borrowers to get ahead of savers and lenders.
Savers who don't stupidly hold their savings in cash are unaffected, since securities prices increase with inflation.
Lenders are affected, but most lenders are banks, who are lending using fractional reserve banking, i.e. the money they lend is created when they make the loan and destroyed when it's paid back. The fact that it's worth less when it's paid back doesn't really affect them.
> -Allows governments to spend more than drunken sailors.
This is generally the cause rather than the consequence.
> -Causes the wealth of the rich to be eroded less than the wealth of the poor (who don’t own any assets).
The primary thing it erodes is contracts (i.e. loans) denominated in nominal dollars. In other words, it devalues nominal debts. This is generally good for the poor and bad for any rich lenders who aren't lending using fractional reserve banking.
> -Causes both the wealth of the rich, middle class, and poor to be eroded away at different rates.
This is true of nearly anything, but who comes out ahead depends more on factors like "are you a net borrow or lender" than your annual income or net worth.
> -Erodes away the middle class and makes them feel like wage slaves.
This is caused by low interest rates more than inflation, though they're somewhat related. The basic problem is that if money is cheap to borrow, people borrow it and bid up asset prices, and then people who don't already have assets (e.g. a home) are forced to buy high.
- webinvest 5y ago>> -Causes borrowers to get ahead of savers and lenders. > Savers who don't stupidly hold their savings in cash are unaffected, since securities prices increase with inflation. Savers save money in their savings account or in other accounts. Investors both save and buy appreciating assets. Savors hold savings, investors hold appreciating (or sometimes depreciating) assets. >> -Allows governments to spend more than drunken sailors. >This is generally the cause rather than the consequence. They’re both correct. The Cantillon Effect, not having to raise taxes from a new bill, and being able to inflate the debt away are all seductive to those with the means to use it. > This is caused by low interest rates more than inflation, though they're somewhat related. The basic problem is that if money is cheap to borrow, people borrow it and bid up asset prices, and then people who don't already have assets (e.g. a home) are forced to buy high. Employee wages at the same company typically don’t rise to meet inflation. In the few companies that do, the employees still move higher up the income tax brackets. >> -Causes people to pay taxes on capital gains even when their purchasing power hasn’t risen. >This one is actually true. We could easily fix it by calculating capital gains as adjusted for inflation (and make up the revenue by using the ordinary income rate instead of the capital gains rate). True.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Savers save money in their savings account or in other accounts. Investors both save and buy appreciating assets. Savors hold savings, investors hold appreciating (or sometimes depreciating) assets. This is just using a narrow definition of "saving" that excludes investing. Moreover, if your "savings" is a hundred dollars, inflation on the hundred dollars is the least of your worries, and if your "savings" is a hundred thousand dollars and you're a "saver" and not an "investor" then the consequences are of your own choosing. > They’re both correct. The Cantillon Effect, not having to raise taxes from a new bill, and being able to inflate the debt away are all seductive to those with the means to use it. Those are all still the causes. If the government prints money and spends it then they don't have to collect the money as taxes, but that causes inflation, it doesn't result from it. Inflation can also devalue existing government debt, but that's counterbalanced for new spending by inflation resulting in higher bond rates because you have to compensate investors for holding dollar-denominated government bonds during a period of high inflation. Unless you have the central bank buying the bonds, which is equivalent to printing the money and we're back to things that cause inflation. > Employee wages at the same company typically don’t rise to meet inflation. Employers who don't give their employees cost of living adjustments would lose them to another company, and then have to pay the higher wages to replace them and the turnover cost of finding a new employee. That is more expensive than simply increasing wages for existing employees.
- brutus1213 5y agoStocks can get wiped out. It has happened before, and it will happen again. I remember when I was a youngin ... Nortel seemed like a sure thing.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThat's why diversification is a thing. The people who invested 2% of their money in Nortel and the rest in 49 other random major companies are doing a lot better than the people who held it all in cash.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 5y agoDepending on your feelings about a wealth tax, we may not need to fix capital gains. Or maybe what needs to be fixed are all the ways to avoid it?
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoWealth tax is ridiculous and the incentives are catastrophic. Basically, if the tax amount is less than the typical investment returns, you have something equivalent to the existing income tax but with a nasty new way to avoid it by finding asset classes that aren't covered or aren't easily valued or reported. And if you try to use a rate higher than typical investment returns, you blow up the whole world as people start burying gold in their yards in secret at scale instead of putting their wealth to productive use, because hiding it from the tax man any way you can becomes more profitable than investing it.
- skybrian 5y agoThis seems alarmist and exaggerated. It doesn’t seem likely that the financial system is going to melt down due to the current capital gains tax and mild inflation. To the extent that the current capital gains tax amounts to a wealth tax, it doesn’t seem like that big a deal.
- imtringued 5y agoYou only need to tax the "bad" things. Namely land and money. There is no need to tax companies or objects. It turns out land and money are very easy to track.
- nullc 5y ago> for inflation (and make up the revenue by using the ordinary income rate instead of the capital gains rate) If corp tax rate + LTCG isn't less than or equal to the top income rate you are effectively incentivizing changes to commercial structures to turn more gains into income to escape the double taxation -- and away from open and accessible public markets.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoOr we could get rid of the double taxation by making dividends a tax deduction to the corporation (but taxable income to the investor). The primary purpose of corporate income tax is to keep investors from shielding their income from taxation by keeping it inside the corporation. If it's being paid as a dividend then that isn't happening. That would also solve the existing perverse incentive to defer the double taxation by hoarding wealth inside of corporations that have no productive use for it, since the corporation can "invest" it (less efficiently) for an arbitrarily long period of time without the investor paying personal income tax on it, and investor's loss of efficiency from the principal agent problem is less than the losses that would be incurred from double taxation.
- nullc 5y agoThat's a fair point, though I believe the double taxation would still exist if companies couldn't pay a 'loss dividend', which would still incentivize keeping wealth inside the corp. Otherwise it's more tax efficient to take a mixture of risks inside one entity, so that the losses in some can offset the success of others resulting in paying taxes on the true returns.
- roenxi 5y ago> Savers who don't stupidly hold their savings in cash... Well, hang on a second. While it would be stupid to hold savings in cash, the group we're really talking about are on the margins - the sort of people who might have 1-6 month's salary saved up for emergencies. That is too small an amount to invest; it needs to be available in an emergency. I think it is unfair to call such people stupid. They are forced by circumstance to make a bad decision; they can't take the risk of being hit by a stock market downturn and a job loss at the same time. Inflation punishes them (saved 6 months salary, in preparation for a big crisis? Like say a global pandemic? Ha! Stupid! We'll drain that). Even if you want to quibble about the wisdom of an investment strategy, inflationary policies are setting up terrible incentives here. People with an emergency fund should be rewarded, their behaviour was appropriate in preparing for 2020. Also, we shouldn't be assigning the tax burden based on who is and isn't stupid. Not that I personally mind, but it isn't fair.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoAgreed. Poor people are not stupid, they just have different constraints. They have to do what they can with very little. Gotta be smart to make that work.
- perryizgr8 5y ago> on the margins - the sort of people who might have 1-6 month's salary saved up for emergencies TIL I'm on the margin.
- roenxi 5y agoThe margin is large. But inflation means that Mr. Mouse is (correctly, in my view) calling part of your savings a little stupid. I'd rather we had a system where that decision gets called prudent.
- imtringued 5y ago> I'd rather we had a system where that decision gets called prudent. That prudence causes unemployment, business cycles and relative poverty. I would rather have a world without that kind of prudence.