2 ms·
An under appreciated aspect of inflation (or lack thereof) is how it’s been driving politics in the US. So long as inflation remains low, public spending doesn’
by rayiner 5y ago
An under appreciated aspect of inflation (or lack thereof) is how it’s been driving politics in the US. So long as inflation remains low, public spending doesn’t require raising taxes. Reagan won the suburbs by lowering middle class taxes. Biden won many of them back—including core Reagan suburbs around Phoenix and Atlanta, which ultimately gave him the election—by promising not to raise taxes on people making less than $400,000. For the vast majority of the electorate, we have eliminated the basic electoral trade off between more services and paying more in taxes.
This is sustainable only so long as deficit spending is cheap—i.e. so long as interest rates and inflation stay low. If European-style welfare programs had to be paid for with European-style middle class taxes, we wouldn’t even be talking about $3.5 trillion in “infrastructure” spending.
If inflation becomes a thing again we could see a real political shakeup.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoSeems to me it's a fragile coalition in the long run anyways; the Biden/Obama formula seems to be: on one hand, promise exciting populist left wing policies in order to pull in an activist core and left wing votes while at the same time having no intention of taking action on them, taking that base for granted (I mean who else would they vote for?) and governing from the right and even openly campaigning in certain districts and audiences with openly "nothing will fundamentally change"[1] type messages. And it will only fool people for so long. In the long run they can appeal to Reagan-type voters from the suburbs only so long before they risk splitting their party base entirely and the left wing of the party starts voting 3rd party at higher rates, or is just demoralized and doesn't show up at the ballot box. "You have no other choice" isn't exactly an inspiring campaign slogan. Though it worked this last time around, I guess. [1] - https://www.salon.com/2019/06/19/joe-biden-to-rich-donors-nothing-would-fundamentally-change-if-hes-elected/ https://www.salon.com/2019/06/19/joe-biden-to-rich-donors-no...
- rayiner 5y agoNobody wants to acknowledge this, but losing the upper Midwest and winning the election based on diverse sun belt states is long term bad for Democrats. The Midwest is relatively economically progressive. Iowa’s income taxes go up to 8.5%. The sunbelt isn’t. Arizona’s taxes only go up to 4.5%. Even minorities don’t want to pay taxes. Many of them moved to Arizona, Georgia, etc., to get away from high taxes in California and New York.
- bittercynic 5y ago>to get away from high taxes I read this online pretty frequently, but haven't met anyone IRL who did this. If you like living somewhere like silicon valley, I can't really imagine choosing to move to Arizona to save a few bucks on taxes. A friend near Phoenix tells me it sometimes stays near 100F all night there. I wouldn't want to deal with that unless I was really backed into a corner.
- iammisc 5y agoWhat? People do this all the time. I know tons of people in silicon valley who moved to Florida or Tennessee or Texas over covid. My own parents moved to Washington state in retirement solely for taxes. People absolutely move for taxes whether you know them or not.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoHow about reverse? I like the idea of CA ( I visited it once; I liked the weather ), but not enough to justify tax cost involved. I am comfortable where I am now.
- tptacek 5y agoPeople definitely move away from where I live in Chicagoland to avoid taxes, though perhaps more often to Indiana than to Arizona.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoThis sounds surprising similar to Republican strategy, just substitute things like abortion.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoI largely agree. In my social circle idea of raising taxes is widely seen as unacceptable. The general mood seems to be 'they are already wasting so much; they don't need more'. The fun part is that it will come almost regardless of what comes next. In practical terms, US will need both a serious cut in spending AND higher taxes just to stay afloat, but that is not a politically acceptable message.
- imtringued 5y agoI agree with the sentiment but the "free lunch" has to be spent on something with lasting value, not welfare. Give people jobs by employing them to build green infrastructure.