6 ms·
In response to something you didn't actually say - news is a classic example of when a free market may be bad, but all the alternatives people tried were much w
by roenxi 5y ago
In response to something you didn't actually say - news is a classic example of when a free market may be bad, but all the alternatives people tried were much worse!
And on what you did say - total agreement. The news has always been terrible. The internet has brought the cost of broadcasting so low actual honest or expert opinions and can make it out as well as the orthodoxies of people who can afford media companies.
- tomnipotent 5y agoWe have unrealistic expectations of news publishing. Modern TV and movies has made certain professions far more glamourous than they are (journalists, police, doctors) because it makes for good media. But most doctors are not ER doctors. Most journalists are not breaking news. Most police never fire their service weapon. But to somehow think the moral distributions of people are superior from the average population, just because of career selection, is dubious at best. Something being protected by law doesn't somehow make its practice exalted.
- cyberge99 5y agoThis was largely due to the repeal of The Fairness Doctrine (USA).
- teflodollar 5y agoI always thought PBS and NPR were pretty good. What am I missing?
- p_j_w 5y agoYeah, not sure what that guy's on about. PBS, NPR, and other not for profit news orgs like BBC aren't perfect, but then what is? If I had to choose a single news source to try to stay informed, I'd take any one of those three over any of their for-profit competition.
- workinghard 5y agoI never trust any media org which is funded by gov. BBC is worst but you have to live to learn though
- denton-scratch 5y agoDon't mistake the BBC for a "not-for-profit". BBC Worldwide is a commmercial operation. The BBC has large shares in various commercial TV operations. The only parts of the BBC that are arguably not-for-profit are iPlayer, and domestic TV and Radio; and the BBC World Service. These are paid for by a controversial hypothecated tax, controlled by the government of the day; as a consequence, the Beeb is fairly consistently pro the government of the day, and anti the official opposition (they can see which side their bread is buttered on). [Edit] The World Service is paid for out of general taxation, specifically the Foreign Office budget. It's not paid for out of the Licence Fee.
- Proven 5y agoThey are state owned - shouldn't exist.
- whatev84584 5y agoWell, let's just consider one example. Did NPR tell people thousands of times that Trump called Nazis "very fine people"? I suspect they did. Did they ever tell people the truth that he hadn't actually said that? I suspect they didn't, or that it was a very quiet and brief admission. Now, do you suppose NPR did vastly better on all the other stuff they gush at the mouth about all day?
- coldtea 5y agoWell, first of all, that they are 1/1000000 of the news produced by mainstream sources.
- maigret 5y agoIn Europe they have a good market share, easily double digit.
- coryrc 5y agoNPR has an implicit assumption in ~every story that a problem is best addressed by government intervention and spending. They're credulous of any claim an "authority" makes. Two quick examples from npr.org right now: 1. Somehow we can model how the economy can adapt to zero carbon in 40 years yet couldn't predict changes to solar PV becoming more affordable in the last ten: https://www.npr.org/2021/08/14/1027370891/climate-change-solutions-global-warming-computer-models-paris https://www.npr.org/2021/08/14/1027370891/climate-change-sol... 2. Could this article be more sympathetic to the administration? https://www.npr.org/2021/08/14/1027552833/heres-why-biden-is-sticking-with-the-u-s-exit-from-afghanistan https://www.npr.org/2021/08/14/1027552833/heres-why-biden-is... the meanest thing they say it's "misjudged the speed". Why not "it's been obvious for two decades ANA could never hold together including the eight years he was VP"
- coryrc 5y agoAnd another acting as if an exorcism was a real thing: https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2015/07/30/424980005/help-wanted-the-philippines-needs-more-exorcists https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2015/07/30/4249800... It's more benign than qanon. I haven't checked their coverage of mask wearing. I'll change my mind if they were pushing masks when Fauci was lying and saying they were unnecessary.
- josefx 5y agoThe key line in this story might be: > Father Syquia leads a team of four priests who get additional assistance from volunteers: psychiatrists, doctors, lawyers and laypeople. There seem to be some trained professionals hidden behind the show and prayers.
- raxxorrax 5y agoQAnon is benign, we wouldn't even know of its existence if it wasn't constantly brought up by press outlets to supply their readers with a desperate need for a boogeyman.
- bko 5y agoAccording to the author's examples of bullshit, NPR peddles the same stuff as the other for-profit main stream publications. > Immerse yourself in news of Russian plots to counterfeit presidential children’s laptops [0], viruses spawned in Wuhan market stalls [1], vast secret legions of domestic terrorists flashing one another the OK sign in shadowy parking lots [2] behind Bass Pro Shops experiencing “temporary” inflation [3], and patriotic tech conglomerates purging the commons of untruths. I listed to them for years but noticed a considerable shift in their reporting in the last 2-3 years. [0] https://www.npr.org/2020/10/17/924506867/analysis-questionable-n-y-post-scoop-driven-by-ex-hannity-producer-giuliani https://www.npr.org/2020/10/17/924506867/analysis-questionab... [1] https://www.npr.org/2020/01/29/800725826/why-wet-markets-are-the-perfect-place-to-spread-disease https://www.npr.org/2020/01/29/800725826/why-wet-markets-are... [2] https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2021/01/15/957421470/when-white-extremism-seeps-into-the-mainstream https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2021/01/15/957421470... [3] https://www.npr.org/2021/07/17/1017264502/the-federal-reserve-says-higher-prices-will-be-temporary https://www.npr.org/2021/07/17/1017264502/the-federal-reserv... [4] https://www.npr.org/transcripts/959667930 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/959667930
- p_j_w 5y ago>According to the author's examples of bullshit That's the author's definition of bullshit though, it doesn't necessarily constitute actual bullshit.
- jollybean 5y agoEdit: I'm sorry for the lengthy post, but I felt giving rough examples was necessary to convey the point. It's true that some unofficial quality voices are disrupting established narratives ... but I'm sorry to say this isn't the shift that matters, because 99% of the 'unofficial sources' are considerably worse than just 'bullshit' in the press. The 'Giant Kraken Monster' of fake news is really shocking, and it's taking over some sectors. I couldn't quite fathom it until I saw it happen to someone in my own life. While we argue about 'truth' here on HN, information is being submerged by nonsense on mainstreet. It's not so much war between civil people arguing over the facts - it's more like Information World War Z of people hopped up on very bad, made up information. I was at a relative's home a few days ago listening as a he was listening to his Facebook stream and it was very shocking. I'm paraphrasing from memory, but: "Tanks will Roll, Power Cut, the Great Reset and Trump will be re-instated by Coup on Aug 10 ..." "I have a source, who cannot be named, because his life would be in danger, that Nanci Pelosi was in direct contact with the Chinese Communist Party on January 6 directing the assault on Capitol Hill" "Those that stole the election, put them ballot boxes full of fake votes for Biden, they need to be executed for treason, the True Patriots Will Rise" "It's masks now, folks, but this is the globalist master plan, it's just the first step. This is the reason the second amendment exists, folks" "Big Pharma does NOT want you to know about natural cures, because, well, why do you think? You are the experiment folks. The Sheep out there doing what the government tells them - but the Lions, the True Patriots, know better." "Q said:" - and then a bunch insane of statements from QAnon etc. It's dizzyingly conspiratorial and it's really scary to watch people eat that up. My family member indicated that they don't believe most of it, but that's their primary news source and, it has affected them greatly. My family member is becoming an information zombie who is losing their grounding in reality, and cannot be reasoned with on these issues, even if they are quite rational otherwise. Once you start to believe cabals of the elite are killing children in basements in blood-lust ceremonies, that mysterious Q controls things behind the scenes, that vaccines i.e. life-saving medicines are invented as a tool of control, and that of course all of the 'main stream media outlets' are all lying, then what? Watching them listen - it's like a form of information hypnotism - it's as though they're in a mystical / religious trance. If someone already has a reason to actually 'want to believe', and they don't care, and they just 'let go of rationality' ... then they fall into the trap. I think it's the same kind of programming that cults use. It's really a sight to behold, and the experience of how the information is communicated, the anger, the tone of voice, etc.. The MSM has a problem with bias that could stand to be corrected, and it's have more quality 'outside' voices, but even some of the better sources often falter. Matt Taibi, probably in the same vein of the author of this piece about 'BS', usually has some great things to say but I feel even he is jumping the shark a bit trying to get attention to his Substack with overzealous headlines. In order to put this into relative context, here is some polling data from Pew [1][2] which shows a material minority of Americans are susceptible to even the more over the top conspiratorial information (i.e. QAnon), for less egregious but nevertheless still completely false information, I believe the number is much higher, reaching up to 30% for those who believe that the election was fraudulent [3]. [1] https://www.journalism.org/2020/09/16/most-americans-who-have-heard-of-qanon-conspiracy-theories-say-they-are-bad-for-the-country-and-that-trump-seems-to-support-people-who-promote-them/ https://www.journalism.org/2020/09/16/most-americans-who-hav... [2] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/11/16/5-facts-about-the-qanon-conspiracy-theories/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/11/16/5-facts-abo... [3] https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/559402-one-third-of-americans-believe-biden-won-because-of-voter-fraud-poll https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/559402-one-third-of-am...
- curation 5y agoMaybe the category "the news" is the problem? What precisely is it?
- coldtea 5y ago>news is a classic example of when a free market may be bad, but all the alternatives people tried were much worse! Were they? News co-ops has historically been quite good.
- roenxi 5y agoNews co-ops are part of the free market. If you want to site successful non-free-market news organisation there are things like the BBC. Which is respectable, and really quite a wonderful organisation if the propaganda is favourable to your cause.
- yogue 5y agoEloquently put! Personal experience- wrote to bbc and asked them to address/edit/revisit their past articles making someone a victim and a 'hero' for a cause several years earlier in light of a court ruling absolving the accused and establishing holes in the 'victimhood'. They refused it flat out! Took a few seconds for BBC's reputation to go 180 degrees in my mind.
- Chris2048 5y ago> but all the alternatives people tried were much worse where alternatives tried? or just quickly squashed?