4 ms·
> After spending a day wading through the stated reasons and back stories of these high-profile resignations, it's difficult to come to any single, clear conclu
by h2odragon 5y ago
> After spending a day wading through the stated reasons and back stories of these high-profile resignations, it's difficult to come to any single, clear conclusion—although "burn this entire pile of serpents down, with the most primal of magics" is frankly tempting.
Excellent article. Why does there have to be a singular "Perl community" and Foundation for it? Usually we get schisms and "Thrice Reformed" vs "New Revelation" groups sprout over differences of opinion that rise to intolerable levels.
Very similar to the "why shouldn't a project be forked" question; i get the feeling that forks are frowned on more severely now than in the past; but I can't see why. Recall Xemacs and ecgs, among others? Forks work or they die without bothering anyone.
- giancarlostoro 5y agoDon't forget Remacs which is kinda interesting if it goes anywhere reasonable.
- myWindoonn 5y agoXemacs and ECGS were technical forks. The issue here is whether the n-word should be allowed in tarballs and git configuration. Gotta be honest, I don't have a problem with the "no" argument, and the "yes" argument is explicitly racist and empty-headed.
- h_anna_h 5y agoThe "git configuration" that you mentioned is about his personal dotfiles in his personal git repo. It has nothing to do with the perl community. > and the "yes" argument is explicitly racist and empty-headed. If you are dismissing any possible "yes" argument before it is even made as "racist and empty-headed" I would say that you have withdrawn yourself from public discourse.
- myWindoonn 5y agoPlease, go on; what is the rationale for a project to publish tarballs with the n-word in their URL? I won't dismiss your argument out of hand; we'll inspect its history and evidence together, and we'll come to a consensus. Seriously, look in a mirror sometime; read what you've posted as if it were posted by somebody else. Are you excited for the argument that you've prepared for yourself?
- zozbot234 5y agoThere's no real rationale, of course. It's just trolling. But the kind of reaction we're seeing from the Perl community is just as disappointing. The worst possible reaction to a blatant trolling attempt like that is to make a huge deal out of it. Just remove the trollishly-named packages and revoke the person's CPAN commit access until they grow up and apologize for wasting everyone's time. Everything else is just pointless.
- lizmat 5y agoFWIW, I would put the actions of the committer for 90% in the area of trolling. The committer is a great proponent of free speech, and uses this to prove that there is no free speech anymore (and choose his friends accordingly). The fact that this may or not be true, doesn't matter to him. Nor that he damages the Raku community with this (as well as the Perl community). However, that this even applies to TPF / the Perl community, is mostly mr. Riedel work, using this trolling for his own agenda (which is reforming The Perl Foundation). The matter has been dealt with within the Raku community already. And Mr. Riedel should know that. Now, there is that final 10%. Whether the committer knows this or not, he does show some other tendencies that could be considered racist. But in a country like the Netherlands, that is still trying to deal with "Zwarte Piet" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zwarte_Piet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zwarte_Piet) this is sadly not as uncommon as it should be.
- h_anna_h 5y ago> he does show some other tendencies that could be considered racist Do you have some specific examples and had the Perl community informed him about these?
- mst 5y agoI sanctioned him for the original cpan upload. Not because I necessarily thought he was racist himself (I knew basically nothing about the dude back in ... 2018? I think it was), but because his behaviour was bloody stupid and going to hurt people and cause problems down the line. He was, unfortunately, unable to understand that my goal was to avoid the "bloody stupid" continuing rather than to accuse him of any particular bigotry, so he got lizmat to force me to revoke the sanctions. He's now in a far worse position as a result, and the "problems down the line" have, indeed, happened. Frankly, as a relatively young developer, full of testosterone and even shorter on wisdom than I am, he deserved better friends.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Grinnz 5y agoThere doesn't, and most of this doesn't actually affect the Perl community or development at large.
- mst 5y agoThere really isn't such a singular thing. The Perl Foundation is a non-profit that handles grants and conferences (and I'm sad to see their work on the latter has regressed since I helped get a code of conduct in place for american perl conferences close to a decade ago). It has no authority over core development - that's the Perl Steering Council. It has no authority over conduct in core development spaces - that's the perl5-porters code of conduct which has its own moderation team attached (of which I am not a member but respect the people who are as effective moderators and also nicer people than I am). It has no authority over irc.perl.org in general or libera.chat #perl - those are handled by the irc.perl.org code of conduct with a moderation team that I helped recruit after taking the lead on the community consultation part of the code of conduct adoption process, but is far from only me and intentionally includes more than one person who will disagree with me quite vocally on the (sadly more common that I would like) occasions when I fuck up. What we need to do going forwards is to get conduct enforcement at the TPF/CAT level up to the standard the rest of the community has been reaching for years.