6 ms·
Volkswagen detects when tests run in a CI server, and makes them pass (2018)
- marvel_boy 5y agoSo true.
- amelius 5y agoTrademark lawyers in 3, 2, 1 ...
- Knoblauchzehe 5y agoThe Last commit and fame of this repo are 3 years old.
- llampx 5y agoOne can only hope... Streisand effect, anyone?
- javajosh 5y agoYou sir have taken naming and shaming to a whole new level. And I for one, applaud you. The VW scandal [1] happened only very recently, and it was very serious, and people deserve a reminder of it (and should avoid VW products). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal
- arghwhat 5y agoWe should also avoid using Amazon due to absurd employee treatment, Google for privacy violations, any oil company because of everything they stand for, etc. It's a little rich to look through fingers with all other companies because it would be inconvenient otherwise, and then boycott VW that saw its punishment.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoVW is too big to be punished, but the folks who discovered the fraud were punished; they should be given millions by governments for the healthcare savings of having less pollution in cities because of their work. Instead they were blackballed. I will only trust VW when they start fighting for the whistleblowers.
- AwaAwa 5y agoVW's supervisory board has co-determination, which means that Union of German workers has half the voting rights. The Supervisory board monitors and approves corporate statutes, and is appoints the members of the board of management. Even with such a democratic (closer to atleast) approach if whistleblowers are salted, I don't have much hope that quasi-secretive exec cabals are going to be more open. Outside a few niche startups, that eventually ditch any 'don't be evil' anchors.
- dylan604 5y agoI don't buy the too big to be punished. If regulation agenencies can approve/deny a corporate merger/sale/etc, I think they should have the power to force change. Rarely, is it the rank and file employees causing the mischief. As the C-suite employees and possibly the board of directors, it is the job responibilities to be responsible. In these situations, why not have the regulators come in and force a leadership change? If one particular individual is more responsible than others, why not ban them from holding leadership positions in the future? Other industries have similar punishments. Allow the company to stay alive under new management. Too big to punish is quite frankly just laughable.
- 5y ago
- jsnell 5y ago(2015). Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18067861 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18067861 (119 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10349026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10349026 (20 comments)
- granshaw 5y agoCloning this package and calling it flaky-test-fixer
- toomanyducks 5y agoHonestly I think this opens up a really interesting discussion in open source. I know this is satire, but bear with me. If I see a project, and I get curious about its test results, I can just look at the logs of the tests running and the ways in which they're run. I can see exactly what's going on, and if something weird's going on, I can fork the project, enable tests, and start a discussion with the maintainers. Maybe it's important enough that the tests are enabled and the code is fixed. What's really interesting to me about this is that there's no competition in sight. There are no market pressures that make someone look at the code or fix it, it's just the desire for good code. Whereas with market pressures, I'm incentivized to lock down code and hide test results! You can say that's an edge case or uncommon, but the fact of the matter is that it happened. Anyway, this makes me curious about two things: 1. In software specifically, does the reduction of competition necessarily contribute to a more collaborative and more productive development process than what we expect with traditional systems? 2. If 1 is true, how widely does this scale? What could be better if some of the control of owners was removed? For instance, if the test processes of VW were public, none of this would have happened. I've spent so long being told that competition is the be all and end all of productivity, so I'm just curious about what's happening here, and I want to know how far it goes.
- atomflunder 5y agoI don‘t think it‘s true that there is no competition in the example you give, rather competition simply happens along a differen axis. In the open source space there are certain characteristics that make your project more likely to succeed. Being, well, open is obviously one of them, just like passing emission tests is a factor in cars. So, open source projects have to be competitive along the openness axis in order to succeed, just like VW needs to pass these tests, one way or the other. To me it seems like the same mechanism really, just fed with different incentives.
- toomanyducks 5y agoAre the produced mechanisms really the same when the incentives change? That's not really something I can quite get myself to believe. The incentives in free software, in my limited experience, are to grow a productively maintained system, not necessarily a profitable one (assuming, of course, the existence of some outside source of stable income). And with that motivation, I feel that competition disappears. When I look at an alternative solution to a problem I'm trying to solve, it's more in the lense of 'oh, that's a good idea!' than anger that their solution is better than mine. Then, if I'm lucky, it might be the type of thing that can be refactored out into a library and shared across implementations. I still feel that competition precludes that, regardless of incentives.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yuppie_scum 5y agoVW’s software quality is pretty atrocious, especially now that that they can rely on OTA updates.
- sensitive-ears 5y agoThis package is still one of my favorite things on the internet, ever. I used to work on python packages at a car company and it hits all the right spots to make me giggle uncontrollably.