4 ms·
Unpopular suggestion: Actual imperial rule for a couple of generations. Tax enough to pay for the effort but not for a "profit". Build infrastructure by bringi
by colechristensen 5y ago
Unpopular suggestion: Actual imperial rule for a couple of generations.
Tax enough to pay for the effort but not for a "profit". Build infrastructure by bringing outside expertise to train and build local business. Take control of schools, make them safe and required for all children. Respect the local culture but smash hard some cultural practices.
Would it be incredibly hard to do without abuse? Absolutely. Is it questionably moral? Absolutely. Could it even be done at all? Questionable.
We keep acting that the outcome of every military conflict is going to be like the liberation of France in WWII, kill the "bad guys" and then champagne and croissant parades with the locals.
The repeated failed attempts at just handing self-government to nations after we depose their governments shows that you can't just win wars and fix problems with force alone. War is awful, it should happen as infrequently as possible, but if you're going to do it, you better have a plan for winning the peace. Corrupt, half-assed nation building doesn't cut it.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Respect the local culture but smash hard some cultural practices. These are not merely in tension, but actually completely incompatible. We can respect local culture or try to impose one that we like better, but you can't do the first and also the second. > Would it be incredibly hard to do without abuse? No, it would be abuse. > Is it questionably moral? No, again, it is unquestionably immoral. > War is awful, it should happen as infrequently as possible, but if you're going to do it, you better have a plan for winning the peace. Sometimes, you just need to accept winning the war. Disrupting al-Qaeda in Afghanistan and providing a deterrent for the Taliban letting a similar group base out of there in the future was a win. The fantasy of then forcibly-but-on-the-cheap implanting a pro-Western liberal democratic regime and society in Afghanistan was...insane. Unrealistic fantasies about “winning the peace” we could do with fewer of.
- lostlogin 5y ago> Unrealistic fantasies about “winning the peace” we could do with fewer of Japan and the Marshall plan are not a million miles from being an example of the change being proposed. A lot of differences though. Edit: it used to say Martial plan. Sort of a funny error.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Japan and the Marshall plan are not a million miles from being an example of the change being proposed. Neither the Marshall Plan nor the post-WWII occupations of Japan were within a million miles of “actual imperial rule for a couple of generations”. The post-war occupation of Germany on paper kind of resembles that, but that's largely a side effect of the subsequent Cold War.
- lostlogin 5y agoThe comparison I was going for was the imposed system coming from an occupying US force.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The comparison I was going for was the imposed system coming from an occupying US force. We’ve tried an imposed system from an occupying US force in Afghanistan longer than we did i Japan. Or Germany, in any real way. It might have worked if we had made the right decisions early on, but successful occupation is path-dependent, you screw it up and you don't get to start over with a clean slate, and the evidence is that we didn't do it right from the outset, if there was a “right” open in the particular circumstances.
- lostlogin 5y agoAbsolutely. The Marshall Plan had a vast amount of resources behind it and a very strong resolve. I’m not sure Afghanistan did.
- angelzen 5y agoThe mass rapes and ethnic cleansing performed by the Soviet armies in the East gave the Germans an existential reason to embrace a distant benevolent empire. No such external threat exists in Afghanistan. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_during_the_occupation_of_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_during_the_occupation_of_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_and_expulsion_of_Germans_(1944%E2%80%931950) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_and_expulsion_of_German...
- angrais 5y agoI'm very confused about your overall response. You can very much respect the local culture while smashing out and cultural practices. For example, key to culture is language and so promoting local language is important. Likewise, the treatment of women in some middle East countries is oppressive and so promoting inclusion as an alternative (preferred) cultural norm is ideal. Same with child marriage.
- dragontamer 5y agoWhy was the Taliban able to destroy libraries and century old Buddha statues and still get the respect of the locals?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fellellor 5y agoBecause those actions are favourable to Allah. If there are those who don’t like Allah, then you get rid of those people. When all in the populace are worshippers of Allah, then actions favourable to Allah will bring you respect.
- vimy 5y agoYou can’t change the treatment of women without changing the culture. I don’t think you understand how deeply embedded those values are. Values we consider barbaric are perfectly acceptable for the locals.
- nradov 5y agoMorality aside, as a practical matter sustaining an imperial occupation in Afghanistan would require also invading and occupying part of Pakistan. It's a package deal. Nothing could ever be accomplished in Afghanistan as long as insurgents have a safe just across the border.
- Tabular-Iceberg 5y ago>Is it questionably moral? Well, we already decided a long time ago that we knew better than the Afghans how to run their own society. This would be an improvement in that we’d actually have the decency to do something about it.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Respect the local culture but smash hard some cultural practices. If you want good self-government of a people, then you must eliminate tribal/clan structures so that advantages aren't given to uncles/cousins, but rather to people independent of their relations. * https://ideas.repec.org/p/sfu/sfudps/dp17-17.html https://ideas.repec.org/p/sfu/sfudps/dp17-17.html * https://www.u4.no/publications/the-kinship-in-public-office-indicator-kin-connectivity-as-a-proxy-for-nepotism-in-the-public-sector https://www.u4.no/publications/the-kinship-in-public-office-... * https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=108992 https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=... * https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055415000271 https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055415000271 How much of a tribal/clan culture is present in Afghanistan? * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinship
- deleted 5y ago
- colechristensen 5y agoYou're new here obviously, but this sort of comment is not well received here.
- ramblenode 5y agoThe 20-year cost of US forces occupying Afghanistan is frequently put at about 1 trillion USD. The current GDP of Afghanistan is about 70 billion USD (Wikipedia). So you would need to have taxed Afghanistan about 70% their yearly GDP for the last 20 years just to pay for the occupation. Needless to say, people don't typically appreciate having to pay their occupiers.
- acchow 5y ago> Unpopular suggestion: Actual imperial rule for a couple of generations. You are trying to breed out extremism? It's not like a fad... You can never breed it out. A couple generations? No. Not even 5 generations will be enough.