19 ms·
I really want to like Snopes, but I'm not convinced that they weigh evidence correctly. For example, they debunked the myth that Marilyn Monroe had 6 toes. Firs
by kstrauser 5y ago
I really want to like Snopes, but I'm not convinced that they weigh evidence correctly. For example, they debunked the myth that Marilyn Monroe had 6 toes. First, I don't believe that she did. Or even care, for that matter. But at the time, one of their "facts" was that if she'd had a toe removed, she'd basically have to learn to walk all over again because it would throw her balance completely off. (Note: the article no longer includes this fact. It did at one time, though.)
However, my wife's a podiatrist. Part of her job is amputating parts of feet when they're damaged or infected beyond repair. I asked her what it's like for an otherwise healthy adult to recover from a pinky toe amputation, and she said it's basically a matter of waiting for the wound site to heal and then they continue with life as normal. Contrary to popular belief, even a big toe amputation isn't that disruptive. A vestigial 6th toe hanging off to the side? You'd never notice it was gone.
I emailed Snopes and said hey, while I agree with your conclusion, this particular supporting fact is invalid according to an expert in the field. They replied basically that I was an idiot for believing she had 6 toes, and they left the article as-is.
That's not at all what I thought, and I actually agreed with their conclusion. I just didn't like that they were using incorrect facts to support it, and especially didn't like that they reacted poorly to a well-meant correction.
Since then, I've been skeptical of Snopes. Although I think they're probably right most of the time, that left a bad taste in my mouth. Are other people sending them corrections about their own fields of expertise and having them rejected? I have no way of knowing.
- colpabar 5y agoHad you checked the article after this encounter? I guess they eventually realized you were right and made the change, but I wonder when that happened. Other comments here discuss how it's odd that they don't allow their site to be archived, and it's interesting to see a real example that illustrates why they may not want that.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoSilent edits seem like a huge red flag that your platform isn't trustworthy.
- LukeShu 5y agoSilent edits and excluding themselves from the Internet Archive Wayback Machine so that you can't look in to the silent edits.
- kstrauser 5y agoI have no idea when or why they changed it. Every few years I'd get a bee in my bonnet to check, and this is the first time I remember not seeing the incorrect fact being there.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoPerhaps others like yourself emailed them once in a while over the years, each getting ignored, but eventually they got that comment enough to check it with an actual authority on the matter, sheepishly realized they were the ones being idiots, and silently edited it without admitting their mistake.
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 5y agoA coworker of mine had his big toe amputated after it was crushed while moving a refrigerator. Afterwards he had no problems and remained very athletic.
- Scoundreller 5y agoThis comment makes me queasy.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoMy mother chopped off the toe next to her big toe with our lawnmower (accidentally.) To this day none of us can figure out how it hit that toe and not the big toe.
- kstrauser 5y agoYep. I mean, obviously you don't want that to happen, but it's something you can make a complete recovery from.
- xorcist 5y agoAlways take skeptics with a grain of salt.
- ffggvv 5y agosnopes is basically just a few skeptical people using google. they arent some world class expert geniuses in all topics like they claim to be.
- j_m_b 5y agoAt one time, Snopes was part of the fact-checking team at Facebook. This comment goes to show that having an arbiter of truth is a bad idea considering it's hard to accurately know everything. Imagine Doctors trying to debunk the official fact-checker statements and being labeled as misinformation simply due to the fact that they disagree with the fact-checker!
- harpiaharpyja 5y agoFact-checking is a dead end, a poor substitute for development of critical thinking skills in the broader population. It may be more challenging, but that's what we need to start working towards.
- unclebucknasty 5y agoBut, even critical thinking ability relies on good inputs. There must be some baseline of facts to work with. I do agree however that fact-checking is extremely challenging, but for different reasons. That is, in a society that is being programmed to choose the reality/truth they prefer, you'll end up with cult-like belief systems that no amount of fact-checking will break through.
- javert 5y agoFor a critical thinker, the baseline facts come from the person's own direct experience. They have to. For example, I probably wouldn't 100% believe that hundreds of people can cross the sky in a metal tube (i.e., modern jet airplane) if I had only been told about it. But I've seen it myself. Another example: I've learned enough about technology to think the moon landings were feasible, and I've learned enough about society to think that a successful conspiracy around the moon landings is implausible. So I believe the moon landings happened.
- technothrasher 5y agoWon't relying on direct experience as a basis for critical thinking lead to all kinds of problems due to faulty perception and cognitive biases that we all share? Additionally, how are we to evaluate situations were are not likely to have any experience with? None of us have any experience with, say, the big bang or anything close to what the universe was like then, but can't we still come to many likely conclusions about it without any even indirect experience? So doesn't critical thinking in fact have to have a baseline in something other than one's own direct experience? Rationality, possibly?
- samstave 5y agoFUCK SNOPES --- They are literally FAKE NEWS and they are actively paid to push narratives. Utter douchebags.
- kstrauser 5y agoNow that's an extraordinary claim. My story was meant to explain why I think they're fallible, but I also believe they have good intentions and are trying to do an accurate job of it. I don't see any reason to think they're getting paid to lie about stuff.
- samstave 5y agoIt was posted that there was only one employee at snopes who was responsible for their answers, and that they were very questionable.... https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=snopes+has+only+one+fact+checker&atb=v268-1&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=snopes+has+only+one+fact+ch... But then again - in these trying times for Truth - I don't know who to trust.
- xqyf 5y agoSurely there's a horrible subreddit for you to secrete hot takes like "literally FAKE NEWS" on instead of this forum?
- samstave 5y agoGo fuck yourself. 4 month old account while I have been on both HN and Reddit for more than a decade? Sure -- I am just someone who doesnt know what the fuck I am talking about because I disagree with you?
- TeeMassive 5y agoSnopes' fact checking is a meme at this point. They fact-check opinions they have re-framed in their own language as opposed to fact-checking the facts the opinion is based on. (Claim: the economy is way better: Truth: no, it's only 5%) They often reframe the claims to add a detail the author never said. (Did John ate ice cream on Sunday? No, he ate it at Saturday 23:35). The worst is when they rely on cherry-picked experts or anonymous sources: (we asked an ex-CIA analyst if the leaks are true, he said it's most likely not, trust us as we trust him)
- Uhhrrr 5y agoThis reminds me of one I saw shortly after 9/11. The rumor was that bin Laden hated the US because an American woman had made fun of his penis. I believe this even less than the Marilyn Monroe toe story, but the Snopes "debunking" was that bin Laden had never been to America so it couldn't possibly be true - ignoring the fact that Americans leave the country sometimes. I was pretty unimpressed by the slapdash effort.
- WalterBright 5y agoI don't see how hearsay evidence could ever be debunked. And even if a recording could be found of him saying that, he could always just say he was joking.
- bartread 5y ago> I don't see how hearsay evidence could ever be debunked. Well, that's the thing, isn't it? Hearsay doesn't reach the necessary standard to be considered evidence in the first place in sensible forums, including most courts.
- Uhhrrr 5y agoYes. But the other thing is debunking rumors is the task they set for themselves. And in these cases, they went for the dopamine hit of writing "FALSE" over the eternally annoying "Unconfirmed".
- emodendroket 5y agoIf the claim is true, the claimant should be able to produce evidence of it, such as someone who would have reason to know stating that it happened.
- brightball 5y agoMy wife just told me she was going to bed. It’s true. There’s no feasible way for me to prove it. Even if she were to record a statement saying that, indeed, she said that…she could be lying for some reason. Most of what we experience in life every day isn’t provable. That doesn’t make it any less true. It’s just exposes a weakness in what a person is willing to consider as truth, which is that it depends entirely on your willingness to trust the source and very little to do with actual truth.
- intellix 5y agoWho replied at snopes and who did you speak to?
- kstrauser 5y agoIt was like 20 years ago and I just tried to find the email but wasn’t able to. I think it was Barbara, but honestly don’t remember.
- ALittleLight 5y agoI think Snopes has pretty clear political biases that detract from their ability to fact check. An example is their article on "Sweden is the rape Capitol of Europe"[1] which they rate false. Their article talks about Trump and immigration and Farrage and doesn't really get to what they are supposed to be debunking, which is the rape Capitol thing. Sweden does have the highest rate of rape per capita in Europe. This is possibly due to how Sweden and other European countries collate rape statistics but also possibly due to Sweden having more rapists or some combination of the two things. I think an article that tried to investigate how to compare rape rates between European countries and where we should fairly consider to Sweden to be in that ranking would be both challenging to write and interesting to read. Instead, Snopes just says Trump is a dumb racist and therefore the claim is false.
- millzlane 5y agoRapes actually dropped. They debunked it in the article. Sweden doesn't have the highest rape rate. If you look at the graph that they mention from the article. https://www.snopes.com/tachyon/2017/03/sd-graph.jpg https://www.snopes.com/tachyon/2017/03/sd-graph.jpg "– The question posed on sexual crimes in NTU includes a wide range of crimes. It can range from minor events [like] flashing and groping, to very serious incidents of rape. Those who say they suffered must therefore answer questions about the severity of the crime. The responses show that in 29 percent of cases [have been] a more serious form of sexual crimes, says Emelie Hambrook, investigator at the National Council." "While Brå noted that the broad category of “sexual crimes” had increased since 2012, the same was not true for rape. Another Brå graph shows that reported cases of rape (represented by the purple line below) did not spike suddenly after the influx of refugees in 2015 – instead, they dropped from 6,697 in 2014 to 5,918 in 2015 (about the same amount as in 2009). " https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/crime-sweden-rape-capital-europe/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/crime-sweden-rape-capital-...
- exporectomy 5y agoNothing you wrote contradicts the claim of it being the rape capital. The rate can drop and still be the highest. Are you aware that you're not logically countering the parent comment but just saying something tangential to it?
- starkd 5y agoAlso, vestigial toes are usually removed in infancy, or sooner rather than later. If you wait too long, they have a harder times getting shoes to fit.
- gowld 5y agoThey also did a faux-debunking of the Trudeau-Castro theory, that didn't even check Justin Trudeau's mother's Wikipedia page to find out her location on the date they calculated for the conception date. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Trudeau https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Trudeau https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/justin-trudeau-is-fidel-castros-love-child/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/justin-trudeau-is-fidel-ca...
- ypcx 5y ago> I really want to like Snopes Herein lies the archetypical problem with the vanilla HN (or should I say "mainstream") crowd conformist mentality. As a human herd animal, we want to belong, but it's not okay to forgo our critical thinking to do so. Downvote away.
- SerLava 5y agoSnopes is run by the Poster's Poster. Of course they aggressively missed your point and accused you of being the idiot.
- timbo1642 5y agoSnopes is bias and cannot be trusted when it comes to anything political at all. Fact checkers always have a bias
- playguardin 5y agoYou really want to like snopes? Why?
- stereoradonc 5y agoKudos for the fact that you bothered to email them for clarification. I never engage with the "fact checking sources"
- WCityMike 5y agoI'm reminded of a paragraph in the Buzzfeed News investigation that brought this to light, indicating that Mikkelson in early days of Usenet was particularly known for trolling. That response to your inquiry seems particularly trollish.