9 ms·
It's interesting that pre-acquisition Android seems like it was very much tailored to high-end feature phones. There was no touch screen support, and even "app
by zozbot234 5y ago
It's interesting that pre-acquisition Android seems like it was very much tailored to high-end feature phones. There was no touch screen support, and even "apps" themselves seemed to be a bit of an afterthought, although of course better planned than the 'J2ME profiles' mentioned in OP. The closest thing to it today would probably be KaiOS, even pure Linux on phones is aiming quite a bit higher. (Albeit with sxmo https://sxmo.org/ https://sxmo.org/ https://wiki.postmarketos.org/wiki/Sxmo https://wiki.postmarketos.org/wiki/Sxmo being a bit more minimalistic, even that is way above most feature phones.)
- jaywalk 5y agoiPhone changed everything.
- zozbot234 5y agoLG Prada changed everything. iPhone was a lame ripoff of that device.
- pier25 5y agoHardware wise, the iPhone or a similar device was pretty much inevitable. The same components were available to everyone. I think Apple's stroke of genius was in the software and UI/UX.
- macintux 5y ago> Hardware wise, the iPhone or a similar device was pretty much inevitable. The same components were available to everyone. I agree (more or less) with the fact that someone would have come out with something similar. I strongly disagree that it would have changed the world. Apple had the "courage" to go all-in on the form factor with the retail footprint to sell it, and of course the built-in fan base and long history of innovation to make it interesting even in its fairly primitive form. Any other manufacturer would have either been too small to be so influential, or would have hedged their bets with a dozen alternatives, and their "iPhone" would have just been another dusty device in the corner of an AT&T store that no one knew how to use.
- pier25 5y ago> Any other manufacturer would have either been too small to be so influential Maybe small manufacturers, but if Nokia or Motorola had done it first (with good software) maybe we'd be a in different world.
- macintux 5y agoYou left out the rest of that... > or would have hedged their bets with a dozen alternatives Nokia or Motorola wouldn't have bet their phone business on a single UI/hardware combination like Apple did, and so I don't believe it would have had the technological impact the iPhone did.
- pier25 5y agoThat's a good point. Maybe you're right, who knows.
- 5y ago
- Mikeb85 5y agoNot really. It was going to happen with or without Apple. The first touchscreen smartphone was in 1992. Microsoft had touchscreen Windows devices from the late 90's through the 00's. Symbian and BlackBerry were things. And the LG Prada which was released before iPhone. iPhone just did what Apple's good at, taking existing technology and packaging it nicely, but it would have happened with or without them.
- crmrc114 5y agoThe reason I left my Treo for the OG iPhone was the data plan. No one could touch that unlimited data at the time. To me that is what sold the iPhone. I don't know that it ever would have taken off if it had been constrained per KB as was popular at the time. Also the data plan was a bit of a requirement considering the first iPhone was all webapps. I was so pissed when I found out it lacked copy and paste.
- downWidOutaFite 5y agoiPhone's capacitive touchscreen was new and revolutionary. Microsoft had some success in the early 2000s with Windows Mobile but they inexplicably stopped investing into it after 2005. Without Apple it might have taken many more years before the mobile revolution kicked off in earnest.
- Mikeb85 5y agoLG released a capacitive touchscreen phone before Apple by a month. The technology was out there and was always going to get used by someone.
- setpatchaddress 5y agoHere's a modern review of the original LG Prada, from the noted iPhone lovers at Android Authority. You be the judge. https://www.androidauthority.com/lg-prada-1080646/ https://www.androidauthority.com/lg-prada-1080646/ >The LG Prada was the first mobile phone with a capacitive touchscreen, but there are reasons why you don't remember it.
- realusername 5y agoI'd say the iPhone 2G changed everything, the first one did not really make a revolution on the mobile landscape.
- jaywalk 5y agoI could not disagree more. No handset manufacturer ever dared to make the demands that Apple did, including full control of the software with no ability to customize or even pre-install apps. It was completely unheard of, but that's what they got Cingular to agree to with the first iPhone. And they maintain that control to this day.
- lostlogin 5y agoYou disagree but then state that Apple did something no one else had ever done?
- kllrnohj 5y agoAnd nobody has done that since. Can it really be an industry revolution if it's still a solo act over a decade later?
- jaywalk 5y agoGoogle has, with Pixel. And even though the other Android OEMs allow for carrier apps to be preinstalled, it's nothing at all like it used to be. Verizon at one point was requiring feature phones to run a custom Verizon OS. Carriers would arbitrarily disable features on phones. The carriers had complete control over everything up until Apple came along. Even Android enjoys the fruits of Apple's initial demands.
- swiley 5y agoThe iPhone changed nothing and has, infact, been holding mobile computing captive in the 2007 era. Modern hardware is more than powerful enough to run decent desktop OSes without all the crap that Apple and Google insist is necessary on a phone.
- zozbot234 5y agoMobile computing was way more limited prior to iPhone and Android. Mobile phones are embedded devices, and the embedded ecosystem has always been messy irrespective of raw computing power. Even today, this is clearly the main obstacle to running "desktop" Linux on phones. (Though one shouldn't underestimate the UX challenges involved in building a viable phone OS, these are largely solved by now thanks to Plasma Mobile and Phosh. What remains is 99% hardware bugs and lacking support.)
- swiley 5y agoI run a desktop UI on my phone. The only place it really doesn't work is when I'm driving and that's illegal anyway. The main obstacle is SoC drivers that are kept closed.
- pjmlp 5y agoWhile Symbian C++ might have been a pain to use, the phones could run J2ME, Apache (yep that web server), Python, Flash and Web Widgets (PWAs before it was even an idea!).
- 5y ago
- joezydeco 5y agoI'd be curious to read this book and learn more about the pivot once iPhone launched. I was at one of those TI partner companies during this time and we were contracted to assist with middleware for Android Sooner. I even got to test with one. Then everything got put on hold.
- wmf 5y agohigh-end feature phones This kind of classification only makes sense in retrospect. Blackberries and Danger Hiptops were pretty much the best phones you could get in 2005. Sure, keyboardless phones existed but they weren't necessarily better.
- bane 5y agoIt's really useful to look at the context of the market at the time. High-end phones ran a mobile variant of Windows, or were Blackberries. Screen sizes were getting larger and having data coming to your phone at all was still considered a bit exotic but was starting to happen. Touch, if there was any, was usually on a non-capacitive screen and was generally pretty terrible. The integration of sensors, data, GPS, etc. was starting to happen, but wasn't ubiquitous. The market was also incredibly fragmented both on the hardware and software side. The hard divide between feature phones and smart phones hadn't yet been delineated in a general sense (the Windows phones were just kind of clunky and weird, and Blackberry basically had it's own market segment and represented "smart phones" in the press). Phones just kept getting higher and higher end, and adding more and more features. https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/best-mobile-phones-of-2006/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/best-mobile-phones-of-2006/ The most anticipated phone for 2007 was Nokia's N95, the press called it a "multimedia device". It came with GPS, quad-band, 5MP camera, Wi-Fi connectivity, an accelerometer, a Web Browser, a big screen, apps. It looks vaguely like an older iPod, but has a pop out numeric keyboard. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_N95 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_N95 At the time it was considered one of the best phones ever released and sold 10 million. At the time it was sometimes called smartphone, but I think today we'd call it an advanced feature phone. Android thus came out in this market, and the phones it originally targeted looked more like the N95 than the iPhone. When Apple introduced the iPhone, they rethought the form-factor and simplified it, getting rid of most buttons and making touch not suck. But functionality-wise the iPhone was about on par with the N95, and so was Android. However, the first iPhone didn't support user apps, had limited connectivity and sold only 6.1 million devices. When Android started supporting phones with iPhone-like form factors, it wasn't a given that it would become the predominant form factor for phones. The first few generations of Android phones still features lots of vestigial keyboards and buttons and rollers and sliders and such carried over from the N95 and blackberry style phones that Android devices were also looking like. Once the iPhone style form factor started leaving everybody else in the dust, Android phones (and the OS) simply dropped that stuff also.
- Izkata 5y ago> and the OS At least as of Android 8, the OS still supports hardware keyboards (and likely the rest); my current phone has one and can scroll by swiping on the keyboard.