8 ms·
50% round-trip efficiency and 3x the density of li-ion sounds pretty good, actually. Assuming your efficiency number is the entire cost of water -> compressed H
by HWR_14 5y ago
50% round-trip efficiency and 3x the density of li-ion sounds pretty good, actually. Assuming your efficiency number is the entire cost of water -> compressed H2.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoToyota's hydrogen tanks looked promising: 300mi range and 3 minute refill time. It's disappointing it never went anywhere.
- s5300 5y ago>It's disappointing it never went anywhere. There's probably a sound reason for that
- Tade0 5y agoIt's 3 minutes assuming the fuelling station is at peak pressure - 700 bars. After the first fill up it needs several minutes to pressurize. Also such a facility costs at least $1mln and is unlikely to ever get much cheaper.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> Also such a facility costs at least $1mln and is unlikely to ever get much cheaper. How much does a conventional gas station cost? I would expect several hundred thousand, at least.
- Retric 5y agoA more relevant question is how much does a single gas pump or EV charging station cost. A gas station can easily have a dozen pumps for ~500k.
- cma 5y agoHydrogen tanks can also have multiple outlets (I get that they are more expensive than gas outlets, but the tank is presumably a large part of the hydrogen station cost).
- Retric 5y agoIf a 1 million dollar instillation can’t keep up with continuous 3 minute fill ups then it’s going to need significant extra hardware to have enough throughput for multiple pumps.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> EV charging station cost. A commercial-grade Level 1 charger (US domestic 110V 15 amp), if they even exist anymore, is probably on the order of $1000 or less - if it breaks buy a no-name replacement from Alibaba until it catches fire. A professionally-installed Level 2 charger without any payment system infrastructure - so one that's basically free-to-use and taps directly off your AC service-panel at 240V 50-90A will cost about $750-2000 including installation by an electrician - most states offer generous tax-deductions for this btw. A Level 2 charger that's part of some charger network, like Chargepoint... I've no idea. The hardware looks nice (i.e. expensive) but I'm unsure who pays the cost of the hardware and installation (is it the landowner or is there a cost-sharing deal with the network operator?) Level 3 chargers... we're talking a minimum 5-figure amount for even a single-stall set-up: as you need a huge (literally: easily 3x3x6 foot) DC transformer appliance for each pair of charging stalls (hidden behind a fence around the corner), connections to seriously high-power mains electricity (imagine a 16-stall Supercharger: that's 8 DC transformers doing ~120kW each: that's 2MW!) in addition to the aesthetically designed car-connector party. According to this article from 2013 (so it's already 8 years out-of-date) Tesla pays $100-200k towards a station, I'm unsure what the cost-split is, but I'd be surprised if the total cost overall was under $250k imo - I also wouldn't be surprised (still) if simply land-use-rights was the majority share: https://techcrunch.com/2013/07/26/inside-teslas-supercharger-partner-program-the-costs-and-commitments-of-electrifying-road-transport/ https://techcrunch.com/2013/07/26/inside-teslas-supercharger...
- darksaints 5y agoWhy would you assume that? Electrochemical compressors, as well as high pressure vessels, are rapidly declining in cost. Fuel station grade electrochemical compressors were ~$1M ten years ago, $300k five years ago, and about $150k today.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoCompare that to hooking up to a grid, costwise. All the H2 equipment is 20x more I'd guess than a charging station for an EV. All the other H2 issues aside, you're competing with a good, established logistic network in EVs: the grid. H2 is like any new nuke: you're 10 years out with a ton of subsidy and investment from being a player against the EVs of TODAY. Your price targets to compete will have to anticipate 5-10 years of accumulated economies of scale, tech improvements, etc in EV/grid/alternative energy/storage. I'd be shocked if a bank would float capital to support that given the uncertainty. Just like I'd be shocked if a bank would float financing to a new major fossil fuel development. It might be BANNED in under a decade.
- darksaints 5y agoYou can't just "use the grid"...existing grid connections can't handle the load. You have to have high voltage lines run direct. Just the equipment to receive and distribute a high voltage connection, you're talking ~$150k. Then another $60k per charger. And before you can even consider installing anything, you have to have lines run specifically for your station, which can often be several miles. That's definitely not cheap. So no...hydrogen infrastructure is not 20x more. It's probably slightly more expensive than an urban charging station, but significantly cheaper than a rural charging station. And remember: electrical infrastructure is mature...it's not going to get significantly cheaper any time soon. Batteries are the innovation driving EV growth, not the grid. The only thing that is unambiguously more expensive is the fuel. And it always will be more expensive...but prices are going down constantly. If it costs $100 to drive a truck across the US, why would it matter if it costs $200 to do the same with hydrogen, especially if it means not having to stop for hours at a time to recharge?
- 5y ago
- rootusrootus 5y agoWe really aren't that far from a plausible charging setup that can do 300 miles in 10 minutes. And that would be perfectly adequate. The infrastructure to support it would certainly be less difficult than trying to get hydrogen available everywhere.
- iainmerrick 5y agoThat’s not adequate at all! The lines at gas stations would be massive. Charging via electric at home or in a parking spot seems a lot more convenient, even if it takes a few hours.
- rootusrootus 5y ago10 minutes isn't that far off what people routinely spend today to fill a tank of gas. Especially people with trucks, which is a large part of the US. Over half the population probably has the infrastructure to home charge right now, so this does not need to replace gas station pumps 1 for 1. I was not suggesting that all of us charging at home need to start using public chargers.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> 10 minutes isn't that far off what people routinely spend today to fill a tank of gas. I don't want to "uhm, acktually", but it's less than 5 minutes: https://www.quora.com/How-much-time-does-the-average-person-spend-filling-up-at-gas-station-during-the-ownership-or-lease-of-their-particular-car https://www.quora.com/How-much-time-does-the-average-person-... - and that's including time spent faffing around with the awful pay-at-pump machines' UX.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI admit my experience is non-typical, as the only gasoline vehicle I own is a truck with a big tank, but 10 minutes is well within normal. For cars with 15 gallon tanks, 5 minutes is probably reasonable. But in any case, 10 minutes is fine no matter what. If you are willing to spend 4x as much for fuel in order to save less than 10 minutes per week when you stop for fuel, then the problem isn't the charge time.
- neaanopri 5y agoCombination of needing lots of infrastructure, and lack of political will. If US decided that instead of waiting for green tech to emerge, we would just simply stop burning fossil fuels and revert to an Amish standard of living until clean fuels are developed, we could have converted to Hydrogen already
- jxidjhdhdhdhfhf 5y agoThat or violent overthrow.
- behringer 5y agoThat's what's coming now.
- jxidjhdhdhdhfhf 5y agoCould be
- labster 5y agoAs long as Jeff Bezos gets to keep his new half a billion dollars yacht, I’m sure the elite would be happy to see the rest of us finally return to serfdom where we belong.
- foxpurple 5y agoWe don’t have to convert to an armish standard. We could have just massively reduced car transport and improve electric rail and walkability. I’m always amazed at how Americans consider driving to be a simple fact of life where you either drive daily or go back to throwing spears in the jungle.
- robocat 5y agoYou are regurgitating a clichéd argument. > massively reduced car transport How the hell could enough people be convinced to spend say 10% of their income on public transport instead of their car and petrol/charging? https://www.statista.com/statistics/748911/us-average-per-capita-vehicle-spending-by-category/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/748911/us-average-per-ca... > improve electric rail and walkability. So click your fingers and you have cheaply and immediately magically redesigned the distribution of residential and commercial property to suit public transport and/or pedestrian/bike access? Finally, ignoring the above, building out that infrastructure and other changes would cost trillions, which indirectly causes trillions of dollars worth of extra CO2… Your argument is as trite as saying “why don’t we just stop producing CO2?”. Edit: disclaimer: yes I own a car and I also use public transport when convenient (I was even 100% carless for a few years, by living close to work and bus route was accessible).
- dTal 5y agoI'm not an expert in fuel cell efficiency, I'd read that number somewhere and a quick google confirms it: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/round-trip-efficiency https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/round-trip-... The energy density situation looks less attractive when you include the beefy 350-bar storage tanks, and the fuel cell itself. A battery just has two wires sticking out and that's it.
- jfim 5y ago> A battery just has two wires sticking out and that's it. What about thermal management, the outer shell that can hold the battery cells and modules, and the battery management system?
- dTal 5y agoSure, but a hydrogen fuel cell system has most of that too. My point was just that hydrogen can't be directly compared to batteries because it's just the fuel, while batteries are the complete system. I guess I worded it badly.
- nightfly 5y ago> A battery just has two wires sticking out and that's it. Considering the heating/cooling mechanisms required for EV batteries this is a pretty disingenuous statement. Not even considering the highly-toxic fire risk with Li-ion.
- dTal 5y agoWell okay, but if we're bringing those things into it, hydrogen requires cryogenic storage and is, ah, famously flammable, even when it's not pressurized to 350 bar. I wasn't saying Li-ion is perfect - all I was trying to say was that if you want to compare like with like, you can't compare batteries with just hydrogen - the hydrogen is just the fuel, while the battery is both the fuel and the generator.
- darksaints 5y ago
- FabHK 5y agoYes, also given that electric motors have an efficiency of 90%+ (or thereabouts) and internal combustion engines only of 20-30% IIRC.
- busterarm 5y agoModern ICE are hitting 40%.
- diarrhea 5y agoI don't know why you are being downvoted. You are correct, and some ICEs (large, maritime) are hitting 50% even. For a thermal engine, that's incredibly good (it's not about the gap to 100%, but the gap to Carnot efficiency).
- busterarm 5y agoThere's a strong contingent here on HN that believes tha continued used of ICEs equates to the imminent death of the human race. It's also a likely wealthy contingent that imports all of its food, flies everywhere, etc.
- AtlasBarfed 5y ago... except the cost of the ICE drivetrain, certainly to hit 40% (that takes turbos and other complexities to the basic ICE, correct?) is about to lose to the cost of the EV drivetrain. It's basically at price parity based on what I see out of Tesla and what Lucid/Rivian/VW/GM are targeting. In three years? Less. And a decade from now? EVs will probably be half the cost of an ICE.