3 ms·
The EFF wrote a really shitty hit piece deliberately confused the parental management function with the matching against hashes of illegal images. Two different
by Spooky23 5y ago
The EFF wrote a really shitty hit piece deliberately confused the parental management function with the matching against hashes of illegal images. Two different things. From there, a bazillion hot takes followed.
- dathinab 5y agoTwo different things which are sold as one package by Apple. Two different things which both are known to be prone to all kind of miss-detection.
- rootusrootus 5y agoYeah I found the EFF's piece to be really disappointing, coming from an organization I'm otherwise aligned with nearly 100% of the time.
- shapefrog 5y agoEFF today is really not the organisation it was just a few years ago. I dont know who they hired badly, but the reasoned takedowns have been replaced with hysterical screaming.
- merpnderp 5y agoCan you quote what you found confusing, because I didn't see anything that didn't agree with the Apple announcement they linked in the piece.
- washadjeffmad 5y agoThe EFF article refers to a "classifier", not just matching hashes. So, three different things. I don't know how much you know about them, but this is what the EFF's role is. Privacy can't be curtailed uncritically or unchecked. We don't have a way to guarantee that Apple won't change how this works in the future, that it will never be compromised domestically or internationally, or that children and families won't be harmed by it. It's an unauditable black box that places one of the highest, most damaging penalties in the US legal system against a bet that it's a perfect system. Working backwards from that, it's easy to see how anything that assumes its own perfection is an impossible barrier for individuals, akin to YouTube's incontestable automated bans. Best case, maybe you lose access to all of your Apple services for life. Worst case, what, your life? When you take a picture of your penis to send to your doctor and it accidentally syncs to iCloud and trips the CSAM alarms, will you get a warning before police appear? Will there be a whitelist to allow certain people to "opt-out for (national) security reasons" that regular people won't have access to or be able to confirm? How can we know this won't be used against journalists and opponents of those in power, like every other invasive system that purports to provide "authorized governments with technology that helps them combat terror and crime[1]". Someone's being dumb here, and it's probably the ones who believe that fruit can only be good for them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(spyware) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(spyware)
- FabHK 5y ago> When you take a picture of your penis to send to your doctor and it accidentally syncs to iCloud and trips the CSAM alarms, will you get a warning before police appear? You would have to have not one, but N perceptual hash collisions with existing CSAM (where N is chosen such that the overall probability of that happening is vanishingly small). Then, there'd be human review. But no, presumably there won't be a warning. > Will there be a whitelist to allow certain people to "opt-out for (national) security reasons" that regular people won't have access to or be able to confirm? Everyone can opt out (for now at least) by disabling iCloud syncing. (You could sync to another cloud service, but chances are that then they're scanned there.) Beyond that, it would be good if Apple built it verifiably identically across jurisdictions. (If you think that Apple creates malicious iOS updates targeting specific people, then you have more to worry about than this new feature.) > How can we know this won't be used against journalists and opponents of those in power, like every other invasive system that purports to provide "authorized governments with technology that helps them combat terror and crime[1]". By ensuring that a) the used hash database is verifiably identical across jurisdictions, and b) notifications go only to that US NGO. Would be nice if Apple could open source that part of the iOS, but unless one could somehow verify that that's what's running on the device, I don't see how that would alleviate the concerns.