8 ms·
The IBM PC, 41 Years Ago
- rbanffy 5y agoNot sure I want to celebrate this. The introduction of the PC caused a mass extinction in the personal computer space. Soon all diversity was gone and everything was PC-compatible.
- hakfoo 5y agoOn the other hand, like natural mass extinctions, this created new niches for diversity to explode. The pre-PC retail market was by necessity constrained. Main-street retailers had to stock so many distinct platforms that they couldn't go deep on any one of them. If you wanted anything beyond the first-party disc drive or the top 10 software packages, you're stuck looking for specialist dealers or mail order, which was a significant barrier to entry for new users. A single dominant PC platform made the late-80s-90s-early-2000s model of "white box" computer retail feasible. They could offer a greater assortment of IBM-compatible software and peripherals, while taking less risk that you'd be stranded with dead inventory. This, in turn, supported a galaxy of small software firms and hardware manufacturers.
- pjmlp 5y agoAnd with the margins gone almost to negative numbers, now we are back to those pre-IBM PC form factors.
- cable2600 5y agoWe are in the Post-PC age with mobile devices and Raspberry PIs. The PC is almost dead as Windows 11 requires newer CPUs and TPM 2.0 that won't run on a majority of older PCs. Apple is a trillion dollar company for a reason, their tech is Post-PC, people want easy to use iPad Pros than a Surface Pro. People want iPhones and the MacOS has evolved to the point that it can be ported to ARM chips.
- pjmlp 5y agoI was the only guy with a PC on our group, everyone else had Amigas, it was just due to some circustances that I upgraded from a Timex 2068 into a 386SX instead of an Amiga 500. So I am kind of biased to those non-IBM PC form factors anyway.
- hulitu 5y agoToo bad you cannot do any serious development on mobile devices.
- pjmlp 5y agoNot every device must have an IDE plugged into it. In any case, there are coding environments available for not-serious development on the go, and then there are laptops.
- Ekaros 5y agoOne also wonders would we have Linux without PC? Unix sure, but would they stay as massive number of slightly different versions on multitude of platforms?
- oblio 5y agoLinux required cheap computing. PCs were the cheapest extensible general computing available on the market, and they were available in abundance.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoOn the other other hand, standardisation on a very poor standard cost the global economy $large_number of billions in wasted time, poor performance, poor security and - let's not forget - incredibly high prices and low specs compared to existing alternatives. Standardisation had already happened in the S100 space. What IBM introduced was mass marketing to businesses. The technology was incidental. Apple already had a consumer dealer network, Amiga/Atari/Acorn had already made inroads, and there would have been a shake-out and consolidation. Without the PC it's likely some other manufacturer - possibly even Compaq - would have jumped on S100 instead and commoditised it. Probably with 68k and maybe Concurrent CP/M and/or BSD. It only needed one company to make the marketing leap. So standardisation was likely inevitable. Sales growth might have been slower, with more churn for consumer/gaming machines. But the technology would have started from a higher base. And it wouldn't have been held back by the miserably poor design of Intel hardware and MS software, both of which regressed existing levels of tech by at least a decade. The worst thing about the PC was that it established such low user expectations: slow, ugly, crippled machines that sort-of worked in a very limited way with poor security, stability, and reliability, and "standard" software products that were even worse.
- oblio 5y agoThat not how anything works. Businesses wanted anything, literally any working product. The competition mostly stood there in their ivory towers (NeXT was the best representative of this), shrugged their noses at the folks that needed cheap computers for, you know, the computing revolution and over time, keeled over. > slow, ugly, crippled machines that sort-of worked in a very limited way with poor security, stability, and reliability, and "standard" software products that were even worse Yet they worked and they were cheap. Slow didn't matter because they worked. Ugly didn't matter because they worked. "Crippled machines that sort-of worked in a very limited way with poor security, , stability, and reliability, and 'standard' software products that were even worse" didn't matter because they worked and nobody truly cares about security as the main ongoing concern. Stability was good enough. Reliability was good enough. The standards were good enough. And the main thing, I repeat this: PCs were CHEAP. Anything I can't afford might as well not exist on the planet. It's not there. I can't do anything with it. Companies could afford PCs and they did what was needed. Not what some people thought would be needed, they did what was actually needed.
- cable2600 5y agoMicrosoft coped the DRI CP/M model. Sell the OS to PC Makers and make it a standard. IBM used off the shelf parts for the IBM PC, so others were able to copy it easily. When IBM made the PS/2 series with Microchannel it was supposed to be a clone killer. Ironic that IBM does not make PCs anymore, and sold that IP to Lenovo.
- pjmlp 5y agoYou forgot the BIOS part, had Compaq not been able to stand in court, the clones would have been dead right there.
- wombatmobile 5y agoThe interesting thing about the BIOS is that IBM published the (fully commented) source code for it in the Technical Reference Manual.
- kolinko 5y agoWell, IBM needed some sort of a business model…
- cable2600 5y agoWindows killed off the Commodore Amiga and Atari ST. It almost killed off Apple until Apple bought out NexT to make MacOSX and bring back Steve Jobs.
- pjmlp 5y agoCommodore management killed Amiga, Microsoft didn't need to do much effort trying it.
- tibbydudeza 5y agoIt was DOOM actually beside Commodore management. It showed that software rendering on increasing faster Intel CPU's could outmatch the Amiga chipset which stagnated because a) The original chip/OS architects left Commodore b) It was too closely tied to the Motorola 68000 timing/bus architecture which did not match Intel.
- smackeyacky 5y agoI dont think it was Doom. The IBM and clones ran Lotus 1-2-3 and Wordperfect. Wordperfect replaced a lot of expensive word processing systems. Lotus had no real competitors on mini or mainframe computers. Lotus was a true killer app that upended office work completely. Once you had those and a serial terminal program for your legacy system there was no way the 8 bit inspired computers like amiga would ever compete again. Macs were a distant but respectable competitor but only in niche markets. Then networking shut the door completely. If you system couldn't do ethernet you were boned. The workstation vendors had a brief period where they had a shot but the PC market caught up too fast. Doom was fun but by 1993 when it was released the PC had already dominated the market for over a decade.
- mikewarot 5y ago>Then networking shut the door completely. If you system couldn't do ethernet you were boned. I did ARCnet for quite a long time before 10base2 and eventually 10 Base-T took off. If you were really poor, you could use "The $25 network" from Information Modes and serial ports.
- kristopolous 5y agoAlright, so let's do counterfactuals. IBM ignores the microcomputer, what's the world of say 1995 look like? Appliance style smart tvs? LCD screen based landlines? Maybe a world of GRiD or GO computing tablets with Penpoint OS running on the AT&T hobbit processor? Jerry Kaplan never writing his seminal book on the affair and the word "startup" never being widely used? Canon and Brother having smarter word processors that take on the role of family computer? Everything run by Apple? Steve Jobs never getting muscled out and Omron introducing their Luna 88k to the US market, eating up the megabyte/megapixel/megapenny market that Jobs dreamed of? Nolan Bushnell never selling Atari and starting Chuck E Cheese? The 1982 video game crash never happening? Acorn flooding the American market with their Arm machines running RiscOS and then getting their ass kicked by Amiga? Quarterdeck DESQview taking off and being eaten up by Digital Research's GEM? RadioShack being the world's most valuable tech corporation with a stranglehold on every vertical in the industry only to finally get taken down by Be Inc? Ted Nelson's Xanadu running on Alan Kay's Dynabook with Jef Raskin doing the design? Microsoft continuing to focus on video games and releasing an 8 bit competitor to the NES that could be used on Control Video Corporation's network who never pivots and changes their name to AOL? Gates snatches up the ID software crew who writes Doom and Wolfenstein 3D as Microsoft projects and Bill Gates is talked about in the same breath as John Carmack and Shigeru Miyamoto? Meanwhile Gary Kildall, famed maker of CP/M becomes the richest man in the world and public enemy #1 in DOJ monopoly trials of the late 90s after he steals the top secret project OS/2 from IBM and clones it out from under them in project Windy City? The Soul of a New Machine by Tracy Kidder movie actually getting made? From the far horizons of the unknown come transcribed tales of new dimensions in time and space. These are stories of the future; adventures in which you'll live in a million could-be years on a thousand may-be worlds!
- TMWNN 5y ago>Appliance style smart tvs? Vernor Vinge's smart settop box as the computing center of the home never made sense. People connect video game consoles to the family TV because they play video games in lieu of watching TV. General-purpose computing can be and often is done in conjunction with the TV. >LCD screen based landlines? Only makes sense in the context of Minitel-style mass distribution of free terminals and centralized networks. The French state had economic and, more important, geopolitical reasons for pushing this; private US telcos did not. >Maybe a world of GRiD or GO computing tablets with Penpoint os running on the AT&T hobbit processor? Newton proved that it wasn't practical in 1995 to deliver accurate handwriting parsing in a consumer-level computing device, and that was by a company with enormous experience with consumer-level computing devices. >Canon and Brother having smarter word processors that take on the role of family computer? Only if they are ever willing to go the extra mile and develop OSes that support third-party applications, while providing developer kits. (Yes, yes, Brother did release a couple of PC-compatibles, but all it had to do was to license MS-DOS like every other clone maker.) There's no reason to think that the Canon Cat would be any less of a bomb in a PC-less world. >Everything run by Apple? In offices, yes. The IBM PC singlehandedly pushed Apple IIs out of corporate America. Desktop CP/M only worked in the SMB market because of VARs and SIs; Fortune 500 needed, if not a brand name it trusted (IBM), a company that seemed professional (Apple). Cromemco, Vector, IMSAI, and such never had the professionalism or market share to get themselves into boardrooms. A possibility is prepackaged CP/M boxes filtering upward from Osborn and Kaypro once they get beachheads into businesses via their sewing machines. But even were that to happen I suspect that the lack of a single 5.25" disk format is alone enough to prevent widespread CP/M adoption. >Nolan Bushnell never selling Atari and starting Chuck E Cheese? Happened before 1981. The best outcome for Atari, really, is Armonk deciding in summer 1980 that Boca Raton and all other IBM facilities are too hidebound to develop a successful inexpensive PC, and instead going ahead and full-fledged buying Atari from Warner Communications. IBM decides to follow the System 360 model and uses the 8-bit computer line as the center of an entire line of products, everything from a next-generation videogame console (the 5200, except in 1982 and 100% compatible with existing 8-bit software) to dumb terminals for businesses to the high-end 1450XLD mini-workstation. >The 1982 video game crash never happening? Only if Atari (whether IBM-run or not) puts out a Nintendo-style licensing system enforced by lockout chip. The problem is that third-party publishers would just focus on Intellivision and ColecoVision instead. The model only works if everyone does it. >Acorn flooding the American market with their Arm machines running RiscOS and then getting their ass kicked by Amiga? Acorn was completely inept at marketing in its home market. Even with government subsidies and status as quasi-official "British home computer" the BBC Micro's market share was far smaller than Sinclair and Commodore, and comparable to Amstrad despite its late entry, and as you indicate the Amiga and ST crushed the RiscOS boxes in the UK too. Commodore UK may have start to finish been better marketers than the US parent, but there's no reason to think that Acorn US would have been any better than in its UK parent; the brief attempt to market the BBC Micro in the US is evidence of that. >Quarterdeck DESQview taking off and being eaten up by Digital Research's GEM? No IBM PC = No DESQview. We might have, however, seen Concurrent CP/M and MP/M continue CP/M-80's co-dominance of the business market outside Apple. >RadioShack being the world's most valuable tech corporation with a stranglehold on every vertical in the industry? Absolutely not. Radio Shack almost willfully throwing away a natural monopoly in the US personal computer market is among the biggest missed opportunities in history. One Tandy Tower got lucky with the TRS-80, then did everything possible to ruin it. It got lucky again with the Tandy 1000 then got run over by the rush to zero margins that hit everyone else in the US industry outside Dell, Compaq, and HP. Even without the PC, by 1981 Apple had surpassed Tandy by encouraging third-party developers despite the latter's huge early lead and massive proven supply and retail chains. >Microsoft continuing to focus on video games and releasing an 8 bit competitor to the NES that could be used on Control Video Corporation's network who never pivots and changes their name to AOL? I know you especially don't mean this to be serious, but ... this isn't completely crazy. Without the PC, Microsoft remains focused on programming languages with small consumer (Adventure, Decathlon) and hardware (Z80 SoftCard) businesses. I know I said that the settop box model doesn't work for general-purpose computing, but I can see ex-P&G marketer Ballmer convincing Gates and Allen that a locked-down videogame console with a razor-and-blades model is both a good moneymaker and a way of getting the Microsoft brand into homes. >The Soul of a New Machine by Tracy Kidder movie actually getting made? I'd like to see on the big screen that unnamed developer toiling away in the background, subtly getting more and more stressed, until sometime in act 5 he suddenly quits leaving that resignation letter on Tom West's desk. Maybe Netflix will do a miniseries.
- kolinko 5y agoPC is just an example of an open architecture that won over the closed ones. If IBM wouldn’t do it nor other producers, we would be locked down in multiple closed systems. As much as I loved Amiga and I like MacOS and iOS, I wouldn’t want a world without alternatives.
- tibbydudeza 5y agoWay too many whacky architectures that was incompatible with each other. 8 bits/16 bit Amstrad - Commodore - Spectrum - Apple - Amiga It was a good thing a standard evolved.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoExcept business has been paying the Microsoft/Intel tax ever since. I'd prefer some more diversity (and that doesn't mean choosing between Ubuntu and Fedora).
- flohofwoe 5y agoI think the success of the IBM PC is the perfect example why an (accidentally) open system without any single platform owner is always better for innovation than a platform that's owned by a single company. Yes, the PC world is chaotic, messy and generally "suboptimal", but during that time in early to late 90's the PC platform simply left everything else in the dust, cheap home computers, expensive UNIX workstations (and Macs, which have been their own category basically). Of course the progress was completely unguided, and 90% of everything was crap, and of the remaining 10%, 90% were just ok, but the remaining brilliant 1% were enough for the "actual" computer revolution. Disclaimer: am still an Amiga fanboy by heart.
- oblio 5y ago> Of course the progress was completely unguided, and 90% of everything was crap, and of the remaining 10%, 90% were just ok, but the remaining brilliant 1% were enough for the "actual" computer revolution. You only need to take a look at the "carefully curated" Play Store and App Store to realize that 90% of everything is crap, since that's the Iron Law of Everything, but now we pay 30% to the gatekeepers because... why not? I swear every company everywhere, since the 90's, and especially in software, has CEOs swearing they're not going to be the "dumb pipes" and become utilities, in order to extract the "maximum value for shareholders", while we get nickel and dimed for everything and frequently get lower quality for it.
- pjmlp 5y agoExpensive UNIX workstations is kind of ironic (and they were quite expensive), because the only reason they came to be was UNIX being freely available with source code like the annotated V6 book and AT&T tapes, versus the existing competing OSes.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoNever understood why they went with that grey color. Even other computers used the same color. I remember buying a Atari 1020st (I might have gotten the number wrong). I bought it for word processing, since writing was my weak subject. I remember getting the computer home, and was hooked. I went through college without telling anyone about my computer. I felt like I was cheating. The only thing I never liked was that horrid beige color. Years later, while in a bad mood, I tossed my computer, and printer. There hasen't been a week that went by where I regret throwing it away. I tossed it because it was becomming obsolete, but mainly because of the color. Does anyone know for sure why so many manufacturers when with that beige?
- GekkePrutser 5y agoIt was the 1040st. But it wasn't beige. That one was light gray. I always thought it was quite stylish. The Amiga was beige like most of the PCs of that era. As for the reason, I think it was just fashion. Beige + smoked glass doors was fashionable in the early 80s in offices.
- kfprt 5y agoThe usual answer is German office furniture design laws but I've not verified this.
- blackhaz 5y agoAmazing color. I wish we could go back from soulless black and silver. Still addicted to it and having a gray 386DX-40 and Pentium 133 MHz, typing this on a gray 101-key keyboard. Mmmmm... :-P
- uniqueid 5y agoI love the 'beige box' color too, though without the nostalgic value I would probably find it hideous. It would be nice if there were a 'retro' fad in mainstream computer design for a few years. It would be a blast to see beige PCs again with multicolored keyboards and glowing green LEDs.
- 5y ago
- tibbydudeza 5y agoAmazing that IBM of all companies managed to do this. Afaik it was an internal skunkworks project led by a rather visionary for IBM leader that knew it would be dead if it did things the IBM way. IBM made the market legitimate and the bus spec was open and anybody could make expansion cards without paying royalties.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoI don't think IBM's vision included companies like Compaq and Dell coming along and undercutting their business.
- tibbydudeza 5y agoIBM top brass considered the PC market something they had to be in that could use to upsell other more expensive IBM kit. They were very surprised when it became a hit and established a new market but then they lost it when the closed spec MCA (Microchannel Architecture) PC. The cloners (Dell/Compaq) banded together and did EISA (Extended ISA) in reponse and went their own way.
- kabdib 5y agoThe technical documentation was really good. Complete BIOS listing (that as fun to read), and IIRC there were circuit diagrams (since there was very little VLSI -- just the processor, memory, and a bunch of gate-level TTL chips). I think that BIOS listing sealed IBM's fate to lose control of the platform; it made it near trivial for a competitor to analyze and shove under the doorway of a "clean room" team to reimplement.
- chadcmulligan 5y agoA lot of things had circuit diagrams then, I did chip level repairs on Kaypro clones, and CP/M machines at the time, and it was all TTL off the shelf chips. You could follow the signals through the diagram with a logic probe, clip out the broken gates, clean the board, and pop in a new one, it was very satisfying.
- 5y ago
- forinti 5y agoPCs didn't seem worth it to me until the 386s came out. I'd much rather a BBC Micro instead of a 5150 or an Amiga or Archimedes instead of an AT. So I'm not sure how they managed to survive.
- throw0101a 5y ago> PCs didn't seem worth it to me until the 386s came out. And what about that sweet, sweet 80387 FP co-processor? Ever have one of those? There was a video game which had an entire section of it available only if it detected an FPU: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_3.0 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_3.0
- rasz 5y agoFalcons "realistic" flight model had broken physics. The only other game from 386 era would be SimCity where FPU gives negligent speedup.