6 ms·
Google may cut pay of staff who work from home
- hiddencache 5y agoYes, I hear they're struggling financially...
- superflit 5y agoIf I move to Luxemburg will they pay more? This is the Nth article trying to convey the new narrative. The narrative that "we need to go back". No! We don't need. The market is hot and we can choose. Take the simple math. 1 hour commuting one way. 2 hours by day, 10 hours by week, 40 hours by month. Working at home gives you back at least 40h. Working at home GIVES you BACK AT least 1 Week! And I am not even talking about better food, spresso machine and gym! Now we are fighting climate change staying at home and reducing our carbon print not commuting. Think of the children!
- joshuamorton 5y ago> if I move to Luxemburg will they pay more? Yes, or at least if you move to higher cost markets (Zurich, sf, etc.) You'll be paid more than you might have been otherwise. It just happens than Google already has established offices in like all of the most expensive cities.
- swader999 5y agoIt's 85 weeks over a 30 year career.
- turbinerneiter 5y agoSo why was the employee not OK with taking a pay cut for all those benefits? And if he is gonna be remote anyway, then why not outsource his job to a country with lower cost of living and therefore lower cost of labor? And doesn't mean that we have to pay everyone more who _has_ to come to work? I.e. because they need to go the factory floor? Or they need to go the power plant? Don't just look at half the equation.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> And doesn't mean that we have to pay everyone more who _has_ to come to work? I.e. because they need to go the factory floor? Or they need to go the power plant? You only have to pay someone more if you cannot find someone to do the job for lower pay.
- 00deadbeef 5y agoI’m already reaping the rewards of WFH. I used to have the energy to go to gym maybe twice a week after work, then eat some rubbish food because I didn’t have the energy to spend another hour in the kitchen. Now I can be at my gym when it opens at 06:30, have a good workout, shower, walk home, cook breakfast, and still have 30 mins before I need to start working. I can even fit in short cardio sessions in the evening and have returned home and made a nutritious meal by the time I’d normally just be getting home from work. I go to the gym seven times a week now with no net reduction in my free time. I eat a better diet. I save money. I’m happier and more relaxed. My home office is a much more productive space than the noisy open plan office we have. I never start the working day in a bad mood whereas a bad commute (delays, bad weather, unpleasant people, etc) used to put me in a lousy mood for the rest of the day.
- Johnny555 5y agoNot all commutes are equal (both in environmental footprint and desirability). One of my favorite commutes was about an hour by train -- I lived 5 minutes from the station and my job was a short walk from the station. It was a reverse commute, so I always got a seat. I got a lot of reading done and I didn't consider it to be "wasted time". Another favorite long commute was 45 minutes by bike, almost all on a separated bike trail. Of course, my current 30 second bedroom to livingroom commute is probably my favorite commute of all time, but my point is not all commutes are horrible. And even my current work-from-home commute has its drawbacks, like no clear separation between office and home life.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> We don't need. The market is hot and we can choose. Then this will not be a problem for Alphabet employees that are unhappy with a decrease in pay.
- oneplane 5y agoI suppose it won't be a problem of similar size, but still a problem. Google does a thing and now you suddenly have to also do a thing as a reaction. If Google didn't do the thing, then the employees also didn't have to to a thing and that would have been easier.
- optimusclimb 5y agoApparently chat around the water cooler was the real source of all of their innovation. It’s worth $600 an hour.
- macintux 5y ago665 comments yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28127240 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28127240 Other active thread today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28141464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28141464
- dang 5y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Google employees who work from home could lose money - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28127240 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28127240 - Aug 2021 (670 comments) Google rolls out ‘pay calculator’ explaining work-from-home salary cuts - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28137561 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28137561 - Aug 2021 (100 comments) Google may cut pay of staff who work from home - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28141464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28141464 - Aug 2021 (41 comments)
- tyronehed 5y agoIn the past, Google's motto was: "Don't be evil." Their new one; "Evil."
- gootler 5y agoOh the horror! I guess they should have googled what would happen if the abandoned the shit slidewalks of San Francisco.
- Swizec 5y agoI really think mentoring and knowledge sharing is easier in person. I am certain heads down work is easier from home. Especially if you have a good setup. I don’t know how to reconcile this. A hybrid approach isn’t it because the best (technical) mentoring happens when someone is heads down and gets stuck. Plus commuting some days and not others is hella disruptive to a routine. I need routine to be most productive.
- Johnny555 5y agoIf the person that lives in NYC (but works remotely) gets paid more than the person that lives in Stamford and works remotely, those Stamford employees should all get together and rent a shared studio apartment in NYC and use that as their primary home address. They can even use it for overnights when they come to the city and stay late.
- brianwawok 5y agoRight, and committing fraud is a good way to get fired or worse.
- Johnny555 5y agoWhy is it fraud? It's an actual apartment that they can use when they are in the city for work. It's not like it's just a mail drop, it's a physical apartment and the employee is on the lease.
- sidhanthp 5y agoYou have to be there for > half the year to legally be a resident
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Johnny555 5y agoMy employer doesn't ask me where I've established residency, they ask for my "Home address", and if I can't find anything in our employee manual describing what a home address is other than "where you can receive mail". I don't know what Google's policy is.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoYou will be violating tax laws by not stating the real location of where you are working.
- hk1337 5y agoIf it’s just because they’re working at home then it’s bullshit. If it’s really a pay adjustment for them moving to a different location, meh.
- amelius 5y agoWhat is wrong with this economy? Why can't we be paid simply for what we produce? Rather than by where we live, the people we know, where we work from, the salary negotiations years ago when we were hired, ...
- lotsofpulp 5y agoHow do you calculate what a janitor produces? Or a programmer? Or a school counselor? A teacher? I have yet to see a better method of determining price than two parties agreeing on a number.
- snakeboy 5y agoThen even harder: How about a stay-at-home mother?
- amelius 5y ago> I have yet to see a better method of determining price than two parties agreeing on a number. There's information asymmetry here, as the employer knows what all the other employees make. Also, it seems that "agreeing on a number" doesn't work as Google unilaterally decides that working from home somehow changes the agreement.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI am a proponent of full price transparency in order to come as close to ideal function marketplaces as possible so that resources are best allocated. But even without full knowledge (which is probably impossible to achieve and one of the functions of a market is to incorporate the various pieces of knowledge of all the participants), prices are still determined by two parties agreeing on a number, and just because Google has more power, the opposing entity is still agreeing to the new number if they continue selling their labor to Google.
- auspex 5y agoI mean if you look at it from the other way… they agree to pay $X for the work but give you an increase of $Y to support a higher cost of living in certain areas to be near the office. This is being spun as a decrease instead of seeing that people actually have had an increase because of CoL. which no longer applies if you move. If you agreed to $X and then move to say the Bay Area would you expect them to keep your salary the same?
- danhacks 5y agoCompanies changing salaries based on location makes it a really interesting problem for someone working remote to find the combination of a high salary location, low expenses, and low or no tax state.
- ChrisLTD 5y agoOnce you're making Google money, I would think the overriding concern would be where you actually would like to live. What environment do you find stimulating? Where are you likely to meet people that share your values? Do you want to be close to family?
- johnnyb9 5y agoActually, I think if anything, when you make "Google" money, the stakes become a lot higher. Taxes are easy enough to ignore when the base amount is low.
- qmarchi 5y agoHonestly, I agree with the policy. The fundamental misunderstanding that people who say "Why aren't we paid for what you produce" is that the existing compensation _is_ paying for what you produce, it's also taking into account the price of the location you're working. Why _should_ an engineer working from Seattle, where rent is ~2k for a 1bd, not get paid more than the engineer working from Bentonville, AR, where a 1bd is $800? Your compensation is made up of what the company expects for you to spend _because_ you're working in a particular location. (Disc: I work for Google, opinion is my own tho.)
- qkqk 5y agoThen the money Google saves on HVAC, restrooms, facilities, support staff and office space should be going directly into the pockets of the employees that convert to fulltime remote, right? > Your compensation is made up of what the company expects for you to spend _because_ you're working in a particular location. That's Google's model?! I can live 10 minutes away from the office or 1 hour away by train, I still live in the same city. If I move my apartment 50 minutes closer to the office, I'm still going to the same office, but my rent will go up. I should get more compensation right? My compensation is based on what I'm expected to spend by location.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoConversely, I can also live 10 minutes away but in a different city. Think LA. Funny, but off-topic story relating to this: I once had my debit card shut off because I tripped a fraud alert by being in 5 different cities on the same day. This was in LA, and I really was in 5 different cities that day, but I probably didn't drive 50 miles.
- bbarnett 5y agoTo be fair, they probably figured it was impossible, due to LA traffic.
- bencollier49 5y agoWould you pay twice the regular rate for an identical pair of trainers that had been made in a different place? Unless the location of the employee has a material impact on their output, it seems bizarre to offer different payment for the same thing.
- lhorie 5y agoKind of not-really-news. FTA: - pay stays the same if WFH is from same city - several employers other than Google have policies to adjust pay based on location - the calculator they developed is to help make employees make data-based decisions (this is in contrast to other companies where no such calculator exists and one is left to guess and/or initiate talks with their boss that may or may not end awkwardly) Another unspoken thing: there's such thing as salary negotiations and exceptions. "If I take a 10% cut, I'm leaving" is a perfectly reasonable thing to say in such a negotiation, and maintaining current salaries is something these types of employers are not culturally against (the way some middle management thinks of performance notwithstanding). The general goal of the policy is to make things "fair" in the sense that they already have employees in lower-pay locations and it's unfair/potentially problematic to have two people in that same location doing similar work but being paid vastly different amounts. The "why don't they just pay everyone SV salaries everywhere" argument is obviously from people who never ran businesses and are just disguisedly wishing they made more money: saving money on salaries is done for the same reason companies do tax-related shenanigans. In Google's case, even the employees are kinda in on the scheme, as bottom line affects quarterly reports, and thus their equity compensation...
- paulcole 5y ago> "If I take a 10% cut, I'm leaving" is a perfectly reasonable thing to say in such a negotiation If you're going to say this in a negotiation, you have to be ready for the counterparty to say "OK".
- vsareto 5y agoYeah, ultimatums kinda suck as a negotiation tool for employees. High risk, low reward most of the time. I would replace it with explaining that the pay cut makes you unhappy and/or makes the position less appealing. Make it an assessment of the position and the pay, but don't talk about actions that will come from it (like leaving or job searching). Telling them what you'll do is like obviously telegraphing your next move in a fight.
- 5y ago
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoIf any of the FAANG companies decide not to collude with the others on this, here's their opportunity to poach talent. Outside of FAANG (and the few others who pay FAANG salaries), companies that do this are going to find retention is a big problem. It's unlikely anyone is going to leave Google for AFLAC and turn a 10% work from home decrease into a 60% change of employer decrease but certainly there could be movement between other companies as some will see WFH as an opportunity to staff up instead of trying to find a path back to where we're never going to be again.
- dep_b 5y agoWell I guess any time is a good time to leave Google, now with a little encouragement from the management. Would be great for actually innovative companies to scoop up some great engineers that would otherwise be working on advertisement money extraction algorithms.
- discopicante 5y agoTwo counter points: 1) I want to be paid _more_ if I'm working from home. My employer doesn't have a right to use my personal property (my home, my energy, my coffee, etc.) without additional compensation. 2) Driving up compensation regardless of location is a great way to incentivize monopolistic behavior (e.g. FAANG) over the talent market while making it more difficult for new / smaller orgs to compete for talent.
- s0rce 5y agoExactly, I live in the Bay area and now that my wife and I work from home our previously totally adequate 1 bdrm is now too small to work comfortably. Particularly when we are both on calls. Getting another bedroom for an office is going to be $10000/yr after tax, don't see my work paying for that. If I was 100% remote I could move somewhere cheaper but I can't since I have to go in occasionally (scientist in the lab).
- abakker 5y agoOTOH, your employer used to compensate you for using your car, your gas, your time to commute. Now they know you are not doing that. I would be surprised if the average FAANG car commuter spent more at home than commuting. My feeling is that things should be left the same, but I think your POV is definitely valid. The _space_ at home becomes a problem especially for those in expensive cities and lower compensations. Affording an extra bedroom is not always possible.
- fab13n 5y agoAnother spin to the same story: major employer agrees that forcing people to commute to office deserves substantial extra pay. Google employees are in a more-than-fair position when it comes to negotiate compensation. If the deal sucks, then Google will revise it and/or lose part of its talents, but the issue will fix itself. Then again, maybe the issue was they were compensating people so that they accept SV commutes and house prices, and everyone is realizing that most people don't need to live in SV. So the ludicrous compensations aren't needed either.
- chadlavi 5y agoThis is truly asinine bullshit. Your work doesn't add less value to your company, you don't work any less hard. Where your body is physically located is irrelevant.
- dathinab 5y agoShouldn't they increase pay because the from home workers costing them less (no office, self paid electricity and cleaning etc.)?
- akmarinov 5y agoWho checks where you work from? Can a 100 devs pitch in and rent a house next to Google’s office and claim that that’s where they all live, while working from somewhere else?