6 ms·
Are they really selling vaccines for $19/dose? Seems like bad business when plenty of countries would have paid $1000/dose if they could get the first deliveri
by londons_explore 5y ago
Are they really selling vaccines for $19/dose?
Seems like bad business when plenty of countries would have paid $1000/dose if they could get the first deliveries and open their economy a few months earlier.
And those higher prices could have supported more factories being built to make more doses quicker.
Where there backdoor payments to decide who got which doses first?
- DangerousPie 5y agoThe bottleneck in Covid vaccine production has never really been a lack of money. No matter how much money you throw at the problem, it would still take years to build up the necessary supply chains and get the raw materials you need. This is especially true for mRNA vaccines, which are a new technology that require different ingredients and manufacturing processes.
- lm28469 5y agoWhen people ask for the difference between US and EU business thinking I'll send them that comment. This shit simply doesn't fly in Germany, it's so insane that no one would ever think about pricing life saving drugs that high
- refurb 5y agoOh really? The first million dollar drug came out of Europe. https://bioengineeringcommunity.nature.com/posts/45406-1-million-price-tag-set-for-glybera-gene-therapy https://bioengineeringcommunity.nature.com/posts/45406-1-mil... “The first gene therapy approved in the Western world is set to go on sale in Germany at a cost close to $1 million per treatment. The record-breaking price tag came to light in November 2014, when Amsterdam-based Uniqure and its marketing partner Chiesi, of Parma, Italy, filed a pricing dossier with German authorities to launch Glybera.”
- lm28469 5y agoI'm not talking about experimental fringe therapies here. We can talk about insulin if you want ;)
- systemvoltage 5y agoYour comment is just fanning the flames with no interesting discussion for the audience. When a counter point is presented, you're moving goal posts. Moderna is selling vaccines for $20/pop. That's a US company. Vaccines are also purchased by the Governments usually to be distributed for free. In US, you can get a COVID-vaccine shot for free anywhere in any state.
- oaiey 5y agoThe key difference: the insurences in Germany would never pay that.
- skybrian 5y agoI agree that they shouldn’t charge that much, but it’s definitely worth that much, and probably a lot more. Maybe they should have done a charity auction of a few doses at the beginning to billionaires to show what it’s really worth, for the marketing value of “you’re getting a medicine worth hundreds of thousands of dollars for free.” Maybe that would convince the anti-vaxers?
- input_sh 5y agoI agree on the worth part. I could afford to spend hundreds of euros to go to a nearby country and get an EU-approved vaccine months ago. Overall I estimate those hundreds of euros got me vaccinated about six months earlier than I would be in my own country. During that time months ago one of our politicians came out and said that thousands of my fellow citizens that did the same were "wasting money on something that only costs €10", but that means nothing when you can't get to that something that only costs €10.
- oaiey 5y agoIt does not work because of our insurance system. In all other businesses it would work. Ask yourself what a security package in any German car brand costs extra. Camera in the rear, extra airbags, lidar/ai, speed sign scanning,.. that is not default but a very expensive extra.
- jopsen 5y agoJust a reminder it was the US that blocked vaccine exports. While we in the EU let the free market handle things. Of course, EU countries were smart enough to buy vaccines collectively :)
- systemvoltage 5y agoEU's vaccine program was a shit show: https://www.economist.com/briefing/2021/03/31/why-the-eus-covid-19-vaccination-programme-went-wrong https://www.economist.com/briefing/2021/03/31/why-the-eus-co...
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoThe EU did the right thing ethically and let vaccines be exported to their allies. In the long run they caught up though. Amazing that Canada was forced to import from the EU because we were prevented from importing from our nearest neighbour and "closest ally" and so were set back by two months on vaccinations.
- blibble 5y ago> The EU did the right thing ethically and let vaccines be exported to their allies. no, it thought it had control over the situation and started virtue signalling that it was being ethical and that vaccine nationalism was only the sort of thing the Trump administration would do and at the point it became apparent that it had lost control: the nationalistic flailing began
- jopsen 5y ago> no, it thought it had control over the situation and started virtue signalling... As I understood it, the US had laws necessary to administratively enact export restrictions during emergencies. I suspect the EU didn't have the same leaver it could just magically pull. Some individual countries might, but that's no use when production is distributed across the EU. Unlike the US the EU doesn't have disasters management agencies, many things are left for individual countries. Generally, there is no administrative authority in the EU that can really do much -- where as the US president can take a lot of actions. The EU would like have had to draft laws stopping exports, and those could be challenged in courts, etc. More likely, the EU just didn't have an easy button to push, and nobody has agreed upfront on which cases such button should be used.
- usrusr 5y agoEven Germany bought from Pfizer, not from Biontech, which indicates that the differences can't be as wide as you suggest (or as gp suggests)
- danck 5y agoIt may help to know that BioNTech were in fact the developers of the Pfizer vaccine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pfizer%E2%80%93BioNTech_COVID-19_vaccine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pfizer%E2%80%93BioNTech_COVID-...
- usrusr 5y agoSure, and they can be proud of it and make all that money, but if you are in the market to ramp up a vaccination programme, you talk to Pfizer and not to Biontech. Almost like you'd go to Apple and not to FHG IIS for buying an iPod. (I'm pretty sure that this comparison is a wild exaggeration of what actually happened and that Biontech representatives were very much involved in all the talks, but I assume more in an expert advisor role than as someone with actual influence on the outcome)
- adventured 5y ago> It may help to know that BioNTech were in fact the developers of the Pfizer vaccine It may help to know that Pfizer directly helped with the development - not just the manufacturing & distribution - and deserves some credit as well (even if not as much as BioNTech). From their March 27, 2020 co-development press release: "Pfizer and BioNTech to Co-develop Potential COVID-19 Vaccine" "Builds on 2018 agreement to jointly develop an mRNA-based influenza vaccine" "The collaboration aims to accelerate development of BioNTech’s potential first-in-class COVID-19 mRNA vaccine program, BNT162, which is expected to enter clinical testing by the end of April 2020. The rapid advancement of this collaboration builds on the research and development collaboration into which Pfizer and BioNTech entered in 2018 to develop mRNA-based vaccines for prevention of influenza."
- suction 5y agoPfizer surely did help monetarily (investments) and offers global distribution, but that doesn't mean they had any hand in developing the science and the product. Any big pharmaceutical company, like Bayer, could have done the same, but randomly Pfizer got lucky this time.
- wil421 5y agoIt costs the same in the US and Germany, $19.50. There will always be a scummy Martin Shkreli[1] type and Germany is not immune to this. See VW and Wireguard. BaFin seemed to ignore red flags presumably because it was another darling of the German economy similar to VW. The US also moves very slow legally but the reckoning is coming for Pharmaceutical price gouging. Lots and lots of hype in the past few years about it. [1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2018/03/09/martin-shkreli-sentenced-7-years-prison/359705002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2018/03/09/martin-shkre...
- albatross13 5y agoHow did you figure out it was 19.50 a dose in the US? As far as I've seen, Pfizer has all but ensured their contracts with various governments are not publicly available.
- wil421 5y agoIt’s mentioned in this article[1] but they won’t tell you the specific contract. I assumed it was universal but I guess Federal and State agencies negotiate their own contracts. My state will pay for it wether or not you have insurance. > Pfizer's agreement with the federal government is the most lucrative to date. The government agreed to buy 100 million doses of the Pfizer coronavirus vaccine, being developed with German biotech firm BioNTech, for $1.95 billion. That works out to about $20 per dose.[2] [1]https://www.fiercepharma.com/pharma/pfizer-eyes-higher-covid-19-vaccine-prices-after-pandemic-exec-analyst https://www.fiercepharma.com/pharma/pfizer-eyes-higher-covid... [2] https://www.gpb.org/news/shots-health-news/2020/08/08/prices-for-covid-19-vaccines-are-starting-come-focus https://www.gpb.org/news/shots-health-news/2020/08/08/prices...
- suction 5y agoWhat VW did was dirty, but didn't really include a component of price gouging. Wiregard was straight-up fraud, by an agent working for Russia and greediness paired with stupidity on part of the CEO etc. Not to diminish the negative effects for the reputation of Germany of these two cases, but they both aren't an expression of libertarianism like the idea that a company has no moral obligations to offer an important drug for an affordable price, but should make as much money as possible from it, which wouldn't fly in Germany.
- lostlogin 5y ago> When people ask for the difference between US and EU business thinking I'll send them that comment. The comment you refer to is also a good summary of US healthcare practices and billing.
- mathverse 5y agoI think countries would simply threaten with nationalizing the company if the company tried something ridiculous during a global pandemic.
- thepasswordis 5y agoFor much of the world there is no difference between $20, $1000, and $100,000. This vaccine should be free. Covid is the biggest threat to the future of humanity that has existed since the development of nuclear weapons and we're holding back the solution over $20. It's pathetic.
- kansface 5y ago> This shit simply doesn't fly in Germany, it's so insane that no one would ever think about pricing life saving drugs that high A sizeable portion of my friends and coworkers managed to work the system to gain access to vaccines well before they otherwise would have. I'd strongly prefer the honest version of that system, wherein we wouldn't pretend that elites wouldn't cut the queue to finagle vaccines for themselves and their families. One option would have been setting aside ~5% of the total supply and putting it on the open market. I'd guess early doses would have gone for a few thousand dollars and we could have used the money to support vaccinations elsewhere.
- trynumber9 5y agoWhy the US? The poster you reply to is from London. It's even in his user name. Did any US companies price their vaccines high either?
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take HN threads into nationalistic flamewar. It's tedious, poisonous, and off topic. Moreover, you don't know anything about where the other user was posting from. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gregoriol 5y agoIt is possible that some countries paid more: EU negociated hard, but maybe Dubai or Israel who go them first paid more, we'll probably never know.
- maratc 5y agoIsrael reportedly paid $35 per shot.
- kgwgk 5y agoEven less than that according to the link in your sibling comment.
- kgwgk 5y agoIsrael has paid only a bit more than that. https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-said-to-be-paying-average-of-47-per-person-for-pfizer-moderna-vaccines/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-said-to-be-paying-avera...
- kgwgk 5y ago> plenty of countries would have paid $1000/dose Really? Could you name a few?
- usrusr 5y agoI guess it would be the list of countries where leadership does not care much about vaccination outside of their close family. Not much business to be made there.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoI've worked with some top level executives of major pharma companies. This may come as a surprise, but they are, in fact, not monsters, and are concerned with the availability of their products to normal people. $19 is about $18 gross margin on each vaccine dose based on a quick google, which is still an exceptionally lucrative opportunity for something that is desired by several billion people.
- jopsen 5y ago> Are they really selling vaccines for $19/dose? Where did you get that number? > Seems like bad business when plenty of countries would have paid $1000/dose if they could get the first deliveries... This is probably why all EU countries bought vaccine collectively. (A) To avoid member states pushing up prices competing against each other. (B) To ensure they could demand some of the first doses, due to increased bargaining power given the sheet size of their order. Finally, keep in mind that with the US blocking exports of vaccines, the only free capitalist market for vaccines was the EU. Lol, one could even say the US went borderline communist :) Overall, it all worked out pretty reasonable. And I seriously doubt lack of capital have kept vaccine manufacturers from increasing production :)
- de_keyboard 5y agoThey were probably worried about border seizures or even forced nationalisation.
- anonuser123456 5y agoI don't know why this is downvoted... the question legitimately opens the door to a fundamental phenomena in markets... The answer is, corporations seek long term profits. Short term gouging tends to make customers angry and seek alternatives, and the same is true for large buyers/government agents. If this were a single transaction, it would make sense to extract as much revenue as possible. But Pfizer/BioNTech have to balance that against their long term relationships and how to maximize profit over long time scales.
- kurthr 5y agoAs someone who watched people from afar try to scale the mRNA vaccine process, the limiting factor was not manufacture of the RNA (BioNTech), but incorporation into lipid nanoparticles. That is not BioNTech's business (they are a subsidiary manufacturer for Pfizer)... it also is not Moderna's business since they outsource, but at least they are a direct source of funding rather than a cost center. Money was not an object to scaling the manufacture of the vaccines. It was people, knowledge, and equipment that had to be designed, built and tested. That all happened in parallel with statistical evaluation and approval processes. Nine people can't make a baby in 1 month no matter how much you pay them. https://www.pfizer.com/news/press-release/press-release-detail/pfizer-and-biontech-announce-further-details-collaboration https://www.pfizer.com/news/press-release/press-release-deta...
- kken 5y agoHere is a documentary about BioNTechs facility in Mainz https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWedf3mhLwQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWedf3mhLwQ The lipid process at shown at 3:00m
- kurthr 5y agoExcellent point to clarify. It is the materials (and equipment) for the encapsulation process that are the limiting step. Those are provided by Croda in the UK (in the case of Pfizer/BioNTech) not by BioNTech in Mainz as implied. BioNTech has very sophisticated manufacturing and packaging equipment there for sure, just not the limiting step. Or to be still more clear many labs have the ability to manufacture small quantities for initial studies, but not the volumes necessary to scale to 100M/mo capacity. https://blog.jonasneubert.com/2021/01/10/exploring-the-supply-chain-of-the-pfizer-biontech-and-moderna-covid-19-vaccines/ https://blog.jonasneubert.com/2021/01/10/exploring-the-suppl...
- toast0 5y ago$1000/dose is too high when everyone knows the unit costs aren't that high, and there are several other suppliers. And there wouldn't be much willingness for developed nations to pay for doses for developing nations at that price.
- _fizz_buzz_ 5y agoNo, you're obviously not understanding simple economic concepts. - They are not the only ones making a vaccine: There is also Moderna, J&J, AZ. So there is competition. - It's more profitable to sell 1 Billion vaccines for $19 than selling 1 Million vaccine for $1000 dollars.
- slumdev 5y agoMartin, is that you?