3 ms·
I don't know why they don't switch to a percentile based system. All the arguments against it are nonsense because people implicitly do it in their heads anyway
by IshKebab 5y ago
I don't know why they don't switch to a percentile based system. All the arguments against it are nonsense because people implicitly do it in their heads anyway. Like when someone says they got an A now you're immediately going to think "in 2019? that's pretty good" or "in 2021? only in the top 50%!".
Here are some common arguments against percentiles:
1. You can't compare grades across years!
You can't anyway because of grade inflation.
2. What if one year is intrinsically better than the previous year? Giving them the same overall score would be unfair.
Subjects at A level are big enough that that is extremely unlikely. Even for small subjects there are ways of doing it fairly though, based on performance in previous years.
3. We don't want people concentrating on tiny differences in percentiles.
They would be quantised like grades are.
- taurath 5y agoBecause in a perfect educating system with perfect students and teachers everyone would get 100%, and a percentile system has the same problems as stack ranking. It punishes success.