4 ms·
If some country decided that the operation of these power plants was a sufficiently offensive attack, they could bomb them. This would probably be a disaster fo
by amluto 5y ago
If some country decided that the operation of these power plants was a sufficiently offensive attack, they could bomb them. This would probably be a disaster for quite a few reasons, but it would strongly discourage the plants from operating.
A gentler approach would be a well designed cross border emission tax. This could make operation of these plants economically impractical.
- zdragnar 5y agoThe plants are being run because they are cheap and have plentiful supply, not because they are the most desirable form of production. Merely adding a new tax would be the most regressive solution available, as it disproportionately hurts the poorest- the consequences would take longer but could end up just as severe. Maybe they dont have access to plentiful natural gas, or grid storage for renewables. Maybe they simply dont have an economy healthy or government free enough of corruption to invest in the capital required to transition. A more reasonable approach would be to set up a program that fronts the necessary investments while letting the locals retain control... effectively a free loan. It would certainly meet the criterion of "gentler", at least, and probably cheaper than fuelling the planes and the bombs as well- those things are crazy expensive.
- tbarbugli 5y agoGermany, Japan and SK are extremely wealthy countries. I am sure they can manage if they really want to. Germany in particular made the stupid decision of shutting down nuclear plants (Fukushima overreaction) and it is pushing this narrative of being a green energy country… to me it sounds like an easy problem to solve once there is enough political attention.
- imtringued 5y agoNobody, not even Germans think it is a green country, they aren't pushing that narrative. Who told you that lie? Most likely you fell victim to American newspapers lying to you that Germany is pushing a green narrative. After all they lied about Germany moving back to coal. What happened is that Germany willingly delayed reductions in CO2 emissions. It clearly cared about the nuclear shutdown more than the coal shutdown. However, the articles are always about how emissions went up "because more coal" when that never happened. It's lies upon lies. Germany is a country that is standing still, neither getting better nor worse and likes it that way. It's not green and nobody pretended that it is green.
- adrianN 5y agoMost countries are very far away for the amounts of renewable production where one needs grid scale storage before being able to build more wind turbines and PV.
- rtpg 5y agoHow about taking the money to bomb and instead just like... build replacement plants? Why can't we just directly try to make things better instead of trying to punish people (especially who might not actually have the resources/power to do it themselves)?
- exporectomy 5y agoNot sure you understand how wars and diplomacy work. Remember how 9/11 strongly discouraged global American military and economic power? Neither. Or how Germany was justly punished into submission for causing WWI. They really were humbled into not starting any more wars weren't they?