10 ms·
> The secret to Blackbird, Cavallaro explained, is that once the wind gets the vehicle going, its wheels start to turn the propeller blades — they're connected
by michaelt 5y ago
> The secret to Blackbird, Cavallaro explained, is that once the wind gets the vehicle going, its wheels start to turn the propeller blades — they're connected to the blades by a chain. As the vehicle speeds up, its wheels turn the propeller faster and faster. The propeller blades, in turn, act as a fan, pushing more air behind the land yacht and thrusting it forward.
That's a terrible explanation - no wonder people doubt the system would work!
- sopooneo 5y agoYou're right that it falls far short, but it corrects one of the fundamental misunderstandings many people have about the vehicle: the wind does not spin the propeller, the wheels do.
- Valgrim 5y agoThen what is spinning the wheels?
- wizzwizz4 5y agoThe fact it's going forwards.
- Vvector 5y agoAnd what's making it go forward?
- foerbert 5y agoThe wind, I think. My current impression is that when it is starting, the whole thing is basically just acting as a big sail. You could lock the propeller and prevent it from spinning and it would still move forward. After that is where I start to get more fuzzy on the matter. On the one hand it makes sense that by using some of the speed from the wind to do other things, you can extract more total energy from the wind. And by doing propulsion as that "other thing" it makes sense you get up to a higher speed. But then it seems to me like there would be a problem once you go faster than the wind, because it's no longer pushing you. I'm not sure if some other effect takes over, or if I'm thinking about the wind in an incorrect way, or if my whole line of thought about this is wrong.
- Joeri 5y agoI may be wrong, but this is how I understand it. The propellers push against the wind. Effectively you’re creating a faster wind by pushing back at it. The energy that drives the propellers still comes indirectly entirely from the wind, but wind across a larger volume behind the propeller so therefore carrying more energy.
- jasonwatkinspdx 5y agoYou've got it exactly right.
- mumblemumble 5y agoAsking what is spinning what is maybe framing it in a way that impedes understanding. A quick summary of the basic forces involved are: The wind pushes the propeller, the propeller pushes the wheels, the wheels push the ground, the ground pushes the wheels, the wheels push the propeller, and the propeller pushes the wind. Or perhaps it's better to say that everything is dynamically interacting with everything else. I think that what this all adds up to is that, by introducing this mechanical linkage, the cart is extracting energy from the difference between the wind speed and the ground speed. This runs counter to our intuition, which assumes that it should be getting its energy from the difference between the wind's speed and its own speed. That's what allows it to go faster than the wind. If it were based off the difference between the wind speed and the cart speed, then the forward force would go to zero as the cart's speed approaches the wind speed. But the difference between the wind speed and the ground speed is not related to how fast the cart itself is moving. So the forward force on it doesn't disappear as it approaches the speed of the wind, and instead it will continue to accelerate until the forward force balances with drag and rolling friction. A kite might be a good starting intuition pump here? Kites generally don't do much of anything useful unless they're mechanically tethered to the ground. From there move on to sailboats. The reason why this cart can go downwind faster than the wind isn't all that far off from the reason a sailboat can sail into the wind (albeit not directly into the wind), but, critically, only if it has a keel or centerboard. (Edit: Another detail to point out is that the linkage causes the propeller to turn in the opposite direction it would if it were spinning freely. And remember that Newton's third law works in both directions at the same time.) (Edit again -- Another observation that might help change one's intuition is that, while the cart as a whole may be moving relative to the ground, the part of the cart that's currently touching the ground at any given moment is more-or-less stationary with respect to the ground. And is also mechanically linked to the propeller.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jfoutz 5y agoSailboats are one I struggled with, especially sailing into the wind. I think my intuition there came from a boat going the same direction as the wind, say, north at 1 meter/sec. now the boat can't go faster than 1 m/sec, but if you turn 45 degrees to the east you can travel sqrt(2) m/sec, because you're still going north at 1/ms and the boat gets pushed along to the east as well. the closer you get to perpendicular to wind, the faster you can go. I still don't quite get sailing into the wind, but I'd imagine this wheel and propeller system works the same way. The vehicle motion restricts moving to just a line, the wind pushes along the x axis, so the vehicle can sort of zoom along in the y direction, much faster than moving along x. __edit__ oh, I see, it's the difference between ground and wind. a sailboat couldn't do this but something clever with propellers and linkages probably could
- jrs235 5y agoSo, did/does the vehicle in the desert start with a push (from a force other than the wind) or did it really get started moving by the wind pushing it? Edit: FYI in the video he does sort of cover his claim even if it got started by a non wind force by stating the vehicle can maintain a speed faster than the wind pushing it. But I'm still curious, was a non wind force needed in the desert to get it started?
- Retric 5y agoNo, it’s light enough for the wind to start pushing it.
- jrs235 5y agoEven with 100+ pounds (50+ kg)?
- Retric 5y agoYes, at the extreme end you can find videos of 3,000+ lb cars flipped by the wind. It looks quite aerodynamic, but by comparison I can start pushing a 3,000lb car on flat level ground. So this thing probably needs less than 10 pounds of force to start moving.
- mumblemumble 5y agoAny wind that's strong enough to overcome static friction would do the trick, and I can't see why 10mph wouldn't be enough. The small models that you can build at home (sorry, can't find the plans anymore; this was 10 years ago now) do not require a push to get started.
- jrs235 5y agoUnderstandable that it doesn't take much wind for a vehicle well under a pound. But what about one that weighs well over 100 pounds?
- 5y ago
- karmakaze 5y agoA better way of looking at this is to not think of 'the propeller' as being in one plane for the wind to 'push'. Since the prop is rotating, consider the 'airspeed' of the surface of a blade. You can have zero airspeed when the vehicle is moving forward faster than the wind. Similarly the airspeed of the blade is slower (actually negative) than the vehicle's airspeed which allows the wind to push the blade surface when the vehicle is moving faster than the wind. If you think of a longitudinal vertical plane you can calculate the speed of a point on the cross-section of the blade moving backward relative to the vehicle as a function of the rotation speed. As the vehicle goes faster, so too does the prop surface 'move' backward.
- cblconfederate 5y agoGravity does
- DebtDeflation 5y agoYeah, my first inclination is that since the wind is turning the propeller and the propeller is turning the wheels via a gear system, the speed of the vehicle will be determined by the propeller speed, the gear ratio, and the tire diameter (ignoring friction and air resistance for a moment). The gear ratio is the critical component. It's not like the propeller is a simple sail. I could be completely missing something though.
- sopooneo 5y agoMost critically: the wind is not turning the propeller. If you watch the videos when the thing is first getting going, it is slow enough to see that the propeller is actually spinning in the opposite direction it would be if it was acting as a windmill.
- bxbb 5y agoThe prop is spun by the wheel, not the wind. The tailwind provide push. Think of the wheels as a power bank: It convert and temporarily store linear force to rotational force. As long as it accumulated enough power to counter the rolling resistance, headwind drag, gravity, gearing loss, etc; the excess rotational force can be used to spin the prop. Which in turn generate additional push to be converted and stored. Within this "loop", the vehicle got two linear input, tailwind and propeller. This will allow continuous acceleration once the vehicle goes faster than tailwind up to the point where the additional force from the prop is completely negated.
- chongli 5y agoNo, the wind is not turning the propeller, the wheels are. The reason the wheels are able to turn the propeller without slowing the vehicle down is that the speed of the wheels over the ground is greater than the speed of the propeller through the air thanks to the tailwind.
- jcims 5y agoGear ratio *is* the critical component, specifically prop pitch vs. forward motion, but not exactly for the reason you describe. Xyla Foxlin built a working model and provides a bit more info here: https://youtu.be/VUgajGv4Aok?t=432 https://youtu.be/VUgajGv4Aok?t=432 In short the working model she built has approximately a 2:1 ratio between forward wheel motion and propeller pitch. IOW if the propeller pitch is 5" per revolution, the wheels will require 10" of forward travel to spin it one time.
- marcan_42 5y agoHere's another take: Step 1: a propeller is like a wall or (straight on, no wing stuff) sail moving forwards forever. When the wind pushes on a propeller it's like it's pushing against a sail or wall, but instead of moving forward it turns in place. Virtually, it's still like a wall moving forward. So it converts linear push to a rotational motion. Step 2: Wheels are the opposite for solid surfaces: they couple rotational motion to linear motion on the ground. Step 3: the propeller on the vehicle is connected to the wheels. The gearing makes the "virtual wall" of the propeller move backwards as the vehicle moves forwards. This cancels out the forward motion of the vehicle from the point of view of the air. So from the point of view of the wind, the propeller is like a wall or sail that isn't moving with the vehicle. It's stuck stationary on the ground, or moving slower. The reason why the wind can't push a vehicle faster than the wind is that once you get to wind speed, there is no more speed difference to impart a force on the vehicle. Here, even when the vehicle is at wind speed, there is still a difference between the (slower) virtual speed of the propeller and the wind. So it still gets pushed, and can further accelerate. TL;DR the vehicle uses the wheels and propeller to make itself appear to be running slower relative to the wind, and so it can continue to accelerate when its real speed has reached the wind speed. Another way to visualize it is: instead of a traditional propeller, imagine it like a water wheel, or an impeller, with vanes the air hits. As the vehicle moves forward, the vanes move backwards. With the vehicle at wind speed, the vanes moving backwards cancel out some of its speed, so that there is still a relative difference between the wind speed and the vane speed, so there is still a force exerted.
- marcodiego 5y agoI really would like a simple explanation of how that is possible. AIUI, when speed is stable, the wheels turning provide power to the propeller. But if the propeller pushes the car, which in turn makes the wheels turn faster making the car faster than the wind itself, what makes it different from perpetual motion machines? I would love a diagram showing how the power flows in this system.
- eyko 5y agoVeritasium did a video on the Blackbird (plus a bet to prove it does indeed work). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyQwgBAaBag https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyQwgBAaBag
- otherme123 5y agoI felt this in a sail boat: when the boat is moving below wind speed, the wind pushes the sail and the boat. At some point, wind and boat equal speeds, so it feels like theres no wind at all except the sail is full. Some well built boats can generate pull (instead of push) in the sail, as if it was a plane wing. The air passing on the convex (forward) side travels faster than the air on the concave, making the pressure lower on the forward side and pulling the boat, and you feel again the wind but against your face (as if you were running forward). It's a bit counterintuitive, because what your eyes see is the sail pushing the boat. So it's not perpetual motion, because the wind needs to keep blowing or the boat slows again. What slows the boat is the friction boat-vs-water. In the case of the car above, the wind needs to reach the point of wind speed == car speed, and beyond that the wheels keeps rotating the "sails", and thus keeping the pull. If the wind stops, the car can keep going for some time, but as the speed of the wind through the sails is lower, the pull is also lower and at some point it stops. But in this case, the friction is wheels-vs-ground, much lower than the boat-vs-water above, so the car can keep going (same what happens with a bike when you stop pedaling in a flat surface, the bike can keep going for long, and even a faint pedaling or tail winds keep the thing going). This car is a clever construction to keep the wind at high speeds through the blades.
- ska 5y ago> as if it was a plane wing. This is how nearly all sailing works. Excepting the case of sailing directly downwind, the curve of the sail works like a wing, and the keel provides something to "push" against - the effective "lift" (if it were a wing) drives you forward. This is why you can sail into the wind at all...
- slowhand09 5y agoIts actually the correct explanation tho. This article sucked by the way. It said "Any sailor worth their salt can tell you that a boat can travel faster than the wind by cutting zigzag patterns; that's called tacking." Any sailor worth their salt knows that is not true at all. This practically destroys any credibility on this topic by this author.
- fanf2 5y agobut it is true? https://newt.phys.unsw.edu.au/~jw/sailing.html https://newt.phys.unsw.edu.au/~jw/sailing.html https://www.boatdesign.net/threads/tacking-downwind-faster-than-the-wind.24761/ https://www.boatdesign.net/threads/tacking-downwind-faster-t...
- chongli 5y agoWhat's not true about it? According to Wikipedia [1] there are a bunch of speed records for sailing faster than the wind by tacking downwind. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-performance_sailing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-performance_sailing
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hend_daszweiter 5y agotacking is up wind by definition.
- tcpekin 5y agoI think it's just very poorly worded. Sailboats can go faster than the true wind speed, like in the America's Cup, and typically do it do it going upwind. The addition of tacking is not wrong, it is zigzagging upwind, but just very oddly worded.
- dahart 5y ago> Any sailor worth their salt knows that is not true at all. You sure? Take a gander at this article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-performance_sailing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-performance_sailing You’re right in the sense that tacking is not the word for sailing faster than wind, but it is true that sailors can tack faster than the apparent wind, and that professional sailors know that. The “apparent” part is an important part of the discussion that the quote didn’t include or clarify, but would be implicitly understood by the saltiest of them.
- yodelshady 5y agoAye, where do the wheels get the energy from? Actually, more seriously, is there any point where the net torque on the drivetrain is zero? Assuming you're happy that, so long as the wheels are low-friction, that's no difference between "Downwind faster than Wind" and Upwind, and that a single design of craft can do both Downwind and Upwind, then all you need for the "dead air" part is to store energy in a battery, spring or flywheel.
- namlem 5y agoThe energy comes from the air. The air molecules in the wake of the propeller have lower kinetic energy than the rest of the air.
- cblconfederate 5y agoGravity. Without it the wheels wont have sufficient friction to generate torque
- yodelshady 5y ago> Gravity I'm sorry but you're either answering a different question than "where do the wheels get their energy from" or extremely confused. We're on a flat plane normal to the direction gravity acts, so I'm going to let you go out and work out how much energy gravity can provide there.
- cblconfederate 5y agoYou 're right, gravity provides the force of friction but not energy. The energy is from the pressure of the wind, the device just makes better use of it compared to a fan-less cart.
- twobitshifter 5y agoIt’s really not that complicated - wind speed is not the same as energy. The propellor is a device that pushes against the air to move forward, it takes energy from the wind, produces a force, and the force produces momentum in the vehicle. We know that a stationary turbine can continually take power from the wind. When that wind energy is stored in a battery it can power your car much faster than the wind. This just takes a shorter route and stores the energy in momentum. See sailboats faster than wind https://www.kqed.org/science/8503/how-do-these-boats-sail-faster-than-the-wind https://www.kqed.org/science/8503/how-do-these-boats-sail-fa... > The America’s Cup sailboats are sleek and fast. The AC72, the type of catamaran used in this year’s race, can travel almost three times the speed of the prevailing wind. On June 18th Emirates Team New Zealand recorded a speed of 50.8 mph (44.1 knots), with a wind speed of about 18 mph (15.6 knots). When sailing directly in line with the wind, the apparent wind in a sail is equal to the actual wind, so there’s no gain. A propellor reshapes the direction of the apparent wind to be in the same direction of the wind. More interesting is that blackbird can go 2 times as fast as the wind running directly_into_ the wind. That ought to help understand how this is possible.
- cblconfederate 5y agoSailboats can run faster than the wind because of lift (which is not involved here), but not when running away from the wind
- 6510 5y agothe blades move sideways
- cblconfederate 5y agoif it sails away from the wind, the lift is pushing it sideways, not forward
- jjeaff 5y agoAnd if you turn a sail sideways and put it on a spindle with several other sails, you have what looks a whole lot like a propeller. So instead of sailing sideways so that your air foil sail can move sideways through the wind, the Blackbird harnesses the power of sales moving sideways through the wind while pushing the craft directly into the wind.
- cfallin 5y agoThe way this clicked for me (it took some thought!) was to see it as a lever, or at least an analogue to one. Imagine a lever with the fulcrum on one end, attached to the ground. Wind pushes on the middle, and the car is at the other end of the lever. So wind exerts more force with less speed, and the car moves forward with more speed but less force. That's basically what the linkage and gear ratio between the wheels and propeller do; it's the counterintuitive power flow that makes it so confusing...
- jcims 5y agoI think this is a good intuition about it, and Xyla Foxlin goes into this a bit in her video explaining the build for Veritasium's video. https://youtu.be/VUgajGv4Aok?t=432 https://youtu.be/VUgajGv4Aok?t=432 The essential 'gear' ratio is between forward motion of the vehicle and the propeller pitch (essentially how far the prop would screw through a tub of jello for a given amount of rotation). The vehicle has to move *faster* on the ground than the prop does through the air for this to work at all, and it sounds like it should be roughly twice as fast for it to work on something that is reasonably simple to engineer. So if your prop pitch is 5", your wheel size and gearing should allow the vehicle to move forward approximately 10" for each rotation of the prop. (Note that her video does not explain 'why' this is the case, just that it is a phenomenon that the Blackbird inventors had determined/discovered and is an essential design criteria).
- slowmovintarget 5y agoAnd one of the Veritasium videos: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCsgoLc_fzI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCsgoLc_fzI
- ummonk 5y agoYes exactly. And if you were driving the other way into the wind, you’d flip the lever and use a turbine to extract energy from the wind and push against the ground.