5 ms·
The WWW was pretty great at age 10, but took a wrong turn in its teen years. We now do signal amplification of the worst of humanity. The giants are walled gar
by echelon 5y ago
The WWW was pretty great at age 10, but took a wrong turn in its teen years.
We now do signal amplification of the worst of humanity. The giants are walled gardens, and in another 10-15 years the "web" will be subsumed by Facebook, and Google's "Cromification/AMPlification" (content lives on their servers and there is no URL bar.)
We've destroyed much of the quirkiness and novelty.
Now instead of sharing content and news p2p, it flows from centralized behemoths that choose for us. RIP personal websites, RSS, IRC, and bittorrent. They still exist, just as shells of their former lives. Their promise sucked away.
It's not like the rest of tech fared much better. You can't even run your own software on half of the devices out there now. Or replace their batteries. Or trust them not to spy on you.
- goalieca 5y agoThe technology is just too tempting for totalitarians and tyrants of all degrees. It feels like humanity itself is in some sort of societal infancy.
- pwdisswordfish0 5y ago> The WWW was pretty great [...] We now do signal amplification of the worst of humanity Aren't non-Web ("anti-Web"?) platforms the greatest driver of this? You mention IRC and bittorrent. Nothing really Web about those, either. Are you thinking of WWW and The Internet as being interchangeable terms? Isn't this just a generic and vague luddite-doomer rant?
- codegeek 5y agoI would focus on the overall positives at least in this thread. Yes there are lot of valid criticisms but that is more on the companies and not WWW in itself. WWW is Free, Open and you can do anything you want with it even today. You mention personal websites. No one is stopping you from getting a cheap server and setting up your personal website. In fact, I would argue it is has become easier to do that with so many cheap and reliable options (.e.g DigitalOcean, Vultr etc). I run my personal website using WordPress (another great invention) and I am free to host it however I want.
- pwdisswordfish0 5y agoUMW in Fredricksburg, Virginia has a program called "Domain of One's Own" where you get set up with a personal site at a domain of your choosing, available to every student and everyone on staff. https://umw.domains https://umw.domains
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> We've destroyed much of the quirkiness and novelty. Yawn. People say this over and over again. It hasn't been destroyed. It's just not at the top of your search results. Within the last week, HN's front page had a link to this little gem: http://www.redwoodworld.co.uk/locations.htm ... a catalog of every (?) redwood tree in the British Isles, lovingly maintained and deliciously retro. How can you believe that the quirky and novel have been destroyed when sites like this (and there are millions more) are still out there?
- echelon 5y agoWhile it may not be destroyed, the reward gradients changed. I'm not imagining a world where technology froze in place, rather a different evolutionary path. The incentive structures today produce a massive amount of negative externalities that we're nowhere close to addressing.