8 ms·
Embarrassed by your Olympic javelin: did cavemen do it better? (2012)
- Clewza313 5y agoJavelin is a bit of an outlier in the Olympics in that throws today are nowhere near the records, even after the changes discussed in the article. The winning throw this year was 87.58m, with only one other competitor managing even 86m. The world record, dating from 1996, is 98.48m, a full 10 meters and then some longer. Germany's Vetter, the one modern javelin thrower who has come within striking distance of that (96m), was off his game and couldn't even get over 85m. So why are we so much worse than 25 years ago? The obvious explanation would doping.
- mikehotel 5y agoFrom TFA: “ Also, javelins were increasingly landing flat, instead of poking upright into the turf, making distance-marking difficult, so in 1986 the International Association of Athletics Federations' technical committee authorized a new javelin design. The center of gravity was moved 1.6 inches forward, the tip was modified to make the javelin less aerodynamic, meaning it would nose down earlier and land sooner, reducing average flight distance by about 10 percent.”
- peeters 5y agoThat doesn't explain why a WR from 10 years after those changes hasn't been even close to beaten recently.
- p1key 5y agoBut it has been close? Johannes Vetter got a result of 97.76m under a year ago, that is only 0.72m shy of the world record. Also the reason he was underperforming in the olympics was that the surface of the run-up track was not able to take his weight on the final step and he would slip, making it impossible to perform on his normal high level.
- vikiomega9 5y agoSource for the reason Johannes Vetter failed? Does not look like this was covered well in the press.
- random314 5y agoI think the throwing surface had poorer grip than standard for various reasons. So Vetter couldn't use his typical speed without slipping.
- nAwYz 5y agoIn german news it was quite widely reported that he had problems with the surface of the runway
- p1key 5y agoMy source for this was watching the final myself. When I watched the broadcast myself it was clear to me that this was the problem. Also the (Finnish) commentators were very knowledgeable in the sport and pointed out the problem many times. I was unable to find a clip of his throws in YouTube, but here's a Google Translated article from a Finnish newspaper: https://bit.ly/3xvZWMk https://bit.ly/3xvZWMk.
- getlawgdon 5y agoVetter's official performances and progressions can be found on the World Athletics (formerly IAAF) website: https://www.worldathletics.org/athletes/_/14408144 https://www.worldathletics.org/athletes/_/14408144 His 97.76 was in 2020 in Poland.
- sdwr 5y agoThat's some high-quality journalism. Matter-of-fact, primary sources, asks illuminating questions.
- vikiomega9 5y agoThanks. Seems like a technical problem on his throw then? I'm not aware of the intricacies of surface and I assumed it was a standardized setup.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoOP was talking about a record set 10 years after that change. I suggest avoiding terms like "TFA", which can be taken to insult someone's reading comprehension. I'm sure that's not what you intended but it can easily be misinterpreted.
- getlawgdon 5y agoI think you deeply misunderstand the statistical nature of a world record. there is a piece out there somewhere about zelezney's record being a more significant outlier than Bolt's. But to be clear, you're insinuating that Jan was a cheat? I had training sessions with the former AR holder and numerous conversations with a former WR holder and threw at a high level. I'm quite familiar with the sport and I'm truly curious as to whether you're making this claim about JZ and if you could name 10 throwers without Googling it.
- lelanthran 5y ago> I'm quite familiar with the sport and I'm truly curious as to whether you're making this claim about JZ and if you could name 10 throwers without Googling it. What does his claim[1] have to do with knowing who the throwers are? FWIW, I think that, if you look at a sport and find that the performance of athletes in that sport decreased significantly after the introduction of more comprehensive drug testing, then it is not unreasonable to assume the higher performance was due to drug-related enhancements. [1] He's just making a point about the statistics. We don't need to know the name of the data points.
- pedrosorio 5y ago"FWIW, I think that, if you look at a sport and find that the performance of athletes in that sport decreased significantly after the introduction of more comprehensive drug testing" The issue is the premise is incorrect. 11 of the top 20 throws ever happened since 2015: https://www.worldathletics.org/records/all-time-toplists/throws/javelin-throw/outdoor/men/senior?regionType=world&page=1&bestResultsOnly=false&firstDay=1899-12-31&lastDay=2021-08-08 https://www.worldathletics.org/records/all-time-toplists/thr...
- getlawgdon 5y agoI think you should spend some time plotting throws of the last 20 years using performances from top athletes the worldathletics website. You'll discover that you are mistaken. This suggestion is related to to for why the claim matters, which is familiarity with the sport (as represented by the ability to name its participants). As a longtime participant in track and field, athlete, coach, and fan, I have invariably found that people reduce perceived phenomena to doping usually have no idea what's actually going on in the sport and aren't involved in it in any substantive way. So, "show your familiarity" is a jabby heuristic to prove the point.
- nl 5y ago> Javelin is a bit of an outlier in the Olympics in that throws today are nowhere near the records, even after the changes discussed in the article. This isn't true. There are 10 different athletes who have thrown within 7m of the world record[1] and Johannes Vetter has thrown over 94m 4 times[2]. > So why are we so much worse than 25 years ago? We aren't > The obvious explanation would doping. Zelezy was a freak - as can be seen by his progression[3]. That kind of long-lived high performance (82m in 1986, 86m in 2006) is rarely because of doping - there are too many chances to get caught, and it's too hard to transition between doping types (eg steroids to HGH), and historical testing catches out too many people. The Men's discuss OTOH... This is what a suspicious progression looks like[4]. [1] https://www.worldathletics.org/records/all-time-toplists/throws/javelin-throw/outdoor/men/senior?regionType=world&page=1&bestResultsOnly=true&firstDay=1900-01-01&lastDay=2021-08-09 https://www.worldathletics.org/records/all-time-toplists/thr... [2] https://www.worldathletics.org/records/all-time-toplists/throws/javelin-throw/outdoor/men/senior?regionType=world&page=1&bestResultsOnly=false&firstDay=1900-01-01&lastDay=2021-08-09 https://www.worldathletics.org/records/all-time-toplists/thr... [3] https://www.worldathletics.org/athletes/czech-republic/jan-zelezny-14168038 https://www.worldathletics.org/athletes/czech-republic/jan-z... [4] https://www.worldathletics.org/athletes/germany/jurgen-schult-14194172 https://www.worldathletics.org/athletes/germany/jurgen-schul...
- hoseja 5y agoŽelezný had a completely different revolutionary technique, hence his success.
- nl 5y agoIt's more than that though. Others have emulated his technique but he's still better. One day his record will be broken. But the density of his high performing throws will always be amazing. Sergey Bubbka is perhaps the closest analogy, although his record was recently - finally - broken.
- getlawgdon 5y agoSpecifically what do you think was Zelezny's completely different revolutionary technique? Because if you're talking about "wrapping", it was not new. Zelezny did not radically change the technique of the event. I'm very curious to know what you think Zelezny did that was something like what Fosbury did... I can tell you what I think Zelezny did better but that's not the same as what he did completely differently.
- saberdancer 5y agoIt's not really an outlier, there are plenty of sports where there are long standing world records, some of them have been broken recently but stood for a long time. It's just the nature of having so many sports, not every sport will attract as much talent resulting in having a much bigger impact when that world class talent appears (Zelezny). Usually these sports are technical in nature and thus harder to dominate through sheer improvement in nutrition and muscle power. Take for example Usain Bolt, he competed in the sprint but if he focused his career on some other less popular athletic sport he probably could have been WR holder there as well. If you combine this with the fact that it's possible there was more doping in the past (especially 80s), you can get these incredible world records that stand for decades.
- arp242 5y ago> So why are we so much worse than 25 years ago? The obvious explanation would doping. Looking at the list of furthest throws[1] this doesn't really seem that obvious at all. The top two are quite large outliers, with a 4 metre gap to #3, and people in general don't seem to have been throwing much further in the past. Indeed, the difference between #1 and #25 is almost 10 metres, or 10% of the record. That's quite the difference! Johannes Vetter seems to be in the same league as Jan Železný; Vetter is 28, Železný established his record at the age of 30. It's entirely possible that Vetter will manage to break the record in the future. So either both Železný and Vetter are exceptionally talented athletes in their field, or they're both doped to the gills without being caught. It's not like there wasn't any attention to this in the past, see e.g. [2] from 1989. There sure is more attention to this now and I suppose it's possible that Železný used doping, but that Vetter exists in the same league as Železný demonstrates that Železný didn't have to be a doping user to be so good at it. So in short: it's not all that obvious to me looking at the data. It's not like cycling/Tour de France with a long history of doping use (which is partly, I suspect, because what's being asked of riders borders on the inhuman). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Javelin_throw#All-time_top_25_(current_models) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Javelin_throw#All-time_top_25_... [2]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/sports/1989/06/18/in-hue-and-cry-over-steroids-athletes-get-caught-in-the-middle/ebe74f3c-9d82-481a-8202-e7e128382e45/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/sports/1989/06/18/in-...
- yathern 5y agoThe article title might seem to suggest we have evidence that cavemen were could throw further than our best Olympic athletes... Instead, the article content is bemoaning that we have a standardized javelin that isn't as far-throwing as can be. Thus, the world record javelin toss may never be beaten. Yes, the permanent world record is a little unfortunate. But it has nothing to do with how cavemen would throw. Standards must be made to judge fair competition among participants. Yes, they're a little bit arbitrary - the 100M dash could very well be a 106M dash. But that wouldn't make the athletes 6% more impressive. Likewise, we could improve our javelins every year to get further and further throws. But our global interest isn't on the throw, but the thrower.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Yes, the permanent world record is a little unfortunate. Why? The longer you keep records, the less likely it is that you can exceed the previous record. Why would we expect javelin throws to get longer over time?
- coopsmoss 5y agoAttainable goals are more motivating and meaningful than unattainable ones. It's in many ways a different event because the equipment is different, so why should a record for a different event stand.
- compsciphd 5y agothere's no reason to not have something that's the "world record" under current rules.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> It's in many ways a different event because the equipment is different, so why should a record for a different event stand. That's a completely separate concern. Once records are established for the current event, you still expect them to be more or less permanent. Turning in the best performance in all of history is not an attainable goal. You can't expect it to be one.
- getlawgdon 5y agoI'm struggling to understand the argument. Zelezny undoubtedly threw farther than any prehistoric thrower, and he undoubtedly killed fewer meals with a spear, too. As a former have thrower I used to wonder what Jan would have done with the old jav...
- arey_abhishek 5y agoFun fact. Uwe Hohn, the permanent record holder, is the coach for this year's Olympic gold medalist.
- msravi 5y agoActually, no. Neeraj Chopra trained with Uwe Hohn until 2019, but then (Chopra) asked for a change. His coach over the last 2 years in the run up to the Olympics has been Klaus Bartonietz. 1. https://sportstar.thehindu.com/olympics/tokyo-olympics/neeraj-chopra-javelin-throw-gold-tokyo-2020-india-athletics-medal-milkha-singh-pt-usha-jsw-sports/article35805144.ece https://sportstar.thehindu.com/olympics/tokyo-olympics/neera... 2. https://thebridge.in/athletics/tokyo-olympics-neeraj-chopra-coach-24291 https://thebridge.in/athletics/tokyo-olympics-neeraj-chopra-... 3. https://www.newindianexpress.com/sport/olympics/2021/aug/08/afis-decision-to-train-neeraj-chopra-with-german-expert-klaus-bartonietz-bears-fruit-2341987.html https://www.newindianexpress.com/sport/olympics/2021/aug/08/...
- arey_abhishek 5y agoThanks for the correction! I should have Googled that one
- getlawgdon 5y agoThere is absolutely no such thing as "permanent record holder" in track and field. The structure of records in track and field is a very specific thing, and the current world record holder, which record is set in accordance with the current matrix of regulation and ratification procedures, is canonically considered the superlative all-time performance. Uwe's throw, while astonishing, is a now a sidenote and asterisk.
- wombatmobile 5y agoThe temptation to compare athletic and sporting performances between different eras, is doomed to disappointment. Whilst we could standardise a javelin, we can’t recreate the culture, diet, stadia etc of bygone epochs, so the comparisons will always be qualified or debased. It is frustrating that we don’t have time machines,but perhaps that’s a reason to think further about what it is that fascinates us about athletic and sporting contests.
- decker 5y agoI'm surprised the article didn't mention the atlatl which would have been the true historic answer to "how far did cavemen throw spears?" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spear-thrower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spear-thrower
- pseudo0 5y agoIt does mention the ankyle, a leather strap that served a similar purpose by increasing the effective length of the throwing arm. I guess some cavemen used ankyles and others used atlatls?
- tk75x 5y ago"booster in the form of a leather thong, called an ankyle, that would set the javelin spinning, getting it to fly further." Sounds like they just used it to wrap around the javelin to give it a spin like you would a spinning top with a string.
- pseudo0 5y agoNeat, that does make more sense actually. Pretty impressive that the spin from a piece of leather would add 58% to the flight distance though. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amentum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amentum
- Ekaros 5y agoJavelin is one of the sports that is limited by venues. That is area limited inside 400m running track. Where inside we simply do not want them throw too far. We could easily design javelin that travels much further, but choose not to, due to safety concerns and limitations venues...
- 838812052807016 5y ago> Best Ever? > Lots of athletes come to the Olympics hoping to be the Best Ever. But not javelin throwers. They've been told to dream smaller dreams ("Best Since 1984!") and I think that's a bum deal. > Why not take this event away from crowded arenas, go someplace safe, design the best flying spear possible, throw it as far as you can, and then whoever breaks the record can say to all spear throwers going back over the ages, "Now I'm Number One, in the truest sense — mine flew further than all of yours! > That would be true Gold. Maybe the best design would use a rail-gun as a booster. And if the goal is to make it go as far as possible, you might want to consider throwing it outside the atmosphere.
- jbay808 5y agoUnfortunately, that just sets the world record for the farthest freestyle javelin throw even farther back, to 1977, when Voyager 1 was launched.
- simcop2387 5y ago> Maybe the best design would use a rail-gun as a booster. And pitch-o-mat 5000 was just a modified howitzer. I agree though, a line should be drawn otherwise you can end up with things going a bit absurd. It's similar to hoe stock-csr and forumla 1 racing draw lines about what things are allowed to be done to the cars.
- eklavyaa 5y agoIndia just had its first gold in track and fields in 100 years in Tokyo 2020, in Javelin throw, and What might be the intention to post this blog from 2012 now ? Its offensive.
- Flex247A 5y agoHackerNews is not about India.
- eklavyaa 5y agoMy comment is not about HN, its about India
- vigothehacker 5y agoI know. This seems fishy.
- vigothehacker 5y agoAlso this post was made by an Indian username. Kinda depressing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smabie 5y agoI think only an Indian would make thar association.
- eklavyaa 5y agoThats racism..
- seanhunter 5y agoWeirdly pointless article to have on the front page. the author literally gives the explanation in the first paragraph- with throwing events absolute distance has to be weighed against safety of officials, other athletes running on the track and spectators in the stadium beyond. Very unfortunate timing unearthing this right now too given that a great throw by Chopra and the inability of the favourites to perform under the conditions has just given India their first ever olympic gold medal in track and field.
- jespere1 5y agoI don’t get the point of this article. Maybe it’s satire? What else does the author want? Boxing without gloves? Fencing with real swords? Perhaps the ancients won’t be so impressed with the absence of blood drawn? If a caveman is unimpressed by how far the modern javelin travels we could just hand one to him/her see how far they can throw it?
- getlawgdon 5y agoI think it can be chalked up to "naive outsider musings" coupled with the "national geographic touch."
- amarant 5y agoThe idea of "freeform" sports competition is interesting. It shouldn't be a replacement but rather a addition to current sports. By freeform here I mean that you remove most of the rules. For example for biking you could allow whatever vehicle the competitors choose so long as it is powered entirely by the cyclist. Not sure what a reasonable "freeform" ruleset would be for javelin, at some point javelins stop being javelins and start being model airplanes, but I can see some entertainment value in "throwing model airplanes as far as possible"competitions too..
- tromp 5y ago> For example for biking you could allow whatever vehicle the competitors choose so long as it is powered entirely by the cyclist. The World Human Powered Vehicle Association [1] oversees such competition, on land, in water, and even in the air [2]. [1] http://www.whpva.org/ http://www.whpva.org/ [2] http://www.whpva.org/hpv.html http://www.whpva.org/hpv.html
- cdbyr 5y agoYou might find development class sailing interesting. For example, the Moth started off as a fairly normal dinghy and is now a really fast foiling boat: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moth_(dinghy) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moth_(dinghy) I’m not sure if there are similar things in other sports, but with Moths and foiling boats, there are plenty of people who say this isn’t real sailing. Fun to watch, though.
- yitchelle 5y agoIn the context of competition, it doesn't matter if you can throw furthest in the history, you just have to throw it further than your competitors.
- workinghard 5y agoCavemen would not even conduct Olympics you know its a big waste of money
- publicola1990 5y agoDid the pole vault record get broken in this Olympics?