9 ms·
FEC Asks Congress to Ban Prechecked Recurring Donation Boxes
- zibzab 5y agoEU guy here, curious how this is received in US. Can someone who donated to Trumps after-election campaign tell me what he/she feels about this? Partisan shenanigans or a generally good idea?
- bluejekyll 5y agoBoth parties do it. IMO this should absolutely be banned. Also the donation checkboxes are not always clear as to if they are enabled or disabled. This is definitely a non-partisan issue of politicians straight up trying to trick people into donating more than they intend.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 5y agoI think the 1-click donations should also be banned. I recall getting a solicitation from one of the two major parties with a “click here to support Foo” button in the email. Fine print at the bottom revealed that if you had a payment method on file that click would, without further action, donate some set amount to candidate Foo. (I don’t recall the details of the amount.) I’m fine with fundraising, but “click here to support” I expect to land me on a web page where I could read more and make a fully informed decision to donate, not to take money out of my account from the email click.
- meepmorp 5y agoThis is just a politics-oriented variant of a "growth hack." It's not about the ideology, it's about roping people into giving them money they didn't really intended to spend, with what is basically adding a subscription service they hope you don't notice. Yes, ban it to death.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoI think you're misunderstanding how bad the general state of political fundraising in the US is. Just over the past week, I've gotten: * An email titled "watch our video [not asking for money]" which links to a request for money * _two_ people - one from each side of the aisle - trying to gaslight me into donating "again" since I've purportedly already joined their campaign * a fake survey where every prompt is some variation on "Did you know how vile those guys are?" and the only response options are "Yes, they suck" or "No, but I know now". * an email written to sound like a personal letter, assuring me that some state legislators will be unjustly imprisoned if I don't sign a petition, but reveals upon clicking into the petition that they also need to collect $2,084 by midnight. (I only personally need to send $16 - it's "today's most popular amount!") And I've only ever made a single political donation from my current email! I don't think it's partisan at all to say the status quo isn't okay here.
- wiseleo 5y agoLet's not forget "official poll" emails that aren't. I have no way of knowing if I am being polled or solicited. Hence, my voice is now excluded from political polls.
- syshum 5y agoI dont donate to PAC's or campaigns.. However I have a problem with pretty much all FEC regulations because I am a free speech absolutist, and I view these "campaign finance laws" at minimum to be a spiritual infringement on the principle of free expression even if they pass legal challenges. They also rares accomplish their stated goals and often end up being an advantage to the incumbents in power who have access to more "free media" as part of their official duties...
- alyandon 5y agoIf you want a real eye opening experience (or just have a morbid curiosity) - sign up for Democratic/Republican donation lists via a throw away email address and read the material you get sent by PACs begging for donations. It's disgustingly manipulative what these organizations do.
- kfprt 5y agoBetter yet, if you absolutely want to force someone to abandon their email you can sign them up with donations. Political campaigners are the best harassment money can buy.
- kaffee 5y agoIt's not well known that the (US) CAN-SPAM act does not apply to political and religious organizations. They can spam as much as they want. First amendment law is full of surprises.
- kfprt 5y agoIt's practically the only issue they care about. "Republican congressman Greg Steube asks Google CEO why his campaign emails are going to spam" https://www.theguardian.com/global/video/2020/jul/29/republican-congressman-greg-steube-asks-google-ceo-why-his-campaign-emails-are-going-to-spam-video https://www.theguardian.com/global/video/2020/jul/29/republi...
- User23 5y ago> Pichai said “there is nothing in the algorithm that has to do with political ideology” That’s an interesting non-denial: he never actually says the spam algorithm isn’t biased against conservatives. There could well be a bias, because many ML systems have unintended biases. Google could easily answer the question. It’d probably take an hour max to write and run the mapreduce or whatever they use now.
- Retric 5y ago
- h2odragon 5y agoProfessional political fundraising is a thing. It's an industry. They sell their services to issue oriented NGO's, too. As far as I know (2 decades ago i had some contact with that world) they're all that slimy. "dark patterns" like this are the least of it, they fake addresses, steal data from customers, fiddle accounting, etc etc. "It's not a crime until you've been caught."
- Spivak 5y agoThe positions are called DevOps if you want to poke around at some job descriptions of the people who do this for a living. Outside of the egregious examples that get spread around (and if you’re not politically active might be the only ones you know so keep that in mind) it’s a pretty boring job. Clicking around Salesforce, lots of mailmerges, event planning, reporting, and the financial logistics of people with conditions on their money or people who donate through foundations or donor advised funds.
- specialist 5y ago> It's an industry. Bingo. Campaigning is an industry. All that money raised? Spent on more fundraising and advertising and consultants. I'm unclear what all the defenders of Freedom Speeches™ think they're defending. The freedom to bury one's opponents under mountains of cash? Any one legit concerned about speech would argue for less money, more fairness doctrine. For a start.
- tenfourwookie 5y agoPerhaps banning recurring donations is the better idea*?. I can sit here for five minutes and think up several ways to achieve the exact same thing some arbitrary UI element (prechecked checkbox) achieves. Don't even need a checkbox. Just change the terms. *Ooops. Forgot Citizens United. Poop!*
- ashtonkem 5y agoI don’t think banning recurring donations would breach citizens United, but I’m not a lawyer. To my understanding, Citizens United controls what you can do with your money. It does not cover what arrangements campaigns can have to charge you money. You can set a reminder to donate monthly if you want, but that doesn’t mean that PACs can necessarily charge you monthly, in my opinion. Similarly, the courts have held that the FEC can’t control what candidates say, which is good. But the FEC can force political adverts to make it clear who paid for it, which is also good.
- dragonwriter 5y agoCU has nothing to so with donation rules for campaign committees; like Buckley v. Valeo before it, it deals with independent expenditures by entities which are not and do not coordinate with campaign committees.
- tenfourwookie 5y agoToo wonk. Please simplify.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Too wonk. Please simplify. Buckley v. Valeo: “you can spend your own money without limit on political ads, if you aren't coordinating with a campaign”. Citizens United: “...and that includes if ‘you’ are a corporation, not an individual.” Neither restricts the ability of the federal government to restrict spending by or coordinated with campaigns, or donations to campaigns.
- mrfusion 5y agoI can’t figure out if this benefits my political team so I’m not sure if it support it. But once I find out I’ll rapidly defend or oppose it. /s
- mattnewton 5y agoI know you are being sarcastic; but I think this probably affects all political teams who otherwise would be giving up a significant advantage by not at least hiring some firm at arms length to try to fleece their supporters this way. I think it’s even better for everyone to ban it so that everyone doesn’t get trapped in this race to the bottom.
- peter422 5y agoDJT’s campaign made heavy use of this tactic but AFAIK no other major political candidate has done this. Unsurprisingly DJT’s donations had much higher chargeback rates. Most politicians don’t want to anger their biggest supporters. DJT didn’t seem to care.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 5y agoYou joke but this is a real problem that prevents us from clearing out our political tech debt so to speak. If you expect worse outcomes from the loss of political territory than the harm from whatever you want to change then it doesn’t happen. And you have to constantly deal with both sides trying to change things that they know in advance disproportionately affect their opponents. Until our political system “stabilizes” where high-profile elections aren’t won by teeny tiny margins or determined by turnout and voting access more than the real preferences of the population this is going to be an issue.
- atlgator 5y agoEmphasis on "Prechecked" here. This isn't a ban on recurring donations. They just can't be turned on by default.
- MiddleEndian 5y agoCredit/digital payments as a whole are backwards. Currently, you give your payment information to some organization, and they can bill you whatever they want and you hope they don't take your money indefinitely. If someone takes your money and you try to get it back, your own credit is on the line when you try to resolve it. Even with chargebacks, your credit card company may only accept so many. Instead it should be client-controlled, they give you some sort of payment token that you can pay or not pay. For recurring payments, you could trust a particular vendor you like (and then untrust them at will), but it should entirely be under your control. Unsubscription should be automatically handled by this as well.
- cyanydeez 5y agoalso, ban all corporations from asking customers for donations.
- teclordphrack2 5y agoThose really should be called Trump boxes.
- FounderBurr 5y agoHow does this “business model” survive the massive chargeback rate it must generate when most businesses live and die by a 1% maximum chargeback rate?
- haspoken 5y agohttps://archive.is/non91 https://archive.is/non91