5 ms·
The U.S. government's long and shameful history of intercepting people's letters
- AniseAbyss 5y agoNot really an American thing, every country does this, including opening diplomatic post. The problem is that intelligence communities operate in complete secrecy with very little oversight so we rarely find out.
- seibelj 5y agoReason is such a good institution, their reporting has a freedom-oriented mindset but their journalism is top notch. FYI it’s a non-profit and donations are tax deductible. If you are interested in other freedom-oriented non-profits I highly recommend: Institute for Justice https://ij.org/ https://ij.org/ Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) https://www.thefire.org/ https://www.thefire.org/ Cato Institute https://www.cato.org/ https://www.cato.org/
- epakai 5y agoFor alternative assessments of the above: https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Reason_Foundation https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Reason_Foundatio... https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Institute_for_Justice https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Institute_for_Ju... https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Foundation_for_Individual_Rights_in_Education https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Foundation_for_Individ... https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Cato_Institute https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Cato_Institute Many seem to associate themselves with libertarian ideals. All have been funded by the Koch brothers.
- seibelj 5y agoYes - I used the term "freedom-oriented" but they are small-L libertarian organizations. Libertarians are freedom-oriented and advocate for private / market-oriented solutions to problems rather than government solutions
- pottertheotter 5y agoPrivate solutions ≠ market-oriented solutions.
- seibelj 5y agoMarkets are emergent phenomena that exist where ever there are free people. They are so natural that even in Soviet Russia markets were endemic, as well as current North Korea. If there exist products people want to buy, and prices are not fixed at gunpoint, there will exist markets.
- cloudfifty 5y agoThis is simply not true. And to argue that some sort of minuscule trading is comparable to today's market economies would be ridiculous. There are a lot of stories in colonial history where the colonialists complain that they need to discipline (or euphemistically "civilize") the native population because they have no concept of labour and property - basically they are "lazy" subsistence farmers and need to be introduced to the market, a.k.a. wage labour through the creation of artificial scarcity (e.g. by the colonialists claiming to now own the land and demand a return, or by requiring a tax in the colonialist currency to cover for their "war costs").
- AniseAbyss 5y agoHa yeah libertarians are the kind of people who want to replace the police with private security. I have absolutely no delusions about what kind of society they would create- and as someone who isn't a millionaire there's nothing in it for me.
- cloudfifty 5y agoTheir use of the term freedom is manipulative. There's no freedom for the propertyless in a Propertarian - essentially neofeudal - society, and they know it. It's 100% propaganda.
- rayiner 5y agoYes these are expressly libertarian outfits. Liberty is a good thing! Also, the Koch Brothers fund a lot of things, including criminal justice reform: https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/03/charles-koch-overcriminalization-115512 https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/03/charles-koch...
- tptacek 5y agoWait wait wait wait wait wait, Rayiner. Liberty is a good thing. It does not follow axiomatically that libertarianism is a good thing. Libertarianism has a quirky and unpopular orthodoxy, one that equates drivers licenses to "a license to make toast in your own damn toaster", and creates utopian New Hampshire townships that are ultimately overrun by bears. Give me liberty, as the saying goes, but also drivers licenses, and hold the bears. Libertarianism isn't bad on spec. But it is not reasonable to suggest that people shouldn't be made aware when their sources are all libertarian, as these ones are, for the same reason that it's good to know if your sources are Jacobin, Current Affairs, and In These Times.
- R0b0t1 5y agoThe same reason the ACLU challenges the no-fly list also serves to challenge driver's licenses, and actually exposes that we are accepting very strong prior restraint on the right to travel. You can keep people from driving, but not proactively. Some other arguments though, yes, they go too far.
- tptacek 5y agoI'm not even saying Libertarians are wrong about drivers licenses, just that they're idiosyncratic and unpopular on that issue, and it's worth knowing what you're getting yourself into if you take their word for everything. I think Reason is generally pretty sane! (But they were idiosyncratic and unpopular on the opiate crisis, by way of example.)
- seibelj 5y ago
- dragonwriter 5y ago> their reporting has a freedom-oriented mindset If by freedom-oriented you mean right-libertarian, which os very much not the only understanding of “freedom”, you would be correct.
- literallyaduck 5y agoThey a good idea with "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated." It was inconvenient so they eroded it. When it came to the black panthers they took away both the 2nd and the 4th.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe tricky part is "unreasonable." When someone's using the mail to send anthrax to people, knowing who communicated with whom to trace it to the source is suddenly very reasonable. Dying from anthrax is a lot less convenient than having record of every letter a person sent or received dry-rotting in a data warehouse somewhere.
- Teever 5y ago> When someone's using the mail to send anthrax to people, knowing who communicated with whom to trace it to the source is suddenly very reasonable. When someone's using the roads to travel to kill people, knowing who travelled to whom to trace them to the source is suddenly very reasonable. No wait, that's insane, we should never expect that it is reasonable to conduct mass surveillance on all the roads in the country to find out where people go all the time. Why do people think this kind of stuff is reasonable and positive for society?
- soup10 5y agoCan't they already track people that way using car or phone gps?
- kragen 5y agoThat depends on who controls the software running on the car or phone. Determining your position via GPS does not emit any signals that can be detected; it's a purely passive process. If malicious software installed on the phone records the GPS data and later transmits it, then yes. However, cellphones in particular do require the cellphone network to track at least which cell they're in in order to work, so in practice controlling a cellphone network gives you a pretty good idea of where all the subscribers are. This is a big problem, and we need to figure out how to stop it if we are to enjoy the sort of freedom from government surveillance that people everywhere enjoyed since the Paleolithic until about 01998. The 20th-century results of giving too much power to governments are not promising.
- kook_throwaway 5y ago"Moreover, this gradual (and, of late, rapidly progressive) decay of freedom goes almost without challenge; the American has grown so accustomed to the denial of his constitutional rights and to the minute regulation of his conduct by swarms of spies, letter-openers, informers and agents provocateurs that he no longer makes any serious protest." - H L Mencken The American Credo: A Contribution toward the Interpretation of the National Mind (1920)
- dehrmann 5y agoIn recent news, Biden lawyer shopped until he found someone who supported reinstating the CDC's eviction ban, despite the supreme court strongly suggesting the previous ban overstepped CDC's power, but letting it stand for mostly practical reasons. This isn't about the ban; it's that a president got a strong signal from the supreme court that he can't do X, then did X two weeks later.
- robbedpeter 5y ago'Signal" implies something indirect, subtle, or nuanced in some way. The Supreme Court was very clear in the majority opinion (and lower courts had ruled) that the cdc overstepped its authority, that it had absolutely no power to impose these bans. The moratorium would have to be implemented by congress - it is their job when things like a brazen violation of basic property rights is involved. That the cdc would go right ahead and roll out a new moratorium is a stunning failure of checks and balances.
- anonymouse008 5y agoI’ve often said we need the next constitutional convention to revise the government in light of society’s progress — this reinforces that view with the heat of boiling blood
- redis_mlc 5y ago> In recent news, Biden lawyer shopped It's worse than that. Biden admitted on video that it was unconstitutional - it was a bizarre experience listening to what he was saying since if he doesn't have to follow any laws, why should anybody else?
- aaron695 5y agoI wonder if they digitally x-ray a lot of them like they can with paintings these days. Spycatcher, Peter Wright, 1987- "Around twenty Post Office technicians worked at these tables opening pieces of mail. They wore rubber gloves so as not to leave fingerprints, and each man had a strong lamp and a steaming kettle beside him. The traditional split-bamboo technique was sometimes used. It was ancient, but still one of the most effective. The split bamboo is inserted into the corner of the envelope, which is held up against a strong light. By turning the bamboo inside the envelope, the letter can be rolled up around the slit and gently pulled out Where a letter had an ordinary typed address it was sometimes torn open and a new envelope typed in its place. But to the end of my career we were never able to covertly open a letter which had been sealed at each edge with Sellotape. In those cases, MI5 took a decision as to whether to open the letter and destroy it, or send it on in an obviously opened state." "Denman's proudest memento was a framed letter which hung on the far wall. It was addressed to a prominent Communist Party member whose mail was regularly intercepted. When the letter was opened the Post Office technicians were amused to discover that it was addressed to MI5 and contained a typewritten message, which read: "To MI5, if you steam this open you are dirty buggers." Denman classified it as "obscene post," which meant that legally he had no duty to send it on to the cover address. "
- known 5y ago"The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to help” --Ronald Reagan (b. 1911)