6 ms·
As someone who comes from a very poor country, I feel like academics don’t do enough to help understand why some countries succeed and why some don’t. They blam
by rayiner 5y ago
As someone who comes from a very poor country, I feel like academics don’t do enough to help understand why some countries succeed and why some don’t. They blame “colonialism” or some such thing, but that doesn’t explain this. Argentina was rich in the early 20th century:
> Something has gone awry in what was the most successful of all the 19th-century liberal republics in Spanish America. In the early 20th century, Argentina’s per capita GDP ranked among the world’s top ten, on a par with Australia and Canada and ahead of France and Italy.
What explains the coups and political instability? If the GDP is the same, why is the government of Canada and Australia so much more stable than Argentina? This seems to be one of the biggest things holding back Latin America, but there seems to be no effort to understand what’s causing it.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y ago> I feel like academics don’t do enough to help understand why some countries succeed and why some don’t What have you read so far? Did you do any research? The field of philosophy and political science does not lack publications. I can recommend "The Rise and Decline of Nations" by Mancur Olson. Further authors which I still have to go through, but seem relevant: Theodore Dalrymple René Girard Roger Scruton James Burnham
- whoaisme 5y agoLOl you're the guy being a dick about how in depth the field of fantasy novels is then your personal recommendation is Harry Potter. Why not become a snooty sommelier and recommend stella rosa while you're at it. Then you recommend writers you haven't read because get real if you're gonna actually read stuff before you talk about how much research there is hahaha
- gumby 5y ago> but there seems to be no effort to understand what’s causing it. I recommend "Why Nations Fail" by Acemoglu and Robinson, a thoughtful look at success/failure factors common across a number of countries. Unlike the implication of the title itself, it's not a "one grand theory" but a set of factors that incrementally tip the scales in one direction or the other. Sure, factors like colonialism certainly play a role, but terms like that are usually used as lazy tropes rather that thoughtful analysis. Acemoglu and Robinson don't focus on such broad factors except to the degree that they might encourage/discourage some more primary factors.
- ashishb 5y agoYeah. The book has some great insights around institutions. My notes from the book https://ashishb.net/book-summary/book-summary-why-nations-fail/ https://ashishb.net/book-summary/book-summary-why-nations-fa...
- roenxi 5y agoThanks for the notes, they made interesting reading on their own. Was there any discussion of military tradition? Something interesting I note in the major Anglosphere democracies is that the military just don't get overtly involved in politics.
- ashishb 5y agoIirc there wasn't. I think it is mostly about strong institutions that keep military in check.
- fastasucan 5y agoI'm not sure if this is a cause for successful democracy or rather a sign of a successful democracy.
- rayiner 5y agoThank you.
- eternalban 5y agoThe simple explanation is the timeline of the resolution of power struggle of the ruling classes in respective countries. Both Canada and Australia were Crown colonies and subsequently member states of the Commonwealth of the British Empire. England experienced extreme violence during its period of power struggle between contending members of ruling classes. If you review the history of England from Henry VIII until the consolidation of the conflict in what they call "The Glorious Revolution", you will note the same volatility and frequent change of power, extreme violence, and vulnerability to external powers. Had England experienced its power consolidation period in modern times, and was vulnerable to external powers capable of projecting power and influence using modern means, it would be another Argentina. In England's case, a chance event of inclement weather neutralized the armada of the super power of the time (Spain), and it should be noted that another invading force (Dutch Orange) finally resolved the matter. The Anglo-Empire (currently administered by the American cousins) enjoys relative concord among the ruling set and the subject classes are effectively propagandized to accept their station in life. (A cursory review of any English work of literature or film supports this assertion.) Should Latin America, Far East, Middle East, or any other non-Anglo region ever enjoy a sufficiently long period unmolested by the Anglo-Empire, they too will pass through their period of contention among the ruling classes and arrive at a stable formula for exercising governance over a docile population.
- noduerme 5y ago>>> Should Latin America, Far East, Middle East, or any other non-Anglo region ever enjoy a sufficiently long period unmolested by the Anglo-Empire, they too will pass through their period of contention among the ruling classes and arrive at a stable formula for exercising governance over a docile population. That stable formula may in turn be imperialist. Colonialism is not the sole province of the Anglosphere. China has already reached this kind of stability and freedom from foreign molestation, to the detriment of its neighbors and conquered peoples. It's also worth noting that countries subjected to Anglo colonialism and Common Law have fared better than those colonized by Spain or France, in large part because British colonies were not organized as plantations run by a few wealthy landlords (at least, not nearly to the same extent). Most of Latin America still hasn't even experienced land reform, keeping large swaths of the population at the level of subsistence. Moreover the lack of property rights and security driven by the occasional socialist/populist uprisings result in a lack of credit or investment that would help build a middle class. The middle class is the group you refer to derogatively as "subject classes [...] propagandized to accept their station in life." That class in China and in the Anglosphere lives a materially much more comfortable existence than the subject classes of LatAm, Africa or South Asia. The material comfort, more than the propaganda, is the key to preventing populist uprising.
- stupidcar 5y agoAlmost all Latin American countries are presidential republics. This is a system of government that basically guarantees instability. The separation of the executive and the legislature is supposed to provide greater accountability, but eventually leads to populist presidents quarrelling with intransigent representatives. The result is political logjam and either the president finally disposes of the legislature, or the military gets rid of both. In contrast, Australia and Canada both have Westminster parliamentary systems, where the executive is drawn from the legislature. Thus, the prime minister is guaranteed a base of support there and populist candidates cannot entirely circumvent it. The system has its flaws, but it does seem to be more stable in the long run.
- gruez 5y ago>Almost all Latin American countries are presidential republics. This is a system of government that basically guarantees instability What about all the european presidential republics, and the US?
- coryrc 5y agoJan 6
- bpodgursky 5y agoI'm sorry, you can consider Jan 6 to be many bad things, but none of those are a meaningful threat to American democracy.
- reducesuffering 5y agoI’m sure you can use your imagination to foresee a variety of concerning scenarios that result from a mob killing many of our federal politicians.
- rualca 5y ago> (...) but none of those are a meaningful threat to American democracy. Jam 6 was literally a coup attempt ordered by the president to disrupt the session in Congress that formalized the election results to avoid stepping down after losing the elections. Exactly which part of this do you believe is not a threat to any democracy?
- noduerme 5y agoI think a lot of it comes down to corruption. The recurring theme in Argentina is that the large landowners and right-wing politicians hoard the wealth of the country; although living standards rise slowly, most people are left behind. Then there's a socialist movement which nationalizes industry and promises reform. But they're just as corrupt, and use the levers of monetary policy to line their pockets. International investment reels in horror, the debt skyrockets, they print more money, inflation goes wild, then they default on the debt and there's a few years of depression. Finally, the right wing gets back into power, removes the currency controls, issues new currency - essentially wiping out ordinary savings but safeguarding land-based wealth - and privatizes everything again. Rinse and repeat.
- scythe 5y agoIt's worth considering Argentina's political history in addition to its economic history. From independence, it quickly became a "feudal dictatorship" under Juan Manuel de Rosas, leading a confederation of largely autonomous provinces, from 1829-52. Then a "cold civil war" ensued from 1852-61 between the dominant province of Buenos Aires and the rest of the Confederation, with Buenos Aires eventually winning under Bartolome Mitre, who established a voice-voting faux-democracy that enshrined de facto one-party rule from 1862-1910. This period of false democracy coincided with Argentina's miraculous economic rise, as well as the subjugation of its remaining autonomous indigenous peoples. The first free election in Argentina was held in 1916, and only fourteen years later the adolescent system was thrown into disarray by the Infamous Decade and half a century of periodic coups. The past 38 years since the election of Raul Alfonsin in 1983 have been the longest continuous period of democracy and peace in Argentine history, by far. When we compare Canada's origin under the partially democratic English system or Japan's gradual adoption of Western values from 1868 to Argentina's eruption from an ossified Spanish Empire in the wake of the Napoleonic Wars, we see more "anchors of stability" in the former two, in one case the tradition of English parliamentarianism and in the second the Japanese "flexible monarchy" that gradually relinquished power. But this is an unpleasant conclusion for those looking to change the fortunes of countries that lack such guideposts; traditions take a long time to build, and for every George Washington there are five Santa Annas.
- dboreham 5y agoCorrelates with the number of Scottish people involved in establishing the country?
- dredmorbius 5y ago... why some countries succeed and why some don’t ... Not for want of trying. That's literally the topic of the foundational book of modern economics, Smith's An Inquiry Into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. And there've been many, many, many subsequent attempts at answers. If there is a modern concensus, it's that there is no accepted answer or understanding. There are several reasons. It's difficult to run controlled experiments. There are a limited number of examples to study. There is a phenomenally entangled set of factors. And many attempts are influenced by specific experiences, ignorance, or ideological alignment. You'll find free-market fundamentalists, institutionalists, Keynesians (fiscal policy), monetarists, American School (National System, following a national policy), socialists, communists, neoliberal school, feudalists, physiocrats, cyberntics / systems theorists, complexity economists, biophysical economics, and numerous others. Among texts I'd recommend: Mancur Olson, The Rise and Decline of Nations. Lloyd Jeffrey Dumans, The Overburdened Econommy. Gregory Clark, A Farewell to Alms. (The series this is part of contains numerous other explorations of economic history.) Karl Polanyi, The Great Transformation Arnold Toynbee, Lectures on the Industrial Revolution.
- ctchocula 5y agoJoe Studwell has written a book called "How Asia Works" that tries to tackle the question of what economic policies help countries get wealthy. You can read a review about it here [1]. But basically he boils down to 3 policies: 1. Land reform - Forcibly buy up farms and distribute it to farmers. This forces landlords into cities to develop more productive businesses. 2. Export discipline - Encourage companies to sell overseas rather than to the domestic market. This helps them become more competitive worldwide. 3. Financial control - Encourage banks to loan to companies that export instead of real estate companies. [1] https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/what-studwell-got-wrong https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/what-studwell-got-wrong