6 ms·
Password of three random words better than complex variation, experts say
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AlexAndScripts 5y agoIsn't this common knowledge?
- yoz-y 5y agoObviously, and unfortunately, not. If it were, then almost all websites would handle their password requirements differently.
- Inityx 5y agohttps://xkcd.com/936/ https://xkcd.com/936/
- ceautery 5y agoCoincidentally, we're close to the 10 year anniversary of https://xkcd.com/936/ https://xkcd.com/936/
- fwipsy 5y agoWhy can't hackers just brute-force word combinations? If there are 170k English words, and 95 possible password characters, then it seems to me that 170,000^3 ~= 95^8 so a 3-word English phrase would only be about as safe as an 8-character random string.
- kazinator 5y agoBut, that is formidable: using three dictionary words, you have something that is as secure as 8 characters, those being chosen from the full set of 95 non-blank ASCII glyphs! It's likely way easier to memorize, not to mention type. Though, by the same lexical token, it's worth acknowledging that words from a 170,000 dictionary will include some difficult ones that are not in the user's vocabulary. Say we use a 30,000 dictionary of common words, and make the password four words. You know, like correct-horse-battery-staple. Wow, I remembered that.
- vlovich123 5y agoIf you need one password, yes. However, most people have accounts on hundreds of sites. And you’re supposed to not reuse. That means you have to remember a unique combination of N words per site. I’m not convinced this is any better than choosing a 20-32 digit password from a secure RNG and storing it in a password manager.
- jjk166 5y agoThis is for people not using a password manager. Good luck coming up with and remembering hundreds of random 20 character alphanumeric sequences.
- rainonmoon 5y agoReusing a complex password (especially in multiple places) is almost as bad as using a weak password, but that seems inevitable given all the accounts a person uses these days if they refuse to use a password manager. In other words, do you think you'll have better luck remembering hundreds of three-word phrases? Or will you reuse your phrase everywhere and make yourself vulnerable?
- jjk166 5y agoYes, it is definitely easier to remember hundreds of three word phrases. If you know the lyrics to stairway to heaven, you can remember a little under 1000 unique three word phrases. How many song lyrics, movie quotes, pieces of trivia, names, etc can you recall? The human mind is well optimized for compressing and storing phrases composed of words, as opposed to random alphanumeric sequences.
- kazinator 5y agoRandomly chosen three word combinations are not "phrases" in the linguistic sense, though they certainly are "pass phrases". I think we are sliding into equivocation over multiple meanings of the word "phrase". There is a difficulty there that should be acknowledged.
- Uehreka 5y agoMost people’s passwords are 10-ish character not-totally-random strings, so that would actually be an improvement. Now bump it to four words like the xkcd comic actually says and you’ve got a stew goin’.
- btheshoe 5y agoYeah, just a pure word combination probably isn't enough. However, if you add in a little leatspe4k and maybe some dashes-between-words and a cApitalization or two the number of possible combinations skyrockets and the password stays pretty easy to remember
- kgwxd 5y agoCertainly not if the complex variation is just as long, right? About 15 years ago I got bit by the common mistake of reusing the same password everywhere, it was my email account and I can't believe I caught it in time before they changed the password or did anything to get my account banned. From then on, I remember just one complex password, the one for my password manager. Every site gets its own random password, as long and complex as they'll let me make it. If I get to pick a user name, I randomly generate that too, along with the answers to any security questions, which I keep in the notes section of the password manager.
- kadoban 5y agoOnce you get entropy high enough, it's no longer the weak link in the chain. So sure, a 50 character long letter/number/symbol line-noise can have more entropy than a 6 word random passphrase, but it doesn't matter and has some drawbacks. By the way, for security questions specifically, I'd recommend passphrases. Often there are protocols where you need to say the security question answer to a human and they need to verify it. You're not going to have a great time spelling out a bunch of nonsense letters, and there's also more chance someone would be able to talk customer service into "oh I don't know, I just typed random keys" or something. Your password manager can likely do passphrases for you as well so it's probably no harder.
- SiVal 5y agoWhat drives me crazy is that it doesn't matter how well I design my passwords if companies immediately sabotage them with their laughable "security" questions. "Pick one of these security questions carefully chosen for you by our marketing director's 4th grader: What was Mommy's maiden name? What was your first pet's name?..." So now a hacker can just claim to have forgotten my password, google for the town I grew up in or mother's maiden name or try a list of the top 100 pet names, and not have to deal with my billion-year clever password at all. So they allow you to harden the front door's security as much as you like but require you to pick one of their six easy-access window designs for the side of the house just in case you (or anyone else) are unable to get through the front door. I can improve security by providing the wrong answer, but then I'll have to record it and won't remember it if surprised by a challenge (on the phone for example). What I always want is the option to create my own security question, because I can design one that only makes sense to me but that I can reliably answer from memory.
- Nekit1234007 5y agoI just put passwords in those fields if they are required.
- yoz-y 5y agoSame, you can generate passwords as answers and save them in a password manager note or something.
- alain_gilbert 5y agoI read somewhere that a hacker called support, and when they asked the security questions, he said: "I remember just putting any gibberish in there." And voila, support person opens the door for you.
- devonkim 5y agoYeah, confirming that I did this to myself and realized in horror that anyone could have reset my password. So the only other option I see is to use real words that look plausible for the fields or to type in a message for support like “read this exactly letter for lettr”
- vlovich123 5y agoYou know what’s even better? Go to http://passwordsgenerator.net/ http://passwordsgenerator.net/, generate as many N-digit passwords as you want and store them in a password manager that’s reasonably sane (that way you can use a very large N). Google, Apple or Microsoft are going to be good ones because they already control your operating system and browser. There’s also a few other popular ones that may offer slightly more features/better organization if that’s important. Also turn on real 2fa (app or even better a U2F key). No, this won’t really protect you from a very determined attacker. Then again, neither will using a password of three random words. The endless debates about the best password policy are counterproductive. At the point it matters, you haven’t designed your security robustly enough.
- wildrhythms 5y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diceware https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diceware
- otherflavors 5y agohttps://www.fourmilab.ch/onetime/otpjs.html https://www.fourmilab.ch/onetime/otpjs.html
- bryan_w 5y agoI usually add something else to ensure its unique because unlike in most TV/Movies, "Horse battery staple" and "Horse BAttery.Staple!" Are miles apart and any legit password cracking tool won't know that there was 20 common characters between the first and second example
- bradknowles 5y agoExcept good password guessing tools know that trick, and can easily uncover all your passwords if you’ve done that. They just have to find that one example before they can start trying this speed up.
- davidgh 5y agoFantastic - and every site out there has a different set of password requirements that make introducing a strategy like this impossible. Password managers for the win!
- FractalHQ 5y agoI’m so glad I started using the open source password manager Bitwarden years ago and haven’t had to think about passwords since. It auto generates a random 20-40 character string of letters, symbols, and numbers for every account (right click an input > Bitwarden > generate pw) and auto-saves/fills it. Can also store passwords for security questions in named sub-fields. The only password I need to remember is my absurdly long and complex Master Password when I install it on a new device. Then it’s just a PIN or Face ID to enable autofill for a session. Even got my whole family on it and gave them a piece of paper with my Master PW in case I die or something.
- happymellon 5y agoAnd then you have banks, such as HSBC, who truncate your password, so only the first 7 characters matter.
- d4rkp4ttern 5y agoWow, shocked to hear this !