6 ms·
It's always to protect children or protect from terrorists or organized crime. And it is always pretended that the bad guys can only exist on the client side a
by croes 5y ago
It's always to protect children or protect from terrorists or organized crime.
And it is always pretended that the bad guys can only exist on the client side and not on the supervisor side.
- nine_k 5y agoThere is a nonzero price to enforce norms and laws. For instance, let's imagine a technology emerges that can render any wall in a building transparent and penetrable for a short time, without affecting the structural integrity of the building. How much easier would it make the job of the law enforcement! How many crimes would it help prevent or at least detect! Of course it will be a securely guarded technology, so that it won't fall to hands of random strangers, malicious hackers, or burglars; only the law enforcement agencies would use it, and only for legitimate purposes! Honest. Would you endorse such a technology in your town? Mandate it for your neighborhood? Why? Are you comfortable with the idea that a number of crimes will go undetected or not prevented because this feature is not implemented? Not rhetorical questions all.
- nine_k 5y agoI don't mind your downvotes, as long as you honestly think about the transparent wall proposition.
- supermatt 5y agoDidn’t downvote, but didn’t understand context of your comment given who you replied to. Maybe that’s why downvotes?
- nine_k 5y agoI think the context is suitable: the arguments for increasing efforts of law enforcement, because "think of the children", accompanied with promises that only the good guys will have the new technical means, and the law enforcement won't even make honest mistakes using it, to say nothing of ever abusing it.
- howaboutnope 5y agoOr as someone on slashdot put it: > Destroying the privacy of several billion people is not an adequate price to pay for capturing a dozen or even a hundred bad guys. > Sure it did get them some. So would carpet-bombing New York City. Success alone is a worthless measure without taking cost into account. -- http://yro.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=4631081&cid=45871537 http://yro.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=4631081&cid=45871537
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eth0up 5y agoOn the subject of rendering walls transparent for the last 10 years or so: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8914962 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8914962 Or http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2015/01/19/police-radar-see-through-walls/22007615/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2015/01/19/police-radar-s...
- nine_k 5y agoI love cyberpunk because its predictions are all coming true, so I feel that I've got a fair warning. This is stuff directly from Deus Ex (1999). Repercussions for posting wrong memes are also mentioned in Deus Ex, and are also coming true. (The epidemic situation is not that dire as depicted there, though. At least not yet.)
- roenxi 5y agoThere is a complicated legal and political process because there are a lot of things which are criminal that really shouldn't be. Historically, the law has been used to come down hard on people who: * Say bad things about the king. * Said good things about the king. * Are homosexual and attempting to live their life. * Are black and attempting to live their life. * Are foreign, regardless of activity. * Are female and attempting to own property. * Are local but not the right type of local. * The actual person is OK but they're trying to help the Jews. * Own the wrong book. * Worship the wrong god. And in hindsight it is generally agreed that those laws were poorly thought out. Giving the police tools to enforce 100% compliance with the law is by no means a sane thing to do. And if that is the plan it would behove us to make sure the law is good first. Which it obviously isn't there are gaping holes in every legal system.
- anticodon 5y agoWhat has really changed? Now in the West there're just as many taboos. You can't openly discuss lots of things. Maybe there's no criminal penalty for this (although in some EU countries there's already a criminal penalty for wrong^H^H^H hate speech, same is planned in Canada), but by saying "wrong" things you'll be expelled from society, expelled from your job. Is taking one taboo and just turning it upside down actually good? Punishing homosexuals was wrong but is forcing people to change gender, brainwashing children with homosexual propaganda and persuading children to change the gender by chemical and surgical means better? I predict that in 5-10 years in USA it would become obligatory to participate in "pride parades". People who avoid them would be put on "the list". This situation is not symmetrical and it looks absurd. There's a writer famous in Russia - Victor Pelevin. In his last book he stated something that was almost obvious to us: USA now is the same totalitarian society as was USSR. «Современная Америка — это тоталитарный совок 1979 года с ЛГБТ на месте комсомола, корпоративным менеджментом на месте КПСС, сексуальной репрессией на месте сексуальной репрессии и зарей социализма на месте зари социализма». Но разница в том, что «в совок 1979 года можно было привезти джинсы из Америки, а сегодняшняя Америка — это такой совок, в который джинсы уже никто не привезет». «Американская культура в современном виде — это проект ГРУ. Яд "novichok" отравил североамериканскую душу и заструился обратно в Россию. (…) Когда все, связанное с Россией, демонизировано на Западе, сетевые дурочки, прививающие здесь американскую культурную репрессию под зычный храп ФСБ, кажутся по-своему трогательными: геройкам слава! Но если рассказать им, что на самом деле они внедряют созданные ГРУ химеры, они столкнутся с таким сарказмом судьбы, который перенесет не всякая душа», — пишет в своем романе Голгофский. (too long to translate, but basically: "Contemporary USA is a totalitarian Soviet state from 1979 with LGBT in place of comsomol, corporate management in place of Communist Party, sexual repression in place of sexual repression, and dawn of socialism in place of dawn of socialism. But the big difference is that it was possible to bring jeans and bubble gum from USA into Soviet state of 1979, while there's no place from where you can bring "jeans" into contemporary USA" (mocking the myth that jeans and bubble gum were tokens of western "freedom" in USSR).
- m4rtink 5y agoTransparent walls - well, walls are transparent to many types of electromagnetic waves, which can be visualized: https://www.sciencealert.com/wi-fi-signals-can-identify-you-through-walls-and-even-track-your-movements https://www.sciencealert.com/wi-fi-signals-can-identify-you-... https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/mit-device-can-detect-people-through-walls-n452926 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/mit-device-can-detect...
- glogla 5y agoOf course I would campaign for it to be accessible. It would be a complete revolution in archeology, architecture, engineering, maintenance, rescue and firefighting and geology should it also work on rocks. Not sure I see the relation to Apple laying Fully Automated AI ThinkPol groundwork though.
- nine_k 5y agoI love the different angle you've taken! Let's assume that it only works with thin walls, so it has limited archaeology use. Firefighting is a very fair point. Would you, reader, trust the firefighters to not abuse such a power by mistake? Would you trust the chance of it being abused for the chance of being rescued during a serious fire? Not an easy question.
- wizzwizz4 5y agoYou can put checks and balances in place. Firefighters have vehicles with ladders, but they don't drive up to houses and break-and-enter. If it can be made obvious when they're using it, and there's independent oversight, I think the trade-off is definitely worth it.
- croes 5y ago>Of course it will be a securely guarded technology, so that it won't fall to hands of random strangers, malicious hackers, or burglars; only the law enforcement agencies would use it, and only for legitimate purposes! Honest. Here lies the problem. You can't guarantee that. Law enforcement itself has criminals. In some countries law enforcement is even one of the largest collection of criminals. And then something like Trump happens. Do you really want to give such powers to people like Trump and it's followers, not to mention more malicious ones? There is no way that this technology is only used for good. And what comes on top, it doesn't stop crime, just it's modus operandi. If they can't use their computer to handle certain data, they use hacked ones and hide it there. You know the trick how drug smugglers use the suitcases of tourists to smuggle their drugs?
- croes 5y agoAdditionally would freely use the toilet, masturbate or have sex if you don't know if someone is just watching even if it's regular law enforcement? If a police officer is in your house and you need to go to the bathroom, do you close the door?
- dpierce9 5y agoWouldn’t a better analogy be: I run a shipping company. You want to send a package. It is illegal for me to handle and ship certain things (e.g., nuclear bombs). Further, I don’t want to handle any of those things. Furthermore, if I find those things (e.g., when a package breaks open), I am legally required to alert the authorities. What assurance can you provide to the me (the shipping company) that there is nothing illegal in your box? Suppose I ask you to attest but then I find out later that a bunch of people have been lying on their attestation forms which means I have been unknowingly, undesirably made party to illegal activities? Every other company solves this by simply opening everyone’s package and looking. Suppose my shipping company’s clever engineers invent a detector I can give to you that doesn’t require me to look inside the package but can tell me with some certainty that there are no illegal things in the package. What statistical properties would the detector need to have to satisfy you that this was better than forcing every package open?
- wrs 5y agoThis isn’t an analogy, it’s just reality, right up to the sentence “every other company solves this by simply opening everyone’s package”. Every shipping company doesn’t open every package today, and in the real world there are no magical package opening robots, though there are some specialized detectors. So we already know from experiment that imperfect detection is better than forcing every package open.
- dpierce9 5y agoIt is an analogy to what Apple is doing. Analogically you are sending something to Apple to handle for you (either store or ship) and they have legal obligations and business requirements. Every other company manages those by ‘opening your package’ is analogous to server-side image scanning like PhotoDNA.
- wrs 5y agoPhotoDNA is analogous to the detectors. The analog of “opening every package” would be human review of every picture. We already have real world evidence for “what statistical properties the detector would need to have” to be better than opening every package, because the real delivery companies are literally doing this today. There’s nothing hypothetical about the question.
- numpad0 5y agoOr the fact that someone is in client side make them bad guys.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- api 5y ago> And it is always pretended that the bad guys can only exist on the client side and not on the supervisor side. This is very much the crux of it. Back during the immediate post-9/11 era there was a huge push to restrict all kinds of civil liberties (and the birth of today's surveillance state) in the name of preventing the next terror attack, which could be "a mushroom cloud" in the words of George W. Bush. There's a problem with this reasoning. Osama bin Laden wasn't some random dude who got radicalized. He was a member of one of the wealthiest families in the world. He was born rich, grew up rich, attended Harvard, and had a family that rubbed shoulders with heads of state and were directly connected to the Saudi royal family. Osama bin Laden was a member of what I've heard described as the "superclass," those who are beyond just being "merely rich" in that they possess not only vast wealth but internationally diversified wealth and powerful political connections. He was of the social class that is behind the glass of a surveillance state, and if he wanted to avoid any possibility of surveillance himself he and other members of his class could easily afford expensive security consultants and specialized devices. They could also afford armies of attorneys to get them off any lists and out of any trouble. If someone detonates an atomic bomb in Washington DC, it will not be some random middle class youth who got radicalized on a 'chan board or a Facebook group. It will not be some random protestor or dissident. It will be someone like Osama bin Laden. It will be someone with the money, expertise, connections, and background to find, recruit, and pay the personnel required to obtain or build a nuclear device. It will be someone with the connections to organize the logistics to smuggle it into the country and put it in position. It will be a member of the global elite. People with bin Laden's level of wealth and privilege are the dangerous ones. The lens of scrutiny should be aimed at them. One member of the middle class radicalized with toxic ideology might shoot up a school, but one elite radicalized with the same ideology could blow up a city or engineer a super-plague.
- quesera 5y agoThe risk to the existing order comes from outsiders with leadership abilities. Osama bin Laden's $30MM (per Wikipedia) inheritance from his estranged family no doubt greased some skids, but mission-driven people with charisma come from all socioeconomic backgrounds, and some of them succeed. (FWIW he did not attend Harvard, and AFAIR never set foot in the US.) The general pattern is that the wealthy are, on average, supportive of the existing order. They are the winners of the current game. Of course there are always rebellious children who are motivated by religion or power or fame etc, but most of them are feckless due to their upbringing. And ultimately, there are so few of them. Leadership abilities can be found across all economic strata. Most are happy to leverage their talents into moderate economic advantage, but some are driven by "larger" causes. I would say that the intersection of leadership abilities, belief in a "larger" cause, belief in victimization, and a willingness to harm innocent people (or to blame them for their inaction against your oppressor) ... is what leads to the risk of violence against the existing order.