5 ms·
I think you're underplaying non-financial incentives. I would rather have a job that pays $X but offers flexible work hours and vacation time that allows me to
by pavel_lishin 5y ago
I think you're underplaying non-financial incentives.
I would rather have a job that pays $X but offers flexible work hours and vacation time that allows me to be a better parent, than a job that pays $1.5X but won't let me take a day or afternoon off to (e.g.) take my kid to the doctor, etc.
Granted, that probably applies more to WFH desk jobs than front-line nurses.
- kevinmchugh 5y agoThere's probably some floor for X below which 1.5x is more valuable than the non-monetary incentives
- skeeter2020 5y agoThere is a well-studied phenomena where money is a very strong motivator until a individual-specific level, than quickly tapers off in perceived value. The challenge is the floor $ value is different for everyone and changes over time and circumstances.
- amerkhalid 5y agoIs there a number that will let you sacrifice your family life but also give you enough money to provide really good life for them? I am not saying it can make up for missing parents from ones life but I have seen kids who grew up with workaholic parents and are thankful for them. They had Better schools, professional nannies and tutors, and now they don’t have to work as hard.
- JohnBooty 5y agoWhat a good, tough question. I'd suspect that it's less of an absolute "magic number" and more like a ratio compared to the alternative. Like a 2X or 3X salary increase, maybe more. If I was making $30K a year (slightly less than the national individual median income) and had kids, I'd have to strongly consider a $150K job that could open up a completely different set of opportunities for the kids. In a lot of places in America that's a leap from "borderline poor nutrition and you better hope you're smart enough to earn a full college scholarship... and try not to get shot in the meantime" to "safety, healthy food, and we're able to invest in your future." If I was already making $125K a year that $150K wouldn't be so persuasive. Not upending my life for that. Although, I suppose, once we start talking nannies and tutors we're probably looking at closer to $250-$500K anyway. A full-time nanny is... well, a full-time employee.
- bigmattystyles 5y agoAn RN I know in New Orleans makes a paltry $28 / hour. Insidiously, they gave her 10k upfront for a 3 year contract. If she leaves, she has to give it back. She put it straight to her student loans so now she’s stuck there. I agree with op, we say we love our front line workers, but that’s just talk. I’m not sure but there’s not much of a union for them down there.
- nwellinghoff 5y agoNews flash. There is no way they can get that money back. She can walk at anytime
- JohnBooty 5y agoCan you back this up? Labor laws vary significantly by country/state.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Jtsummers 5y agoThis would largely depend on the particular contract. Money can be paid conditioned on an expectation of working for a period of time. Failure to meet your end can result in having to pay it back (in full or in part).
- R0b0t1 5y agoCase in TX where this was overturned. Employer was Buc-ees. The amount in question was far higher, about $100k, as the employee was given a $X/hr raise contingent on at least Y years of service. Court ruled contract violated right to work. This may mean bonus clawbacks can't work.
- Jtsummers 5y agohttps://cases.justia.com/texas/fourteenth-court-of-appeals/2017-14-15-01061-cv.pdf?ts=1507810495 https://cases.justia.com/texas/fourteenth-court-of-appeals/2... Interesting case. I'm not a lawyer and have only given this a quick read, but it seems that the amount she could owe back was essentially unbounded, the longer she was there the more she could owe back. That was a major factor in the decision against Buc-ee's. See pages 8 and 9, in particular. I don't think this would work against bonus claw backs in general, only if they were similarly considered unreasonable and also only in TX, whose laws were violated in this case. (EDIT: Or states with similar laws, obviously.) A $10k signing bonus that has a bounded and shorter obligation period could be considered reasonable. > As noted above, an enforceable covenant must contain limitations as to time, geographic area, and scope of activity to be restrained that are reasonable and do not impose a greater restraint than necessary to protect the employer’s business interest. https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.15.htm https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.15.htm Sections 15.50 and 15.51 are the relevant parts.
- mumblemumble 5y agoThe disgruntled nurses I know don't want more money anywhere near as much as they want things like lunch and bathroom breaks. Money can't buy happiness, but not being able to take care of your basic bodily needs can absolutely buy unhappiness.
- zepto 5y ago> Money can't buy happiness No but not having enough will make you unhappy, and keep you trapped there.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dividefuel 5y agoMy spouse is just starting her first RN job. As part of the onboarding, an administrator/HR person called and strongly suggested that she sign a paper waiving one of her 30 minute lunch periods. Even though the paper says "I am not being coerced", it's pretty clear that signing it is necessary for getting the job.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sjdrc 5y agoHow can a document like that even be legal? What reason would a worker have to willingly sign away their rights?
- skt5 5y ago> Money can't buy happiness Usually when someone says this to me, I respond with "then you're spending your money poorly". What I mean to say is that more money buys more flexibility and options, which should lead to more opportunities to leave unhappy situations or at least add more happy situations. Note that this is a generalization so there are plenty of edge cases to counter this.
- analog31 5y agoIs such a tradeoff common? Or do the best employers offer both?
- erikerikson 5y agoThe best employers offer both and often have far better profitability.
- MattGaiser 5y agoMoney can be used to care in different ways. It can be in cash for your current workload or it can be to hire others so your workload is less. But both cost money.
- res0nat0r 5y agoI think in this case, I think hospital staff at least would like to be paid more for the hell they've been going through over the last year vs. having folks stand outside on their balcony and clap at 7PM and pretend that will fix everything.
- syshum 5y agoThat only works if $X is over your what you feel is "required" to sustain your life style. Generally Speaking in all but the biggest cities that is probably around the 60K-70K annual mark anything over that a person might put other things ahead of salary However if you are working for $60K you bet you ass MONEY is how a company should be showing their love...
- arp242 5y agoThat's all very good; I genuinely agree with it, and I think it applies to nurses too (schedules etc. permitting). But it doesn't work if you're struggling to make ends meet. There are hospital workers who don't have health care because they can't afford it for example.
- ledauphin 5y agoyou're right about these other incentives, but they're all forms of time off. I believe the GP was referring to the other "stuff" companies try to do to get you to feel like they care about you, but that don't impact your ability to make your own choices about your life the way more time or money do. e.g., "free" swag, company-wide retreats/outings