4 ms·
Why do deliveries need flying drones? A truckload of wheeled delivery vehicles that could be released each time the truck stops might be more practical in subu
by gumby 5y ago
Why do deliveries need flying drones? A truckload of wheeled delivery vehicles that could be released each time the truck stops might be more practical in suburban environments (and flying drones don't make as much sense in a skyscraper environment either).
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere are some domains in which delivery is highly time-sensitive. Food is one canonical example, best illustrated here: https://idlewords.com/2007/04/the_alameda_weehawken_burrito_tunnel.htm https://idlewords.com/2007/04/the_alameda_weehawken_burrito_... Burritos are particularly robust to delivery (along with Pizza, Chinese takeaway, and curries). Most finer meals, and even items such as sandwiches or hamburgers, aren't. I don't see a large market for duck a l'orange avec quadcopter however. Even food deliveries, though, probably don't pass the sniff test. For me, seeing some new fancy tech prototype or proposal that looks to be unsuited to general commercial or residential use, I tend to see a submarine military application. Drone distribution in a combat environment could conceivably make sense (though it would risk blowing cover in many cases). Emergency response, research, fieldwork, construction, and disaster response are a few other potential fits. Much less price sensitive, high time sensitivity. But mass delivery of random consumer stuff in an urban or suburban environment? Not very likely. I suspect the problem just sounds too cool and is sufficiently engineer-catnippy for anyone to say "no" in time.
- Leszek 5y agoNot that this is very relevant to drones, but I've found over the past ~year that burgers survive being delivered surprisingly well, and the burritos I've gotten have been disappointingly soggy by the time they got to my door.
- ravel-bar-foo 5y agoIn Korea McDonalds has a long history of delivery. A typical franchise will have 10 red and yellow electric scooters parked outside. Typical delivery time is 15 min or less.
- DonHopkins 5y agoTacos are more drone-friendly than burritos. https://tacocopter.com/ https://tacocopter.com/
- gumby 5y agoSays the inventor of the pizza menu. You have a thing about food!
- prometheus76 5y agoAs soon as you say "food" I imagine cans of beans being dropped into windshields or onto heads.
- Syonyk 5y agoBecause a particular vision of the future requires everything that can be done to be done via "Flying X." Even if they're literally worse at everything than the alternatives, cost more, are less reliable, etc. We've had flying cars almost as long as heavier than air flight - they're not some future tech that has yet to be invented, as much as everyone pretends that they're some magical thing just around the corner. We've had them for over 100 years, and they've sucked as cars, and sucked as airplanes for 100 years. Any materials breakthrough that will "make flying cars possible and too cheap to meter!" can also easily be applied to both cars and airplanes to make them better (see carbon fiber). Drone delivery is worse than wheeled delivery in just about every option, but "flying is the future," so people have gone down that path, dorking around with it for a few years (which, honestly, sounds like a ton of fun). The results end up being quite reliable, which is "There is no way in hell we can actually make this work in any practical, economical sense."
- munk-a 5y agoI don't really agree that wheeled delivery is superior when you start to consider how dangerous and varied sidewalks can be - does your wheeled vehicle have the ability to easily manuver stairs or circular stairs? Can it make it over sidewalk fringes without issue - what about when there is snow and ice everywhere? Do you want your drones to have to navigate the social interactions required to ask someone for right of way on a sidewalk or avoid getting in the way (and tripping) a couple that's moving a couch? I think that when you think of sidewalks you're thinking of how they look in your town (assuming you actually have sidewalks) they look quite different in different areas - in the southwest they're wide, expansive and quite level - in new england they're broken frequently by tree roots and frost heaves and, honestly, frequently just don't exist at all in a lot of the cities. I do agree that people fetishize "Flying X" but saying that drones are worse than wheels in just about every way is pretty ridiculously hyperbolic - they have tradeoffs and it's quite possible that the market winner will be whoever sends out a van with wheeled delivery vehicles for most runs that can call in a drone if it runs into difficulties.
- gumby 5y ago> but saying that drones are worse than wheels I meant wheeled drones, not flying ones.
- temp8964 5y agoWheeled delivery vehicles do not make sense to me, because they can be easily ran over by cars (limited view bc of very low height). Many suburban roads do not have sidewalk on both sides, but bushes can be seen almost everywhere. Actually, bodies of dead animals ran by cars are so common...
- blackoil 5y agoAdd a flag on top.
- mkl 5y agoI think there are far more obstacles and safety considerations on the ground than in the air. Kids running around, branches off trees, long grass, gates, other vehicles, etc. An autonomous ground vehicle couldn't reach my front door, but a flying one would have little problem.