11 ms·
The humble egg is an example of what’s wrong with nutrition studies (2019)
- mrfusion 5y agoEven if eggs are somewhat unhealthy you also have to balance that with the fact that they have every possible nutrient and micronutrient needed to create a living animal. You could be getting trace nutrients we don’t even know we need.
- 1_player 5y agoImagine how rigorous nutritional science can be when state-of-the-art double-blind scientific tests are pretty much impossible or extremely expensive to do, and when there is a lot of $$$ interest and lobbying in presenting one outcome or the other. Nutrition is not rocket science, we are all expert in eating and especially in how our body reacts to certain food types, yet we take studies of abysmal quality for granted and preach them to our fellow human as if they were the ultimate truth. I can say I'm going to run a marathon naked in Antarctica and everyone would cheer me, but if I mention I'm going vegan, carnivore or adding some butter or tofu to my cheeseburger, everyone, from both camps, is ready to point out why I am killing myself and on the way to premature death. Yet they are not speaking from experience, but mostly from hearsay from their favourite echo chamber. I've stopped caring what common wisdom around nutrition is, and since I've started listening to how my body reacts I feel much better, healthier, and I roll my eyes every time I read the latest "nutrition" article or comment thread posted on here or anywhere else. We're still in the middle ages of nutritional sciences.
- spidersouris 5y agoEggs could easily be replaced with salt. Consuming too much salt (more than 2g a day) is heavily discouraged by some because it is said to increase the risks of cardiovascular diseases as well as increase blood pressure to a dangerous level, but others repudiate these claims and assert they are untrue, and that salt has positive health benefits above this limit. Even if we take a group of people, put them in a closed place and strictly control what they eat, it is extremely difficult to say if a certain food has had a particular impact on X or not. There are some many elements which are unrelated to nutrition at play that X could decrease or increase for any reason other than what one ate: stress, tiredness, physical activity, mood... Now, I reckon the wisest thing to do is to follow what the author concludes with: eat moderately and have a balanced nutrition. I doubt we'll ever get concrete and truthful research on nutrition soon enough. We first need to learn more about the extremely complex system that is the human body.
- snarf21 5y agoAgreed. The thing that irritates me so much in all these studies is how they conflate correlation and causation. Studies to truly isolate just one ingredient would be both time and cost prohibitive. We are better served by just eating as varied and unprocessed a diet as possible.
- caeril 5y agoI think the issue with salt and eggs is that we talk of humans in the aggregate. For eggs, there is some small percentage of the population that passes the cholesterol into actual high levels of serum LDL. For salt, there is some small percentage of the population that reacts to high sodium levels with hypertension. And these subsets of population studies skew the results to a degree that adversely affects the conclusions for the median case. For most of us, dumping salt onto a plate filled with eggs is not only fine, but healthy. Medicine deals in aggregates, averages, and statistical variation, which is to some degree useful. But it does precisely nothing to offer testing to tell you if you are in a reactive or nonreactive group to stimulus X, which would be extremely useful. We do this with allergies - stick 50 different allergens on a grid pattern into your back to determine your precise reactivity. But with nutrition? Haha, go screw yourself, all humans are the same, eat your 14 servings of grains, regard bacon and eggs as poison, and we'll medicate you for your resultant metabolic syndrome.
- bserge 5y agoPretty much. Same with humans with a "leaky" blood-brain barrier. They can actually get GABA and other amino acids from the stomach to the brain, leading to vastly different effects than the majority of people get.
- fivefifty 5y agoThis is very true, a few years ago that I started eating around 4-6 eggs a day because it seemed a good source of nutrients and I had seen various articles saying the cholesterol thing was a myth etc. After about 3 weeks of that many eggs per day, I ended up at the doctor feeling lightheaded and not quite right and turned out my blood pressure was insanely high and after a blood test my cholesterol was through the roof. I cut out the eggs but otherwise kept my diet fairly similar and about a month later my bloodwork showed I was back to normal cholesterol. Definitely there are some people who when they eat eggs it will spike their blood cholesterol significantly, but I have also seen other people who can eat lots of eggs and it doesn't seem to change their cholesterol in bloodwork at all.
- sorenn111 5y agoI'm having deja vu. We had a top story on HN recently where either the article or the consensus of the comments was "you pretty much cannot believe any studies about food or nutrition."
- faeyanpiraat 5y agoThe problem is that humans are incredibly complex and diverse, react to stuff in wildly different ways, and you cannot A/B test on the same individual, as you cannot reseg it to the same starting state, you cannot run two experiments on them, and you cannot get two completely matching people.
- InitialLastName 5y agoAnd it's somewhat-to-entirely unethical and logistically impossible to conduct even uncontrolled studies over a human's entire lifespan, which is really what we're talking about here. I don't think anybody is worried that eating eggs every day will cause health problems for an otherwise-healthy 25-year-old.
- rafaelero 5y agoThat's too dramatic. If we were that different, research into medications would be a waste of time.
- faeyanpiraat 5y agoExample: any drug can have some side effects with some probability. So basically an unknown set of people will have the side effect. But there is no way for me to objectively test whether I will have the side effect. The description of some drugs even contain: we have no idea how this works, it just does (for some people, also with unknown “parameters”).
- rafaelero 5y agoAre you really concerned about the side-effects of eating broccoli?
- ssivark 5y agoMost “science” that denies the reality of studying complex systems is broken. The concept of studying strength of correlations, even applied in the context of randomized controlled trials is only really effective in low dimensional spaces and linear dependences (I’m being very loose here, for brevity). But complex systems break all those assumptions. To steal a quote, researchers use data/statistics like a drunkard uses a lamp post — for support, rather than illumination. This applies to nutrition, medicine, ecology, economics, etc. I wouldn’t be surprised if their experimental arms run largely on confirmation bias.
- spicymaki 5y agoIndustrial egg production is bad for the chickens, especially male chicks. I consume egg alternatives such as Just Egg and use alternatives (e.g. tapioca starch) for baking and no one notices.
- faeyanpiraat 5y agoIndustrial anything production is bad for the thing.
- jtdev 5y agoYou can find locally raised free range eggs in almost any city/town in the Americas... Egg alternatives are nutritionally inferior to real eggs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pvaldes 5y ago> Industrial egg production is bad for the chickens Most successful bird in the planet. Almost 26 billions of chicken lives in this planet because egg production. But yeah, farming is bad. Dodos are fortunate to live such wild and happy lives currently.
- reducesuffering 5y agoYou'd be wishing for the fate of the dodo if you were trapped inside a cage 1.5x your volume for your entire life, your only consolation being there's another 100 billion of you. "How successful of me," you'd be saying to yourself?
- pvaldes 5y ago> You'd be wishing for the fate of the dodo if jailed Not, I wouldn't. To be alive and bored is better than to be dead and rotten. Rethink your priorities. Chicken are equal to humans only in totalitarian dreams And by the way only idiots and cowards choose suicide when life is not so good as the expected
- tersers 5y agoThe concept of sticking to one particular form of eating has always bothered me. It's always felt like an attempt to find a panacea that doesn't require much analysis by the person of what they input to their bodies. Realistic eating is a lifelong responsibility of paying attention to what you're eating and the effects it has on your body. Perhaps what we need is a faster feedback loop of what the current state of your body is so you can make an adjustment. There are definitely some foods that are better than others, but choosing a diet because it'll solve all your problems is the wrong way to address health.
- Akronymus 5y agoI am trying to shed quite a lot of weight. The only guideline I strictly follow is trying to keep my caloric intake slightly under my usage. (Altough, I am additionally aiming towards cutting out as much added sugar as possible and instead consuming more fiber and protein) A specific diet would just lead to me giving up and rebounding.
- nedludd 5y ago"Dr. Mehmet Oz even touted it on his television show." Yeah, no.
- Gibbon1 5y agoThere is also this "Other nutrition research critics, such as John Ioannidis of Stanford University" There is a good appeal to authority for you.
- nradov 5y agoJohn Ioannidis is a critic of bad clinical research in general, not just nutrition. This is his most widely cited paper on the topic. Ioannidis JPA (2005) Why Most Published Research Findings Are False. PLoS Med 2(8): e124. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124 https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124 https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/jo...
- Gibbon1 5y agoIoannidis has zero credibility at this point.
- Ensorceled 5y agoI remember him initially being sort of balanced and reasonable then he started pushing supplements etc. Then a few years later, he started showing up in infomercials pushing all sorts of crap. I liked his cookbook, I presume it was ghost written.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoHis usual shtick is to have a guest on who promotes quack notions and he just sits there pitching softball questions without challenging the BS coming from their mouth. That gives him cover when Congress calls him in to testify about misleading the public.
- faeyanpiraat 5y ago“the study tracked participants’ health outcomes over periods ranging from 13 to more than 30 years, and participants were queried about their diet only once, at the beginning of the study. Can we assume that the participants gave a reliable depiction of their diet at the outset, and then that they maintained that same diet for the years — in many cases, decades — that followed?” That seems like an awful way to design an experiment.
- rich_sasha 5y agoI was going to say something defensive about the science, like it’s really difficult to do a double-blind large randomised diet study over decades, but then I read this bit. It is beyond bad science. If someone makes an error in statistics, well, happens, we can’t all be experts. But this is almost taking the mick.
- Graffur 5y agoI eat 3 eggs a day - I hadn't heard of that study that more than 2 would kill me! In general I aim for lots of protein, a good bit of fat and less carbs.. with a specific aim to avoid carbs from bread, fries, cakes, chips/crisps
- the-dude 5y agoIIRC in the 80s, the Dutch Nutrition board said max 1 egg a week. They just discovered Cholesterol or something.
- drdrey 5y ago> Most experts recommend avoiding processed foods as much as possible and sticking with a Mediterranean-like diet because it makes intuitive sense. It is not too restrictive. It is heavy in fruits and vegetables. It has the right kinds of fats and some grains. It includes fish and generally lean proteins. But that’s the point of the article, who’s to say what the right kind of fats are? Or if grains should be part of your diet, etc?
- rednerrus 5y agoMy experience with this is that you have to take a n=1 approach to nutrition. You need to figure out what works for you by experimenting.
- fomine3 5y agoEven if N=1 is fine, accurate measuring is hard. There are many variables and placebo works very well. Is there any good way?
- adrianN 5y agoGetting regular assays of all relevant biomarkers to make informed choices in your diet seems like a lot of work that I would like to outsource to some team of scientists...
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoHonestly I expect diet doesn’t matter that much unless you are trying to lose weight, except that eating lots of sugar is probably not good for you. Exercise is probably more important for long term health than what particular kinds of animals or plants you eat.
- abfan1127 5y agomy experience has been exercise moderately, avoid sugar, and life is good.
- dalbasal 5y agoSo... I think I have 3 points. First is worst. Looking back over a few generations, standard nutritional advice informing doctors, institutions and the public have been poor. Not only inaccurate, but de facto pushing people down bad paths. Low fat & low cholesterol labels led to foods, with processed foods with high sugar & many additives. Cereal instead of a boiled egg. Second is that many norms, like the food pyramid hanging in classrooms during the 80s & 90s were based on long forgotten, often arbitrary decisions. Self correction was fatally weak. Challenging norms had a higher burden for proof than the norm had faced. Proof is really hard, it turns out. Third is that "what's a healthy diet?" was never answered better by science than book gurus or old cultural understandings of nutrition. That is, a practicable, science based understanding of nutrition wasn't achieved. Lots of things about nutrition have been learned but it doesn't really add up to a Big Theory. I think the real issue here is "what to do when we bust." Science doesn't predictably produce answers to questions we think it should answer. We discover what we discover. But, what do you do when hospitals, health ministries and such need scientific guidelines? IDK is not an acceptable answer. I do know is not a scientific one. "Lets not do science " doesn't (didn't?) work either. The only choice left is between a lie and a delusion. Postmodernism is inevitable.
- colordrops 5y agoYou are leaving out one of the biggest reasons "science" has failed us - big food industry has been heavily influencing politics, public opinion through PR campaigns, and even science by funding their own studies.
- FredPret 5y agoActually, IDK is a great answer if it’s true
- dalbasal 5y agoIn theory, sure. In practice, skepticism can be impractical. The guys printing the food pyramid postor needs science's guidelines. The hospital director wants to provide guidelines for the catering contract. Etc. IDK is fine, but they'll just ask the next guy until they get an answer. What do you mean science doesn't know what we should eat? Oh FredPret, you're such a contrarian. Don't be difficult.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoI eat astonishing numbers of eggs, and salt nearly everything heavily. My N=1 study shows its all good for you, letting you stay active for life with low cholesterol and no health issues. It reminds me of the 100+ year old lady asked "What do you attribute your advanced age?" and she replied "Whisky and a cigar every day!" I wonder if she was in this study?
- stronglikedan 5y agoAnother anecdote: My grandma lived to 98, and only couldn't get around so well and lost mental sharpness around 96. She grew up on "southern" cooking, complete with lard at almost every meal. She refused to eat anything green. Most of her diet in her later years, when she just didn't feel like cooking any more, was KFC chicken, Papa John's wings, and Domino's pizza, and always a sugary dessert. Her joke was the grease kept her lubed. She never went to the doctor for checkups, and the only time she set foot in a hospital was when she had a cancer on her neck in her late 80's. The doctors asked what she did to stay so healthy for so long, and she said, "I just keep breathing". She died of nothing more than old age. I hope I got most of her genes.
- bserge 5y agoSome people are obsessed with diets and risk factors that amount to pretty much nothing over the course of one's life. There's heavy alcoholics and smokers living to 90, then there's the poor sods doing everything "right" and dying of cancer at 50. Nutrition is just a very small, imo insignificant, part of it - assuming you're not starving or eating the exact same thing every day for years.
- Inate_Hikkers 5y agoIt's probably more genetic; I know a family that lived to about the same age (late 80s, early 90s) but they suffer from dementia at around the 70s. (I'm the guy from reddit, I noticed your account got suspended and reverse searched your username)
- yboris 5y agoNutrition Science is broken because of the financial incentives of companies to fund sham research to get their products sold. I strongly recommend going to https://nutritionfacts.org/ https://nutritionfacts.org/ for your information -- a nonprofit that never sells anything or promotes any products, just tries to distill research on nutrition in easy-to-understand videos and posts. Here's an example: "How the Egg Board Designs Misleading Studies" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2s25RaOZsFM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2s25RaOZsFM
- bigcorp-slave 5y agoIt would be great if this website answered the question “what is a healthy diet”, instead of trying everywhere to get me to watch some of its hundreds of videos.
- beering 5y agoI feel like this attitude is part of why nutrition science is the way it is. People are boxed into this "healthiness is a one-dimensional scale" thinking. Are eggs healthy or not healthy? Are potatoes healthy or not healthy? Is pizza healthy or not healthy? But reality is way more complex and nutrition science knows very little about "healthiness" (to the extent that you can distill diet into a one-dimensional scale). Scientists only claim, "X is maybe correlated with Y (in Z population)". So this simplification, plus the lack of definitive known truth, leads people to latch onto B.S. like "eating eggs is unhealthy because eggs have cholesterol".
- Spivak 5y agoI don't think it's an attitude problem that people expect nutritional advice to be actionable in some way. Because at the end of the day the only decisions I'm able to make is choosing to eat or not eat something. If you can't write down a set of rules for me to follow that eventually halts and resolves to a "yes" or "no" then there's no point.
- bigcorp-slave 5y agoI don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect that there be a landing page that says “most healthy people should follow a Mediterranean diet” or similar. Sure, there are food allergies - I have some myself - but this site seems like it’s trying to get me to buy the book and give the video views. I want information in text quickly. Then if I want to learn more, more information in longer text. This is how almost all valuable information is conveyed across all topic areas.
- mcguire 5y agoYa know, technically,... "Nutrition research tends to be unreliable because nearly all of it is based on observational studies, which are imprecise, have no controls, and don’t follow an experimental method." You could say the same things about astronomy.
- beiller 5y agoYa if astronomy was done by taking photos of the sky 30 years ago, erasing them, and only using their verbal descriptions after 30 years to draw a hypothesis.
- jessaustin 5y agoIn 1695 Edmond Halley predicted the return of his comet in 1758. That was one of the first astronomical experiments, but it was hardly the last.
- DubiousPusher 5y agoBut observation is the point of most astronomy. Determining causatiom is usually not the goal. Observing people's weight over time is ome of the reliable and useful things nutritiom research has accomplished. But the goal of the kind of research being discussed here though is to study causation.
- adrianN 5y agoPredicting the movement of the stars is a vastly simpler problem that predicting the health effects of food.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoEat food, not too much, mostly plants. Side note: Why do we constantly cry about recommendations from the 1970s being different from today's recommendations? That's a lot of time. Over time we tend to figure things out. It doesn't mean that in 40 years today's recommendations will be overturned.
- nradov 5y agoThe point is that in the absence of really solid evidence we should make no recommendations at all rather than having recommendations that change over time.
- dotcommand 5y ago> Side note: Why do we constantly cry about recommendations from the 1970s being different from today's recommendations? Because hardly anything in nutrition "science" has proven to be predictive. It's all junk. Most of it intentional junk pushed by political and business interests. For example, "Eat food, not too much, mostly plants." is just nonsense based on junk "science" funded by vegan/vegetarian aligned interest groups. I'm guessing with major multinational corporations peddling veganism, we'll get more junk nutrition science. Considering life expectancy, health and development has increased with more meat consumption. This is true of the countries with the highest life expectancy - japan, switzerland, spain, etc. Since we are omnivores, perhaps we should eat a variety of everything in moderation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoThat is not a vegan take. I am not vegan. >perhaps we should eat a variety of everything in moderation. That's what the quote means?
- dotcommand 5y ago> That is not a vegan take. I am not vegan. Didn't say you were vegan. Just like mothers telling their children "eat your veggies" makes them vegan. But the prevalence of that saying today is due to the vegan lobby. > That's what the quote means? Nope. A balanced diet perhaps, but certainly not your quote. Your quote part of vegan propaganda. Sneakily get the naive to accept "mostly vegetables" and then "why not only vegetables". You see it everywhere on social media. It's a propaganda campaign funded by the largest corporations in the world and the vegan fanatics teaching kids/people a toxic and unnatural diet to humans.
- azinman2 5y agoN=1. I was eating eggs daily. My cholesterol was high and my doc wanted to put me on statins. I said let me try diet and exercise. I changed it what I was eating (no more daily eggs) and 6 months later I dropped 50 points in bad cholesterol.
- jbotz 5y agoDid you do the exercise as well? There is a lot more evidence that exercise lowers your cholesterol than that eating eggs raises it. Not only is your anecdote N=1, but you also probably changed severak variables with controlling any of them.
- azinman2 5y agoI did do the exercise. I'm not sure of the exact timeline, because part of it was me eating heavy breakfast ham & cheese croissants, but I also was eating eggs leading up to my wedding as part of the slow food diet to lose weight. I don't remember at which points my cholesterol was measured, but I did stop doing the daily eggs.
- lmilcin 5y agoAnd the egg and cholesterol example is even more complex. Because the cholesterol that is ingested does not necessarily increase amount of cholesterol in your body. Because body produces cholesterol on its own and when you ingest cholesterol -- it just produces less of it. At least assuming you are healthy person. If you are not and your body already has problems regulating cholesterol - adding more cholesterol might actually be a bad idea. This shows how important it is to actually understand processes and relations and not just rely on correlations. Studies are flawed because we are looking for correlations and then immediately try to look at study result as a general rule to guide our decision process. What we should do instead, we should still do these studies, but then we need to follow with more research to actually understand where these correlations come from exactly. Like understand actual biochemistry of what is going on.
- legerdemain 5y agoThe venal, profit-driven corruption in academic nutrition science is exactly why we should stop paying attention to it and start paying much more attention to philosophies of health that humanity has tested over decades and centuries: ayurveda, TCM, and osteopathy.
- zz865 5y agoAnother article recommending Mediterranean diet. The healthy Greek and Italian people I know seem to have coffee and a cigarette for breakfast. It seems traditionally food was tight and often in the winter they'd skip meals and go hungry, so Med diet is probably closer to intermittent fasting.
- abfan1127 5y agomy own observation is that when money is tight, sugar based products tend to disappear. When money is loose, they appear. The hitch is that industry has found a way to produce highly refined carbs cheaply.
- robocat 5y agoYeah - the bullshit of attributing differences to diet, and ignoring lifestyle differences. For example cars per capita: US=0.8 Italy=0.7 and Greece=0.5 (so Greece has more than twice as many people without a car – ignoring distribution).
- mekoka 5y agoComplex synergistic systems are notoriously challenging to understand. They can have multiple moving parts, with various intertwined causes and effects. But with our limited tooling, we often have to isolate a part from the whole to get but a glimpse at how it works. The approach is scientific, often clean and elegant. It's quite tempting. It also gives the illusion of predictability. I wish scientists would realize that sometimes, all they've actually discovered is exactly that, how the part works in isolation, with no guarantee that the sum of the set can predict the outcome of the whole.
- tus89 5y agoDo researchers even get taught about the difference between correlation and causation? People who eat large numbers of eggs probably also eat large amounts of bacon (compared to others), and bacon as a highly cured meat with high levels of salt and other toxic compounds, could easily explain the results. And then there is this: > But on the other hand, the study tracked participants’ health outcomes over periods ranging from 13 to more than 30 years, and participants were queried about their diet only once, at the beginning of the study. Wow I don't know what to say.
- ALittleLight 5y agoYeah, I had a hard time believing that. Surely there's no way you could publish a paper purporting to be about health affects of what people ate if you only asked them once what they ate and used that to evaluate a multi-decade time frame. That hardly seems better than basing your findings on intuition.
- armchairhacker 5y agoPart of the problem is that nutrition is incredibly nuanced and unknown, but people want simple, absolute answers. Different people have much different bodies: they react to foods differently, have different metabolisms (at least based on sex/age/height/weight/bodyfat/exercise), and different preferences. Bodies are also complex, and there are 500 different causes that can all lead to you feeling like garbage. But that wouldn't sell papers, there wouldn't be much to write. So people make blunt statements. Most of what I see online seems to be geared towards the "average American". Which ironically means, the people reading these articles who actually care about their nutrition, most of it doesn't even apply to them. And this isn't even getting into another factor, which is that people get particularly defensive about nutrition. So others take these blunt, over-generalized statements as fact and double down on them. I see this in-person by people who are otherwise really smart. Examples: "eat less salt and more fiber" - you don't know how much salt / fiber I'm eating. "Almonds keep you full" - idk some people eat loads of almonds. "Keto changed my life / I hate keto" - that's your anecdote, it only applies to you. Specifically, for eggs: if someone has high cholesterol, it will show up on bloodwork, and if the eggs raise their cholesterol, cutting / reintroducing them will show up too. If I eat 6 eggs a day and have great cholesterol, some study that says on average people who eat eggs die of a heart attack, that means nothing to me. If I eat 6 eggs a day and have terrible cholesterol, and after I stop eating eggs my cholesterol lowers, some study that says eggs usually don't spike cholesterol, that also means nothing.
- rafaelero 5y agoI think these types of takes are too harsh on nutrition. Nutrition are not only observational studies, you know? For example, we know that LDL is causally connected to our killer number one (atheroschlerosis). We are pretty pretty pretty sure that it is true (both clinical interventions with statins as well and mendelian studies confirm that). So, if that is the case, we can just split people into groups that consume one pattern of food and another one that acts like control. What happens to their LDL after some weeks? See, not that hard. There are a bunch of other biomarkers as well that can be used to do experiments like that. There are of course always a possibility that these changes on biomarkers don't mean anything at all, but this is something that will eventually show up on data. So... I don't really understand all these skepticism about nutrition as a field. People are too dramatic and react weirdly with all this "omg they are lying to me! I can't trust anyone" and go on to trust bro science. Grow up. Obesity epidemic is very real and somewhat there is this idea that we don't know anything about what a healthy diet is. This is ridiculous and shouldn't be that hard to discredit. Tribalism perpetuates that shit.
- ncmncm 5y agoWe were told for decades that saturated fat was really bad for us. Now it turns out (as some pointed out even back when it started) that saturated fat is absolutely fine. All the people dropping dead from heart disease were being poisoned by trans fats, which were being added to everything (as e.g. Crisco, and margerine). There is something wrong in (American) beef, but it's not the saturated fat. We lost decades, blaming the fat, and still don't know what it is. Now we are being poisoned by the fructose in sugar that is added to everything. It is really hard to buy things made in the US without a phenomenal amount of sugar dumped in. Bread, pickles, salad dressing, soy milk, you name it. The US massively subsidizes production of corn, to the point there is so much more than the market wants that they have to turn it into sugar and pump that into everything. That's not enough, so they also have to feed cows, pigs, and chicken on it, which makes them sick. That's not enough, so they have to make it into ethanol and add it to gasoline. What is ironic is that actual corn sugar, glucose, is fine. But they catalyze corn into fructose because it is sweeter when cold. And, incidentally, toxic. Your liver can neutralize a strictly limited amount of almost any toxin, including fructose, but most Americans take in much more than that. So, before you eat/drink sugar, think: how much sugar do I expect to need to neutralize today? For more actionable information, consult Robert Lustig lectures on Youtube.
- 1_player 5y agoRecent studies point to fructose and vegetable oils being toxic for the human body, at least in the proportions used in mainstream dietary advice. Big supermarket brands in UK are still selling low fat variants of food, more often than not packed with sugar for taste. Because of course, fat in the arteries comes from dietary fat, isn't it obvious? Let's not even start with the red meat propaganda.