12 ms·
Are our immune systems out of practice?
- xunn0026 5y agoAs if it wasn't obvious the mass isolation and sedentarism will have massive mental and health impact.
- blub 5y agoHealth care impact because of shifting infection wave timeframes. The immune system will continue to deal with the viruses as it normally does.
- xunn0026 5y agoDid you have a cold the past year? I did not. All because of the social distancing. Turns out if you personally avoid people and crowds (social distancing) and if indoor places are closed there's fewer situations to get any virus. Unless the virus comes on Amazon packages or through the air in the back yard. Kids have been massively more sheltered too. Either by parents or because schools were literally closed. It's a good thing that we are reopening the society by Autumn, so we can have a nice wave of colds, flu and COVID by people that didn't catch anything in 1 year. (As in, I worry a bit about what Autumn will bring). Bubble boy meets bubble society.
- blub 5y agoI didn't back in 2020 during the most strict lockdowns, but afterwards sure, plenty of colds. And I hate to brag, but I have a (light) cold right now. :-) For the record, there was nothing special about those after-lockdown-colds compared to regular colds. Based on my own experience and that of other parents I know, I would say that we've sheltered our kids, but as soon as school was back on it was game over.
- xunn0026 5y ago> And I hate to brag, but I have a (light) cold right now. :-) LOL
- refurb 5y agoWas reading a healthcare forum where doctors were giving multiple examples of people with advanced cancer that would have been curable 1 year ago when the patient first noticed it, but now requires major intervention with an uncertain outcome.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThat happened pre-pandemic, too. Some people hate going to the doctor, others are trying to avoid paying their deductible for what turns out to be something benign, etc. Confirmation bias may also be at play. It'll be a while before we know the impact in a data-driven rather than anecdote-driven fashion.
- krona 5y agostatistical breakdown from the British Medical Association: https://www.bma.org.uk/media/2840/the-hidden-impact-of-covid_web-pdf.pdf https://www.bma.org.uk/media/2840/the-hidden-impact-of-covid... I'm sure a qualified actuary will be able to take this data along with models of expected outcomes and give you (well not you, but an insurance company) a fairly good idea of the consequences in terms of lives lost over the next 5 years or so.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThat link backs up my statement: it's a bunch of "we estimate" statements and attempts to model the future based on a survey of ~2k physicians. A qualified actuary will likely admit to uncertainty on something unprecedented like the first pandemic in the modern era.
- refurb 5y agoThat’s a total cop out to say it happen pre-pandemic. We’re talking about people actively seeking care being turned away. Not sure you need much data when countries like Canada were canceling all elective surgeries during their Covid waves. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/covid-19-ontario-hospitals-elective-surgery-icu-patients-1.5980755 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/covid-19-ontario-hosp... This happened in most countries that were hit hard. We’re talking going from a packed schedule of preventative screenings and elective surgeries to zero. The backlog will take years to clear.
- dna_polymerase 5y ago> The immune system will continue to deal with the viruses as it normally does. Even if you know nothing about medicine, just from the fact that the COVID vaccines need booster shots you should be able to induce that the immune system in fact has a time component to it, and therefor any timeframe has an impact on it's ability. With a little more knowledge on the topic you can see that a single year of basically blocking everyhing off from your immune system makes it less powerful. The flu season will be devastating, and the long term effects of blocking kids from training their immune systems will be even worse.
- RandomLensman 5y agoI don't think a booster shot is a good example, lots of other vaccinations are administered in 3 shots. On others, the current view is that one is enough for life. If there is really a degradation in immune capability, is there any evidence of that from other vaccinations not working as well as in the past? How far the immune system is actually depressed from the lockdowns etc., we will find out. Could also be the other way around, i.e. overreaction. What I have not observed since things are getting back to normal in my part of Europe is that everyone gets a cold etc. as soon as they meet more people.
- blub 5y agoYour premise that everything was "blocked off" from people's immune systems is wrong and the whole argument falls apart. This is incidentally also addressed explicitly in the article.
- smorgusofborg 5y agoWe've lived millions of years in the lifestyle of the lockdown (many parts of the world still do) and for a few freakish millennia, some parts of society sort of managed in the style being resumed..
- throwaways885 5y agoWe lived in tribes, not pseudo-prison cells with just yourself or your family at best.
- ubercore 5y agoHow large do you think those tribes were?
- throwaways885 5y agoProbably more than 2.4 people, which is the average household size in the UK, for example.
- ubercore 5y agoProbably, and I haven't experienced lockdown in the UK, but in the US and Norway, even people being quite careful see more than just their immediate household.
- teamonkey 5y agoIt's been pretty loose in the UK. Even during the strictest lockdown, which only lasted a couple of weeks, you could still go out for exercise, go to shops for "essentials" (the definition was liberal). People went to exercise and just happened to be walking 2 metres away and in the same direction as their friends. Hardly house arrest.
- tokai 5y ago1727.9 ± 620.6 persons. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5756541/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5756541/
- tambourine_man 5y agoAll much milder than post covid complications or death. None put as much pressure on public health systems.
- nradov 5y agoFor most people the social isolation is a greater risk than COVID-19.
- selfsimilar 5y agoI’d love to see any statistics to support that claim. Anecdotally I disagree with that risk assessment but I don’t have any hard data on the risk(s) associated with social isolation.
- Loughla 5y ago"Most" is a very strong word to use in this situation. How do you back that up? Demographic data? Psychological profiles of those demographics? Or just because you want it to be true?
- tambourine_man 5y agoA country severely affected by covid like Brazil has seen its population decline for the first time ever since the Portuguese set foot. People were asphyxiating to death in Manaus because hospitals couldn't meet the oxygen tanks' demand with patients coming in hordes. It’s that bad. The amount of people that committed suicide due to depression induced by isolation is several orders of magnitude less. It’s sad and scary that we still have to have this conversations in well educated forums like HN one and a half years in this pandemic.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ethbr0 5y agoYes. But more generally, and especially as infants. Eat more dirt. Lick more doorknobs. https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/6/42/eaba2578 https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/6/42/eaba2578 At this point, your average (pre-Covid) developed world immune system was already like a home-schooled kid suddenly being thrown into a cocktail party.
- ramraj07 5y agoNo, don’t lick more door knobs. In the rural environments you have more germs but not everything there is out to infect humans. A good fraction of the crap in door knobs is here to kill you. The correct advice is to grow up in a farm or a wooded area. Eat everything as soon as you can. Visit Africa as a child and get a worm or two in you.
- krona 5y ago> Visit Africa as a child and get a worm or two in you. You're not going to get river blindness from licking a door knob.
- voisin 5y ago> like a home-schooled kid suddenly being thrown into a cocktail party. I downvoted you because this is an idiotic statement.
- ethbr0 5y agoFigured that would ruffle feathers somewhere. I'm open to an argument that home-schooled kids are better peer socialized. Have at it.
- Exmoor 5y agosigh You argued that homeschooled children would essentially fail when exposed to a fairly normal social situation. As someone who was homeschooled from pre-k until I went to college and whose social circle 20 years later still includes a huge number of people who were homeschooled I can say that this stereotype doesn't really hold true in my experience. Most homeschooled children get plenty of opportunities to socialize with peers. I certainly knew of a few homeschooled kids who were socially awkward, but I also knew plenty of kids who attended traditional school who were similarly inclined. Two decades after I graduated I can say conclusively that professional outcomes of the homeschooled kids look as good or better than the non-homeschooled children I know. As to your initial point regarding immune systems, I find that to be a fairly simplistic view as well. While children today may not be exposed to some things as much as they used to, the amount of travel and food transportation likely results in a much more diverse amount of viral and bacterial exposure than a few generations ago. We have some anecdotal evidence (although with lots of confounding factors) that people in countries with a higher percentage of children having grown up around agriculture have suffered worse than rich world countries.
- kumarsw 5y agoAs with all good internet journalism, the answer is at the end: > The immune system is 'not a muscle.' All this begs the question: Will kids have more severe infections after the COVID-19 pandemic if their immune systems missed out "training" during winter lockdowns? Carsten Watzl, the secretary general of the German Society for Immunology, says we may see more infections, but not necessarily more severe ones. TL;DR: Eating dirt won't work out your immune system because it doesn't work like that
- heavenlyblue 5y agoHow come it’s not a muscle if the vaccination works? Obviously getting more sick isn’t going to make your immune system stronger, but just getting sick is going to make it learn how to make antibodies for specific illnesses.
- weavie 5y agoThat implies the immune system is more like a library.
- naich 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- genzoman 5y agoExposure to smallpox wiped out populations in two continents from no prior exposure. The quoted “not necessarily” isn’t a ringing endorsement. Chickenpox is another example of early exposure/vaccine or very bad things happen.
- paulryanrogers 5y ago> Chickenpox is another example of early exposure/vaccine or very bad things happen. Side note, even early exposure may not help. I got it twice and the second was rough. It also carries a higher risk of shingles later in life and could impact the nervous system. Please consider vaccinating your kids against chickenpox.
- elzbardico 5y agoComplex systems are, well..., complicated. Policy choices always have trade-offs, most side-effects are only obvious with hindsight. I think it will be years, and it will take hundreds of thousands of person/years of research to really assess what we did wrong and what we did right in the pandemic. And it is best to be this way, as any conclusions we come to now are going to be probably contaminated with politics.
- Loughla 5y agoI am completely pessimistic that any substantive learning will come from this entire mess. It's already political; any results will either be massively and inappropriately influenced by politics, and/or valid results will just be scoffed at by one side or the other, depending on the result. I have no faith in major world powers to not use this as a continued power grab and cynical boost to their voting base.
- lrem 5y agoSee, my country saw some 300 years of democracy. At that point the progressives used a trick to pass a new constitution proclaiming all people to be equal. Conservatives felt their rights were violated so hard, they passed a resolution inviting neighbouring countries to intervene and another one for the army to stand down. Mere 200 years later all political options agree that was not very bright of them. Just give it some time.
- RandomWorker 5y agoMaybe it’s time to let go of this comfortable idea that we are a animal doing natural things in nature. We are really like Yuval Noah Harari said Homo dues. We are letting go of this idea of natural a long time a go and we have been interfering with our own immune systems, environment and what not for centuries. Maybe we will get yearly shots to strengthen our immune system from the flu to train it some how and not get sick. oh wait that exists already and is common practice. The flu shot.
- disabled 5y ago> Maybe we will get yearly shots to strengthen our immune system from [all kinds of infectious pathogens] I already do. I have to self-administer subcutaneous immunoglobulin twice per week due to having a rare immune mediated disease affecting my peripheral nervous system. Subcutaneous inmunoglobulin is a blood product, which is administered under the skin, which contains antibodies from tens of thousands of paid donors, as required by law for the each batch. I have not gotten a cold in about 5 years because of it. It also helps me recover from illnesses (for example food poisoning this year) quicker. However, the antibodies being infused does not train my immune system to produce them (applies to everyone) as the memory effect from the administration does not exist.
- bserge 5y agoThat sounds interesting. Where do you get the immunoglobulin?
- disabled 5y agoThrough health insurance. It’s a medicine approved by government agencies (FDA, EU Medicines Agency, SwissMedic, etc.). It’s administered the same way as an insulin pump. The only big difference is that a much larger volume is being infused.
- bserge 5y agoAh, prescription only. Nevermind then.
- globular-toast 5y agoI heard this theory right at the start when lockdowns started but I don't buy it. If nobody is getting colds and flus, then there are no colds or flus to get. The viruses can't just keep going on their own while we hide away. They need us.
- nradov 5y agoThe cold and flu viruses haven't gone away. They continued circulating, just at a lower level (in some countries). As soon as pandemic control measures are relaxed those viruses quickly come back.
- M2Ys4U 5y agoThere are sizeable non-human animal reservoirs for many viruses, including other coronaviruses (which are one cause of many for the "common cold") and influenza. The viruses can survive just fine without us.
- heywherelogingo 5y agoMine's on fine form. I've ignored this virus; no mask, no vaccine - no problem. This whole episode seems to me to be financial incentives and vocal minorities.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]