8 ms·
The alternative is extremely straightforward - ramp up public spending on infrastructure and social services and increase the minimum wage. You can do this ess
by pydry 5y ago
The alternative is extremely straightforward - ramp up public spending on infrastructure and social services and increase the minimum wage.
You can do this essentially without any inhibitions to growth until inflation hits about 7%.
Downside : it'll get a lot of very wealthy people seeing red and will scare upper middle classes who are more used to their security being provided by assets rather than social services.
- eli_gottlieb 5y agoOr if you really want the wealthy to see red, just deflate the damned asset bubbles. Cancel the underlying debts. Just null the whole damn thing. If you bet on real-estate prices or bank stocks or whatever rising 15% per annum when the economy was growing at 2.1% per annum, you eat the loss.
- krrrh 5y agoI don't want anyone to see red, but this is probably the better path forward. OP's suggestion amounts to an official policy of stagflation, and that has huge drawbacks. If we let inflation run away eventually we're going to need another Volker to break its back.
- frockington1 5y agoHow would you cancel the underlying debts and maintain any semblance of order?
- eli_gottlieb 5y agoHonestly? I'd just void them, nationalize any banks that go under, and give everyone who's actually using the underlying assets free-and-clear ownership. If you bought a house in the middle of a bubble in 2020, good job, you get a house and your mortgage is cancelled. The Sunk Cost Fallacy is a fallacy for a reason: there is always ultimately someone who pays for a speculative bubble out of their own use-values, and that's the someone who should be made whole, not the speculators. And again, I don't mean to be inflammatory (well ok, I do), but I really feel that constantly reflating asset bubbles for the rest of time, rather than accepting a one-time severe penalty whose moral hazard applies only to people who need things for their use-value, really is a Sunk Cost Fallacy that amounts to throwing good money after bad.
- frockington1 5y agoI'm down, I have a few properties. No mortgage and inflationary rent means I wouldn't have to work anymore
- eli_gottlieb 5y agoI mean, I'd be fine with screwing homeowners too, and I am a homeowner. The Zillow estimate of how much I could charge in rent is several times over my mortgage and HOA payments. The estimate for how much I could sell for is $25k over what I paid, two years ago. You can't tell me my house is making $12.5k/year for literally nothing, while I live in it and repairs accumulate, and tell me that's a sensible way to run an economy.
- frockington1 5y agoLow interest rates and high inflation will pump those numbers up even more. I don't see a way to stop the increase without the debt imploding on itself which the government would never let happen (I'm personally in favor)
- kazen44 5y agoalso, the rising real estate prices have detrimental second and third order effects. For instance, birth rates are dropping because young adults cannot afford a house, which in term means they have to rent against higher prices which means they have less income to actually put into the economy. What will we do once we have a generation which doesn't have any wealth and doesn't own a place to live? People who have little to show for it after a lifetime of working while subsidizing those who own the properties they live in is not a situation you want society to be in.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoDon't forget that those young people have parents and will eventually inherit their real estate, so they will have something to show for it after a lifetime of working.
- listenallyall 5y agoCancelling debts will only make asset prices skyrocket. Why worry about paying $400k, $600k, or $1 million for a house, if you anticipate that a few years from now the govt will wipe away all your debt?
- betterunix2 5y agoDo you like the idea of insolvent pension funds that suddenly lose their debt assets? Moral hazards from people who start taking on loans they cannot afford under the assumption that more cancellations will happen? Higher interest rates and more aggressive collections/foreclosure efforts from lenders that must now account for debt cancellation? Canceling debt does not make wealthy "see red." Long-term it would harm those who initially benefit from the cancellation by leaving less credit to go around and forcing people at the lower end of the income scale to accept less favorable loans. If you want to upset the wealthy, you can do any or all of the following: 1. End stock buybacks. These sound nice in theory but in practice they have promoted short-term thinking and have disproportionately benefited the wealthy. 2. Eliminate the long-term capital gains tax rates and treat all capital gains as income (perhaps with some provisions for retirement income). 3. Treat cash loans backed by financial assets (stocks, bonds, investment properties, etc.) as income (many wealthy people use loans backed by their investment portfolios to avoid paying income tax, and their heirs pay no capital gains tax because of cost-basis adjustments), with possible exceptions for loans that are immediately invested (to allow for leveraged investment strategies) and exceptions for mortgages that pay for a personal residence. 4. Eliminate the various industry-specific carve-outs introduced in e.g. the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (which were nothing more than a corrupt way to buy votes from various senators). and so forth. We have accumulated decades of policies that favor the wealthy, and as a result the income and wealth gaps have exploded.
- labawi 5y agoIf you want to upset the wealthy, institute a wealth tax (and redistribute as UBI). If you want to decrease asset prices, tax them (without loopholes) and see their valuation drop real fast, or slow - depending on tax rate. Just remember to equitably distribute a part of proceeds so you're helping, not hurting the poor.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI agree with increasing minimum wages and creating robust social services (universal healthcare, mental health support, the elimination of homelessness and enough food support no one goes hungry) in order to set a really solid floor for all. With regards to infrastructure, we have to be exceptionally mindful to not build for a future that doesn't use or need infrastructure that has a lifetime measured in decades (or, wishfully thinking, 100+ years). To see the peril, witness the rapid decline in need for commercial real estate with the very speedy transition to remote work, real estate which is very expensive to convert to other purposes. We don't want to be building "bridges to nowhere." for the sake of economic activity. > Downside : it'll get a lot of very wealthy people seeing red and will scare upper middle classes who are more used to their security being provided by assets rather than social services. Change is hard, but inevitable.
- pydry 5y agoIf you treat infrastructure as a special kind of investment that requires a guaranteed return you will likely end up with shitty infrastructure.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI'm not suggesting traditional financial return on infrastructure, but genuine demonstrated need and use regardless of return. If you build an unprofitable but highly utilized HVDC transmission line to avoid CO2 emissions for somewhere than can't generate their own clean energy (ie the Faroe Islands, for example, which hovers constantly at ~40MW of electrical generation using oil with occasional reliance on pumped storage), that would be a win imho. Japan's rail infrastructure is another prime example (although profitable if I recall). Avoid boondoggles, avoid status seeking projects, avoid nepotism and corruption, but deliver value. Edit: As someone else in thread pointed out, renewables should be invested in.
- jason0597 5y ago> witness the rapid decline in need for commercial real estate with the very speedy transition to remote work Is this actually happening? Feels like a tech only phenomenon, and tech workers are only a small slice of the US office labour force...
- throwaway20875 5y agoI don't think it's as straightforward as you propose. Debt is itself deflationary and dampens growth. Public and private debt are already at global highs. Every dollar of debt is far less effective at stimulating the real economy than in decades past. Further, how much infrastructure spending would stay in a local economy without a significant manufacturing base? I don't have the answers, but this seems to be borrowing from a playbook written for a different era.
- pydry 5y agoPrivate debt is deflationary as people prioritize paying it off, reducing the velocity of money that would otherwise be spent. The causality is reversed for public debt though - governments react to deflationary environments by increasing public spending to compensate for the private sector's propensity to save - as a "spender of last resort" as it were. That's how Japan ended up the way it did. Arguably it should have spent even more to offset deflation in the 90s.
- throwaway20875 5y ago>The causality is reversed for public debt though - governments react to deflationary environments by increasing public spending to compensate for the private sector's propensity to save - as a "spender of last resort" as it were. Again, we're at levels record levels of global public debt. There is no free lunch. Debt financed spending is only possible through financial repression (real default through inflation in this case and in the 1940's following WWII, the last time US debt reached 130% of GDP) which ultimately drives speculation as capital searches for yield. Rinse repeat deflationary shock as a result.
- pydry 5y agoAll this speculation and capital going a little crazy searching for yield are side effects of an overabundance of capital. We are seeing this now thanks to wealth inequality brought on by capital being given preferential tax status to labor for decades and stagnant wage growth again for decades. This wasnt a problem following WW2 - wage growth was high and given vastly preferential tax treatment to labor.
- jdhn 5y agoBy this logic, shouldn't Europe be growing at much faster rates than the US? Their social services are more extensive, I believe the minimum wage is higher, and they spend more on infrastructure.
- pjc50 5y agoThe EU imposes strict fiscal discipline. That basically prevents the possibility of taking advantage of Keynsian fiscal expansion. In other words, to the extent that greater spending causes growth, it's cancelled out by the matching taxes that reduce growth. https://www.ecb.europa.eu/mopo/eaec/fiscal/html/index.en.html https://www.ecb.europa.eu/mopo/eaec/fiscal/html/index.en.htm... > Compliance with this rule is to be examined on the basis of reference values for the general government deficit (3%) and gross debt (60%) in relation to GDP, whereby a number of qualifications can be applied. The simple key to understanding what can and cannot be done with printing money is to understand that you can redirect activity inside the country almost at will by printing, a pseudo command economy; but you can't print (a) foreign currency or (b) oil, steel, vaccines, or other constraints of physical production. Worked example? If you print money and the citizens spend it on imported goods, that depreciates the currency and is usually Bad. Currency depreciation against hard currency (USD) usually shows up as inflation. Weimar prints money to buy up domestic gold to ship to France for reparations => hyperinflation. Zimbabwe prints money but is unable to subsidize kerosene in shops at any price because the country doesn't export enough value to import fossil fuels => hyperinflation. US prints money for domestic stimulus while being oil producer and having labour slack and a generation of anti-wage-rise policy => almost nothing happens except asset inflation.
- tbihl 5y agoWhat in the US economy isn't inflated? The only thing I can think of in my life is utilities. Everyone knows housing has gone way up. As I go about trying to do work on my house, it's very clear that the price of getting work done when you want it is not what it was in 2019, because I pay those same prices in order to be in a line. I haven't needed anything enough to figure out what the price of prompt work is. Food prices have gone up. Cars have increased in price significantly.
- choeger 5y agoNot quite as straightforward. Infrastructure comes with maintenance costs. These costs can tie you down in the next decades. But even worse, you literally cannot spend an arbitrary amount of money even for absolutely obvious ideas. Try to renovate or rebuild all schools in one state at once. Or create new bike lanes. You will soon see that there's only a limited amount of companies that actually can do what you want. The one thing that seems to work surprisingly well is direct subsidies for switching to a better but more expensive product (electrical cars, house insulation). Personally, I agree that the government should take negative interest rates as a sign to massively invest. But I struggle to find an investment that is both just and sustainable. There is, for instance a huge pension gap in Germany. It would be wise to borrow money now if we could invest it to mitigate that gap. But how would such an investment look like? Buying children?
- danaris 5y agoOne thing worth noting in this is that, at least in the US, a lot of the "infrastructure spending" that has been talked about recently is, in fact, maintenance. We have roads, bridges, and buildings that were built decades ago, then the funds that should have gone for their maintenance spent on tax cuts instead, so they're limping along with stopgap solutions.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoThe US talks about infrastructure and then nothing happens because of political impasse on Capitol Hill. Biden is no Deng Xiaoping and the Democrats are no CCP.
- jason0597 5y agoMaybe it's time for radical political reform to end these deadlocks? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ySL82WbcvU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ySL82WbcvU
- Retric 5y agoRenewables are one option for massive investments without massive long term costs. The important thing is to subsidize them upfront rather than subsidizing their income stream or you get high electricity prices. However, the idea of stimulus makes basic assumptions that the economy can sustain a higher level. That economic article of faith may inherently be flawed in many cases. Another option for developed countries is rather than trying to stimulate the economy instead focus on increasing efficiency. Japan’s workforce increased 1% in the last 22 years. Long term stagnation should be expected in countries like Japan with stagnant and aging populations. Even 1% growth assumes the economy will double every 70 years. Relative stagnation isn’t inherently bad as long as the economy is still doing all the things an economy should be doing.
- nerbert 5y agoYeah once one realizes that yields are directly influenced by supply and demand, then that is the right conclusion. Political irrationality and specific interests are what’s holding us down. It is said that one day, if the CCP has to choose between relaxing power or scarifying economic growth, they would sacrifice economic growth without blinking. The same can be said about the 1% in western countries.
- Pokepokalypse 5y agoI agree with this, but if you merely throw money at the economy without resolving supply chain issues, (which is the case we have now) - we get inflation. Because it's more money chasing after fewer (available) goods. The previous US administration basically created supply chain problems with it's Hooverian trade policies. (ie. doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. Nope. We got the same results we got in the late 1920's + COVID). It's going to be hard to unwind that. I think the central bank has done a pretty good job making arguments that sustained low interest rates are a necessary evil. Unfortunately, the government (ie. aggregate of congress, senate, SCOTUS, and POTUS) are having a hard time swallowing that we need a looser fiscal policy. All because of political idiocy. I feel like Keynes should be taught to all children in primary school.
- ikerdanzel 5y agoPrevious admin brought the economy up. A lot of people getting jobs in those 4 years compare to Barry's lacklustre 8 years and near zero interest. I suggest you check back with historical data before association with Hoover. Wuhan virus bought it down. We will see the the old guy can do anything with suppose more popularity votes than Barry.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoYou can leave out SCOTUS. They don't have much impact on fiscal or monetary policy.
- betterunix2 5y agoThey have the power to kill major initiatives; see e.g. how SCOTUS curtailed some of the New Deal programs (and how it took the extraordinary threat of court packing to stop them from going further).
- d6ba56c039d9 5y ago> The alternative is extremely straightforward - ramp up public spending on infrastructure Hang on. Isn't that essentially what the Japanese did? I wonder which domestic investments turned out to be the smart move in Japan.
- frockington1 5y agoI just bought a few rental properties hoping this comes true. Lock in 2% mortgage for 30 years while inflation ramps up to 7% is free money. Open up the border and I might not have to work any more