7 ms·
This should be read along with https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28042185 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28042185 "Wealthy Americans Targeted by U.S. i
by pjc50 5y ago
This should be read along with https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28042185 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28042185 "Wealthy Americans Targeted by U.S. in Panama Tax-Fraud Probe". The fundamental question is "should paying tax be optional for rich people?" Large parts of the crypto ecosystem believe that the answer should be "yes". The US government believes the answer should be "no".
- genocidicbunny 5y agoNot only should 'paying tax be optional for rich people' be illegal, it should be heavily punished. If you are rich, and you avoid taxes, you should be punished extremely harshly, to the point of poverty or termination.
- lifty 5y agoWhen the rules make it illegal to not pay tax then rich people will pay tax. The rules are made in such way that people can avoid paying tax, legally. So you should call your representative and make it clear that you want it, but I doubt they will listen to you.
- Retric 5y agoA great deal of tax avoidance strategies used by the rich are illegal, but the IRS either doesn’t notice or frequently chooses not to prosecute them. A recent great example of why they don’t notice. Rich individual 1 was paying for an employee’s children/grandchildren to go to school while deducting that money from his salary via a second set of books. Rich individual avoids payroll tax, employee avoids income tax, and on the surface it looks legal except the second set of books made it a clearly illegal action. It’s exactly that mix of personal and business activities that makes such criminal evasion so hard to track. Another interesting example of not prosecuting, personal Roth IRA’s may not invest in companies under specific conditions and transactions must be at the fair market rate. Rich individual 2 broke both rules, but the IRS investigation decided to leave it alone. This is adding up to hundreds of millions of dollars in tax fraud, but if the IRS chooses not to prosecute then he’s free and clear. PS: Names redacted to avoid political discussion.
- xorfish 5y agoYou mean that the IRS frequently doesn't have the funds to prosecute them.
- Retric 5y agoIt’s telling that local law enforcement frequently receives money from confiscated items but the IRS doesn’t. On one hand that’s great from a conflict of interest standpoint, but when IRS funding pays for it’s self via taxes collected it’s an interesting argument to starve them of funds.
- adventured 5y ago> If you are rich, and you avoid taxes, you should be punished extremely harshly, to the point of poverty or termination Advocating murder on HN is wildly inappropriate behavior, genocidic bunny.
- Anktionaer 5y agoIf the government does it it's not murder, because murder is specifically unlawfull killing. I also agree that tax evasion should not be punished by the death penalty, but prison and extremely harsh fines would be a good start imo.
- imwillofficial 5y agoMurder is not unlawful killing. Murder is a killing that is not just. There have been many legal murders. (Look at the Ruby ridge incident for a non recent example)
- RHSeeger 5y agoAccording to the dictionary, murder is > the unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another.
- ultrarunner 5y agoDoes it mention who’s laws?
- RHSeeger 5y agoPresumably the laws of the society/government currently in charge where the homicide in question took place.
- imwillofficial 5y agoSo Nazi’s did not commit murder because it was legal. Got it.
- conjectures 5y agoWell, that escalated quickly.
- genocidicbunny 5y agoI would damned well hope so. That's sort of the point.
- dmichulke 5y ago> Large parts of the crypto ecosystem believe that the answer should be "yes" Citation needed. Also, why do you think crypto people think that rich people should pay no tax?
- toofy 5y agoI suppose people could quibble over what “large” means, but there is unquestionably a not insignificant portion who want cryptocurrency for the express purpose of keeping the government out of money. And another not insignificant piece who believe taxes is a key piece of this. Anyone who believed governments of the world would sit by and say “oh, a technology that can greatly aid in tax evasion, we’ll just let this grow with zero input from laws” are fooling themselves.
- ypcx 5y agoThe technology is perfectly sound and in its original blueprint it was never meant to be "traded" or denominated in an actual mainstream or fiat or government currency. So if centralized elements (i.e. major exchanges) are the cancer, then regulations such as these are the scalpel. If adopted, a cryptocurrency can perfectly serve an ecosystem as an exchange of value, without ever crossing the barrier to the mainstream monetary systems. I.e. a loaf of bread for a certain fraction of a Bitcoin.
- toss1 5y agoThat sounds lovely in theory, but once you get to an exchange of value, you cross the line into taxable territory, and will have to exchange something for fiat currencies. Sure, most minor barter transactions are ignored as de minimus, but that does not make it legal (i.e., not tax evasion). So paying your neighbor for a loaf of her home baked bread with a wad of coupons for the local store (or Satoshis) is probably ignored because she is not an official business, but if you do the same at the store, or she grows to anything beyond casual home cooking, the store and your neighbor will need to pay both sales tax and income tax - in fiat - on those transactions. Same goes for us trading anything large, say we barter my car for your boat (or a bunch of BTC, gold, gift cards or whatever), we'll have to pay taxes on the transaction, in fiat. And we may have the additional pleasure of needing to get an appraisal too. So the idea that crypto currency could never touch fiat was never anything more than a lovely figment of the internet imagination.
- DennisP 5y agoBelieve it or not it's possible to support tax enforcement, and still not want the core functions necessary for cryptocurrency to be made illegal.
- pjc50 5y agoIs privacy, or specifically the ability to earn income while concealing it, a core function? (It's an unfortunate feature of the weightlessness of modern money, crypto or otherwise, that proportionate privacy is now hard. In the old days, if you wanted to move a lot of money, especially internationally, you had to go to a lot of physical trouble: https://www.rte.ie/news/newslens/2019/1204/1096878-poland/ https://www.rte.ie/news/newslens/2019/1204/1096878-poland/ ; this was hard to hide and easy to intercept. Nowadays you could theoretically move billions with a brainwallet. The binance cold wallet is twice as much as the Polish wartime gold: https://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-bitcoin-addresses.html https://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-bitcoin-addresses.... So we end up with a situation in which in order to track the large transactions a system is built which tracks all transactions.)
- DennisP 5y agoContrary to popular belief, privacy is not a core function of most cryptocurrencies. Every transaction is on an open ledger viewable by anyone. If you fund an address from a regulated exchange, it's simple for the government to know who you are. Mining is a core function. None of it works without that (or staking, which is equivalent). A miner is not able to know who you are, since the regulated exchanges are not reporting their KYC to all the miners. Making miners responsible for sending 1099s would effectively make it illegal to run public blockchains.
- WJW 5y agoA miner could know who you are, though such functionality is not implemented in any of the current currencies I know of. There is no technical reason that a transaction cannot contain a cryptographically signed identifier of the sender. A very rough sketch of such a system: - Any exchange that wishes to offer crypto services to US citizens must do KYC according to the existing regulations. - Those exchanges make available each day a file with all the KYC-ed wallet adresses. - Miners can theoretically choose which transactions to include and which to reject, but at the moment the main (only?) criterion is how much fees are attached to the transaction. You could mandate that they also do a lookup into the KYC data and only accept the transaction if the sending address is present in the list. - I could even see the SEC or some other central body (perhaps one per country) maintaining such a list, exchanges submit their lists and miner can download it. This is already done in several other sectors of the economy.
- fallingknife 5y agoOnly if the government continues to insist on taxing income as a main source of income. The government could easily implement a sales tax and crypto would only be a small obstacle to enforcement. And as a bonus feature we could fire a bunch of bureaucrats too.
- ajackfox 5y agoSales taxes are regressive and affect the poorest the most. Income taxes (can be) progressive. Progressive taxation benefits society at large.
- roenxi 5y ago> Progressive taxation benefits society at large... ... claim the poor and the people who make their money off capital gains. Who gets to decide what "good for society" means in context of taxation is possibly the most political question out there. It is not at all obvious that making the most productive people pay most of the burden gets to the best outcome.
- dnautics 5y agothe more people's lives you are affecting in a positive sense the more likely it is you are making a very high income. the opposite arrow is not necessarily true, but one wonders if there isn't a 'baby with the bathwater' effect with progressive taxation.
- bgitarts 5y agoThis legislation will not raise more tax revenue like it proposes. It will stifle the US crypto industry and push it into friendlier jurisdictions. Ultimately it could end up reducing tax revenue compared to not touching the crypto industry.
- xadhominemx 5y ago> It will stifle the US crypto industry and push it into friendlier jurisdictions. And nothing of value will be lost
- cheeseomlit 5y agoPaying tax is and will always be optional for the rich. Crypto offers the middle class a chance to evade taxes as well, so lawmakers are of course far more adversarial to it than they are to the methods used by themselves and their corporate friends. One cold hard look at https://usdebtclock.org/ https://usdebtclock.org/ is enough to convince me that paying taxes to the US government is not a moral imperative. Every penny I pay is going towards paying off a massive ever-expanding black hole of debt that is mathematically impossible to ever pay off, the government is going to spend the same amount regardless of the revenue it collects since the Fed just prints it all anyways. So what's the point in "paying your fair share" in such a system? You'd be a fool not to evade as much as you possibly can.
- flerovium 5y agoThis misses the point: 'loopholes' often require sacrificing optionality. Most "X billionaire paid Y in taxes" have to do with _deferred_ taxes or charity, which can't exactly be spent on lamborghinis. There are definitely bad tactics and real loopholes, but this isn't the main problem. The real problems are more subtle and they require trade-offs. These problems won't be solved as long as the tax code remains as complex as it is. Massive tax regulation is a surprisingly recent invention.[1] [1] https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2017/oct/17/roy-blunt/tax-code-so-long-nobodys-really-sure-its-length/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2017/oct/17/roy-blunt/... EDIT: the parent author's very strongly worded statement isn't true. I'm trying to add clarity to a vague statement, not wage an ideological battle.
- aosmith 5y agoWhat about the situation where they borrow against their stocks, pay some small amount of interest and then when they die all the stocks pass to their heirs after settling any remaining debt without paying any income tax?
- doopy1 5y ago"Crypto offers the middle class a chance to evade taxes as well" - how?