7 ms·
The single most important job for humanity right now is to save this one planet we have from destruction. There is enough time to think about colonizing the sta
by paxys 5y ago
The single most important job for humanity right now is to save this one planet we have from destruction. There is enough time to think about colonizing the stars after that. I'm as much into spaceships as the next nerd, but people need to get real. The world isn't going to end because his next launch is a month late due to pesky safety regulations or whatever else. This effort is going to play out over many generations and centuries. Meanwhile our entire species stands no chance against one slight more deadly virus released tomorrow.
Criticizing regulators is Elon's MO, whether it is the SEC for his Tweets, various transportation departments for self driving software safety, labor departments for covid restrictions for worker safety, FAA for rocket launches... You'd think there is some national conspiracy against him at this point.
- colordrops 5y agoInstead of parroting what you read on social media, how about doing a bit of critical thinking on this. What about all the resources going into video games, sports, movies, music, amusements parks, television, weapons systems, desserts, travel and vacations, etc? They dwarf everything put into space exploration, and are arguably less useful. Do you make the same tired comments when those industries are brought up? And that's not even getting into the fact that multiple things can be done by humanity at once. edit: apologies for the first sentence here which was unnecessary to make my point.
- mulmen 5y agoThis whole "whatever I don't like and/or understand isn't worth doing" philosophy is just not interesting. Humanity is not a hivemind. We can do more than one thing. History has countless examples of innovation in one area leading to breakthroughs in another. Just make your own contribution to humanity where you can, we will be fine.
- lucideer 5y agoThat's true most of the time. Where it falls down is in cases where it's not "we". There's plenty of orgs doing worthwhile and important space exploration. There's a bunch of individuals destroying this planet who want to go to space and are selling a nice colonists fantasy to get backing. You're right that it's not either or: let's continue supporting viable space efforts. But let's not be naive about it.
- meepmorp 5y agoGP: >> The single most important job humanity has is to get our eggs into more than one basket. OP: > The single most important job for humanity right now is to save this one planet we have from destruction. You're arguing with nobody's point.
- colordrops 5y agoI'm arguing with this: > There is enough time to think about colonizing the stars after that. Which directly states that problems should be worked on serially - that space travel should be worked on AFTER we solve other problems.
- paxys 5y agoYes we can do multiple things at once. In the thread you joined we are discussing the single most important thing. So what really is your point here?
- colordrops 5y agoYour comment clearly indicates that we should hold on on space travel until after other problems are solved.
- Talanes 5y ago"Clearly" is a bit too much, given that you've had to comment multiple times to people who didn't read it that way.
- colordrops 5y agoCan you explain what you meant by that comment then?
- Talanes 5y agoYou said that GP "clearly" intended one thing, yet I've seen you in two other threads with people who did not share your reading of those words. It's fine to state your own reading of what they said and respond in kind, but dictating that your reading is universal when your comment is directly under evidence that it is not is a big leap.
- colordrops 5y agoIt's basic English dude, let's not complicate it. It's very easy to see what was meant by that, and it's a common sentiment all over the internet that these "space barons" should reallocate their resources towards saving the planet. If you insist on using 3rd party interpretation rather than 1st party intent to decide the meaning of a statement, I've got 16 upvotes on my comments here so others seem to be reading it the same as I. But we don't need to vote to understand what "until after" means. It's not esoteric philosophical language - my 6 year old would understand it.
- lucideer 5y ago> They dwarf everything put into space exploration If you want to make it into a discussion about comparing & contrasting impacts, you're going to have to take the collective impacts of those pushing the space-colony agenda: everything from perpetuating individual road transport & UK airline companies to the largest "bookstore" in the world and lots in between. Space exploration is an extremely important and worthy scientific endeavour & orgs like NASA have been criminally underfunded for decades. What is absolutely not worthwhile and shouldn't even uttered in the same breath as the history of efforts on ISS and similar, is a bunch of budding space cowboys sending phallic representations of themselves into orbit on PR missions and hiding their own destructive impact on our planet behind a colinist fantasy so thin only a complete scientific illeterate would fall for it. SpaceX has contributed positively to benign public missions by being a contractor, but all the marketing bullshit outside of that around Mars is demonstrably nonsense. > a bit of critical thinking Indeed.
- merpnderp 5y agoWho looks at a rocket and thinks "Hmm, I bet the engineers could have gone with a more efficient design, but they decided to go with a dick?" Like do people really think that there's better shapes to go with? And if people really believe this, what part of our public education system failed them most? Because my money is on critical thinking.
- lucideer 5y agoWell if you're really looking for alternative shapes, one of the Mars fantasists I was alluding to actually went to space recently in a rather flat triangular vehicle. Which is of course completely irrelevant when one is evoking a male ego megaphor and not opening an engineering discussion on aerodynamics. I would have hoped critical thinking could also help with that distinction in topics. Fwiw, I'm at least glad that single word seems to be the only part of the comment above you found objectionable.
- merpnderp 5y agoLol, the last time NASA built a space plane to do real work in space, it was grossly inefficient than the previous giant dick it replaced, wildly more dangerous, and NASA had to attach it to three other dicks just to get it to space. Face it man, people making fun of dick shaped rockets are seeing dicks where no one else is seeing them and calling themselves clever.
- ncallaway 5y ago> Instead of parroting what you read on social media, how about doing a bit of critical thinking on this Totally unnecessary. That gratuitous dig doesn't advance your argument at all. > What about all the resources going into video games, sports, movies, music, amusements parks, television, weapons systems, desserts, travel and vacations, etc? That doesn't seem like it's u/paxys issue to address. The person they responded to made a _very_ strong claim: "The single most important job humanity has is to get our eggs into more than one basket". It seems entirely consistent with both the original argument and the reply that humans could have two very important jobs to address (climate change, and becoming multi-planetary) and still have resources to dedicate to all those other things you describe. > Do you make the same tired comments when those industries are brought up? I would make a similar argument that u/paxys made if the amusement park industry claimed that building amusement parks was the single most important job that humanity had. Similarly, for sports, video games movies, or most other industries. Claiming the mantle of "the most important job humanity has" is a very big claim. > And that's not even getting into the fact that multiple things can be done by humanity at once. u/paxys didn't say that we could only address one thing at a time. They were disagreeing with the claim that becoming multiplanetary is the single most important job humanity has. Disagreeing with which singular job we have is the "most important" one makes absolutely no claim as to how we should be dividing our time. Ultimately, I actually agree with the original poster that becoming multiplanetary and multistellar is an important feat we should be aggressively perusing. But I also think surviving any extinction-event filters that may come along the way is equally important.
- colordrops 5y ago> Totally unnecessary Good point, I should have restrained myself here. The rest of your comments would be fair, except that u/paxys said the following: > There is enough time to think about colonizing the stars after that. Which clearly indicates that we should not be working on space travel until AFTER we've solved humanity's problems.
- ncallaway 5y ago> There is enough time to think about colonizing the stars after that. I didn't read it as indicating that we should fully postpone humanity's problems. For example, the next few sentences read: > The world isn't going to end because his next launch is a month late due to pesky safety regulations or whatever else. This effort is going to play out over many generations and centuries. That indicates to me that the delay the person is considering is on the order of the delay imposed by FCC regulations (i.e. months or years), not "start working on it after we've solved humanity's problems". But that's just how it reads to me
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bpodgursky 5y ago> I'm as much into spaceships as the next nerd, I think you lack some self-awareness here. Space is clearly a mild curiosity to you at most.
- ncallaway 5y ago> Space is clearly a mild curiosity to you at most. I think it's extremely unhelpful to tell people what their interests are, or what they believe. How much could you possibly know about this person's interests from that one post?
- bpodgursky 5y agoHow could the OP possibly know how interested other people are in spaceflight? They did exactly as much, by claiming they were as interested as the average nerd.
- midasuni 5y agoWhy are you posting on HN then? Get out there and save the planet.
- shakezula 5y agoThis isn't helpful or insightful input for anyone, including the people literally trying to get out and save the planet.
- s5300 5y agoConsider the fact, that the publicly richest citizen on Earth, as well as one of the people behind one of the largest financial transaction sites, may have genuinely already concluded that, as the history of politics among other things have shown, that the Earth/humanity may simply be unsavable, for whatever reasons they find. He has a lot of talent at his disposable, and presumably information to a decent bit of otherwise locked away studies/reports. Do I think he is correct? Perhaps not, but my nor your opinion really matters. If he's made the decision shits truly FUBAR, ala Foundation, then leave him alone while he works on what he may genuinely believe to be a shot at surviving the FUBAR long-term.
- what-the-grump 5y agoOr you know it's vaporware again like FSD and he is just making bank in an industry that is new? Now that technology allowed capital to keep up with government cheese enough to take on space freight.
- shakezula 5y agoI'm getting bored of watching rockets land like they do in the movies. Soooooo. It's probably not vaporware homie.
- sangnoir 5y agoThe publicly richest citizen on Earth doesn't believe that at all - in fact, he believes earth is savable, and is the best home for humans and should be kept pristine by performing all (polluting) manufacturing in space. Sure, it's not as romantic as "Let's colonize Mars", but IMO, its a lot more practical. Not polluting earth is far easier than terraforming Mars
- ryan93 5y agoElon has special information about whether humanity is worth saving? Lmao
- gridspy 5y agoI think the best way to save the planet is to move heavy industry into space. Move our power generation into space and beam it down. Make advanced technologies in space which benefit those on Earth. Move people into real orbital habitats. Make Earth proper a gigantic park / nature reserve. We can't "wait" for anything, or the window during which we can develop space travel will close. 10 or 100 years from now we might no longer have the motivation or the means to fund and build new vechicles like these.
- tablespoon 5y ago> I think the best way to save the planet is to move heavy industry into space. Move our power generation into space and beam it down. Wasn't one of the disasters in Simcity 2000 having your power-beaming space laser miss your power station instead light your city on fire? It seems like such a thing would cause massive hazards. > Move people into real orbital habitats. > Make Earth proper a gigantic park / nature reserve. Or force people to live deep underground. Then when they save up enough money to buy a ticket, they can be transported there much more economically. As for me, I like living on the surface.
- sebzim4500 5y agoI don't know anything about the physical feasibility of any of this but honestly I don't think 'argument by video game' is terribly convincing.
- midasuni 5y agoA 1 hectare receiving plant taking in 2kW/square metre won’t be burning any cities, but generate 120MWh continuous base load even with just 25% efficiency. Dial that up tenfold and I suspect you’ll be fine - especially with the plant in the desert (nothing to burn) 1GWh/y/ha. That’s a 4,000 ha requirement for the US electrical needs, about 10 square miles.
- pyrale 5y ago> I think the best way to save the planet is to move heavy industry into space. Good luck dealing with the absence of cheap oxydizer and the lack of convection which makes heat dispersion a nightmare. > Move our power generation into space and beam it down. Our power is already generated in space, and beamed down to us. It also comes with no infrastructure cost, which is truly an engineering wonder when you think of it.
- sebzim4500 5y agoHe's not claiming there is a national conspiracy against him. He is claiming that between regulatory capture and regulators trying to justify their existence, government agencies are not acting in humanity's interest.
- solraph 5y ago> > The single most important job humanity has is to get our eggs into more than one basket. > The single most important job for humanity right now is to save this one planet we have from destruction. Aren't these two sides of the same coin? If we colonise Mars, but leave Earth a smoking ruin, then we've made things worse by trading a planet with a function biosphere for one without. If we wait till Earth is in perfect state before colonising another planet, we'll never leave, and be subject to many of the same risks.
- supperburg 5y agoNo, you’re wrong. Every little bit of friction counts. Funding, regulation and public support all contribute to the end result. It’s already super hard, the only way any progress has been made is because we rolled one in a trillion with an super genius who is immune to stress and is interested in space. The amount of stress, the relentless pressure of doing all this and doing it in the public eye and suffering the cosmic level of irony of being publicly maligned for it… it would crumple you. It would crumple ten of you. If it were at all easy or probable then there would be other players in the space. There aren’t. If you contribute to the friction that opposes spacexs forward progress then you bear the responsibility for working against the things that you claim to love as a self proclaimed nerd. There were people who put on demonstrations against wealthy people spending their money on being patrons for scientists and early biologists. It was very unpopular for rich people to sponsor nonsense, the collection of random fluids and samples. All of which is the basis for modern biology and medicine. So which side of history are you going to be on? The idiotic mob or the people making things better?
- da-x 5y agoWe can fix the Earth's ecology from the damage of the last century and expand into space at the same time - these are not mutually exclusive. There can be enough people and funding to do both. And even better - the technology developed from the latter can assist for the former.