3 ms·
what is the legal situation here? wouldn't laws that require the employer to make accommodations for the disabled simply force the company to not use this tool
by em-bee 5y ago
what is the legal situation here? wouldn't laws that require the employer to make accommodations for the disabled simply force the company to not use this tool for blind employees?
the company would have to prove that using this tool is strictly necessary, which i believe is hard to prove, because if it was strictly necessary then everyone at home should be using it too.
there should only be few places where such a tool is strictly necessary, and those places already use it. anyone who only starts using it now when it gets more convenient can't make the claim that they could not do their work without it because they could until now.
- mwcampbell 5y ago> what is the legal situation here? Honestly, I don't know. We may disagree on whether browser isolation is strictly necessary. But to the extent that Cloudflare's marketing efforts convince IT departments that it is, and that it's important to adopt it company-wide, that's bad for blind people unless Cloudflare makes the product accessible. I don't know if their marketing efforts are succeeding, but I'm being proactive here.
- em-bee 5y agowell, i mean strictly necessary in the eyes of the law. but that's something we won't find out until affected people start suing employers for discrimination or whatever the appropriate claim here is. and until then there will be casualties as you already predict.
- brudgers 5y agoThe legal situation is akin to speeding. While technically it is illegal to drive 56 in a 55, you won’t get a ticket for it. And lots of places the flow of traffic will be 85 in a 65 and the cops are not about to hold things up. Same with accessibility only there are powerful economic interests at play too.
- adventured 5y ago> And lots of places the flow of traffic will be 85 in a 65 and the cops are not about to hold things up. They sure will. They'll pull a traffic break when something is wrong. They get out in front of a block of traffic, throw on their lights, and begin swerving across lanes, instructing the speeding flow of traffic to collectively slow down. I've seen cops routinely do that in both California and on the East Coast. Cops will do that for various reasons, including safety purposes (if something has happened up ahead) or just to reassert control if they decide the flow of traffic is going too fast. Here is a safety example of it in action in Utah: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9IsAu_96oo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9IsAu_96oo The Germans apparently do this for safety as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-TZBhy-jDk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-TZBhy-jDk
- namibj 5y agoThe German example was about debris on the traffic lane(s) that had to be removed ASAP, and for a safe working environment, the traffic has to be slowed down/stopped.
- novok 5y agoTBH it only becomes an issue when its required for the blind people to use this browser. If I was running a company and ran into this, I would just say the blind people and other unserved edge cases should just use normal chrome until cloudflare delivers the full version. Security is a probability spectrum, not a binary as many are fond to think of it.
- mwcampbell 5y agoI hope any companies that adopt this product agree with you on this point. But in case they don't, I still think it's important to urge Cloudflare to make this product accessible.
- novok 5y agoA small company TBH would not adopt this kind of browser, and a large company that might is too paranoid about lawsuits & CYA behavior to not make such an exception once it got escalated. And if it became very wide spread, I think it would have that stuff built in too, because to get some big company / govt contracts an accessibility requirement eventually gets thrown in somewhere.
- mwcampbell 5y ago> A small company TBH would not adopt this kind of browser At $10 per month per user, that's dependent on whether one decision-maker in that small company can be swayed by Cloudflare's marketing, right?
- novok 5y agoI hope then, at the small company you can just talk to the person and ask them to let you use the normal browser, just like you would if any other tool was interfering with your edge case, be it disability related or not. The nice thing about many small companies is they are biased towards less 'paperwork' and more action. I find in most companies that you are not a minimum wage worker, the only real blocker towards not being able to do something is compliance law preventing you from not doing something. That conflict of laws is where most companies seize up. I hope something like this doesn't become a mandatory thing for compliance security things one day without proper accessibility support.
- sonicggg 5y agoWhy is everyone here saying the same thing, given that we had a Cloudfare employee clarifying that this feature can be disabled, for now, in the machines of those that are visually impaired?
- em-bee 5y agoi didn't say anything to the contrary. of course it can be disabled. but am i going to allow it to be disabled for some of my employees if my customers start demanding that i use this feature while i develop their software? probably not until there is a lawsuit that clarifies which need takes precedence.